5 ms·
AI Determines Sex of Person from Brain Scans
- isaacfrond 3y agoI can't find the paper. Can you?
- andy99 3y ago> This breakthrough supports the theory that significant sex differences in brain organization exist, challenging long-standing controversies. It doesn't, because there is no explanation for how it determines the difference. It's just as likely some confounding thing that's not causally based on the brain, like all these other "AI can tell" studies that don't identify an actual mechanism. That said I'm surprised that we can't tell men and women apart from the brain. I would have assumed there would be some differences that would make it obvious at least for the average brain. It's more surprising to find they are indistinguishable.
- Spivak 3y agoIt's in the article. > Until recently, a model like the one Menon’s team employed would help researchers sort brains into different groups but wouldn’t provide information about how the sorting happened. Today, however, researchers have access to a tool called “explainable AI,” which can sift through vast amounts of data to explain how a model’s decisions are made. > Using explainable AI, Menon and his team identified the brain networks that were most important to the model’s judgment of whether a brain scan came from a man or a woman. They found the model was most often looking to the default mode network, striatum, and the limbic network to make the call. What's more fascinating it that it's not just a parlor trick and actually can be "validated" in some sense by doing a cognition test for just that part of the brain and observing the differences. So the model said "check here and you'll see a difference," and apparently, they did. > They developed sex-specific models of cognitive abilities: One model effectively predicted cognitive performance in men but not women, and another in women but not men. The findings indicate that functional brain characteristics varying between sexes have significant behavioral implications. > “These models worked really well because we successfully separated brain patterns between sexes,” Menon said. “That tells me that overlooking sex differences in brain organization could lead us to miss key factors underlying neuropsychiatric disorders.”
- ashleyn 3y ago> “These models worked really well because we successfully separated brain patterns between sexes,” Menon said. “That tells me that overlooking sex differences in brain organization could lead us to miss key factors underlying neuropsychiatric disorders.” Although never demonstrated, it's always been most intuitive to me that sex-related brain differences underlie gender dysphoria. I would feel exceptionally relieved and vindicated to finally have some objective, falsifiable observation to point at that suggests the reality of dysphoria.
- Spivak 3y agoI love that idea! Honestly even if it doesn't show up as a sex-difference doing this same trick might be nonetheless fruitful by asking it to predict say cis woman / trans man.
- at_a_remove 3y agoAh, but this is science. How would you feel if it were not vindicated? What if it were not a matter of "born that way"? Plus, there's a whole ton of confounding business we'll have to look out for. Just off the top of my head, you've got certainty intervals. And wouldn't it be prudent to at least examine the effects of various hormones like testosterone, dihydrotestosterone, estradiol, progesterone on the brain? Say, post age twenty five, pre age twenty five. And so on. Might exist, might not. We're a long way from being able to have much certainty at all.
- spondylosaurus 3y agoI would be shocked if hormones didn't have some effect on the brain considering how much of an effect they have everywhere else. Hell, I know some people who take the "brain sex" angle re. transness speculate that varying levels of hormonal exposure in utero could be what causes gender dysphoria post-utero... in which case, would adult endogenous hormones be responsible for brain structures, or would brain structure dictate which kind of hormones your body expects?
- 3y ago
- spacebanana7 3y ago> It doesn't, because there is no explanation for how it determines the difference I don’t think an explanation is required for this. I should be able to state that two species have a different lifespan based on a difference in mean age of death - without needing to provide any specific biological mechanism in my study. Substitute that mean for a linear regression / neural network and the species lifespan for some vector of brain organisation to get the results in the article.
- biomcgary 3y agoMales are known to have larger brains by volume (https://www.news-medical.net/news/20210326/Size-is-the-only-difference-between-male-and-female-brains-shows-study.aspx https://www.news-medical.net/news/20210326/Size-is-the-only-...). If this is the only explanatory variable doing the work, the AI model is completely uninteresting.
- AgentOrange1234 3y agoI was thinking about this too, but I don’t know how widely they overlap? Like, if (say) 30% of male brains are at least 10% smaller than the average male brain, and 30% of female brains are at least 10% larger than the average female brain, then a model that just considered volume might not be very accurate at all, because anything in the middle still has a significant chance of being either sex?
- karpierz 3y ago> I should be able to state that two species have a different lifespan based on a difference in mean age of death - without needing to provide any specific biological mechanism in my study. You need to control for confounders. For example, if I told you: - Mean lifespan of species 1 is: 3 years - Mean lifespan of species 2 is: 10 years Does that mean that species 2 has a longer lifespan than species 1? What happens when you find out that species 1 is domesticated cattle, which has (almost) all of its males slaughtered at age 2? You could then say "I meant for two species that are in controlled conditions", but now you need to define what conditions you're controlling, which implies what casual mechanisms you're controlling for.
- coldtea 3y ago>It doesn't, because there is no explanation for how it determines the difference. You don't need to know the mechanism to prove that it "supports the theory that there is a difference in brain organization". If there wasn't a difference, it wouldn't be able to find it. >It's just as likely some confounding thing that's not causally based on the brain Given that it does it's identification by looking at the brain, whatever the cause is, it is ALSO manifested as a "difference in brain organization". >That said I'm surprised that we can't tell men and women apart from the brain. Who said we can't? The article points to that we can. And there are other brain attributes besides organization we can use to tell them apart, the biggest being size, including size of certain structures.
- refulgentis 3y agoI’m reminded of the tale of a similar breakthrough, and upon ablation, it was found to be indexing on a particular artifact found on one X-ray machine. Or maybe the patient name? Anyways, would recommend some caution, there’s no reason to believe there’s some obvious fundamental difference in brain organization that we can’t see ourselves, until the research is a bit further along :)
- jfoutz 3y agoAI research is old. There's an (apocryphal?) 30 year old tale about using computer vision to detect tanks. All the photos of tanks had clouds in the sky. And few to none of the counter examples had clouds. So darpa paid for an expensive cloud detector. Without more information about the study, I'm guessing there's a 'M' or 'F' stamped on the image somewhere. _edit_ Ah - https://gwern.net/tank https://gwern.net/tank the tank story
- mplewis9z 3y ago> Given that it does it's identification by looking at the brain, whatever the cause is, it is ALSO manifested as a "difference in brain organization". I think the person you’re responding to is talking about confounding factors _outside_ the brain scan, like when a model that could identify skin cancer used the presence of a ruler as its most weighted input: https://venturebeat.com/business/when-ai-flags-the-ruler-not-the-tumor-and-other-arguments-for-abolishing-the-black-box-vb-live/ https://venturebeat.com/business/when-ai-flags-the-ruler-not... This is a huge problem in medical use for AI - you have non-technical medical professionals influencing the data used to train the model, and introducing biases in the data that the model is learning from.
- karaterobot 3y ago> That said I'm surprised that we can't tell men and women apart from the brain. According to the article, we can.
- throwaway49849 3y agoI believe this is a clue to where the GP post is coming from: we can't, therefore the study must be flawed.
- miracle2k 3y ago> I believe this is a clue to where the GP post is coming from: we can't, therefore the study must be flawed. How so? They are clearly saying they expected this to be possible already, until this article claimed otherwise (by suggesting AI is contributing something new here). They are saying that this result will not resolve the disputes, because it doesn't address the core thing in dispute: that there are meaningful differences that people actually care about. For example, maybe it is possible to tell the sex based on the shape of the brain. This doesn't mean that men and woman think differently, which is what people are actually arguing about. And the AI in this study can't proof that, because it doesn't give us any further insights into how cognition works. This point strikes me as actually pretty mundane and obviously correct. The fact that 5 people immediately seem to have misunderstood it (as in, they are not responding to the argument) seems to tell us something about their priors instead.
- throwaway49849 3y ago>They are saying that this result will not resolve the disputes, because it doesn't address the core thing in dispute: that there are meaningful differences that people actually care about. That's not their claim. Their claim is that there is some flaw ("confounding thing") in the study. They then go on to say that men and women's brains are "indistinguishable." Well, of course you will automatically assume there is a flaw if that is your belief.
- archagon 3y agoThrowaway accounts posting pointless snipes should be banned.
- yeknoda 3y agoThere’s some linear and obvious differences like the brain volume. Don’t need ai for that lol. I think I remember that it’s a 20% average difference. Downvote me please
- PeterisP 3y agoCan't archeologists determine sex from the skull, which also would probably show up in brain scans?
- bamboozled 3y agoWay less edgy... On the other hand, welcome to the machine...
- petesergeant 3y ago70-90% accurately only, iirc, although the article’s method is also only 90%
- worksonmine 3y agoI might get decapitated for suggesting this here, but it would be interesting to see the results on people with gender dysphoria. Do the hormones change the brain or does it remain the same? Test it both on patients starting as teens and as adults and study over time.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y agoI was wondering this too. Some transgender people say transition is valid because brain scans show they have a brain of their identified gender. I don't know if I want to stake my legal rights on an MRI machine. Even if I have a "guy" brain I'd still rather stay on E.
- 000ooo000 3y agoIf I can derail conversation for a moment, what is the idea behind 'valid' or 'invalid' transition? It's not a phrase I've heard before sorry. I'm not in any kind of other forum where I think I could ask this without getting very emotionally-charged responses.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y agoIn this case I meant valid as in, transitioning is really the best way to treat gender dysphoria and it's not useful to think of dysphoria as a delusion that would go away with conversion therapy or with time. Hope that helps!
- 000ooo000 3y agoThank you
- faeriechangling 3y agoLook into gender essentialism, which contrasts with gender constructivism. It's often associated with TERFs, but it is VERY common within transgender communities themselves. There's notion that certain gender identities are valid and others are not (especially being male/female), and there's also the notion that diagnosable medical issues are required to be truly transgender. In this conversation, if you're AMAB, and have a male brain, and claim to have transitioned to being non-binary a gender essentialist might go "aha! Science proves they are nothing but a transtrender and a man" A constructionist would say "aha - the fact they have a male brain yet expresses a non-male gender identity proves they're a truly unique and special transgender person". It seems like an easy way to be on the "Right side of history" to reject gender essentialism, since you end up never calling a transgender person invalid. There is a dark side to rejecting essentialism, which is if gender ISN'T essential, than logically it should be possible to change people's gender identity to a "better" one. Which can result in things like Joan/John https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Reimer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Reimer.
- jorticka 3y ago[flagged]
- ackbar03 3y ago[flagged]
- bigbillheck 3y agoOne joke.
- RangerScience 3y agoUsually, “sex” refers to biology (“what’s in your pants”) whereas “gender” refers to the social construct (are people expect you to wear pants?). “Asexual” then usually refers to someone’s preferences about getting what’s in their pants and what’s in someone else’s pants together; asexual typically means “they’re not interested in that”.(“heterosexual” meaning they want what’s in the other person’s pants to be different than what’s in theirs) There’s a lot of namespace collisions in all this.
- quickthrower2 3y agoLike the XKCD thing explainer style!
- CuriousCosmic 3y ago> Usually, “sex” refers to biology (“what’s in your pants”) "Sex" refers more specifically to hormonal expression than anything else. What's in your pants, what chromosomes you have, etc aren't really great indicators for that. What hormones you have in your body in practice is really the only surefire thing. This applies especially in the historical context since after social clues, the main thing you have left is osteology/bone analysis and that's driven predominantly by hormones more than anything else. And even if you subtract the people on hormone replacement therapy, intersex people (people who naturally express "nonstandard" sex characteristics) make up upwards of 2% of the population. So in the end sex really only refers to what your hormones are and nowadays you can change that with medication. Sorry for being pedantic but this is one of the things that irks me with sex/gender discourse
- peteforde 3y agoIs 90% accuracy good enough to be useful?
- AgentOrange1234 3y agoFor what?
- xbar 3y agoA good question. It seems like sex could often be identified with simpler scans.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CuriousCosmic 3y agoWell if there's a high sensitivity in the test (which to get 0.9 would suggest a lower specificity) then that'd mean it always can tell when a brain deviates from the "established" sex. i.e. for people who ahead of time aren't known to be intersex or trans, it would be able to identify them with high accuracy. And the sensitivity vs specificity will depend for each category they are testing for (i.e. testing cis male, cis female, trans masc, trans fem, nonbinary, and some of the different intersex categories). i.e It could be a cheaper test to do than genetic testing and if particularly effective may be useful in identifying genetics associated with different sex characteristics.
- quickthrower2 3y agoThat might convince someone they are trans, who may have not come to that conclusion by themselves, which is the AI affecting the ground truth!
- CuriousCosmic 3y ago
- Vecr 3y agoNow do it with race race from bone scans. I'm skeptical on the confounding issue as well.
- Lockal 3y agoForensic investigators can reconstruct the face from a skull, not only race/ethnicity/gender. It is probably just a question, how to measure improvement of AI, added to existing method. Let's say you find the skull of the alleged "new Saddam Hussein", the AI reconstructs the face, the face looks "similar", but are you willing to go along with the AI? Maybe the neural network just got good at drawing the face of the average Arab.
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoI’d be much more surprised if it didn’t. This isn’t entirely new information, right? Just a novel way of detecting it?
- janalsncm 3y agoI don’t like comments like this. I’m not picking on you in particular because I see them all the time, especially as drive-by comments. What I like a lot about HN is that typically these drive-by comments are not highly rewarded. There is a kind of cocktail-party level expertise that is behind comments that scientific results are obvious. First of all, even if they were, it’s likely there’s a novel angle the researchers are targeting. We should ask ourselves why a researcher would spend time on such “obvious” results. Conveniently, the article author asked the researchers why they would study this. It’s not just a question of whether their brains are dissimilar, but how. Second, whether male and female brains are structurally similar is controversial. As the article states, brain structures tend to look mostly the same in men and women.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoThis is the rather more interesting part of the article; not just claiming some magic task AI can do, but explaining how it does it, and what it bases its decisions on. This means that in theory, someone can validate whether this approach is actually true, or if (as others have pointed out) the AI is just reading something else off those images that we're not aware of. > Until recently, a model like the one Menon’s team employed would help researchers sort brains into different groups but wouldn’t provide information about how the sorting happened. Today, however, researchers have access to a tool called “explainable AI,” which can sift through vast amounts of data to explain how a model’s decisions are made. > Using explainable AI, Menon and his team identified the brain networks that were most important to the model’s judgment of whether a brain scan came from a man or a woman. They found the model was most often looking to the default mode network, striatum, and the limbic network to make the call.
- andy99 3y agoThis (feature or attention maps) is BS. A real explanation would show what factors were being used to make the determination. Claiming the model is "looking at" something has no explanatory power. We already knew it was looking at the picture. These heat maps are great for showing people what they want to see and making wishy washy claims like this but they really don't explain anything in the commonly understood sense of telling us what is different.
- MarkusQ 3y agoI disagree. It clearly tells us _what_ is different, it just doesn't tell us _how_ it differs from case to case. So it's not a full explanation (which would, as you note, require a model of how it differs and, optimally, _why_) but it is a step towards a explanation, and not to be sneered at.
- orand 3y agoThis is comparable to trying to determine sex based on secondary sex characteristics. Sex is binary, based on gametes which are binary. Anything with a bimodal distribution will by necessity never be the right tool for determining something which is truly binary. The next best determinant of sex other than gametes is the presence or absence of the SRY gene.
- yukkuri 3y agoThis is going to turn out to be the new phrenology, completely flawed, but it won't stop phobic types from using it to "prove" their antisocial theories.
- throwawa14223 3y agoIf it works well isn't it not similar to phrenology?
- rcxdude 3y agoI think the implication is it doesn't actually work well. Running hard-to-explain models on brain scans has a history of producing papers which fail to reproduce, there were a bunch of bunk results in fMRI research a few years ago.
- yukkuri 3y agoExactly, it's going to turn out that it didn't work well but it will still get used harmfully.
- throwawa14223 3y agoWhile skepticism is healthy, I don't understand how you can say with certainty it will not work. A hypothetical technology that could very accurately determine the sex of a brain would seem to be a boon for transgendered people. Early detection could mean better treatment and less suffering with fewer cases of desisting.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]