21 ms·

Old People Icons That Don't Make Sense Anymore

• clone1018 15y ago
  They do make sense, they are and have been the standard for years, and even the new generation understands what they do, in almost every case.
• nathanbarry 15y ago
  The floppy disk icon has always frustrated me. Though I still haven't seen a great replacement. Would love to see this list with more thoughtful options to use instead.
  • notatoad 15y ago
    the floppy disk icon for saving is a bit of an anachronism, but so is saving. there doesn't seem to be a whole lot of value in re-imagining the icon for an action that is mostly unnecessary in modern apps.
  • rapidsnail 15y ago
    There was a discussion on stackoverflow that talks about it http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1019573/save-icon-still-a-floppy-disk http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1019573/save-icon-still-a...
  • SaigonKick 15y ago
    Why would a perfectly suitable icon ever be replaced? When something else becomes iconic that replaces it.
  • blake8086 15y ago
    It's because "saving" is an activity that exists only to appease computer architecture choices. It's not a natural thing to do at all. A more humanistic approach would be to save versioned history of everything you do and then "save" by marking points in time as versions you would like to share with other people or systems.
• TwistedWeasel 15y ago
  The idea that people don't know what a cog or a wrench is seems like the author is taking this a step too far. I wouldn't call those things "shrouded in mystery". Similarly there are still plenty of microphones that look like that, they're professional microphones, not "old fashioned" ones.
  • batista 15y ago
    Plus, once a reference is established (like the floppy disk) it's idiotic to always replace it with the latest tech (we'd have zip drives in the nineties, usb drives in the '00s, the cloud today, etc etc..)
    • TwistedWeasel 15y ago
      Exactly, who cares if an icon is based on a dated object if it's understood. All things become dated eventually, especially in the tech world What's the alternative, pick something abstract that confuses people. That didn't work out so well for the recent GMail redesign.
    • FuzzyDunlop 15y ago
      We might similarly go to another extreme and phase out the use of 'alpha' and 'beta', or just the ancient Greek alphabet altogether. It's thousands of years old, thus despite our ability to record and learn from history, we should replace it with something more modern.
      • philwelch 15y ago
        If you phased out "alpha" and "beta", you'd have to call the alphabet the aybee.
        • NLips 15y ago
          A lot of people DO call it the "Ay-bee-see"
    • antidoh 15y ago
• psylence519 15y ago
  How could you possibly associate an object with an action without first intimately knowing the object's function? And when did we all get rid of wrenches? I didn't get that memo.
• MCompeau 15y ago
  This discourse goes beyond the anachronistic references indicated by these icons and calls into question our entire system of interface metaphors. At one point in time imagining the information stored on your computer as a system of "files" and "folders" was pivotal in transitioning a society from the physical world to the digital one. Now that the transition is largely complete and many people are coming of age who have never known a world without computers, its time to move beyond anachronistic metaphors. We must discover new means of interaction that take advantage of the unique features of the digital medium.
  • bryogenic 15y ago
    I would like to hear an "explain it to me like I'm five" that explained what computer "files" and "folders" are and how they work without using the words or their associated metaphors. I agree some of the actual system specific icons and metaphors are outdated and junk, but I guess I'm in the camp that thinks these basic metaphors are actually useful in the education of computer interface / mechanisms.
  • batista 15y ago
    >Now that the transition is largely complete and many people are coming of age who have never known a world without computers, its time to move beyond anachronistic metaphors. They might have been metaphors once, now they are idioms. The people who "have never known a world without computers" have also never known a world where there weren't filesystem folders and files.
    • mietek 15y ago
      iOS devices mostly does away with both concepts, and I hear they've sold a few.
  • billybob 15y ago
    CS Lewis said that ""All language about things other than physical objects is necessarily metaphorical." I can't find the examples he gave, but from your sentence: we must "discover new means of interaction that take advantage..." "Discover" is made of "dis-cover", meaning "remove the things covering the other thing." The "inter" in "interaction" implies movement between objects in a physical space. To "take advantage" evokes physically grasping something. Perhaps this is more philosophical than you wanted, but I doubt we'll be leaving behind physical metaphors anytime soon.
• nsmartt 15y ago
  I have a handset in my house. Envelopes are still used for lots of things. I still get mail. I use screwdrivers pretty often, and I have access to wrenches. I recognize the old microphones from movies (and even if I didn't, they look similar to newer mics.) I've also used a polaroid in the past 5 years. I've also seen TV sets with "rabbit ears" in the past 5 years. The others I'm at least familiar with. I'm 18.
  • DavidAbrams 15y ago
    Yep. I'm pretty sure Blue and others sell mics designed to look exactly like those old chrome ones.
    • cdcarter 15y ago
      Well many large diaphragm condenser mics look like that because that's what the footprint of that kind of microphone is! And Shure still faithfully makes the Super 55, your iconic "Elvis mic."
  • shanselman 15y ago
    You are a renaissance person. I asked my 16 year old niece and she gets envelopes and tools but that's it.
  • Duff 15y ago
    The hot trend for visionary types to do today is wax on about how kids these days only text and use Facebook between Netflix show. Everything else is just too difficult, supposedly.
• ktrgardiner 15y ago
  The article began with an introduction to what could have been a really great dialogue. Why do those who didn't experience the inspiration for icons still inherently understand them? Yet it dropped that in favor of the same schtick for each icon.
  • shanselman 15y ago
    Yes, I ran out of time. It could have been a great post.
  • JadeNB 15y ago
    I think that the point, which the article may miss, is that we don't inherently understand them. We have to be taught to understand them—but we only have to be taught once to use a given set of icons, so it's good to use the same ones other people use, even if they're meaningless. (I'd draw an analogy to "Why do we inherently understand menu items written in English?" We don't inherently understand them (witness non-English speakers); we just get to draw on our existing familiarity with English to make the understanding easier.)
• radley 15y ago
  That is not a floppy disk. It's a Save icon. See the difference?
  • gdubs 15y ago
    Brilliant explanation of Semiotics :)
  • pmiller2 15y ago
    | <- Ceci n'est pas une pipe.
    • shanselman 15y ago
      Touché ;)
  • ak39 15y ago
    Agreed. It's no longer a floppy disk. Its meaning in the new context has a life of its own. The fact that the metaphor no longer has any connection with is original context IS the reason why it is now effective! :) "When things, signs or actions are freed from their respective ideas, concepts, essences, values, points of reference, origins and aims, they embark upon an endless process of self-reproduction. Yet things continue to function long after their ideas have disappeared, and they do so in total indifference to their own content. The paradoxical fact is that they function even better under these circumstances." Jean Baudrillard from "The Transparency of Evil" http://www.amazon.com/The-Transparency-Evil-Extreme-Phenomena/dp/0860915883 http://www.amazon.com/The-Transparency-Evil-Extreme-Phenomen...
  • pbhjpbhj 15y ago
    >Soon the envelope itself will go away and the next generation will wonder what this rectangle means Exactly as radley says. The rectangle in my quote here means '[send] email' (whic itself is anachronistic; emessage?).
• radley 15y ago
  Why do I have to still log-in to Facebook? Why can't I run Windows games on my iPad? Why can't I just talk to my computer like Star Trek? Programmers know why, but users don't. Same goes for icons: designers know what they're doing & why...
  • DavidAbrams 15y ago
    The question is why Facebook forces you to use an E-mail address as a user ID. Now THAT's amateur hour.
    • damoncali 15y ago
      They don't.
      • DavidAbrams 15y ago
        Hm, yeah, check their page: http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7233/7169306722_60b500bf36.jpg http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7233/7169306722_60b500bf36.jpg Munch munch! It's fun to play stupid, right?
        • tkahn6 15y ago
          You can use your vanity username that appears in the url of your profile page. You can also use your phone number.
    • cdcarter 15y ago
      You can log in with your URL.
      • DavidAbrams 15y ago
        Assuming you've defined one, and a URL is not an appropriate user ID either.
• holyjaw 15y ago
  The difficult part about reading this thread was having to ask, after every point, "well, then what?" Out computer verbs are based off of (admittedly, maybe outdated) similar verbs. Our electronic work mirrors our physical work solely because of the limitations of our language constructs. I have it on good authority that there is not a single language that has words that that specifically define what we do on a computer that would be better suited and more efficient than a physical-describing counterpart. So, as mentioned earlier, the floppy metaphor: OK, I get it. But clipboards, bookmarks, Manila folders? How would you describe an object that lets you take information from one place to another in 32px? What physical object are you aware of that allows you to mark your place amidst a vast density of information? Don't even get me started on the folders. It's coy to label them "old-people icons" -- it's clever, I dig it -- but if tomorrow we were to unveil a new set of nouns and verbs to describe computer objects, the reigning argument would be that they never made sense at all. And have fun trying to explain to your grandfather/mother/nephew how to uses computer without having any real-world jargon to borrow from.
• tricolon 15y ago
  While I support the point behind this article, some of them are... not on point. > Want to indicate Settings or Setup to a twenty something? Show them a tool they've never used in their lives. What have screwdrivers and wrenches been replaced with?
  • StavrosK 15y ago
    Who cares? A floppy disk nowadays is the thing that indicates "save", and that's it. You don't have to have seen a floppy disk to know that it's the save icon. If that were the case, company logos would be objects. A swoosh is Nike, and that's that.
    • dpcan 15y ago
      Sure, but if you're not old enough to know what a floppy disk is, someone would first have to tell you that the floppy disk was the save icon. I think the op's point is that icons are no longer making the user experience intuitive, they are actually adding another step. Young people have to figure out what they represent first before they use them where the point of an icon is to eliminate that step.
      • StavrosK 15y ago
        Definitely, but I didn't know what a clipboard was before I started copying and pasting (text on the computer)... You probably learn which button is "Save" when learning what saving actually is, I don't know how intuitive the pictograms for these actions can be.
  • philwelch 15y ago
    > What have screwdrivers and wrenches been replaced with? (cynical) A trash can followed by a trip to Wal-Mart.
• StavrosK 15y ago
  I love how there's a spool of camera film in the photo for the "voice mail" icon. Sounds like someone's too young for those flat cameras!
  • DavidAbrams 15y ago
    Not to mention that the icon is for the reels in a cassette, not a reel-to-reel tape.
  • caf 15y ago
    That would be to illustrate the phrase "but it always looks like a container of 110 Film.".
    • StavrosK 15y ago
      Ah, I missed that, thanks.
• alaskamiller 15y ago
  I wonder if the Egyptians had the same problem.
• liamgriffiths 15y ago
  This gave me something to think about. When icons fail to be understood, they can fail hard. I spent a lot of time frustrated with the new gmail design until I changed the icons to text.
  • DavidAbrams 15y ago
    Even then, the Gmail UI sucks badly: http://farm7.staticflickr.com/6034/6310566055_4a5f5d4a53_b.jpg http://farm7.staticflickr.com/6034/6310566055_4a5f5d4a53_b.j...
• mindstab 15y ago
  I'd love to go to schools and get kids in groups like <15years or <10 years and ask them to design icons for these things and see what they come up with. They have a lot less cultural history and technological history. might be interesting. Or maybe they've learned all these icons and while not getting what they did mean, they understand what they mean now, like letters of a new alphabet. Like how many Asian script characters are descendants of more obvious pictograms of actions. They still have meaning even if they've evolved a bit and even changed.
  • radley 15y ago
    UI designers are constantly forced to come up with new icons for crazy new features. It's a common practice to look for it on Google images, i.e. "Save Icon", and see if there's a common metaphor. If not, you look for similar use cases - something so that it's much quicker for users to grok what it does. That's the fundamental purpose after all. This was the problem with Google/Android's new icons as well as GitHub. Google got caught up with minimization and left out the telling differentiators. Githup went nuts on illustration and lost the original meanings.
    • DavidAbrams 15y ago
      Yep, and you have supposed "leaders" like Apple that just give up and stop trying. Apple widely just throws up a button with a "gear" on it when they're too lazy to organize functions properly. And there's no telling what the gear button will do. Even worse is the Easter-egg UIs that are becoming a widespread problem: There's no icon (or even control) at all until you accidentally roll the cursor over the area. WTF? Are users supposed to sweep across every pixel on the screen now, looking for hidden goodies?
      • radley 15y ago
        Not sure what the gear is you mention, but I can't think of another company that has Apple's drive for intuitive UI, which is the fundamental purpose of icons. In contrast, HN is a text-dominant application designed for text-dominant users...
• radley 15y ago
  The irony is that there's a concurrent and opposite reaction to the non-traditional new icons used on Github. The simple reason the save icon still looks like a floppy disk is because everyone expects it to look like that.
• SaigonKick 15y ago
  Is this from the future? We still save to disks... sure the media has changed, but we're doing the same task. After reviewing the author, filed under: Comedy!
  • rbanffy 15y ago
    Well... Some people have been saving stuff to flash memory (even calling them SDD's is an anachronism)
• jes5199 15y ago
  wow, I never knew that "radio button" meant that - I sort of imagined that they were checkboxes that had walkie talkies with eachother?
• joejohnson 15y ago
  Clipboards are are everywhere: sexy business men and ladies in movies; gym coaches; bitchy stage managers; kids use them in school occasionally, etc.
• evoxed 15y ago
  Around halfway through I jotted down a few thoughts. I like and appreciate people thinking about this sort of thing however, so I'm not saying any of this to offend. > I don't see any reason that we couldn't be storing our files in abstract squares rather than folders in the sky. ...because they're called folders, and we know how to use them? If I said, "Here, have a square," is your first instinct really to think oh! that must be for putting stuff in/on? Sure, you can abstract them to just a symbol but it's unnecessary. It's not like the system cares what you call it or how you choose to display it. > The world's most advanced phones include an icon that looks like a phone handset that you haven't touched in 20 years, unless you've used a pay phone recently. I have in fact, but that's not the point. Again, we know the shape. There aren't many things it could be besides a phone. You could show someone a glossy brick I guess, but what good would that do? The best alternative I can think of would be something like a speaker or microphone, but where's the argument that that would actually be better? > At some time in the past the magnifying glass became the "search everywhere" icon, but for some reason binoculars are for searching within a document. I'm just now realizing that he must be thinking of a specific piece of software. I gathered he was on Windows, now I see he worked at MS. Is this Office? This one I agree with, but it sounds like a quirky error made by some engineer or perhaps phony UX consultant. Same goes for the clipboard– hell if I know why MS would use that icon for paste, but in no other software that I can think of is that normal. > Envelopes Same thing as folders. So our terminology expanded to cover abstract digital entities, but that doesn't make it a hinderance to our intuition. Folders, packages, envelopes... maybe they're too nostalgic for the bold futurist, but generally it's about as practical as you can get. > Wrenches and Gears Who hasn't used a screwdriver? Or never seen a wrench? Even the people who don't own one probably know what it is. I'm indifferent to the gears/tools thing. It still makes sense, but I'm open to new ideas– preferably a little more clever than a circuitboard. > Microphones For speech recognition, would an ear be better? I think most people would get the microphone bit simply from watching cartoons, talkshows, album covers etc... but I admit this will likely be more foreign in the future, and is already disconnected from people in developing countries without that much media exposure (although they apparently have an iPhone/Pad/Pod). > Photography It's kitsch. It still makes sense because the alternative to a square with a border is a square without a border. But for all of us who still use medium/large format cameras from time to time or for work, we can simply pretend. Lenses are a-OK. > Televisions Actually, for the large number of people who gave up cable for hulu and netflix but still want to catch the news– yes! I do have rabbit ears! Maybe it's a little too retro for most video icons, but again– it till makes sense, it just may be better suited to apps that show live broadcasts. > Carbon Copies and Blueprints Eh, so the term's (carbon copy) a bit outdated. But then again, when was the last time I "pasted" a document together? Yeah, Drawing I. As for blueprints... it makes sense for XCode right? And CAD. We may not use blueprints so often anymore, but it's less ambiguous than "construction documents," which might as well be "layouts". Which might as well be squares with a shape on them. Etc... Basically, this would be a far more interesting post if the author would go further into making actual suggestions. Some of it makes sense because it's intuitive, some of it makes sense because we're used to it. If you want to correct the latter, you've got to show something what's better. Edit: ouch, that's an ugly post. Not sure if I can format it in any way. Also, I'm looking forward to seeing what people suggest in the discussion here. It's an interesting topic for sure (and I'm sure there will be plenty of people to disagree with me).
• ars 15y ago
  So that's where radio buttons comes from! And yes my TV has rabbit ears, only they are the wifi antennas on my router :)
  • Osiris 15y ago
    I also did not know the origin of the term radio buttons, though I DO recall that our old cars as a kid did have those type of buttons on them.
    • WalterBright 15y ago
      I looked into replacing the old AM radio in my ancient dodge with a modern one, but eventually decided I simply liked the look & feel of that pushbutton thingie, and anything more modern just looked wrong in that car.
• jack-r-abbit 15y ago
  I use an SD card (one way or another) almost daily. It would only take a small amount of reworking to make the "floppy disk" Save icon look like an SD card and still look enough like the original icon to not confuse people. The cloud is cool and all but many devices (even cloud enabled ones) make use of some sort of physical storage. Many devices do not have the capability (or even the need) to get data straight from the cloud (or at least can't if they aren't able to connect to cell/wifi).
  • duaneb 15y ago
    > It would only take a small amount of reworking to make the "floppy disk" Save icon look like an SD card and still look enough like the original icon to not confuse people. What would be the point, though? Surely the floppy disk icon has more meaning now as "save" than as the original metaphor of "save to floppy disk." Besides, SD cards are outdated now - I think the only thing of mine which uses it is my camera, and I never actually remove the card. I would guess that more people would recognize the floppy disk than the sd card.
    • jack-r-abbit 15y ago
      no point. just offering a suggestion.
• DavidAbrams 15y ago
  This headline illustrates the importance of the hyphen. The headline refers to "people icons" that are old. I went to see how many people icons there could even be. Turns out that what he really means is old-people icons.
• acheron 15y ago
  There's a good article to be written on this subject, but this isn't it. "folders": we can go back to "directories" if you'd like. It's still what I say most of the time. "wrenches/screwdrivers/gears": This was the most baffling one. Who's never used a screwdriver? And he says it as if it's obvious. "phone": 75% of the US still has a landline (as of a year ago anyway), so I find "you haven't used this in 20 years" to be a rather dumb statement too. "tv antenna": Antennas have actually come back recently when broadcast stations switched to digital and HD feeds. This would have been a better criticism ten years ago, and makes him the one that sounds out of date. When I saw the article title, I figured "floppy disk" = "save". And sure, that's somewhat valid. But as others have pointed out, it's idiomatic. It happens in language all the time: people still say that someone is given "free rein" even if nobody involved has ever ridden a horse.
  • DavidAbrams 15y ago
    And he missed the "film" icon for movies. I think about this one when I see the stylized movie-chain trailers in theaters: What percentage of the audience even knows what that strip is supposed to be?
    • excuse-me 15y ago
      Do directors still say cut? Or do they now shout fclose() at the end of a scene? If it's a really good take - do they say that's "a burn to disk" - instead of a print?
  • baddox 15y ago
    The obvious response to all his critiques is that they're all idiomatic. Apple didn't choose a handset icon because everyone is familiar with those old handsets, they chose it because everyone will know that the icon means "telephone." Sure, it's fun to go back one more "etymology generation," but it's not necessary.
  • bgilroy26 15y ago
    "phone" - The shape he's talking about is this one[1]. While the Wrench/Screwdriver etc. are in common use, the shape here is from the rotary phone, which is not in common use. The page I linked was literally the first google image result for me, and that top cluster of images includes many recognizeable clip-art phones, all with the same rotary phone shape. 1. http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2008/01/getting-the-interview-phone-screen-right.html http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2008/01/getting-the-intervi...
• gdubs 15y ago
  Fun read. However, if the suggestion is that we force ourselves to constantly update iconography because the metaphors are outdated, I don't agree. Sailors still say "knots", but I bet young ones don't all know why. People say "breadboard" all of the time when building electronics. Similarly, the very letters of our language evolved out of symbols that meant something to some humans long ago, just as words have an etymology. People simply start to associate icon with action. Mail on my Mac is represented by a postage stamp. I never realized that until I just analyzed it. Good icons are subconscious like that.
  • jack-r-abbit 15y ago
    For us young ones: How do sea navigators measure their ships speed? http://www.physlink.com/education/askexperts/ae400.cfm http://www.physlink.com/education/askexperts/ae400.cfm
    • philwelch 15y ago
      That's interesting. I just assumed it was a sound-alike for "nautical miles per hour", spelled "knots" instead of "nauts" for some arbitrary reason.
    • benholmen 15y ago
      Another interesting word is 'log' which we use daily in a digital sense but it has a very physical nautical origin: log: "from log (n.1) which is so called because a wooden float at the end of a line was cast out to measure a ship's speed. General sense by 1913." Source: http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=log&allowed_in_frame=0 http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=log&allowed_in_...
  • deleted 15y ago
    [deleted]
  • guynamedloren 15y ago
    > Mail on my Mac is represented by a postage stamp. I never realized that until I just analyzed it. Good icons are subconscious like that. Honestly? I don't believe you. The postage stamp is in no way subtle - in fact, it couldn't be more obvious.
• deleted 15y ago
  [deleted]
• GDH 15y ago
  Icons are the hieroglyphs of the 21st century. I can promise you that in a few thousand years if a human came across a functioning computer from the 21st century they would be truly confused by the funny little pictures all over the place. They would (WILL) most likely study our icons and try to understand our language.
• excuse-me 15y ago
  In my app I just have the same little image of a CPU for everything - much more logical
  • deleted 15y ago
    [deleted]
• brc 15y ago
  This goes back a lot further than computer icons. Road signs for railway crossings still show steam trains. Men/Women signs for toilets show women in skirts that nobody wears, on images that hardly resemble people at all. My car has a snowflake for the AC button, even though snow doesn't come out of the vents when you switch it on. Interestingly, signs that ban music players in certain areas now look like Gen 1 iPods, even though a modern iPod (or any other player) doesn't have a clickwheel. The point is that, iconography is meant to be clear and concise. As long as everyone agrees on what something stands for, then it doesn't matter what that is. Generally, that thing refers to a classic image of a thing, because the original shape will always be associated with the modern version.
  • bazzargh 15y ago
    Indeed. This one used to mystify us on the UK driving test 25 years ago - way older than steam trains, and presumably anachronistic even when it was standardised: http://wwwdelivery.superstock.com/WI/223/1848/PreviewComp/SuperStock_1848-161827.jpg http://wwwdelivery.superstock.com/WI/223/1848/PreviewComp/Su... It's not a UK sign. Most Europeans will recognize it, but I doubt it travels well, and even where it has local currency, many peoples grandparents won't remember these in real life.
    • ben1040 15y ago
      As an American I had to use TinEye to find out that this image was of the Deutsche Post logo. Then I realized it was a horn, and understood the connection. But only because I had once seen this faux historic mailbox in a SkyMall catalog or the like: http://www.mailboxnet.com/townhouse_mailbox/mb500_townhouse_mailbox.html http://www.mailboxnet.com/townhouse_mailbox/mb500_townhouse_...
    • brc 15y ago
      I recognised that one as a horn, but I had no idea what the connection to post is, and still don't. Just took it for one of those weird corporate logos that meant something to someone at some point but doesn't anymore.
• martincmartin 15y ago
  It's not just icons. Phrases are the same. I'll bet many people here have never heard a broken record, but still have heard the phrase "sounds like a broken record."
  • wunderland 15y ago
    I think the phrase "broken record" is used more when referring to someone repeating themselves over and over again.
    • deleted 15y ago
      [deleted]
    • epo 15y ago
      What do they call it if it is a sportsperson repeatedly regaling stories of their "fastest of all time athletic performance".
• JulianMorrison 15y ago
  It seems to me that what we are doing is creating new ideograms - that their icon nature will soon enough be beside the point, because they will be something closer to letters, like 漢字.
• polshaw 15y ago
  This is, essentially, how language itself has always worked. Common sense labels are applied to things, and they make them things their own and outlive the original reference. A tin (can) is still a tin despite the fact it has nothing to do with the element today, a light bulb has no bulb any more. The floppy=save isn't going anywhere.
• gmisra 15y ago
  This article would have been interesting if included actual suggestions for replacement icons. Being anachronistic isn't inherently a flaw. However, if our attachment to anachronism is preventing us from using more intuitive icons, then our bias toward anachronism is something we should examine critically. So, the real question is: are there more intuitive visual representations available for common computer actions? What does an e-mail address book look like?
• LyleK 15y ago
  Why do we even have a save icon function anymore anyway? Just to torture people who forgot to save their file? Google Docs doesn't have a save button because it is saving all the time. Why would you not want to save what you are doing? Why is not saving the default? (Alan Cooper made this argument in About Face in 1995.) Also, if you want to talk about outdated terminology, theres "disk" and "drive". These are being incorrectly applied to flash/solid state storage. They do apply to hard disk drives, and optical media.
  • grkvlt 15y ago
    > Why would you not want to save what you are doing? Because the document is public, and you don't want work-in-progress to be shared until it is complete?
    • jeffool 15y ago
      Don't publicly share the document until it's finished?
• WalterBright 15y ago
  I always wondered what was wrong with English. You know, using 'print' instead of a 'what-does-that-box-of-kleenex-mean' icon? And for non-English speakers, is it really harder to learn what 'print' means than consulting a cheat sheet for what the icons mean?
  • DavidAbrams 15y ago
    Are you saying you don't recognize a printer when you see it?
    • WalterBright 15y ago
      Printers come in all sorts of shapes, and I've seen quite a few different printer icons. The first one I saw looked like a box of kleenex, and did so to several of my coworkers at the time. For most of the gui programs I use, I have to hover the mouse over the icon till the tooltip comes up so I know what it does.
• WalterBright 15y ago
  I found it bizarre (and sad) that the author believes that a screwdriver and wrench are somehow only tools for old people, that 20-somethings would have never wielded one in their life?
  • deleted 15y ago
    [deleted]
• hoov 15y ago
  I'm not sure that I agree with the "Photography" examples. Even for people who haven't seen actual Polaroid cameras, the icon is clearly some sort of camera. The author finishes his argument with a quote from a recent pop song, which probably means that Polaroid pictures aren't an extremely obscure reference. Also, I bet that Instagram's early adopters know exactly what Polaroid cameras are, and the reference isn't lost on them. I'd also be willing to bet that there's at least some overlap with early adopters and people who are aware of the Impossible Project. Those people would at least make the connection between analog photography and the filters that Instagram provides. That being said, Polaroid-inspired icons are probably not ideal for every use.
  • philwelch 15y ago
    > The author finishes his argument with a quote from a recent pop song "Hey Ya!" was released in 2003, nine years ago, and the exact same year that Dell finally removed floppy drives from its computers.
  • excuse-me 15y ago
    Even more bizarre is the road sign for speed cameras - it shows a camera that nobody has seen for a century http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcToxHFPJthCpR32ukk5h9juENVVeXOmzTUfsI7a473Sp9PBLH7q http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcToxHFPJthCpR32ukk5h...
    • rwmj 15y ago
      If they've never watched a period film or TV program ...
      • excuse-me 15y ago
        Yes that's why I have a papyrus plant as the icon for my word processor
    • blt 15y ago
      Looks like a Mamiya RZ67: http://inyopro.com/images/mamiya_side_view.jpg http://inyopro.com/images/mamiya_side_view.jpg Still in production, but only familiar to pros in their late 20s and older...
• rodh257 15y ago
  The reason we still use these old icons is because every single icon requires people to think about and learn what it represents. The only icons that don't require the user to think are ones they see all the time. If you've never seen an icon before you can only really guess what it means, the shorter the time it takes to guess, the better the icon is. It's for this reason that I don't like icon-only user interfaces, they require too much thinking and guessing from the user. Take a look at these ones that show up when you select text in Android ICS: http://asset3.cbsistatic.com/cnwk.1d/i/tim/2011/10/18/ICS_copypaste.png http://asset3.cbsistatic.com/cnwk.1d/i/tim/2011/10/18/ICS_co... What on earth do they mean? I've been using ICS since January and I still don't know what they do except for the cut one. Because there's no way for them to show tooltips on hovering the only way to learn is to press it and try and work out what it just did.
  • klez 15y ago
    Well, the first one has multiple identical squares, so it seems to me intuitive that it means 'copy'. For exclusion (and resemblance to the folder+sheet on, e.g. MS Office) the last one has to be 'paste'. Oh, I never used ICS, so it's not because I tried them.
• ggchappell 15y ago
  Interesting. I'm 46. I've used reel-to-reel tapes because they were the normal thing to use at the time. But it has never once occurred to me that the voicemail icon represents a reel-to-reel tape. Now I'm trying to figure out if I'm stupid or not.
  • flomo 15y ago
    That recording tape symbol was also used on VCRs and stereo equipment, so it was already an "old person icon" long before it evolved into the standard phone icon for voicemail.
• deleted 15y ago
  [deleted]
• qntm 15y ago
  Not that the floppy disk being used as a Save icon was actually floppy, of course.
  • sklinger 15y ago
    You mean, except for the disk part of the floppy disk, of course.
  • epo 15y ago
    They had flexible cardboard cases once and were 8 inches across, so they were floppy originally as opposed to removable disc packs which had rigid platters. They were still called floppy discs when they stared appearing in smaller rigid plastic cases because the old ones were still commonplace and it reminded people they were the same thing.
• crazygringo 15y ago
  This blog post is fairly useless without proposals that do a better job of communicating these concepts. It almost seems that the author wants to do away with metaphors entirely? If we aren't going to use an address book as an icon for our list of contacts, then what on earth are we going to use??
  • Raphael 15y ago
    The contacts icon could resemble a person.
• lr 15y ago
  One which is not on here, and is my favorite, is the icon to start a PowerPoint presentation: portable projector screen. Sure, they still exist, but most people these days have never had to actually carry and/or set one up. Well, maybe I take that back... If you are using PowerPoint, perhaps you are old enough to remember using one... :-)
• Fuzzwah 15y ago
  Reminds me of a Bucky Fuller rant about the "incorrect" words we still use every day even though we know more now than when they came into use. His best example is "world wide", which he put forward should really be "world around" since we all now know that the earth is a globe and not flat.
  • tallpapab 15y ago
    Wow! This really should be known more widely.
• goldmab 15y ago
  My TV has rabbit ears. I can watch NFL games in high definition with them for free.
  • tallpapab 15y ago
    This. I get a couple dozen channels over the air eight of which I watch from time to time. Still having a hard time recognizing rabbit ear icons though. One pole on mine is broken.
• Mz 15y ago
  Makes me wonder how old the author is. Reminds me of an anecdote I read about an elementary school that had a rotary phone for the kids to use well after digital phones were the norm. The kids had to be taught how to use it. One child ultimately concluded it was not too different from a digital phone though it was real slow. Reminds me of my standard flippant remark to my sons when they were growing up: "When I was a child and had a pet dinosaur and rotary phone." To my young sons, both dinosaurs and rotary phones were "prehistoric" -- I.e. existed before their time. For me, only dinosaurs were actually prehistoric.
  • shanselman 15y ago
    I'm 39. The post was written in brief lunchtime fit of get of my lawn. :)
    • Mz 15y ago
      I will be 47 in June ...and I have a condition with a life expectancy in the thirties. In human years, that makes me the equivalent of about an 85 year old. So get off my lawn already, you young whippersnapper!! (More sinecerely: Thanks for responding.)
  • tallpapab 15y ago
    Ah yes, rotary phones. What a wonderful modern invention. Saved much time and prevented many errors over having to tap on the handset cradle.
• jberryman 15y ago
  We do the same thing with written language (no one knows or questions where e.g. "pull out all the stops" comes from but it doesn't matter), so why should our visual language be any different?
  • Mz 15y ago
    Actually, I discuss origins of such expressions with my sons quite often, which they find helpful and enlightening. But I had old parents -- my father is one year younger than my ex husband's grandmother and my ex and I graduated high school together -- so I grew up with somewhat more exposure to where things like that come from historically than most people appear to have.
  • NLips 15y ago
    On the other hand, pipe-organs are not outdated, whereas floppy disks are (for most of us).
• MicahWedemeyer 15y ago
  Envelopes are a very common item for anyone who runs a business. The vast majority of correspondence with Uncle Sam is done via USPS.
• philipdlang 15y ago
  Really interesting, but a correction should be noted: CC is for courtesy copy, not carbon copy
  • shanselman 15y ago
    Ah, I did not know that!
    • shanselman 15y ago
      Interesting, I did a little looking and it seems it means both. http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc733 http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc733 indicates carbon for BCC. It may be a backronym as Wikipedia mentions.
      • tallpapab 15y ago
        Ironic that you refer to an RFC. CC was used in correspondence long before internets and RFCs (as was BCC). It meant "carbon copy" just as you said originally. This is a bit like updating an icon. The icon (actually acronym) was left unchanged and someone thought to call it "courtesy copy" because they must have thought carbon copies obsolete and confusing. Actually, I don't know the genesis of the term "courtesy copy", but I'm pretty sure it was an update. Sorry this whole rambling note is further evidence that old people (and their icons) don't make sense anymore.
  • epo 15y ago
    Citation required, my understanding is that CC predates emails and would designate those to whom carbon copies were to be sent.
    • brlewis 15y ago
      It definitely predates emails. I'm 44 and I've always heard "carbon copy", never "courtesy copy". http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=cc http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=cc http://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/carbon-copy.html http://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/carbon-copy.html
• wtvanhest 15y ago
  Back in my day we didn't care what the icons looked like. I had to use a mouse with hard to move wheel to scroll all the way across a 10 inch screen! And I liked it! The entire internet was AOL! It took 30 minutes from the time you turned on the computer to the time you loaded your first website. That is when you got all your thinking done!
  • tallpapab 15y ago
    Oh yeah? I'm so old that my mouse was hairy and used to squeak and vomit when I squeezed it.
• the_mat 15y ago
  He missed the point of the Instagram logo. The whole purpose of Instagram is to make retro-styled photos, so a retro camera icon makes total sense.
• moocow01 15y ago
  The problem is that if we modernized most of our iconography, a heck of a lot of things won't be able to be represented simply with something distinctive enough. This is largely due to what I'll call the merging of things into the same form largely driven by computing. For example... Icon for a phone - rectangular screen Icon for a TV - rectangular screen Icon for a tablet - rectangular screen Icon for a camera - rectangular screen (with a little dot in the corner) Icon for a video recorder - rectangular screen (with a little dot in the corner) Its true that most icons refer and represent a visual form of something from a decade or more ago. But what do you replace them with that will be any better when a lot of these things have no distinctive visual form anymore?
  • shanselman 15y ago
    Exactly, I suspect there is nothing we can replace it with. A TV with rabbit ears will always be a TV - perhaps a hundred years from now?
    • jreeve 15y ago
      This reminds me very much of how the genesis of ideographic writing (such as Chinese characters) was related to me. I'm not at all certain that it is correct, but gist of it was that these forms of writing start with illustrations but gradually become encoded over time.
      • 1337p337 15y ago
        Not only that, but the author also seems annoyed by older terminology taking new meanings, as with "radio buttons", "bookmarks", and "folders". The irony here is that he has no problem calling the device he uses a "computer", despite the older definition no longer holding true, or especially referring to "files", which is certainly not a term used in the old sense. Dijkstra's "On the Cruelty of Really Teaching Computer Science" rails against analogies (the source of these terms) at length, but I'm not certain that there's much validity to the argument when the new meaning of the term eclipses the old one.
      • 15y ago
• tomflack 15y ago
  This is awfully condescending towards people in their twenties and younger. > Want to indicate Settings or Setup to a twenty something? Show them a tool they've never used in their lives. > If you don't know who Johnny Carson is, how could you know that this is a old-style microphone? > No one under 30 has seen a Polaroid in years but we keep using them for icons. We don't live in a cultural vacuum where everything that existed prior to our birth ceases to exist or be represented. We watch old movies, we watch old TV, we read old books and we see old photographs. Some things go missing and some things stick around. The icons that stop having a useful meaning will either disappear or be transformed and some icons will come to be a somewhat abstract representation of what they do, even if they're based on things that existed in the past. I don't understand people's obsession with telling everyone they should modernize their icons - if you think so, then you should do it. See how your users react.
  • jmsduran 15y ago
    Actually, I find the article quite funny and thought provoking. It makes you wonder how long icons like these will remain the norm, and if they'll ever change.
  • davidjohnstone 15y ago
    I didn't like the post as much as I expected to. The floppy disk as an icon for save is a legitimate complaint, in the sense that it is early technology that has been deprecated by later technology, and [almost] nobody will ever use one again. That said, good luck finding a new icon. The difficulty is that the concept of "saving" only came about with computers, and unlike zooming or even grouping things together in folders, finding a real-life pictorial representation of saving is... difficult. But the others... The last time I checked, bookmarks, calendars, envelopes, magnifying glasses, and screwdrivers all exist in the real world and are used regularly by a lot of people, and they aren't going to go away any time soon. Also, it's not hard to find microphones today that look a lot like the one in the icon.
    • DanBC 15y ago
      I'm glad we're using a floppy disk rather than the alternative (dead now) "piggy bank". Imagine how confused most people are seeing a tiny pig in the tool bar. It's an effort to get from "little pig" to "piggy bank" to "save". And that's for people with english as a first language.
• josephcooney 15y ago
  There was a discussion on Reddit about this a few days ago: http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/t4z2o/the_save_icon_is_a_floppy_disk_and_everyone_still/ http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/t4z2o/the_save_ic... As pointed out by Mike Kazarnowicz in the comments of Scott's post. Coincidence or cherry-picking?
  • shanselman 15y ago
    Coincidence. We had been tweeting about this a few days ago and many of the ideas were from my followers. Then my coworker Pete showed me his 2008 post on the topic http://10rem.net/blog/2008/11/18/when-will-the-floppy-disk-die-as-a-save-icon http://10rem.net/blog/2008/11/18/when-will-the-floppy-disk-d... and later after I wrote it, the StackOverflow question http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1019573/save-icon-still-a-floppy-disk http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1019573/save-icon-still-a...
• damian2000 15y ago
  I believe this post to be the definitive authority on the subject of dead icons ... ;-) http://ux.stackexchange.com/questions/3117/save-icon-is-the-floppy-disk-icon-dead http://ux.stackexchange.com/questions/3117/save-icon-is-the-... seriously - there's some good points made here, including: "The floppy disk icon is an idiom, not a metaphor. It doesn't matter that we're no longer writing files on 1.44MB 3.5" disks. It doesn't matter that many users don't even know what a floppy disk is. What matters is that users associate the icon with saving." -- Patrick McElhaney
• Tloewald 15y ago
  Icons are becoming dead metaphors, which is fine. We pick concrete concepts to represent abstract processes and eventually the concrete concept becomes obsolete. This is exactly what happens with language -- should we stop using the word "deadline" because we've forgotten what it used to mean before it became a metaphor for a due date?
  • twelvechairs 15y ago
    I agree completely. Just because the original uses have stopped being so common doesn't mean the icons are bad now. In language terms, you could compare this to street names - very few people would know why the street they live on is named that way - its just useful that it has a name so people can find it.
• paulsutter 15y ago
  Great thought provoking article. A general tone of "isn't this interesting" rather than "isn't this stupid", might reduce the negative reactions. It never occurred to me before that the use of physical objects for software functionality may be transitory. Clearly these icons do work today (and their use is not stupid), but it's probably a matter of time that a new approach may be needed.
  • shanselman 15y ago
    Thanks, that is a good point. I was aiming for "isn't this silly" but your point is well taken.
    • tallpapab 15y ago
      Clearly a thought provoking article none the less.
• DavidSJ 15y ago
  Icons are visual words, and like words, they have a history (etymology) which is often long forgotten. But even with their history lost, they become familiar as identifiers of a concept, and so we keep them for that reason.
• TorbjornLunde 15y ago
  Icons don’t have to make sense if people can learn them. I think people are being way to hung up on things being too skeuomorphic. Remember that A didn’t start as an A, it started as a sign for ox. That’s right, our writing system had skeuomorphic origins. Someone growing up today might not know what a handset it, but I’m pretty sure they recognize the handset icon. This is true for a lot of stuff in our culture (think of non-textual road signs).
• jacobr 15y ago
  The clone action in VirtualBox is represented by a sheep (http://twitpic.com/767oui http://twitpic.com/767oui). Took me a while to connect it with Dolly the sheep, but now it's both distinct and funny.
  • ranit8 15y ago
    I can't believe I had used CloneDVD for such a long time without connecting its icon to Dolly. I feel so dumb.
• epaga 15y ago
  I thought Hanselman's tweet made the point far better than the entire article because the article very quickly became quite the stretch trying to find examples: overlooking the fact that many, many people are still using dead-tree calendars, folders, and clipboards. As well as binoculars and magnifying glasses. The really interesting point - that there are more and more icons that truly are becoming "icons" in a more metaphorical sense of the word - was already made quite poignantly by the tweet.
• harisenbon 15y ago
  Great premise, no so great execution. Other that the floppy icon, which I do agree with, the others are either not icons (radio buttons are just circles -- radio buttons just happen to be what they're called) or show use items that are still in very common usage.
• smutticus 15y ago
  iconic -- executed according to a convention or tradition (reference.com) Isn't the whole idea of updating traditions a little silly. They're traditions. We don't follow them because they make sense. We follow them because the people before us followed them. 100 years from now we'll still need a symbol to conceptualize saving something. The other ones might go away but we'll probably still need to save our work. I expect the floppy to still symbolize this. The users at the time will not understand what a floppy is. But unless there is good reason to upend convention why bother. Just look at all the linguistic idioms we retain from yesteryear. I don't have any axe to grind with icons. But tradition is nothing to sneeze at. Remember, a picture is worth a thousand words.
  • epo 15y ago
    Absolutely, icons are... iconic. The whole point is that we know what they mean, not they are a literal representation of the object or concept being designated.
• stretchwithme 15y ago
  We started using horsepower to describe how much power an engine has and that has nothing to do with horses. And last I heard, many of us are still measuring things in feet. Conventions hang on for generations because speaking a common language is more important than being up to date.
  • ssdsa 15y ago
    Well, horsepower has absolutely something to do with horses: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horsepower http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horsepower "Horsepower was originally defined to compare the output of steam engines with the power of draft horses in continuous operation."
    • stretchwithme 15y ago
      Yes, of course. I meant horses have nothing to do with engines. Nobody today is going to compare the power of a car to what they know about horses.
• drewmclellan 15y ago
  What's really interesting is that a lot of these rudiments (save, open, copy, paste, print) simply do not require icons in modern software. I can't remember the last time I saw a save icon in any of the software I use. Not because saving has gone away, but because it's so fundamental to document-based applications that it doesn't need a dedicated button to call it out, and having one just wastes space. Saving isn't special functionality requiring an icon - you either use File>Save, or Cmd/Ctrl-S, or even just close the document and follow the prompt to save. Copy, paste, open, these things don't need to take up valuable interface space as if they're some novelty functionality that uses must carefully be introduced to. We don't need a new save icon, because we don't need a save icon at all.
• zerostar07 15y ago
  That's not something limited to computers or technology. Many entities are represented with an icon of the first or first popular iteration of am item. A train has smoke, lights are bulbs, authors use feather pens etc. One could argue that it's actually faster to parse words than icons sometimes (don't know what traffic sign planners would think about that)
• slavak 15y ago
  I think some of those are pushing it quite a bit... Printed books aren't going anywhere in the foreseeable future (and I'm pretty sure all young people know what they are, even if they're not really into reading); the (Exchange-connected VoIP) phone on my desk at the office still has a handset shaped exactly like the icon; and what kind of magical sci-fi world does the author live in where no mechanical device requires gears any more, or where wrenches aren't necessary for basic home repairs?
• drewmclellan 15y ago
  I was fascinated that Google chose the name "Google Drive" for their latest product. Without a hint of false naivety, my initial thought on hearing the name was that it was either: a) Something to do with journey planning/directions, or b) Some new in-car technology When I saw it was neither of those, I presumed the cloud storage service had been named in the same way razors are named, i.e. "puts you in the driving seat" sort of thing. It was only several hours later did it occur to me that, OMG, they mean like a FLOPPY DISK DRIVE? Yikes. "Drive" is not really a word I've heard used in relation to storage for years. Mainly because we only think about the distinction between disk and drive when the two can be parted, like a floppy disk drive. Put the disk in the drive. Most removable media is USB-based these days, so the term isn't used. I guess in 1990s-era Windows NT networks you'd be told to save your work to "the M: drive" or such, but yeah, 1990s. To me it's a moronic product name. "I'll save that to my Google Drive!" Sure thing, you do that Grandpa.
  • GreenNight 15y ago
    I too thought about their car technologies, but to me it doesn't mean drive like a floppy disk drive, it means drive as in hard disk drive (HDD). Google Storage would have been a more descriptive name, but it'll be a while until we get rid of our C: and D: drives.
  • tallpapab 15y ago
    Actually, there were also hard disk drives. The drive was the motor attached to a spindle which would spin the disk whether the disk was floppy or hard. Your point still holds that spinning media are starting to be replaced by solid state devices. I agree that Google made a poor choice with the name. BTW the word drive goes back further than motors. It was and still is the term to cause sheep and draught animals to move where you wanted them to go. Still not great for Google's product.
• Mordor 15y ago
  Conversely, how about redesigning them for something older...
• TekNoir 15y ago
  It doesn't matter what the icons look like as long as they are different enough from each other to be recognizable. Someone who hasn't used a computer before isn't going to know that a floppy disk icon means save, even if they have seen a one before and know what it is used for. For all they know it's means open a file.
• nsns 15y ago
  That's exactly the way culture gets built, there are always traces left from past generations - not only in icons, more so in the software and technology they assist. These traces, sources forgotten, slowly turn into obscure quotes, then become alive with their own new meaning, and act as channels for the transfer of knowledge from one generation to another. And a little OT remark about the so called "dead tree format" - it helps hide the fact that e-books might actually be more harmful to the planet than "dead tree" ones (think carbon imprint).
• andyjohnson0 15y ago
  I thought that the article did a good job of explaining the problem of changes in the world making things change appearance or shape, but not some other causes of icons not making sense. To me, icons indicating actions (save, print, etc) work well when they depict (wholly or partly) a physical object that is obviously used to enact that action. I assume that this is because our visual cortex is tuned to recognise physical objects that do actions, not visual representations of actions themselves. We see a depiction of a hammer and know that its for driving nails, but its hard to depict driving nails without depicting a hammer. You could presumably do it (i'm not a graphic designer) but you're making people work harder to understand your depiction. The problem is that sometimes changes in the world result in the recognisable physical object no-longer being recognisable and/or physical. This can happen we make an action abstract ("save to floppy" becomes "save to cloud storage"), virtualise an action ("pick up phone and talk" becomes "make skype call using laptop"), or merge a once-external object into a multi-function object ("save to floppy" becomes "save to internal disk"). (What others have I missed?) I don't know what to do about this. You could use a logo or graphical device/convention to indicate actions (e.g. skype logo indicates make a voice call) but you're also increasing the cognitive load on the user of the interface and increasing visual clutter.
  • Angostura 15y ago
    Since we are still going with file and folder, why not make the metaphor complete and go with a filing cabinet with an arrow either directed towards or away from an open drawer.
• RyanMcGreal 15y ago
  In the 1800s, broadcasting meant standing in the field and throwing seeds in every direction. We've been adapting old idioms to new uses since long before everything turned into a computer.
  • tallpapab 15y ago
    Nice. Learned something.
• npsimons 15y ago
  Oh man, not another one of these "durr, icons are based on technologies that don't apply anymore!" articles. Tell you what, you invent "better" more "modern" icons that everyone can recognize and then maybe I'll be willing to read your blogarrhea.
• napierzaza 15y ago
  So every icon should be a computer chip now? People will still know what a folder is for some time into the future, so I don't think the icon of a directory tree would do them any good in place of it. Maybe files should be leaves and folders can be trees? And bookmarks can be text "<A href>". This would not be a nightmare.
• fforw 15y ago
  Actually, my TV has rabbit ears again -- only they're for DVB-T now.
• blt 15y ago
  That pointy gear icon on iOS drives me crazy. Gear teeth don't look like that!
• debacle 15y ago
  Google is a good example of what happens when you modernize icons - no one knows what the hell is going on. The old icons are fine.