7 ms·
Headphone and Amp Impedance (2011)
- willis936 3y agoThis whole blog is a treasure for new EEs. The great mystery is that the author disappeared while working on a DAC revision but has kept their site running for over a decade.
- Hamuko 3y agoDo you need to put any effort into a Blogspot site to keep it online?
- anthomtb 3y agoYou need to pay hosting bills. Or keep a server running somewhere in your home.
- Hamuko 3y agoAren't Blogspot blogs free and hosted in Google's DCs?
- proto-n 3y agoBlogspot is google's blogging platform
- AlecSchueler 3y agoAnd Google will happily delete your blog if it's associated with an inactive account: https://support.google.com/blogger/thread/226117604/my-blog-was-deleted-today-without-a-trace?hl=en https://support.google.com/blogger/thread/226117604/my-blog-...
- Hamuko 3y agoIf you've bought something using a Google account, it won't be marked as inactive even if you don't log into it. So it could be possible that he died in a car accident or something, but his blog will just keep on trucking along for years and years because he bought an app for his phone from the Google Play Store.
- AlecSchueler 3y agoYes, you can take measures to avoid your account being marked inactive but A) not as easy as "it's Google, you can trust it" and B) Google could change their minds about this stuff and go on a deletion spree at any moment, or even shut down blogspot entirely, it's not like they haven't shown form previously.
- anthomtb 3y agoD'oh! Somehow my brained mapped blogspot to Wordpress.
- COGlory 3y agoThe domain NwAvGuy.com was last renewed in 2023.
- lelanthran 3y agoInteresting. Does the 1/8th rule apply to matching amplifiers with speakers as well, say for car audio?
- michaelrpeskin 3y agoDigging deep into my memory here, but I always remember that when Zout==Zin that's what you want for maximum power transfer. My guess is that the 1/8 trick is for the typical characteristics of small-speaker headset. Big speakers may have different capacitance and inductance characteristics. I don't know though. That's the first time I heard that approximation, and it doesn't seem to align with anything that I learned in electronics.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWhy would one optimize for maximum power transfer at all? Worse, why would one un-optimize the power source by adding impedance so that it works at maximum capacity? It's much better to just leave the extra capacity there. That 1/8 rate is a property of our hearing, and so will apply to any system that creates sound. But it's a quite hard target to achieve in large bass speakers, so a lot of systems simply don't.
- ahartmetz 3y agoThe radio stuff is about "wave impedance", the speaker or headphone stuff is more like a power supply situation at (in RF terms) very low frequencies. You want your power supply to have low impedance so it doesn't sag and keeps tight control over its output voltage. There must be a mathematical description of these different situations but I can't be bothered to work it out. An important part of it is probably that an audio amplifier has feedback, an RF amplifier just emits a wave and the consumer must make itself compatible with it. Lower output impedance = more effective feedback control for an amplifier with feedback.
- screcth 3y agoAnalysis becomes much simpler when frequencies are low enough. Wavelength is large compared to the dimensions of the circuit so you can ignore the effects of wave propagation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- squarefoot 3y agoI'm very skeptic of that 1/8th rule. Usually output impedance should be as low as possible, so that the resistance added by the cable becomes negligible in comparison, and its intrinsic capacitance won't turn it into a low pass filter. Unless I'm missing something, at least in audio, amplifiers with lower output impedance are always better than those with higher output impedance.
- notfed 3y ago> most headphones work best when the output impedance is less than 1/8th the headphone impedance This doesn't seem to disagree with what you're saying?
- squarefoot 3y ago1/8 max seems still too high to me. For example it would be satisfied by a 12.5 Ohm Zout amp with a 100 Ohm headphone, but that wouldn't be ideal in case of long cables. I'd aim to much lower impedance anyway, especially today that it's easy to obtain with common parts.
- kristianp 3y agoWhat happened to the rule of thumb that output impedence should equal input impedance? That's just a general rule from antennas IIRC.
- Kirby64 3y agoHonestly I don’t know what reasonable headphone output today has these high output impedances. They’re all class D amplifiers with quite low impedance directly to the power supply. This 1/8th rule is kind of pointless… you just specify output voltage drive at various loads and measure frequency response. Most do this very well. No need to faff about with damping of responses.
- atoav 3y agoJup, but when the post was written good class D headphone amps weren't as readily available as it is today, if I recall correctly.
- pclmulqdq 3y agoClass A and AB amps often have significant output impedance due to how they are constructed, and used to be the standard. They still are the standard for HiFi audio. The other types of amps are generally pretty low impedance. Edit: Amp types as pointed out by another commenter.
- smolder 3y agoI wouldn't call Class A "standard", unless you're including class AB in that? Pure class A is a bit esoteric since it's wildly inefficient compared to D or even AB.
- kazinator 3y agoClass AB amplifiers (basically class B but with an overlap region when switching between the output devices) have very low output impedance when they feature negative feedback. Which is the standard for hi-fi audio.
- kazinator 3y agoI also never heard of this 50-ohm-1996 thing. Any headphone output worth its salt in the last 70 years is going to have near zero ohm output impedance. Some headphone amplifiers use cheap integrated circuits that can only drive outputs no lower than around 150 ohms, like the JRC4556 (a device that NavGuy has written quite a bit about, incidentally). I suspect that's where that idea might come from? If you have a JRC4556 that doesn't go lower than 150 ohms, and the headphones are 32 ohms, you can pad in some series resistance to make up the difference.
- kragen 3y agothis is great, i've been reading a lot about headphone impedance this week, but from the perspective of 'i want to use 3.5mm jacks for super simple data communications and power for small devices, so how do i keep from burning out headphones if someone accidentally plugs them in' (also it turns out that these jacks briefly short-circuit as you plug and unplug them) because 'super simple' excludes power negotiation schemes like usb-c, whatever power i deliver to small devices is also available if someone plugs in a resistor, and earspeakers are pretty similar to resistors at dc, and normally driven at only about a milliwatt the vast majority of current headphones (and headphone-driving amplifiers) out there today conform to the android specs (though probably approximately 1% of the headphones of interest to nwavguy) jack: https://source.android.com/docs/core/interaction/accessories/headset/jack-headset-spec https://source.android.com/docs/core/interaction/accessories... plug: https://source.android.com/docs/core/interaction/accessories/headset/plug-headset-spec https://source.android.com/docs/core/interaction/accessories... relevant appnotes on driving them include david guo's https://www.analog.com/media/en/technical-documentation/application-notes/an-1429.pdf https://www.analog.com/media/en/technical-documentation/appl... and the anonymous https://www.digikey.com/Site/Global/Layouts/DownloadPdf.ashx?pdfUrl=83910E9C9595434A8E39DA9873B12F9D https://www.digikey.com/Site/Global/Layouts/DownloadPdf.ashx...
- frabert 3y agoThis is unwanted advice, I know, but here is what I would do: I'd make it so that both the transmitter has a very high output impedance (so that plugging in an headphone causes its output to drop to near zero) and the receiver has very high input impedance (so that it doesn't bog the tx down). It will cause some noise issues, because a very high impedance front end will pick up stray radio transmissions, but I think it's doable given a small enough bandwidth
- kragen 3y agojust in case this wasn't clear, plugging headphones or other audio equipment into these 3.5mm jacks is not the intention of this design; rather, i want to minimize the chance of destroying expensive equipment if it happens by accident noise is pretty irrelevant on the power rail. but if i put a high constant impedance on the power rail—say, a 100Ω resistor in front of 5 volts—none of the devices powered from it can draw much power, 25mA being the limit in that case (for the data line, sure, resistance is not at all futile, resistance is a perfectly good solution, along with some clamping diodes) what i have in mind is two things: 1. maybe use a trrs connector and use the second sleeve for the power rail? that way the only thing that ever gets plugged into it by accident is a microphone, which i think is unlikely to burn out at 5 volts (even if normally it's not subjected to more than 2.2 volts) 2. also, limit the current with a linear current source. this design simulates as having about 10Ω impedance over the 0–100mA range and a few kilohms once you exceed the current limit: http://tinyurl.com/23qvuylw http://tinyurl.com/23qvuylw
- amelius 3y agoWhat I want is an electrical equivalent circuit, that models not only the ohmic losses but also the reactance and the output power. For different kinds of headphones and speakers. And then a way to tune the parameters in that model to an actual device.
- em3rgent0rdr 3y agoSPICE model ideally.
- screcth 3y agoWhy don't sources try to measure the frequency response of the driver + cable + headphone circuit and apply a digital prefiltering step to compensate these distortions?
- kazinator 3y agoBecause it has to be done individually for each headphone. It would require specialized equipment, like a super accurate reference microphone capable of accurately listening to a headphone speaker, in the same way as your ear. The best thing is for the speaker manufacturer to assume zero ohm output impedance from every amplifier, and for them to do their work to get their speaker to have a close to flat response. (Or whatever: some markets prefer a huge bass.) Then it has that designed response in any such amplifier.
- Kirby64 3y agoYou don’t generally want to compensate, as impedance that isn’t flat doesn’t necessarily mean that the output SPF isn’t flat.
- Aurornis 3y ago> Why don't sources try to measure the frequency response of the driver + cable + headphone circuit and apply a digital prefiltering step to compensate these distortions? Because the effects are negligible and trivial to overcome with even basic attention to design. The distortion of speakers or headphones is orders of magnitude higher than the distortion from even a basic headphone amp design in the modern era.
- kazinator 3y agoThis business of damping or lack thereof, is really just a frequency response change. The concern with the resonance of the speaker is overblown. When you boost a frequency range electronically with an equalizer, that is also resonance (electronic rather than mechanical). Instead of your speaker ringing for a couple of cycles, the circuit is doing it.
- kragen 3y agoa couple of cycles? q=2 isn't much of a resonance
- Croline79 3y ago[dead]
- boomskats 3y agoFor context, the NwAvGuy O2 amp[0] design is pretty famous now. The dude even lays it down right there[1] in the comments of the linked article. And then soon after that iirc he just disappears? [0]: https://nwavguy.blogspot.com/2011/07/o2-headphone-amp.html https://nwavguy.blogspot.com/2011/07/o2-headphone-amp.html [1]: https://nwavguy.blogspot.com/2011/02/headphone-amp-impedance.html?showComment=1323051662721#c8427763185355748585 https://nwavguy.blogspot.com/2011/02/headphone-amp-impedance...
- bscphil 3y agoYep, I remember following these articles when they came out. I bought their DAC design and it's been in continuous use for close to a decade now. I've actually got this entire blogspot site mirrored just so I can make absolute certain nothing ever happens to the posts.
- mmmrk 3y agoYeah, I also got an ODAC combo (amp and DAC sandwiched in an enclosure) in continuous use since it released way back when. The only annoyance is that there's probably something wrong with the USB cable, as it loses connection depending on how you twist it, so I may accidentally strike it and then spend a few minutes wiggling the connectors to get it back. The Micro USB connector choice didn't age too well, so I can't easily find a replacement with chokes :)
- dusted 3y agoI find myself guilty of deep-diving into headfi-territory audiophilia once in a while, this time it got to me as well and I started thinking how neat it'd be to finally do it and get some high-end replacement for my 250 ohm dt990 pro cans, and I've heard both the hifman arya and sennheiser hd800s and know they are quite a lot better.. but THEN comes the amp question... and the rabbithole deepens.. and then the DAC and in the end I give up, every time.. this time too! I've also heard the o2 amp, and it's quite nice.. In the end, a year ago or so, I went a bit overboard and decided that since my subjective experience of even cheaper studio monitors have been on-par with even the most expensive headphones, I should go all-in on that account instead.. I somehow managed to convince myself that a pair of Genelec 8350s would solve all my problems, so I replaced my Presonus Eris E5s with them, and replaced the scarlett 2i4 with a Yellow Tec Puc2 lite, and got the calibration box and mic and the silly volume knob (so I could pour pure PCM at 0dB straight into the monitors DACs).. Of course, audiophilia is a sickness, and it never ends, so I've been looking at a rather pricey stereo-subwoofer setup to go along.. but fortunately, my room can't support that at the moment.. I guess what I hate about gear, is what others love, that there's no one right, no one truth, and that subjective experience has to be taken into account.. I don't want subjective, I want the objective truth, accurate reproduction.. but what is even that..
- dmix 3y agoI went the customcans hifiman route after my open dt 990 pros blew from feedback https://customcans.co.uk/shop/product-category/home/headphones/audiophile-headphones/?orderby=price-desc https://customcans.co.uk/shop/product-category/home/headphon... Not quite the thousand dollar Arya but I like the dampening/venting work and signal testing he did + nice cables + I switched to a balanced xlr setup with my amp as I have grounding issues in my house. I personally find the amp the most interesting part over headphones. I really like the tone of tube amps. It's fun testing out the (noticeable) differences. As long as headphones are relatively flat I'm happy. Not sure the planar thing is as dramatic as people say but I only have a modified entry level one. If I was going this path again I'd probably get a (modified) 990 Beyer again cuz I loved that one and I don't find much value in spending a couple K since it's never just the headphone purchase... I know from experience a new fancier speakers/headphones means you then notice how bad your amp is, or your phono preamp, or turntable, or your DAC, etc and you invest a tone of time/money on upgrading everything.
- Freedomboy 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- logicallee 3y agoQ. What is the impedance of a bluetooth headphone? A. 32-100 ms depending on model. (This is a joke.)
- nyanpasu64 3y agoThis is also why cheap resistive 3.5mm "volume knobs" sound like shit; they produce a high source impedance (as seen by the headphones), which causes frequency-dependent amplitude (and phase?) shifts of output sound (even before the potentiometer starts failing, causing the sound to crackle). A few years ago, I've built attenuators out of voltage dividers (using around 2-20 ohm resistors). Unfortunately at any given attenuation factor, there's a limit to how high of an impedance you can expose to the audio source, along with how low of an impedance you can expose to the headphones. Additionally, to compensate for stray ground-line resistance causing inverted crosstalk between the stereo channels, I also add a crossfeed resistor or potentiometer of 500 ohms or so, ideally tuned based on the headphone impedance. If you use a potentiometer you can take one side of your headphones/earbuds off, send loud noise to that side alone, and turn the potentiometer knob until no sound is audible in your remaining ear. (To determine the correct fixed resistor value, you can send quiet noise to the remaining ear and adjust its volume until it cancels out crosstalk.) Also since I use TRS cables/sockets, this breaks headphone mics. I've been meaning to make a PCB version of my attenuator with SMD resistors to reduce space, but don't know where to find a reliable PCB-mount headphone jack (or 3.5mm dongle cable). If anyone has suggestions for a PCB-mount headphone jack (available in the US), let me know!