17 ms·
Universal Basic Income Has Been Tried over and over Again. It Works Every Time
- woofcat 3y agoI don't think anyone is doubting that giving people money improves their lives. That seems to be the conclusion of these studies. However what is seemingly _never_ studied is how to finance such an operation. The money has to come out of the system somewhere. Is it with new taxation on XYZ, or slashing services somewhere else etc.
- TriangleEdge 3y ago> The money has to come out of the system somewhere. Governments have the ability to print money out of thin air. What I'd like to see is how UBI impacts inflation and economic growth.
- hosteur 3y agoCurrency yes. But not value.
- psunavy03 3y agoGoogle "hyperinflation." Printing money out of thin air causes the existing money to be worth about as much as toilet paper.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoDepends on how much you print, and what happens with supply as you do so. Some countries (eg. Japan) are struggling to increase inflation, so this seems like a straightforward policy. At the same time it can solve the problem of weak consumer demand: productive factories making desirable goods that citizens nonetheless feel too poor to buy, causing those factories to shut down, resulting in the country getting poorer in real terms. After all, "demand" is desirability times spending power: if spending power is low in your target market, then demand is low, even when your products are desirable. Putting money in the hands of the largest number of people works well with production economies of scale. For the same total quantity of money, having it concentrated in a few hands means your society is incentivized to produce a few yachts and private jets, and too low on the quantity curve for economies of scale to make that production efficient. When that same money is distributed, the incentives are to produce large quantities of vacuum cleaners and washing machines, where mass production is very efficient, so total utility can be higher.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoPrinting money is not a useful framing device. What is useful is thinking about money sources and money sinks. As long as the (source rate - sink rate) ≅ Δvalue of goods an services, inflation is checked. "Printing money", paired with a comparable sink, is completely fine and a more useful tool than "never print money". The biggest roadblock we have when it comes to employing this tool is that our system of governance has different systems when it comes to monetary and fiscal policy that over-complicate its use.
- jstummbillig 3y agoWe are actually, right now, "printing money" out of thin air. The process is called "fractional reserve banking" and is a cornerstone of modern economics systems. You can of course read up on it, but, suffice to say, if we did not do it, financial systems would be extremely unergonomic. Hyperinflation is one of the things that could happen, when you do it badly, I suppose, but there is a lot of ways to get hyperinflation, if you do things badly.
- psunavy03 3y agoThank you for insulting my intelligence by assuming I don't understand fractional reserve banking. My point remains. A government does not have carte blanche to inject money into an economy without hyperinflation beyond a certain point.
- jstummbillig 3y agoIf you were a little more honest and a little less into making a point of being offended, you would probably find it fairly easy to concede that the statements you made in both comments are substantially different.
- danpalmer 3y agoBoth statements are true. Governments can "print money", but printing money comes with many caveats.
- stray 3y agoWhat could possibly go wrong?
- SoftTalker 3y agoPrinting money out of thin air makes existing money worth less. So it is effectively a tax by another name, you are taking the value from the people who have money now, without actually changing the balances in their bank accounts. And it's regressive, since there's no way to limit inflation to any selected demographic.
- netbioserror 3y agoRight. And if they can print it from thin air and just give it to everyone, then it has no actual value. Price discovery will force significant inflation on every class of product and service because that is what people will be buying with it. Its effectiveness drops with scale, which is what they are not testing. It's great that UBI works in a lab, but this experiment has been run at multiple points in history and absolutely thrashed societies every time without significant external input (conquest, exploitation, etc.). Money by definition derives its value from its scarcity relative to the economy it is representing. There is no free lunch here.
- jvanderbot 3y agoYeah, as much as I hate the inefficiency of some wellfare programs in the USA - their inefficiency is a feature in that it provides a kind of scarcity.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lenkite 3y agoThe folks down-voting you down appear to have no problems with hundreds of billions of dollars spent on War every year - the money for that was printed out of thin air. The current U.S. Biden administration even removed the debt ceiling to do this!
- vharuck 3y agoThe US has raised the debt ceiling multiple times across multiple administrations. And the debt ceiling isn't raised so that we can pass a specific bill or take a specific action, it's so we can pay for the bills and actions we agreed to months beforehand.
- stray 3y agoOr how increasing the money supply affects the price of eggs...
- CuriousCosmic 3y agoConsidering the price of eggs skyrocketed due to an outbreak of avian flu forcing farmers into mass culling tens of millions of egg laying hens across the US, it's probably not the money supply that caused that.
- stray 3y agoWhoosh! Ok, the price of literally everything, then. Google "Weimar Republic".
- op00to 3y agoOh, they had UBI then?
- stray 3y agoThey increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices, so they increased the money supply which led to increased prices...
- kevingadd 3y agoMoney isn't zero sum. We've never let such concerns interfere with funding wars.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoThis isn’t an argument. What do you say to someone who doesn’t think ubi will scale and who is also anti war?
- riskable 3y agoJust declare a war on needless bureaucracy or something. No need for actual violence.
- kevingadd 3y agoI'd have to see their argument. A basic "better things aren't possible because where will the money come from?" Isn't possible to engage with seriously. We don't fund our state with gold mines.
- virissimo 3y agoThere absolutely is a tradeoff between defense and civilian spending: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guns_versus_butter_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guns_versus_butter_model
- FredPret 3y agoYes we have? There's an ongoing funding crisis for Ukraine's defense, and there are legions of conservatives who are mad about the trillion + spent blowing up Afghanistan + Iraq. Taxation in the US came about to fund a war. Money is in the top-three concerns people have about war; it's right after lives lost and infrastructure destroyed.
- kevingadd 3y agoYou're saying people are mad about war funding. I'm saying the wars and dod get funded every year no matter what. Both things are true.
- sodality2 3y agoI’ve seen proponents suggest we take the money from other welfare programs, as paradoxically the means-testing overhead costs so much that we can afford to pay everyone $X instead of thousands of workers to process thousands of welfare applications. I haven’t seen specific numbers about this though. Edit: I'm failing to find numbers to support this now.
- HideousKojima 3y agoI hate welfare programs as much as the next libertarian leaning conservative, but overhead from means testing (and admin overhead generally) really isn't a major expense. Medicaid overhead is a grand total of 5% of the program. It's really just UBI advocates handwaving away the question of funding.
- mauvehaus 3y agoThe cost of means testing isn't just what you see on a budget. It's also all of the people who are eligible, but incapable of demonstrating that fact because of some byzantine requirements imposed on them to show eligibility[0]. There will, of course, be people who consider this to be a feature, not a bug. That's an ideological difference outside the scope of this comment. [0] Source: I know someone applying for long-term disability. Getting an answer to a question as straightforward as how to sign the paperwork (wet signature, digital, print/sign/scan, fax?!) has been a challenge for them. It's also unclear if the three different signatures needed of them are even to be done the same way. This is a generally competent, functional person I'm talking about, by the way.
- HideousKojima 3y agoThat's not a "cost" of means testing though, at least not in the accounting sense. If anything, that causes the program to spend less money. Like you said, whether or not otherwise qualifying people get excluded from a welfare program is a good or bad thing is up for debate, but if it has any effect on the cost of a welfare program it only reduces it.
- danpalmer 3y ago> I don't think anyone is doubting that giving people money improves their lives. I think this is actually more controversial than you're giving it credit for. Giving money as opposed to other non-monetary forms of aid is quite a radical concept. Many people believe that giving money to the poor results in bad financial decisions, short term spending, and few long-term effects. This is the main belief that the trials of UBI so far have disproven. Another example of this is charitable giving. Most charities tackling poverty focus on giving food, water, medicine, etc, whereas studies have shown that giving money is a remarkably efficient way of donating. Give Directly has done very well with this.
- anon25783 3y agoThe GDP of the USA is about 28 trillion dollars. The US military's budget alone is over eight hundred billion dollars. I think we can manage.
- dandy23 3y agoThat would mean around 2000 USD per person per year if taking the full US military budget and paying everyone. But this is much better than subsidizing home ownership for the rich.
- HideousKojima 3y agoPlease try to do some actual math here. What annual UBI are you targeting, and how much could be funded from pillaging existing spending vs. new taxes?
- slowmovintarget 3y agoWe did this during the pandemic and it resulted in inflation that we're still trying to deal with. Exactly the kind of inflation that detractors claim would happen. Safety net, yes. UBI and other redistributionist fantasies, no.
- racl101 3y ago> or slashing services somewhere else Military budget?
- radicaldreamer 3y agoMilitary is actually a big jobs program itself, both for people directly employed by the military as well as for industrial contractors.
- jvanderbot 3y agoAny sufficiently large purchase is indistinguishable from a jobs program.
- ToucanLoucan 3y ago> Is it with new taxation on XYZ Bring back the 70% corporate tax rate that was considered normal when Reagan was elected. That should give us a solid start. After that take all the money from every billionaire. You can have up to $999,999,999.99 in your bank + assets, and everything after that goes to healthcare and UBI. If you get to a billion, we'll name a dog park after you and you get a little trophy that says you won capitalism. More importantly though, why is it that the funding of vast government expenditure is only a problem when it stands to benefit the working class? We always have heaps of money for tax cuts for the wealthy, blowing shit up overseas, and buying this year's crop of tanks to replace the ones we're about to shove into a field to rust. How many millions in PPI loans were forgiven, when most people got maybe $2,400 total over COVID when the economy damn near imploded?
- FredPret 3y ago70% corporate tax rate will get you another Reagan. It's a fast track to destroying entrepreneurship, reducing competition to introduce new, better products or lower prices of existing products. This is bad for the middle-class consumer because they'll have less to buy, and fewer places to work at. Furthermore, even if you went full Stalin and confiscated the entire wealth of all the billionaires, that's only $12T [1]. Sounds like a lot? It's a whopping $1500 per person in the world. You'll completely obliterate the economy for the ability to give everyone a check for $1500. One month later, 95% of that money will be spent and back in the hands of innovators and value providers. [1] https://www.forbes.com/billionaires/ https://www.forbes.com/billionaires/
- ToucanLoucan 3y ago> 70% corporate tax rate will get you another Reagan. What do you mean? We still have Reagans, they never went away. > It's a fast track to destroying entrepreneurship, reducing competition to introduce new, better products or lower prices of existing products. Right America wasn’t even remotely an economic power until the 80’s. How could I forget? > Furthermore, even if you went full Stalin and confiscated the entire wealth of all the billionaires, that's only $12T [1]. Sounds like a lot? It's a whopping $1500 per person in the world. You'll completely obliterate the economy for the ability to give everyone a check for $1500. One month later, 95% of that money will be spent and back in the hands of innovators and value providers. It’s not confiscating, it’s tax. Tax everything above one billion at 100%. It’s not one time, it’s every year. And it’s not like we wouldn’t still have incredibly rich people, we just wouldn’t be permitting them to lock up entire GDPs worth of money in nothing. Like if you think there are tons of people out there who will refuse to create businesses because we cap wealth at a mere, paltry one billion dollars, I think that’s a those people problem not an argument against that idea.
- jvanderbot 3y agoAlso, I'm curious about the tipping point from local basic income, to universal basic income. How is that not just asking for inflation?
- Acebulf 3y agoThe thing that I question is why is this requirement for this fiscal balancing only required for giving money to poor people? In 2018, the US Government added $2 trillion to the US national debt to give a 5k/capita/year subsidy to the top 5% of earners. If we're already in the business of chucking money at people in fiscally irresponsible ways, I don't see why changing the target from "rich people" or "oil companies" to "everyone" is suddenly a problem.
- chimprich 3y ago> However what is seemingly _never_ studied is how to finance such an operation You haven't understood the concept of UBI. It doesn't have to be "financed". It's a different way of assigning tax and benefits. E.g. imagine a population of only two people, Alice and Bob. Currently Alice pays £100 in tax, and Bob receives £50 in welfare payments because he's unemployed. You could set up a UBI scheme to be net zero. Under this UBI system, Alice would pay £150 in tax, and receive £50 in UBI. Bob would receive £50 in UBI instead of benefits. It doesn't have to cost anything (in theory). You could make it redistributive, but it doesn't have to be. The proponents of UBI would say it's worth it because you wouldn't have the expense and unfairness of means testing for benefits, and Bob would have the incentive to look for work (any work) without any reduction in benefits. In addition people could do things like start companies on a small guaranteed wage with less risk. Opposers of UBI would say some proportion of people wouldn't work at all if they were guaranteed an income. There are likely many more advantages and disadvantages that would only become apparent if a country actually tried it.
- entropicdrifter 3y agoI mean with progressive tax brackets it'd be redistributive even if everyone got the same exact payments
- mjevans 3y agoI would like to counter with first hand observed real world evidence. Raising the minimum wage near where I live (Seattle area) has raised the prices of everything. Rent seeking land owners raise their rents, which passes through to everything and absorbs the water trying to sate the parched desert. IMO either directly supplying what UBI is supposed to provide, or encouraging local supply to match the market need, thus driving down cost with competition as demand is finally met are how consumer welfare / buying power can be increased.
- kevingadd 3y agoMinimum wage and ubi are totally different, though? Why would you expect them to have the same effect? Or are you arguing that people need to be poor?
- jvanderbot 3y agominimum wage can be confused with UBI, because it has a disproportionate (positive) effect on the poorest - a significant % boost to their disposable income. There are a number of effects that boost disposable income in the US: lower tax brackets, tax credits, minimum wage, etc. I don't think anyone is arguing that people need to be poor, just illustrating that it's difficult to really say what the effect will be of increasing disposable income. Isolated studies of UBI suffer from this same problem. A localized increase in spending power may not tip the wider economy, but if everyone had it? That really might. We just don't know.
- jvanderbot 3y agoDuring a time of general inflation, it's difficult to tease out the effects.
- psunavy03 3y agoFunny that you blame landlords off the bat as opposed to the fact that everyone who employs folks at minimum wage is forced to raise prices in order not to go out of business.
- 3y ago
- SirMaster 3y agoWhen has UBI actually every been tried? I don't think any trials really qualify as "Universal". IMO the universal part is the hard part and changes it drastically. Compared to a small limited trial of giving people money, where does it all come from when it's actually universal? And what are the effects on the overall economy when it's universal?
- SoftTalker 3y ago> what are the effects on the overall economy when it's universal? Inflation.
- stray 3y agoHyperinflation.
- ben_w 3y agoThat depends how it's funded. Printing money? Yes. Taxing economic rents? Probably not. Owning a fully automated workforce? Yet to be determined.
- Detrytus 3y agoIt doesn't depend on how it's funded. It's a simple mechanics: once the word gets out that everybody is getting free money then all the companies raise their prices, trying to capture that money, because why wouldn't they?
- dfxm12 3y agoGreedflation already exists without any type of UBI in place. UBI is not meant to combat greedflation. You're right to be worried about greedflation, but being against UBI because greedflation exists simply doesn't follow.
- 3y ago
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoShockingly, when you give people who chronically lack resources those resources, they use them to better their circumstances. Who knew.
- monero-xmr 3y agoIn the US, we gave money to people during the pandemic. Worker shortages in low-skill labor resulted and inflation hit 10%. I think that's the major flaw - young, childless people without responsibility see no reason to work, when they can watch Netflix all day, either paying their mom some token rent or sharing a flop house with a bunch of friends.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- darthoctopus 3y ago> Fears that the experiment would engender laziness in participants were not borne out in the project’s findings: “The ‘laziness’ contention is just not supported by our findings,” the chief data analyst of one of the experiments said. “There is not anywhere near the mass defection the prophets of doom predicted.”
- monero-xmr 3y agoWe already did the experiment, across the whole country!
- Acebulf 3y agoYeah, and correlation isn't causality. Causal studies under controlled conditions don't back up what you're saying.
- jsbg 3y agowhy are the results of a study with a limited reach preferable to the results of an actual universal real world event?
- NoraCodes 3y agoThere is no control available; we don't have a second population of people who did go through the beginning of the COVID pandemic, 2020 political environment, and so forth, but did not receive the stimulus package. I suggest looking into some basic experimental design texts if you're interested in why this is so important!
- tuututututu 3y agoI'd like to make food stamps automatic for everyone. It makes pretty good sense to me. Everyone who has a driver's license or is enrolled in school or is registered to vote gets food stamps. The most hateful southern baptists in my family who are still screaming about Obama's death panels can still agree that donating to food banks is a good idea. I can understand people who say "I don't want to pay higher taxes to support other people." I think that's a shitty philosophy, but I can understand where they're coming from. But if we make food stamps universal, then those people get the benefit they're paying taxes for and some of them will stop complaining. It ensure a basic level of public health and removes the stigma from receiving and using food stamps. After we take care of that and instill the idea in everyone's mind that automating the basic necessities is good for everyone, we can work on housing, healthcare, and higher education.
- mattw2121 3y agoMake them transferable and I agree. If I get the food stamps and can easily transfer them to my adult kids, that would be great. Yes, it would probably mean drug dealers will take food stamps, but whatever.
- dfxm12 3y agoWhy is food different from roads? Schools? Police? Fire departments? Have these people ever made an insurance claim? Set foot in a state/national park? Cashed a stimulus check? etc. My point is, someone saying "I don't want to pay higher taxes to support other people" has already lost the plot. They are already receiving benefits paid for by someone else. If they weren't already convinced that this is a good thing, they're either not paying attention (in which case, why would they start now?), or care more about keeping poor people suffering than improving their own lot in life (which, in my experience, is more likely).
- Izkata 3y agoI have seen people complain about paying taxes for schools when they don't have kids, and all your other examples go back to the taxpayer in some way. Food stamps are like the school one, they don't go back to the taxpayer - they're paying without getting anything back, hence complaining. GP's idea might be a decent way to sidestep that - at the very least it's tighter in scope so the negative effects would be limited.
- dupertrooper 3y ago[flagged]
- throwway120385 3y agoThe real problem here is that we expect an individual to operate on the same footing as a firm. The firm can use its army of people to devise new ways to bamboozle the individual, but the individual has only their wits and their free time to use to defend themselves. The only way to protect yourself as an individual is collective action.
- dingnuts 3y agoand that's why the Soviet Union won the Cold War
- FredPret 3y agoIf you believe in science, you have to also believe that the free market is working. Instead of getting worked up by online talking points spewed by your fellow Bernie Bros, you should look at some stats about the wealth creation and quality-of-life stats over the past 200yrs, 50yrs, 20yrs, etc.
- throwawa14223 3y agoYou confuse my goals with your goals. Conservative economics advance my goals fine.
- jackthetab 3y agoHave anything to back up your first statement? Might be useful ammo...not that I've ever bought into conservative economics before.
- pydry 3y agoUBI is sold to us as a pipe dream by people who will fight tooth and nail to prevent the minimum wage from being raised. It's also not a particularly new idea. The Roman empire had UBI in the form of Cura Annonae.
- danpalmer 3y agoReally? Thinking of all the people I know personally who think UBI is a good idea, I think all of them would say raising minimum wages is also a good idea. There may be a few fiscally conservative influencers pushing the idea (sama?), but among regular people I think it's only those who strongly support spending on social security, worker rights, minimum wages, etc, who support it.
- pydry 3y agoIm talking about the billionaires who talk about how theoretically great this idea is, not the receptacles for their propaganda. If it became politically feasible theyd quickly sour on the idea. However, pipe dreams are a-ok - they arent inflationary.
- orangecat 3y agoUBI is sold to us as a pipe dream by people who will fight tooth and nail to prevent the minimum wage from being raised. If there's a UBI, why do you need a minimum wage? A UBI gives people negotiating power to decline unfairly low wages, because they don't have to face homelessness or hunger if they're not working.
- pydry 3y agoIndeed there are many different kinds of political pipe dreams that would negate the need for a minimum wage.
- CityOfThrowaway 3y agoYes, of course giving people money makes their lives better. It especially works when a very small subset of the population receives such treatment, such that their relative income is higher than those outside the experiment. The issue with UBI is that enacting it at scale has two huge problems: 1. Financing it. These programs are monumentally expensive. You need to get the money from somewhere. The easiest place to take it is via the money printer and the second is from the rich. If you do it via the money printer, it's a self-own in terms of inflationary impact. If you do it by taxing the rich, you wind up hobbling and punishing your most productive citizens. Look at China's economic situation right now to see how ultimately unproductive that can be. 2. Diminishing effects. A bit more money is great when everybody else in your local economy didn't get it. But when everybody gets it, things just become more expensive. The USA did this during the COVID era. We basically implemented UBI. We expanded the M1 money supply from $4T to $18T and largely handed it out in a diffuse way. For the first 6 months it was awesome. And then shortages started spiking and inflation started creeping in. We ultimately had to roll it back. I don't think these problems are fundamentally solvable. Instead, we should foster competition, incentivize innovation, and let markets do their thing. This will create lower prices for basic goods and create employment opportunities so people can have what they need for cheap, under the financing of their own effort.
- tnel77 3y agoWhile I agree with many of your points, I feel like blaming item shortages on COVID payments is ignoring the massive impacts that panic buying and shutting down ports and factories had on the situation. Yes there was more money floating around, but people were purchasing items like it was the end of days and we had factories worldwide shuttering randomly due to COVID outbreaks and various government mandates which threw supply chains out of wack.
- CityOfThrowaway 3y agoYou're right, the problem in the US was multi-causal. I mention that case because it is probably the best large-scale deployment of a UBI-like program any country has ever done. While we can't completely untangle the exact contribution magnitude, I think we can deduce that at least some meaningful % of the shortage/inflation situation was caused by the UBI-like program.
- giantg2 3y agoThe speech in this article is highly politicized. "Universal Basic Income Has Been Tried over and over Again. It Works Every Time" Depends on how we define "works" and also on the scope. All of the examples given involve small sample size programs that end rather quickly, programs that are not universal but based on some need, or programs funded by state owned natural resources (oil). I appreciate the examples and some of them history around them. I don't agree with the title since most of these are small, short programs, and they are usually not universal. These sorts of tests do nothing to explore macroeconomic effects if everyone recieved the same money. They also don't explore longterm sustainable funding solutions.
- dingnuts 3y agoI wish political dreck like this wasn't allowed on HN
- Detrytus 3y agoUniversal Basic Income has never been tried, because all the trials lack "Universal" component to it, they are limited in scale. Once you start giving out free money to millions of people the only result is inflation, and people receiving UBI would not be better off at all. In fact, the closest thing I can think of that would be similar to introducing UBI was "500+" program in Poland, which, as the name implies, was about giving families 500 PLN monthly per each child that they have. As you might have guessed, inflation in Poland has been brutal since then.
- arp242 3y agoMost of these are either fairly short-lived limited pilots, or aren't really "UBI" (e.g. Alaska's $1,600 a year hardly qualifies as UBI as it's just enough to buy groceries with, never mind rent or any other basic needs). A large population with basic needs met and nothing particular they have to do is untested. I don't really know how that will end, but I fear it may not end especially well. Let's be real: no one works at McDonalds because they have a great passion to fry burgers. SpongeBob was a lie! Would extra income from McDonalds be enough to motivate people to do this kind of stuff anyway? Perhaps. It's currently unclear. I'm somewhat skeptical that large changes are afoot though; current AI systems aren't really good enough for most things and it's unclear what future developments will bring. And you can't automate frying burgers or stock shelves in the first place (well, not without huge investments that just aren't worth it).
- Shadowmist 3y agoI’d go work at McDonalds for a PS5 or whatever, even if I didn’t have to pay for rent and food.
- arp242 3y agoSure, but it's not clear if there are enough people who will do that. And we also need to ask the question: what if there aren't enough jobs? Everyone without a job should just live off the bare basic necessities without entertainment? Or what will that look like? There's a lot of optimistic views about UBI, but here is what I think it will be like realistically: poverty. Surviving, but not really living. The bare minimum to not riot in the streets. This is how these sort of things have usually worked out in the past. "Bread and circuses" etc. As I said, I'm skeptical that all this post-scarcity everything-is-automated future will come to pass any time soon, but if it does, we almost certainly need to do more than UBI. A lot more. Sam Altman is mentioned in this article: OpenAI is built on all of our work. Whether that's "fair use" or "pilfered" is a matter of opinion, but neither view changes the fact that OpenAI takes the works of our culture that we all contributed to and uses it for private profits it keeps to itself. That's not really a huge social problem if it's "just" a company – maybe you can consider it unfair, but that's something else. But if OpenAI and companies like it really do eat the world as the AI maximalists claim it will we end up with a situation where an exceedingly tiny minority will have an enormous percentage of the world's wealth, all of which is very directly built on the public's work, and it's no longer "just" a company with handsome profits. That entire situation will be spectacularly untenable. So what do we do with that? The entire "OpenAI is a foundation for the public good" thing went out the window as soon as green bits of paper became involved (and of course that was going to happen). That's not the bit Sam Altman wants to talk about. "Silicon Valley philosophy" like this is usually only remarkable in how profoundly shallow and self-serving it is.
- magic_hamster 3y agoI've read the comments on this thread so far and while there are definitely some good points, I think everyone is ignoring a central issue when it comes to welfare: in the US, anything that even remotely resembles socialism is going to be shut down violently regardless of how well it could work. Free education & free healthcare are staples of most western countries, but not the US. Universal basic income has also been given out in some places in Europe. But in the US, all of these ideas are traditionally rejected by the people, and of course, any kind of wealth distribution is going to be countered with strong resistance from corporations, lobbyists and certain individuals. Bottom line is, regardless of how well it works, all the pieces need to fit a certain way for this to be implemented, which is very unlikely.
- bombcar 3y agoThe US has free education from kindergarten through high school. The US also has something akin to UBI, called the earned income tax credit. It's not much to expand that, especially since social security already covers a percentage.
- ugh123 3y agoMaybe all we need is universal health care plus housing allowances. Let people live. Let them figure out how to prosper themselves
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- babelthuap 3y ago[dead]
- ernestipark 3y agoAs long as we dont increase housing stock (at least in the United States) if we implement this more universally, the money will just further increase the value of real estate and make homes more expensive.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoAny money given to non-property owners will eventually be extracted by the property owners. UBI given to everyone will eventually lead to the same effective poverty we have now and much wealthier landlords.
- orangecat 3y agoWhy specifically landlords and not sellers of food, gas, cell phones, etc? Everyone would like to raise their prices, but as long as there's competition they can't do so arbitrarily.
- J_Shelby_J 3y agonot just landlords. Property owners as well. You extract wealth from the system either renting or paying your self rent. It’s just a matter of when you take those gains. Homeowners do when they sale. As to why it’s unique to housing; you answered your own question: the housing market is arbitrarily limited in supply, which means it’s artificially low competition, which means people that own take an artificially high profit from owning. There are many rent seeking businesses, but housing is so universal and universally fucked that it accounts for by far the largest wealth transfer. Everything I’ve written is true for housing now, but direct cash injections make it more apparent. See rent prices exploding after COVID stimulus.
- neom 3y agoA Capitalist Road to Communism (1986) - https://www.researchgate.net/publication/24015173_A_Capitalist_Road_to_Communism https://www.researchgate.net/publication/24015173_A_Capitali... and: The capitalist road to communism: are we there yet? - https://books.openedition.org/pucl/1853?lang=en https://books.openedition.org/pucl/1853?lang=en
- orangesite 3y agoSam Altman diverting the salaries of folk replaced by AI into his own pocket: "Yeeeerrrrs… I think we should replace those salaries with taxes paid by the people who still have jobs left and don't y'all think I'm just such a wonderful guy for saying such a socially progressive thing?" What the hell is everyone smoking? Is there no systemic awareness left in the world?
- neilv 3y agoHow about Universal Limited Income? No one can have more than $X of wealth. Analogy: Town of houses. Everyone gets help building a house, can fix it up however they like, etc. One day, some person tries to take many house lots, to build a massive temple to themself. As a corrective mechanism, other townspeople repeatedly throw that person into the river, until the person is cured.
- febeling 3y agoUBI is the weirdest thing. I'm certainly no fan of an economic system which casually threatens each of it's member with starvation and homelessness if personal misfortune strikes. But universal basic income is something different than support for someone in need. It has to be paid by someone, but this someone isn't ever mentioned. It's somehow the government. But government needs to be funded, too. So ultimately it's an attempt make everyone hand over responsibility of our lives and livelihoods to some opaque sustenance function, without thinking or asking any questions.
- beaeglebeached 3y agoGovernment should be forced to compete in the free market like the plebs if they want money for their programs and salaries, rather than sending men with machine guns to prey on victims. Hope the fucks in office are good at flipping burgers and can cut out the avocado toast.
- J_Shelby_J 3y agoAmericans spend 1/3rd of their income on cars, and 1/3rd to 1/2 on housing. UBI is not going to fix this. It will just move the prices of these nessecities up like we saw durning the COVID stimulus. America and most of the developed world is stricken with a supply problem. Car dependency is resource intensive and housing is in such short supply that it costs 2x what it would in an efficient market. Any attempt to fix it on the monetary side via ubi or minimum wage is a waste of time. Although, if we did fix it, then UBI would be great, but probably not really necessary.
- whitewingjek 3y agoUBI may sound like a worthwhile endeavor to a great many people, but I can't help but think of what we give up with such a system. If I politicaly dissent from the majority (whomsoever that is or whatever they believe) what stops them—the government as often described—from stopping UBI from those that are deemed "unfit."
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoBy definition they're not doing UBI then. That doesn't alleviate your concern that that's how things might go, but your concern is that UBI might not be UBI.
- whitewingjek 3y agoThat would be a correct assessment, but that would not stop people from calling it that if that does happen.
- caekislove 3y agoI'm old enough to remember influential TV people advocating for the revocation of the "rights" of certain people to healthcare, employment or even being allowed to leave their own homes if they refused to be injected with the special science juice. That was just a hypothetical scenario! The sad reality in America is that anything real like UBI would be politically weaponized from practically day one.
- ls612 3y agoIf you give 500 people a few thousand dollars (in cash or in kind) it makes them better off. If you give everyone a few thousand dollars you cause inflation.
- tillinghast 3y agoUBI for very small values of U.
- Erratic6576 3y agoDavid Graeber argued that there are bullshit jobs, that keep people busy with tasks that are useless for their development or the society. He didn’t take into account that there are destructive jobs, whose workers significantly contribute to the destruction of the conditions which render the planet habitable. The planet would be better off if those folks received a UBI for staying at home
- TrackerFF 3y agoLiving in poverty is expensive and stressful, and can trap you into staying in poverty. You become desperate, and make very suboptimal decisions. You get rewarded for short-term rewards. A good example would be jobs. If you could dedicate all your time to applying for jobs, you could maximize your salary - but what poor people can afford that? So you take the first and best job you can find, as you need the money now. 6 months without pay is an eternity. If you're poor, you can't really go longer than 2 weeks without pay. And when you're shit out of luck, not a single cent in the bank (negative balance, even, with the overdue fees running) you start to look for expensive loans to float you. Payday loans, expensive credit card loans, and what not. You get hit with late fees for every bill you can't pay on time. Things which are somewhat affordable early on - like getting cavities in your teeth fixed, become horribly expensive down the road. Those are just one of many, many things. And we haven't even considered the physical and mental stress - the first and last thing you think about, is money. At least UBI, or some similar system, can remove some of those stressors.
- deviantbit 3y agoUBI essentially occurs for everyone in the United States at age 67. It is called Social Security. "Works" has not been defined in this article, and I'm not sure by reading it I understand what that means. If it were implemented for the population at large, this would drive commodities, and housing prices up. Also, with no limits on its use, drug use would most likely increase, as would crime. This would also incentivize further immigration problems. As other programs with good intentions, this would quickly spiral out of control. Approximately $1.7 trillion dollars of our deficit is spent on Medicare/Medicaid. That is more than a third of the total revenue of the United States. I do not see how UBI or GBI would benefit anyone other than those unwilling to work. There are two books I would recommend people read. The first is Understanding Capitalism: Competition, Command, and Change by Martin Wolf, and the second The Crisis of Democratic Capitalism by Bowles. Both go into detail the problems we are facing. The first book was a text book one of my kids had for their economics course. I decided to read it out of curiosity. It changed my view on several key issues. Futhermore, the UBI experiment in Finland failed. Every notable economist agreed, Finland's own report showed it was a failure. They noted not only the economic failure, but also the social failure, with their populous overwhelmingly feeling there was an unfairness in the system. Let me tell you how Medicaid/Medicare is being abused. You might find I'm cruel, or I don't love my mother. But here are the facts. My mother went on Medicare in 2007. She had two different cancers. Medicare picked up the tab up for both. Treatment for each one was well over $1 million dollars. She then had both knees replaced, both hips replaced for a total of almost $450,000. Then COVID came. She refused to get vaccinated. She was placed in ICU for 60 days on a ventilator. Furthermore, she had a heart attack, and her stomach ruptured while on the ventilator. How she survived is beyond me. The total bill picked up by medicare was well over a million. She viewed it as her right. She is a Woodstock hippie, everything had to be natural, and kept those beliefs until she was old enough to get on Medicare. I don't think we understand what we're doing when we allow this kind of gross spending and how it works in our political system. For me, if I require millions of dollars to keep me alive, let me die. I don't want those costs passed onto my children and the next generation. If I'm so poor I need UBI, I would hope, I would do something not to cause others to be inconvenienced and work. Be careful of the government programs you want. The people you think won't abuse them, will absolutely abuse them. I feel UBI would be disastrous, but would be abused and further corruption in our country.
- nojvek 3y agoUniversal Basic Income has NEVER been tried. i.e Giving every citizen of a relatively large country (> 10 million) a fixed sum of money every month. It works on small samples because that doesn't suddenly change the demand curve relatively to supply. Everytime the govt prints money and gives it as a stimulus check, that is akin to UBI. The problem is usually supply. One can always pump up demand by dolling out free money. Even if you gave every US citizen a million dollars but the housing inventory doesn't go up, house prices go up by a million dollars. Money is merely a means fill demand with supply. Universal basic distribution is a phenomenal idea. e.g everyone receives free basic healthcare (Most modern countries do this). Capitalistic competition is a good thing when there are multiple players working hard to output the highest quality at cheapest prices. Governments as single player monopolies aren't the most efficient at distribution. Universal Basic Supply is an idea I can get behind. UBI has a big gaping hole called inflation.
- jrflowers 3y agoThe problem with UBI is the vibe — I did not get it so, obviously, no one should I could post about inflation or hobbling the prime mover class but mostly when I think about people getting money it just sort of feels icky so I make sure to be vocal about my opposition to it on the grounds of my lived experience whenever it gets brought up
- euroderf 3y agoThe surface of the Earth is no longer every person's birthright. Every damned square inch is "owned", with rare exception. The "frontier" is no more. The wide open spaces are no more. The commons is fully fenced. I see UBI as a hack that attempts to address this new reality. Instead of a place to plant your flag, you get a stipend. And an aside: If you don't like the UBI, then alternatively how might you feel about putting limits to land ownership ? Rather than perpetuity, how about replacing ownership with 99-year leases ?
- npmccallum 3y agoUBI is also the most effective tool ever devised for implementing tyranny.
- RetroTechie 3y agoIgnored often: $$ at the lower end make a much bigger difference than same $$ at the higher end. Tax wealthy individuals a few hundred $/month extra, and it'll hardly be a blip on their radar (although they might make a stink politically). Give poor people a few hundred $/month extra, and it could transform their lives. In short: those $$ have a much higher ROI if spent on the lower end of the population. And thus a much higher bang-for-buck when trying to maximize a population's overall well-being.