5 ms·
One place Planet 9 could be hiding
- api 3y agoI've always thought the idea of planet nine being a primordial black hole was kinda cool, but AFAIK we have no evidence to suggest this. Unless I'm mistaken if PBHs do exist then one with 2-4 Earth masses is within the plausible range. It'd be about the size of a billiard ball. The existence of lots and lots of PBHs of various sizes is one dark matter candidate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primordial_black_hole https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primordial_black_hole If there were such a thing out there we could send a probe to it. I can't imagine what kinds of interesting physics we could do if we could directly examine a black hole. It'd be neat if it were actually useful in the far future too, like as a power source to generate and beam energy to interstellar spacecraft. There's even concepts like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_starship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_starship A PBH of that mass would not be useful for this but perhaps there'd be a way to leverage the extreme conditions created near the event horizon to generate smaller ones that evaporate quickly... like the extreme physics analog of sourdough starter.
- marcosdumay 3y agoThe idea of a black hole starship is that you carry the black hole around, just like any other engine. If you want to beam power from it, there isn't anything at all there to gain compared to beaming power from the Sun. And if you want to carry it with your ship, it weighting 2 Earth masses is kind of a drawback.
- djbusby 3y agoYou don't move the blackhole+ship, that's crazy. You'd simply move the universe around your ship.
- moritzwarhier 3y agoWhich is already possible by shoveling dark matter into an oven, right? I always wondered why there's no episode where the implications of more than two dark matter engines working at once were explored :)
- coffeebeqn 3y agoHow would you move a black hole around?
- calamari4065 3y agoJust get out and push
- marcosdumay 3y agoAFAIK, the most popular answer is to give it an electrical charge. I really don't know how are you supposed to maintain that change long-term. But then, it's similar to the problem of deciding whether the emissions from the black hole are particles that you can focus around, so I guess it's an open problem.
- mcswell 3y agoThere was a scifi story decades ago about using small but heavy objects (neutronium, IIRC) as an integral part of space ships. The idea was not to use them to generate energy, but to generate a gravitational field to counteract the effects on humans of high acceleration. The object was held in front of the spacecraft, and would be moved closer when high acceleration was needed. I guess if the ship was just drifting, you'd have the heavy object at a sufficient distance to cause ~1g gravity. I don't remember the story's title or author(s), but it likely appeared in Analog.
- at_a_remove 3y agoIt's Charles Sheffield, in particular his McAndrew series.
- mcswell 3y agoThank you! With that help, I was able to find the story: "Moment of Inertial." And here's a link to the story: https://www.baen.com/Chapters/067157857X/067157857X__2.htm https://www.baen.com/Chapters/067157857X/067157857X__2.htm
- at_a_remove 3y agoIf I recall, he used that invention in several stories. They're quite enjoyable. Sheffield, as a writer with a hard science background, came up with some very interesting ideas, such as The Sturm Invocation, and the entire Proteus series was very well-considered. Sometimes I get a taste for the diamond-hard sf and he scratches that itch. Hal Clement, too, if you're into that; Half Life is probably the best novel where the concept of the scientific method itself is at the forefront.
- mcswell 3y agoI now have Half Life on order, your fault. I was intrigued by another Hal Clement title, Trio for Slide Rule and Typewriter. I have a slide rule sitting a few feet from me as I write this, in case of emergency. No typewriter, though.
- kunrii8528 3y agoThere are far more feasible alternatives to deep space propulsion that could actually work now, and all you have to do is detonate a couple of nukes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsion) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propuls... See also its cousin: https://www.centauri-dreams.org/2012/07/20/medusa-nuclear-pulse-propulsion-and-the-sail/ https://www.centauri-dreams.org/2012/07/20/medusa-nuclear-pu... You can even try these in KSP with mods afaik
- sparrowInHand 3y ago? Are you serious. We have concepts for light driven probes now. They even can slow down, by ejecting a parabolic lightsail, that bounces light from the opposit direction back to them. Its all lightweight and - way more feasable, if you abandon the " a human has to go there idea". Communication would be an issue, but otherwise...
- api 3y agoYeah I'm familiar with the old "Devil's pogo stick." Apparently thermonuclear Orion could achieve as high as 10% the speed of light, which would get you to the Centauri system within a single human life span (barely).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- codethief 3y ago> If there were such a thing out there we could send a probe to it. You might be interested in Ed Witten's paper about this topic: "Searching for a Black Hole in the Outer Solar System", https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.14192 https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.14192 (See also this related comment from the HN discussion back then which puts Witten's paper into context very nicely: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23135031 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23135031 )
- tejtm 3y agoA PBH that size would be extremely useful for getting out of (and back into) our solar system, at least for probes that could survive being slingshot to a fraction of light speed. It could be like slingshoting around the sun, but but at a few miles from the core instead of a million miles.
- Zee2 3y agoIn that scenario, I'd love to see the kinds of cool relativistic time dilation experiments we could run on those probes.
- jfengel 3y agoIt's hard to imagine a scenario in which the solar system captures a wandering black hole. If it comes in it's going to keep going, or take the hyperbola back out the way it came. It's not impossible and such scenarios can be constructed. But they're really narrow and it's hard to justify putting a lot of effort into looking for wild coincidences.
- thegrim33 3y agoMaybe you could elaborate? As the solar system already contains bodies with masses both smaller and larger than the primordial black holes mentioned, what would be the issue?
- roywiggins 3y agoall of the stuff I'm the Solar system that we know about probably was here from the beginning, forming out of the same cloud of dust that produced the sun. A black hole would have to wander in from elsewhere and somehow get captured rather than zipping by on a hyperbolic orbit.
- scheme271 3y agoThe relative velocity of stuff that wasn't in the cloud that formed the solar system would almost certainly be really high. So it would take a lot to capture the an extra-solar body. Any bodies from outside the solar system would probably either travel straight through the solar system or do something like what ʻOumuamua did.
- jvanderbot 3y agoIf you draw a box around the solar system, and want a fast moving BH to settle in without rejecting on hyperbolic orbit, you'd just have to throw out another object that's comparable in size, at comparable speed. Momentum conserved. A near miss with one of Jupiters moons might sling the BH into an orbit at slower pace and throw that moon into, say, earth to create our own moon. This stuff probably happens more often than we think, on a galactic time scale.
- malfist 3y agoI mean, Pluto is right there man
- adastra22 3y agoThat would be Planet 12 :)
- davidmurdoch 3y agoNah. It should have been grandfathered in as planet 9.
- svachalek 3y agoIf you want to stand on tradition, planet 9 has to go to Ceres.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- adastra22 3y agoYeah that's where 12 comes from. IIRC it was the 12th known "planet" when it was discovered, if you include spherical, gravitationally differentiated asteroids. The air quotes are because by the geophysical definition of planet (the only scientifically reasonable definition, fight me) our Moon, the Galilean moons of Jupiter, and Titan are all also planets, and I think they were known at that time. Our solar system likely contains thousands of planets. I wish people could get excited over that rather get stuck up about tradition and "how will kids ever remember them all?" My kids can name the stats and special powers of 350 Pokemon. They'll be just fine.
- mrcartmeneses 3y agoPluto needs to up its game and become GRAVITATIONALLY DOMINANT!!!
- fghorow 3y ago
- johnea 3y agoIt's obviously being hidden by the lizard people inside the hollow earth...
- mondobe 3y agoObviously, the lizard people's base would be inside planet 9! Common sense, people.
- kibwen 3y ago> continues to search for the elusive Planet Nine (also called Planet X) In light of Pluto's demotion, surely we should deprecate "Planet X" in favor of "Planet Ix".
- dividefuel 3y agoWould it be a bigger surprise if Planet 9 existed, or if Planet 9 doesn't exist? This isn't my field of study, but as I understand there's a good amount of indirect evidence for a Planet 9... and still no direct proof. Assuming we're searching in the right areas, if a scan of the first 80% didn't reveal it, it seems unlikely (but of course not impossible) that we'll find it in the last 20%.
- pmcf 3y ago“Space is big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's long way down the road to the chemist's, but that's just peanuts to space.”
- iszomer 3y ago"Don't Panic."
- 14 3y agoI like to tell people how big space is just by describing how fast voyager 1 is moving and how long it will take to reach 1 light year of travel. Voyager 1 launched back in the 70's and is traveling around 38,210 mph. Even at that speed it will take another approximate 18,500 years for it to reach it's first light year traveled. The closest star is about 4.2 light years away so at it's current speed it would take about 75,000 years for it to reach Alpha Centauri.The more you start getting into the numbers and things like how many light years across the milky way is and how far to the next galaxy and how many galaxies their are you start to see the universe is unimaginably large. I don't think one could fully grasp it's size. Amazing
- halfcat 3y agoThere’s a difference between completing 80% of the work, and ruling out 80% of the options. We could rule out 80% of the options and still have 99% of the work yet to be completed. Like if we’re looking for a bacteria on the land surface of the earth, and we rule out 80% of the options, that leaves us with searching an area the size of Africa for a microscopic life form.
- fabiensanglard 3y agoI wonder if it could be opposite from us, on the other side of the Sun. Rotating at the same speed and hence never observable?
- coffeebeqn 3y agoAll our eyes aren’t on Earths orbit
- jfengel 3y agoIt couldn't be stable there for very long. It's a three body problem. If it ever existed it would have been ejected billions of years ago.
- bee_rider 3y agoIt would have to be orbiting at the same distance as the Earth to have the same speed, which seems unlikely, and only gives it a fairly small amount of space to live in, so I’m sure we’ve checked there. The hypothetical planet 9 is speculated to be far from the sun, past Pluto.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoIf you mean on the opposite side, in the same orbit(in the earth-sun L3), this has been hypothesised as far back as the presocratic Greeks(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counter-Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counter-Earth), but we now have a lot of evidence that it isn't there. Also, planet 9 was hypothesised in order to explain the orbits of transneptunian objects, which an antiearth wouldn't do. If you mean behind the sun on a completely different orbit, well it wouldn't stay behind the sun relative to us forever, and likely would only very rarely be obscured by the sun.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoMost likely explanation is that Planet 9s population is a higher level civilization that understands the “dark forest” hypothesis. They’re probably nervously eyeing their noisy neighbors
- sliken 3y agoNeil deGrasse Tyson, an astrophysicist, claims [0] that if you remove one observatories data, that the anomaly that leads to the conclusion there's a planet 9 disappears. [0] https://www.youtube.com/shorts/RvNYL5sPItc https://www.youtube.com/shorts/RvNYL5sPItc
- pmontra 3y agoMaybe the name of that observatory was too long to fit in that 59 seconds video. Do you have any idea about which observatory it is?
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoThis is about a different hypothesised planet beyond Neptune.
- dgrin91 3y agoHe also tends to be full of hot air. His biggest contributions are in science communications towards younger and non-science oriented people. I'm not saying he is wrong or lying or anything like that, but a youtube short is not a good standin for a scientific hypothesis.
- medstrom 3y agoWhat is this reasoning? A scientific hypothesis can fit in one sentence on the back of a napkin, certainly it can in a youtube short too.
- fragmede 3y ago> His biggest contributions are in science communications towards younger and non-science oriented people. that's a huge contribution and not to be undervalued!
- dgrin91 3y agoCorrect. I'm not saying he is bad for the world, just that he is more focused on soundbites to reel people in than on the detailed discussion being proposed by his video.
- autokad 3y agoits in Pluto's orbit. mainly because Pluto is planet 9.
- wyldfire 3y agoHave you checked across the 8th dimension? Ask any Lectroid, they'll tell you.
- tiahura 3y agoHow can we spot exoplanets 20M light years away, but not have absolute metaphysical certitude about the number of planets in the solar system?
- ivanjermakov 3y agoNot sure where 20M l.y. are coming from, because the farthest exoplaned seems to be 27k l.y. from the Sun: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SWEEPS-11 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SWEEPS-11 Regarding your question, perhaps it's harder to perform direct imaging of a planet in the solar system than of an exoplanet against its local star(s). In the first case, relative motion is much higher.
- vikingerik 3y ago1) We spot exoplanets by their influence on the star, which is nearly nil at distances of 100+ AU. 2) We spot exoplanets that have huge volumes and masses, like Neptune or Jupiter size (15x or 100x Earth's mass, or even multiples of Jupiter), but the ones we're talking about beyond the Kuiper belt might be on the order of 0.1 Earth mass or smaller. 3) 20M light years is an exaggeration, most detected planets are within 1000 light years.