7 ms·
Amazon blocks long-running FireTV capability, Breaking apps with no warning
- bonyt 3y agoInteresting, they’re not disabling adb. It sounds like they’re just disabling the ability for apps on the device to connect to adb on localhost and run (e.g.) shell commands that way.
- xyzzy_plugh 3y agoAIUI this is also the case in "upstream" Android but apps like Shizuku work around it, and those workarounds seem like they'd transfer fine to FireTV.
- bdavbdav 3y agoYes I was worried when I started reading, was assuming they’d pulled ADB altogether. This isn’t quite such a big deal (to me at least)
- MBCook 3y ago“While it’s not a capability used by many Fire TV apps, without it, Fire TV apps can no longer perform certain advanced tasks, such as freeing up internal storage space by clearing the cache of all installed apps” That seems like a failure of the OS. Why should apps have to force that? So what else does it do? That’s the only example in the entire article. It’s not clear to me at all why this is necessary other than “I already had it so don’t take it away”.
- supertrope 3y agoWhen devices ship with 8GB of storage, average users may or may not follow system prompts to free up storage on an ad hoc basis. (This is analogous to 16GB iPhones and constantly having to free up space). More savvy users can figure out that FireTV is Android compatible and use adb as a power tool. Or just buy a different streaming device that doesn't run at 75% storage full after installing YouTube and Netflix.
- MBCook 3y agoBut none of that should be necessary. Caches should be managed by the system. If they get too big the system should empty some of it. Giving the user a prompt is a bandaid on the OS failing to do its job.
- roneythomas6 3y agoIt does. But cache clearing only goes to a certain point after that it will stop you from updating apps and installing new apps, until you free up space by uninstalling an app.
- MBCook 3y agoThat I understand. That’s a user caused issue, it’s fair to ask the user a question. Or you could provide a feature like iOS where unused apps are unloaded automatically (if enabled). But the user should never have to manually manage cache space.
- roneythomas6 3y agoUser never has to manage cache space which has always been the case. Also your normal user cannot do that, without system level privileges. Third party apps where to able to call adb directly on FireTV which is not the case on other Android devices with GMS. In fact if you build Android with access for third party to call adb, Google will never let you pass CTS and you cannot have Google Play on it. It’s a huge misstep from security point for Amazon sell devices with adb access for third party apps.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoDon't even get me started on Samsung's Nexus S, which is partitioned into 1 Go "internal" and 15 Go "external" space with a bunch of apps being extremely annoying about insisting on being installed in "internal" space only...
- mvdtnz 3y agoBecause users want to do it. It's absolutely none of your (or Amazon's) business why. How did we ever get into this bizarre situation where supposed "tech people" are questioning whether basic functionality should even exist? This billion dollar company is not your friend.
- MBCook 3y agoUsers want to do what? That was my question. What useful thing does this allow besides the single example in the article? And if you don’t want to be beholden to a billion dollar company, maybe don’t buy suspiciously under priced hardware from them that is obviously subsidized by their ad/service empire? And again, I contend this is not basic functionality. The example in the article isn’t basic functionality, it’s a bandaid on a broken OS.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoStorage and memory management is basic functionality. OSes universally suck at this. Partly because they can't predict the future and are mostly reactive in their behavior. Partly because they can't reason. The user can.
- mvdtnz 3y ago>Users want to do what? That was my question NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS!
- notatoad 3y ago>Why should apps have to force that? it's not clear that they do, or that this functionality is necessary or helpful in any way. "cache-clearing" apps have always been popular on android, and they range in effectiveness from being useless to being actual scams. but people like to push buttons to feel as though they're optimizing performance somehow.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoPerhaps because to this day, Android refuses to provide the basic, fundamental, user-facing feature of making a process go down and stay down. All we get instead are lame excuses about complexity of battery management or such other nonsense, despite all the reluctantly added battery optimization functions are all nerfed versions of regular task manager.
- charcircuit 3y agoIt's called uninstalling. The whole point of having an app installed is so that its activities / services can run or other apps can use the providers and services it has. For apps on the system partition settings will let you disable the app which will have a similar effect.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoNo, the whole point of having an app installed is to have an icon you can tap to bring up said app when you need it. Same way as with desktop: installing != running.
- MBCook 3y agoBut the example wasn’t about apps not running when the user didn’t want them, it was about wasted cache space.
- bhaney 3y agoOn something as locked down as a FireTV, I'm surprised debug functionality like this was available at all.
- roneythomas6 3y agoIs FireTV even locked? FireTV is the most popular Android stick for STB emulator apps.
- PlutoIsAPlanet 3y agoYou can install APKs and use ADB over USB.
- 1shooner 3y agoTangentially: Is there a FireTV implementation that is anywhere near e.g. Apple TV in basic performance? Every FireTV device I have used has seemed practically unusable, but it could be there is just a low bar for what hardware they let go to market.
- PlutoIsAPlanet 3y agoNah, most Android TV sticks and boxes (bar Nvidia) ship with underpowered chipsets that lack the raw performance to render smoothly at 4K, using HW acceleration to at least get acceptable video decode performance. Apple, being in control of the software and hardware, has better optimisation, as well as imho, a more fluid animation system on their OS.
- jwells89 3y agoThe stick and dongle streaming device variants in particular are astonishingly weak. The current Chromecast 4K dongle for example is handily outgunned by a first gen Apple TV 4K, which this year will be a 7 year old device.
- mh- 3y agoWow, thanks for pointing that out - didn't realize I'd had these ATV 4Ks since 2017. They feel a bit sluggish.. probably just that everything else got faster. Time to upgrade.
- me551ah 3y agoWhy would anyone even use a Fire TV compared to other alternatives. It's a giant ad screen on your TV.
- muppetman 3y agoThey're cheap.
- mr_mitm 3y agoAnd you can sideload apps. If you put Kodi in it, it's just one click to avoid all the ads.
- tuna74 3y agoYou can install Kodi from the Play store on an Android TV device.
- barrkel 3y agoWhat is an Android TV device? Is that distinct from the FireTV? I plug my FireTV Cube into my projector. It has some kind of smart TV functionality and a second remote to go with it, but it's on a dongle and I don't plug it in because I don't use it.
- epcoa 3y agoIronically, name one better for convenient (so, not Apple TV) 4K HDR Sponsorblock capable YouTube near that price point or really any price point unless you’re going the HTPC route. Form factor is also a consideration. The FireTV would not be the only media device in my setup but it serves a purpose.
- sys_64738 3y agoI bought one as a basic TV and media player but never connect it to wifi. It's actually not too bad as it's a 32" LCD I bought for 80 bucks.
- 3y ago
- charcircuit 3y agoAllowing apps to use adb breaks the security model. Apps should only be able to run code as their own user. Any capabilities these apps need should be properly provided by an API for them to use instead of using such a hack.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoBeen a long long time that Amazon has basically been good for consumers, done well enough. Amazon Video for Prime getting worse was a signficant first ding (loss of hdr, ads). Now the appliances getting worse... This is like the mega trend, of massively profitable huge companies decimating their workforces, of the world being squeezed tighter.
- xerxesaa 3y agoThere's even a word for it. It's called "enshittification" https://www.ft.com/content/6fb1602d-a08b-4a8c-bac0-047b7d64aba5 https://www.ft.com/content/6fb1602d-a08b-4a8c-bac0-047b7d64a...
- acka 3y ago> ‘Enshittification’ is coming for absolutely everything > Padlock icon > Subscribe to unlock this article This. I couldn't have written a better exemplifying summary. Anyway, guess it's off to the depaywallification service then.
- ipython 3y agoNot surprising. Amazon is terrible at delivering consumer apps. The Apple TV prime video app freezes often, then after they added ads, the app now actively prevents you from muting them! You can mute during an ad, but then the app will immediately turn the volume back up. It’s straight out of black mirror.
- foepys 3y agoNot to mention that on all devices I used the official Prime Video app (yes, even Fire TV Sticks), there we massive audio latency issues up to the point where I stopped watching. On FireTV Netflix had also lagging behind audio, which it never did on any other platform. I am talking about a like 1 second delay here, not 50ms (which is already not good). Amazon doesn't care about the viewer/user experience. It is always a disaster.
- hmeh 3y agoI appreciate people taking the time to write articles like this, but please consider the people who are going to read it. ADB is an acronym. Not everyone knows what it means. If you're going to write an entire article about a feature being removed, please at least describe the feature in a way that people can understand without having to google it so that they can have an idea as to whether or not this is relevant to them.
- xref 3y agoAndroid Debug Bridge, for future readers
- dhosek 3y agoI was thinking Apple Desktop Bus. Obviously dating myself.
- greenyoda 3y ago"adb" was also the name of the debugger in early versions of UNIX. I remember using it in Version 7: https://www.unix.com/man-page/v7/1/adb/ https://www.unix.com/man-page/v7/1/adb/
- shermantanktop 3y agoI always mentally converted it to: Android De Bugger Does that make sense? No. But that’s what I subliminally assumed it must mean.
- lubutu 3y agoIt does make sense — the Unix debugger has always been *db, with no bridges in sight. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Debugger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Debugger
- sp332 3y ago"adb" is the name of the executable. Expanding the acronym isn't that relevant. It wpuld be like explaining that KDE stands for Kommon Desktop Environment.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mavsman 3y agoFun fact, I recently bought an Apple TV that I connect to my FireTV. Amazon video is nearly unwatchable on the FireTV unless I switch the input to the Apple TV and watch it there.
- PlutoIsAPlanet 3y agoI mean, sounds like these apps were using a feature to do something it was not designed for, can't really complain that Amazon plugs the hole.
- gagabity 3y agoProbably people are using adb to disable ads or something? Amazon has indicated that they are creating their own TV OS in Rust running ReactNative Apps and going away from Android although it might take a few years.
- afavour 3y ago> Amazon has indicated that they are creating their own TV OS in Rust running ReactNative Apps What an incredible unholy combination that doesn’t exist anywhere else. Between this and Roku it video app developers in jobs, I guess.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoAmazon broke customizing branded buttons, took away Prime Video, and now this. Dumped FireTV for Apple TV. Much nicer experience overall except for a lack of related content in major apps.
- extraduder_ire 3y agoSurprised nobody's developed a custom rom for these things, since I've seen so many other random cheap android devices get custom roms on the xda site.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoI don't see how that would work. Although there was adb access, they weren't rooted. Note you can add a microusb USB hub, other USB devices including external storage, and Ethernet to most Fire TVs regardless.
- pushedx 3y agoIn the Android security model, this is not a capability that should have ever been provided to apps to begin with. It allows for apps to have almost free reign over the filesystem of other apps (read, write, modify), among other powerful capabilities. No flagship Android phones on the market allow this. It would be like if the Facebook app on your iOS device could read all of the files of your banking app, or notes app. It's just not something that is enabled in any Android system claiming to have some level of security.
- PEDRO0147 3y agoIt is heartbreaking and very disappointing to feel not loved and appreciated enough because if you are loved and appreciated enough by your partner there will be no need for her to cheat and give any attention to any man other than yourself, I felt this way for so many years without knowing what to do and I couldn't leave her because there was no concrete evidence to back up the feelings I had and none of my families believed me when I told them I think my wife was seeing someone else so I was determined to prove it, I went searching online on how to hack or spy my wife phone without her knowing then I saw a lot of people recommending Marie as the best in the game well I wasted no time in contacting via on (MARIECONSULTANCYOZ@GMAIL.COM and INSTAGRAM :MARIE_CONSULTANCY) and she gave me full access to her phone I was able to get the evidence needed
- oefrha 3y agoYeah, it’s amusing that the author simultaneously claims that (a) it’s a “core OS capability”; (b) it’s a developer debugging capability gated behind so many hoops that it can’t be abused (which is of course nonsense because even though each connection needs to be approved, the app allegedly only clearing other apps’ cache could be doing any number of evil things after the approval). These are incompatible claims. You can fundamentally disagree with the Android security and isolation model, but if you were okay with it before this update, then the arguments presented are just an incoherent mess.
- barnabee 3y agoWith my permission an app should be able to read all the files on the device, even those created by other apps. It’s my device not the OS or app manufacturer’s! I’m totally onboard with per-app segregated storage as a default, but this feature is clearly gated behind user permission.
- dan-0 3y ago> all under the, seemingly false, guise of enhanced security. Maybe just me, but this became excruciatingly hard to read after this. At this point, I don't know what they're talking about, but they're implying something being done for security reasons is wrong without an understanding of the problem and it's already sounding like a rant. That was before even mentioning the feature is adb, which yes, that is a security concern because you can bypass Android's security model. Why that's been open for so long in the first place is an even bigger story IMO. Regardless these app and cache killer apps are at best barely useful and often scams. This functionality is handled by the OS on its own. And it should still be possible to kill apps and clear caches manually from the device settings if needed.
- KaiserPro 3y agoSide note: I have recently moved away from Firetv stick, because it was unreliable. The product idea was great, a <$50 device that gave you access to all the media you could want. Bonus there were apps and games. However in practice its a deeply unreliable product thats deeply frustrating to use. It appears that not even amazon targets the stick for optimisation, as even the home screen is exceptionally slow. Moreover it looses network connection frequently, but doesn't tell you. So you need to reboot the stick, but that takes an age because often there is some sort of memory leak causing the whole device to crawl. Updates appear to be optimised to happen during use of your apps. The virtual remote is deeply unreliable (and has been for years) I didn't realise how bad it was until I tried a friend's apple TV. Much as it annoys me to admit, the apple TV, whilst twice the price (although its now more expensive) is 8 times the product.
- lakpan 3y agoThe Apple TV is an Apple product, with all the pros and cons that carries, but the Fire stick honestly feels like a low quality knockoff of a knockoff.
- genericacct 3y agoAgreed, the latest SW release is unbearably slow, I've started moving to cheap rk boxes.
- moritzwarhier 3y agoReading this I'm glad having chosen Chromecast w Google TV last week for my new "dumb tv". I didn't have the opportunity to try Fire stick but slowness and an unpolished UI what I was fearing. Google TV otoh has a polished interface, supports all streaming services and the remote can control your TV as well. Can recommend. Despite being an Apple user who bought into the ecosystem, I don't like any of their offerings in the media streaming space. Too expensive, too much lock-in, catalogues too small.
- interpol_p 3y agoI bought a FireTV stick for the lesser-used TV, having been accustomed to the Apple TV in the main room. It was cheap, and seemed to do all the stuff The software was horrible: * Highlight a search field, think you can use Alexa to dictate text? No, it'll just do a regular Alexa query. AppleTV gets this right: if you're on a text field, the mic button will just activate dictation to enter text * Screensaver comes on, exit screensaver, also exits currently playing show back to the screen where you have to hit resume * Slow, janky UI built with zero love I felt bad when I eventually gave it away to my mum, who had a very early gen AppleTV that could not run Disney+. I felt so bad about inflicting the FireTV experience on her that I soon bought her a new AppleTV to replace it
- bogwog 3y ago> While it’s an unpopular opinion, I see nothing wrong with Amazon protecting its Fire TV revenue by stopping the use of alternative home screens. It’s crucial to the business model Amazon has chosen to use for the Fire TV and if customers don’t like it, they don’t have to buy one. Why are some people like this? I would assume fanboyism is the answer, but this isn't Apple. If a business chooses a flawed business model, they should fail. Consumers should always go for what benefits them the most, not make sacrifices to try and protect a business. If the business is unsustainable, it should die so that actual sustainable business can take its place. If Amazon based their business model for FireTV around homescreen ads, yet customers found a way to easily get around them, then Amazon chose a stupid business model and should face the consequences. Crippling the product with a software update is an action that is harmful to customers, and should be illegal.