5 ms·
MIT researchers demonstrate rapid liquid metal 3D printing technique
- unraveller 3y agothere is a video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H93W-CiOT4A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H93W-CiOT4A
- mateo1 3y agoCool idea. Impractical but cool.
- amelius 3y agoHow much energy does this use?
- jameshart 3y agoWe know enough from the article to be able to ballpark estimate it. Heat capacity of aluminum is 0.9 kJ/kg °C, and the latent heat of fusion is 390kJ/kg. The temperature they heat the aluminum to is 700°C, from presumably room temperature around 20°C - so 0.9*680 + 390 kJ/kg = 1002 kJ/kg is going to be the basic heating requirement, or as near as dammit 1MJ/kg. Getting that heat into the aluminum and then maintaining that temperature during the print presumably introduces some inefficiencies (induction furnaces can heat aluminum with about 40-50% efficiency), plus they have to move the mass of aluminum around with their print motors... but the heat to melt the aluminum feels likely to be the main energy sink. Inductively heated, with good crucible insulation, 2MJ/kg sounds like a reasonable energy budget? For a comparison, that's about ten times the amount of energy you use running your microwave to heat up a ready meal, for every kilogram of aluminum you want to form.
- amelius 3y agoOk. How much less efficient is this process compared to mass-fabrication techniques?
- barelyauser 3y agoMass production is not only about energy efficiency. It is also about material efficiency and time efficiency. People want stuff NOW. Each process has its advantages. 3d printing can do stuff that mass fabrication techniques can't.
- Qwertious 3y ago>It is also about material efficiency and time efficiency. People want stuff NOW. Also, if you have a $1M machine then the machine-time really adds up.
- barelyauser 3y agoPrecisely. $1M and interest rates of 6% per year mean almost $7 per hour just to cover financing.
- jameshart 3y agoThat energy cost is intrinsic to aluminum casting. If you’re recycling aluminum like this, you are going to have that cost anyway - even if you use a different technique like rolling or pressing or extrusion to form the final pieces (that said I bet induction heating aluminum scrap to melting point is a lot less efficient than heating an ingot)
- gregw2 3y agoI wonder if you could just 3D-print a mold and then pour the aluminum in as part of a 3d printer like this, rather than use a nozzle, and you'd get better quality/resolution.
- amelius 3y agoOr a 3 step process: PLA mold -> silicone mold -> aluminum object.
- jan_Sate 3y agoI'm thinking about the other way around. Assuming that their aluminum 3D printer works, print the aluminum mold using their 3D printer. Then make plastic parts with injection molding.
- frognumber 3y agoInjection molding molds have precision requirements well beyond any 3d printing. They're very expensive for that reason. It's hard even for precision machining.
- naasking 3y agoYou can print molds that you literally cannot machine.
- numpad0 3y agoBut how do you get the product out!?
- lazide 3y agoYou break the mold
- frognumber 3y agoFor injection molding? Or other types of molding? Injection molding processes I've seen have super-tight tolerances. Something like plaster or sandcasting do not.
- frognumber 3y agoNeat to see this! As the technology improves, I am skeptical of the necessity of sacrificing resolution. I can think of a half-dozen ways to improve on this as it moves from V0 to V1 to V2. The video mentions post-machining, but aside from that, we have: - More sophisticated media than uniform glass pallets. In particular, an outline could be preplaced, so it is more like casting. For example, one could have large glass pieces, smaller glass pieces, etc. arranged prior. - Combined methods, where this prints the coarse shape, and slower techniques fill in details. This could even be the same technique but with successively smaller nozzles. And simple process improvements (esp. refining nozzle design, temperature, and flow rate, so in some ways). I suspect moving from liquid to something more like extrusion, could help as well. Extrusion can be quite precise. Better process control, with some form of feedback loop, would help too. Imaging aluminum in realtime through the glass pallets in realtime should not be fundamentally hard. By "not hard," I mean "known engineering process with known technologies" (e.g. solvable, but a serious multiyear engineering effort). First press release + video I've seen from MIT which doesn't oversell / overhype results or grossly exaggerate potential impact. That's refreshing too.
- Animats 3y agoWasn't this on HN a few days ago? There are already good metal printers. They're usually sintering systems - put down a powder and fire it in a furnace. There are systems for 3D printing sand molds for casting.[1] Both of those processes are much more precise than this one. Metals do usually have a phase in which they're solid, but malleable, and can be worked with modest forces. "Modest" usually means hammers, large presses, or a rolling mill. A good metal extruder working with red-hot but not molten metal would need to be able to apply similar forces. That's what the 3D printers that work with wire and are similar to welders do.[2] There's directed energy deposition, which converts metal powder to molten metal for a fraction of a second at the deposition point.[3] This liquid system has the same problem as the 3D printing systems for concrete that were being touted a few years ago. Some kind of molding or die is needed to guide the material at the point the metal becomes a solid, or the result is very rough. [1] https://www.voxeljet.com/3d-printing-solution/sand-casting/ https://www.voxeljet.com/3d-printing-solution/sand-casting/ [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z3nNlVcoba8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z3nNlVcoba8 [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oL7bMhPTtDI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oL7bMhPTtDI
- massifist 3y agoHere's an older HN link from an MIT article. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39156463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39156463
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoLots of progress, still clearly many improvements possible. Baby steps! This could be very useful in a lunar colony, quickly smelting parts and structures out of the lunar soil. It's around 8% aluminum (bauxite) which melts at a reasonable temperature. Strong enough for larger-scale building uses such as airlocks and beams.
- LargeTomato 3y agoIt is a shame we're seeing a divestment in 3D printing technologies. Relativity Space recently descoped their entire 3D printing department, but I believe they still may be using some commercially-acquired printers. I hope we can see someone else take up the mantle on complex 3D printing manufacturing. There's an Indian space company that is trying to do what Relativity did. I hope it works out for them.
- nickpinkston 3y agoI thought Relativity Space pulled back on their use of 3D printing for the major fuselage parts, saving it more for the engine components, etc., which SpaceX was already doing.
- LargeTomato 3y agoI believe you are correct. Relativity is now only printing engines, just like SpaceX, Rocket Lab, Astra, Firefly, Stoke, and others. They are no longer a company driving forward 3D printing technology and that's too bad.
- bbarn 3y agoIt's been amazing to watch the 3D printing space grow as far as it has. In just the last 10-20 years it's gone from something only dedicated people were able to build and get reasonable results to high precision devices any hobbyist can get their hands on for a few hundred bucks. I have two resin printers and a PLA printer and I never expected at-home capability to get this far this fast. But, that's still all effectively plastic we're talking about. I think the problem with metals is still well.. metals. The same types of metallurgy needed for 3D printing have been researched and hit almost a dead end with injection molding (I know there are some metal injection molding systems out there, but it's not hit anywhere near the strength of machined steel yet)
- ok123456 3y agoPeople are 3d printing metal right now with LPBF, DED, and Wire EDM. For LPBF the challenge is controlling keyholing and lack of fusion defects through the process parameters.
- projektfu 3y agoWhat class of fabricated metal does it compare to? Cast metal? I didn't see it in the article.
- SmokeyHamster 3y agoThis was posted before. Not really 3d printing. It's more of a quick casted mold maker, since it just uses a conventional CNC machine to "draw" the shape in sand and then it pours molten metal in the sand mold. A clever enough idea, but the results are mixed. It's limited to fairly simple 2d shapes and the quality of the "prints" are quite poor and require a lot more post processing than true 3d metal printers.
- helpfulContrib 3y ago[dead]
- willmadden 3y agoWell, that clickbait headline certainly has James Cameronesque overtones, does it not?