5 ms·
This is basically a polite way to fire a customer. You don't want to sell to everyone - you need to make sure the cost of retention+support is significantly le
by alephnerd 3y ago
This is basically a polite way to fire a customer.
You don't want to sell to everyone - you need to make sure the cost of retention+support is significantly less than what they are paying.
If a customer is too troublesome or spending too little (for a company like VMWare, a $8m contract is on the smaller end) this is the politest way to fire them.
It sounds like this customer is a legal firm, which makes sense - they tend to have a much smaller IT footprint.
Every dollar isn't the same.
Edit: to elaborate - it's all about margins. Is that $8m worth it if in aggregate you spending an equal amount of time on that account as you are on a $20-30m account? It ain't
- biorach 3y ago$8m doesn't cover retention (what retention?) and support? Not sure that makes sense.
- alephnerd 3y agoAbsolutely. When you reach VMWare size ($13.5 BILLION in revenue in FY 23), $8M is chump change. The margins on support might not make sense. With the level of revenue VMWare had, it's realistic to assume mean deal size is in the 8-9 digit range. > what retention TAMs, CSMs, constant PFRs, constant escalations, etc
- jraph 3y agoI don't understand. I can understand VMWare doesn't want to keep doing this, but with $8M, assuming a 100k annual salary, you can dedicate 80 full time employees to this customer yearly. I understand 8M is nothing next to 13.5B, but that can't be unprofitable, can it? Or the contract is too low.
- alephnerd 3y agoThere are several flaws with your assumptions 1. "assuming a 100k annual salary" - the cost of salary is 1.75x stated wage, so in reality it's $175k 2. "you can dedicate 80 full time employees to this customer yearly" - you mean you need almost a hundred bodies per customers?!? In fact, this is a major reason to fire a customer. It means they are demanding and trying to outsource their entire org to you. Either pay up or piss off. > that can't be unprofitable, can it Nope. > Or the contract is too low. Exactly.
- jraph 3y ago> 1. "assuming a 100k annual salary" - the cost of salary is 1.75x stated wage, so in reality it's $175k I know, this was ballpark thinking, it's not a fundamental flaw in my thinking. 100k with taxes is still a 60k salary and that's about what I was thinking. Not great everywhere, but still good in many locations. I also don't know how much support people are usually paid, and 200k is still 40 people. Now, indeed, I wasn't imagining hundreds of people per customer required. I'm willing to believe it's realistic for some kinds of businesses, for very big customers.
- alephnerd 3y agoAnd $8m is LOW. F1000s will spend the same amount on AV or endpoints alone. For backbone infra, you can expect a price that is 4-6x higher, as network security, IT infra, etc is bundled.
- everforward 3y ago60k is likely very low for this kind of support. The people calling in are generally IT professionals that have issues a script won't solve. When I worked with VMWare, it also wasn't uncommon for us to have support on site. If we were doing a big migration or had a significant issue, they'd send someone out for a week+. They likely paid a premium to have support willing to travel for significant spans of time, plus now they're paying for hotels, daily stipends, etc. Then you need labs for engineers to try to replicate problems, office space, general overhead like taxes and payroll providers, etc. Then there's costs to the platform itself from some customers. E.g. small customers tend to be less homogenous. Every Fortune 500 has a SAN, many small companies don't. Now you need an "integrates with EMC" storage option for big companies, and an "integrates with everything else" option for small companies. Big companies want a service mesh, small companies want a billion different networking configurations, etc. Basically big companies tend to resemble each other and view their differences as a competitive advantage they will pay their vendors to support so they can keep. Small customers diverge a lot, don't want to and/or can't afford to pay for the changes they need, and are generally more price-sensitive due to their ability and ability to switch vendors. So simultaneously the small clients are profitable, but at a lower margin than bigger customers, and more willing to migrate away. Rather than taking a risk that they can do enough development to keep the small customers, they'd rather double down on the customers that can't switch, raise their margins, and cut their risk.
- baq 3y agotaxes, margins, capex, etc. means you could do maybe 10. offshored to somewhere with competent people, 20-40 depending on location.
- Ekaros 3y ago13,5 billion is 1687 8 million customers... That is not actually that many...
- rootlocus 3y agoThat's what I don't get either. If they can shove off one of their top 1500 customers (probably much higher) and, as someone put it, "everyone is using them", that means unless you're one of the top few hundred customers, this can absolutely happen to you. Which is what people are upset about.
- alephnerd 3y agoIt's how companies work. I can guarantee for a fact that a F1000 will be spending 8-9 figures for a VMWare type product (I've worked on similar products as a PM). $8m is low. > Which is what people are upset about All that matters is purchasing committees are ok (not happy, not sad - just meh). All I see here is just IC engineers pouting.
- ehvatum 3y ago> All that matters is purchasing committees are ok Large enterprise purchasing committees are foremost concerned with risk, you absolute dolt. The risk that price will jump 12x, requiring all kinds of scrambling, is fucking awful. I don’t know what planet you’re from, but you gotta stop acting like it’s this one.
- everforward 3y agoAnd the risk they're most concerned with is the business ceasing to function. I worked at a F500 that used VMWare; they'd probably pay a 12x subscription fee. Not because they want to, but because they started trying to get rid of their mainframe 30 years ago and 70 something percent of their business still relied on the mainframe last I was there a decade ago. VMWare will likely go the same. It'll take them a year or two to PoC an alternative and get contracts signed, another 5 to move the low hanging fruit, and a decade to finish off the long tail of stuff that won't migrate easily. We're talking migrating stuff running versions of Java that were EoLed a decade ago, using an app container (like Tomcat) that was also EoLed a decade ago, and trying to get that all working on a new infra stack. And it's not just one of them, there are thousands of apps, many of which are outdated or have bizarre vendor requirements you'd likely never accept (like "we will not support you if you run this bog-standard Django app on a VM"). Stuff like this moves slooooowwww, especially at companies who only use tech to enhance their primary business (as opposed to tech being their primary business).
- biorach 3y ago> The margins on support might not make sense. Yeah, maybe. Without some real figures this is very speculative > TAMs, CSMs, constant PFRs, constant escalations, etc You seem to be assuming the customer takes up man-weeks or months of support and legal, not particularly typical for a repeat customer in that game - not sure how else you could account for the margin on $8m being completely eaten up So... speculative and unconvincing
- alephnerd 3y agoThis is my bread and butter. These kinds of numbers are closely guarded for competitive reasons. Go chat with the sales or account teams at your employer - they can confirm in broad strokes what I've mentioned.
- biorach 3y agoI think the strokes are a bit too broad for meaningful conversation
- alephnerd 3y agoIt's Sales and Pricing - there isn't a predefined curriculum around this. Most of this is tribal knowledge you learn working a Field facing job. Like I've said before, talk to SEs, AEs, and TAMs at your employer. They can confirm similar strategies and numbers.
- brazzy 3y ago> With the level of revenue VMWare had, it's realistic to assume mean deal size is in the 8-9 digit range. 8 million is quite close to the low end of 8 digits. And at the high end of 8 digits, your assumption woud already mean they have only a few hundred customers in total, which is about as far from "realistic" as can be.
- alephnerd 3y ago> only a few hundred customers in total, which is about as far from "realistic" as can be That tends to be good enough for a PL within a larger organization, which VMWare is now. Zscaler uses the same strategy and PANW is transitioning to as well.
- Rastonbury 3y agoI work in enterprise saas as well and I can't imagine how bad this customer must be that they can break pricing unless VMware runs really low margins vs the industry. There must be other things as well 8m is 0.6% of their revenue, and they grew in revenue 4% from 2022 to 2023[1]. Losing 0.5% kinda hurts when they are growing that slowly. That 8m can't be that easily magicked out of existing customers or the freed up resources supporting that customer they fired. I know nothing about their business or financials however [1]https://finance.yahoo.com/news/vmware-reports-fourth-quarter-fiscal-210500904.html?guccounter=1 https://finance.yahoo.com/news/vmware-reports-fourth-quarter...
- alephnerd 3y ago> There must be other things as well My hunch is an Account Team gave a heavily discounted deal to land an upper market customer in order to meet quarterly commitments or get a nice commission. The customer ended up accepting the $100M price-point as well (https://twitter.com/cioontherun/status/1761882689886433742 https://twitter.com/cioontherun/status/1761882689886433742), so they were clearly mis-tiered. If you can afford (what I assume is) a multi-year contract with a 9 figure TCV, you are generating 9 or 10 figures in revenue. I've heard of similar shenanigans down the grapevine at w/ Cisco and Dell EMC and absolutely wouldn't be surprised if a similar thing happened at VMWare.
- Rastonbury 3y agoIf they accepted the 100m renewal then all is good for them, seems like a load of speculation about nothing - they were just simply overly discounted
- jsmith99 3y agoIs $8m small for a VMware contract? Surely if you’re big enough at some point it becomes cheaper to put something together in house - surely this point is far before spending $100m a year?
- alephnerd 3y ago> Is $8m small for a VMware contract Absolutely. For an Enterprise SaaS generate $13.5B in revenue in FY23, you can realistically assume mean deal size is mid-upper 8 or low 9 figures. Everyone and I mean everyone is using them
- nunez 3y agoits kind of like AWS. with them, some customers are spending $20M+/month, while others (me) spend close to zero.
- alephnerd 3y agoPretty much, though AWS doesn't use direct sales to bring in lower revenue tier customers whereas VMWare did.
- nunez 3y agoHow do you mean? Signing up on aws.amazon.com and providing your card is a direct sale.
- alephnerd 3y agoDirect Sales means there is personnel (inbound or outbound) selling directly to the customer on behalf of the Vendor. If you sign up to AWS on your own credit card, there was no inbound or outbound sales motion at all. AWS's self service motion is extremely efficient for lower tier customers (as the upside is basically infinite as you basically spend $0 to generate N dollars). <- This is also why YC's Request for Startups is mentioning Open Core startups, as the open source offering acts as a loss leader (eg. Kong, Hashicorp, Pulumi eventually) Traditionally, companies like VMWare didn't support such a model and your only way to purchase was to jump on a call with their account team, but companies are transitioning to that to target low tier sales.
- wjnc 3y agoIt is the most shitty (and stupid) way possible to act though. Old price x 12 is not in good faith. Contracts are based on good faith. Give them a rationale, give them a deadline 24 months hence and a fair price increase. Dare to say no to individual customers. Any customer should now start planning for the end of their Broadcom VMWare-contract. If they do not act in good faith to a random customer, why would they to you? Large company contract management is based on trust. This might cost Broadcom a lot more than a few individual customers that they were planning on 'letting go'. I work at a company that got sold by another company with an indefinite LTA (long term agreement) in place. Former owner did not honor the LTA, but at least was transparant and timely about it. We got two years to sever several key processes. We will end up severing all ties, since the business risk of leaving open ends without the LTA is too big for my risk appetite. Fool me once. And that's our business consequence of not honoring an LTA even when the former owner severed the ties in good faith. If the buy-in is not there for both parties to the contract, then there is no ongoing relationship.
- alephnerd 3y agoThis is how I know you haven't been on an enterprise account team. The strategy you described has no upside for the vendor (in this case Broadcom VMWare).
- mschuster91 3y ago> The strategy you described has no upside for the vendor (in this case Broadcom VMWare). It has. Product/brand trust matters... the most obvious example being Google, who have had an extremely hard time getting their stuff to be actually used as they have shown time and time again that even if you're the biggest game publishers on this rock, you won't be able to rely on Google keeping up their end of any deal.
- alephnerd 3y ago> Product/brand trust matters At Enterprise SaaS level it does not. You do not have an individual purchaser - the deal will be vetted by committee for 1-3 quarters. > most obvious example being Google, who have had an extremely hard time getting their stuff to be actually used Extremely hard disagree. GCP does well in enterprise/strategic accounts where a customer in some way competes with Amazon (which is around 20-30% of the F1000) and also doesn't have a significant Windows presence (minimizing the need for Azure+MS Support)
- siod 3y agoThere is nothing polite about this, it's predatory behaviour. If you can't make a 8m saas contract work your then company is broken.
- AshamedCaptain 3y agoI have seen companies that would refuse to serve customers that had not been growing as expected. Literally. Bogles my mind.
- alephnerd 3y agoWhy? Margins matter, not just dollars alone. If you spend 75 cents to earn a dollar on one customer and can spend 25 cents to earn a dollar on another customer, you'd be dumb not to take customer 2.
- badcppdev 3y agoIt's a SAAS product why not take both customers. Don't leave breadcrumbs to feed your competitors. It seems nobody can believe your assertion that a company would deliberately fire a profitable customer by quoting an x12 contract increase. There's no point asking me to talk to people in my business. You're going to have to point to publicly accessible resources.
- mamonster 3y agoTl; dr thing you should keep in mind(and this will happen to every SaaS): 1.5 mio in revenue per employee. Your SaaS vendor will hike prices or fire people until they get to this number. Why ? Because VC/Wall Street told them that if they want a Meta/Apple/Microsoft like valuation or a good upround they need to hit this key metric. Over the next 2-3 years every SaaS that is priced by some sort of market(so not passion projects/ projects run by guys who don't look at comparables) will at least try to hit the above metric. Whether that is massively laying off people(ring any bells?) or massively hiking pricing depends on the product in consideration. The era of "profitable customer" is over. Now it's all about how profitable he is, and 1.5 mio in revenue per employee is the benchmark.
- senordevnyc 3y ago[dead]
- 3y ago
- bachmeier 3y agoDo you have information not in the link? I don't see anything related to your comment. > This is basically a polite way to fire a customer. I'll throw out that raising the price like this is also a strategy to increase profit. In the absence of a source for your claim, I'll go with that instead. > Is that $8m worth it if in aggregate you spending an equal amount of time on that account as you are on a $20-30m account? If that's how these decisions are made, the person making them needs to be fired, and fast. They should have considered that they could handle both accounts. Increasing the number of customers is called expansion.
- alephnerd 3y ago> Do you have information not in the link I do this for a living, first as a PM and now as a VC. These multiples are fairly common knowledge for anyone in Enterprise SaaS, and have have worked with accounts teams that have done this and have recommended similar strategies (at a smaller scale) to portfolio companies. > the person making them needs to be fired, and fast. They should have considered that they could handle both accounts. Increasing the number of customers is called expansion. I can expand the # of customers by selling 1,000 $1 contracts - that doesn't materially impact my company's financials. You want to increase your (Revenue-COGS). If you need to drop a needy customer to increase COGS because you have mistiered accounts caused by an account team targeting a hefty quarterly bonus (happens everywhere, and caused a big shitshow at a major cybersecurity startup recently that brought a federal investigation) so be it.
- bachmeier 3y ago> I do this for a living, first as a PM and now as a VC. These multiples are fairly common knowledge for anyone in Enterprise SaaS, and have have worked with accounts teams that have done this and have recommended similar strategies (at a smaller scale) to portfolio companies. So the answer is no, you don't have any information not found in the link, and everything you wrote was speculation. > You want to increase your (Revenue-COGS). Exactly, and without knowing anything about the financials of this deal, there's no way to know if your claims are correct. It might have been an attempt to take advantage of someone that built on their product, expecting that they'll pay more.
- nisegami 3y ago>Is that $8m worth it if in aggregate you spending an equal amount of time on that account as you are on a $20-30m account? I think it depends? Let's assume that both accounts are profitable overall, but one is massively more profitable. The logic to cut off the $8m account makes sense if you can move those resources towards more $20m accounts. But that isn't something that is necessarily possible, is it? There's only so many of those $20m customers out there. This obviously changes if the $8m customer is not profitable or is just _that_ unpleasant to work with.
- alephnerd 3y ago> But that isn't something that is necessarily possible, is it At VMware size it absolutely is. I've worked on accounts at similarly sized vendors and even AV or Endpoint spend will be in the $1-5M range alone even if per unit price is in the $20-30 range. With a backbone product like VMware, you can safely assume spend is 4-6x as you will be bundling network security along with IT infra.
- shrubble 3y agoThis strategy works... until it doesn't. You may well be correct for the next 3-5 years; but after that those customers will leave and they won't come back. Ever. Tech is littered with the twittering ghosts of companies that had something "essential" and "irreplaceable". The strategy is "a retreat to the high end" and a self-serving re-definition of "who are customers are" and "what we do".
- solarkraft 3y agoYes. Mind share is important. Does VMWare have the best product or are they so popular because "that's what I know"? As smaller shops switch away (the Proxmox folks must be in a pretty good mood), the job market will be full of people who know the alternatives, but not VMWare products. And when "the real thing" is so incredibly expensive, why not switch to something comparable that your people already know?
- alephnerd 3y agoAn enterprise would switch to Citrix or Nutanix before Proxmox, as having on-call support is critical at that level
- throwawaymanbot 3y ago[dead]