9 ms·
Feds want to ban the Flipper Zero – Experts say it's a scapegoat
- INTPenis 3y agoI actually gave my two flippers away because I didn't think there were enough viable attack surfaces here in Sweden. But I can totally see how they're useful in other less developed countries.
- Astraco 3y agoI saw what you did there.
- 2024throwaway 3y agoI knew from the headline this was about my beloved Flipper Zero. It is absolutely a scapegoat. There's nothing magical about it, and it doesn't do anything that can't be done with other devices.
- jgrahamc 3y agoWhat do you love about it? I have one and I've only used it very occasionally (e.g. https://blog.jgc.org/2024/02/repairing-sort-of-dyson-fan-remote.html https://blog.jgc.org/2024/02/repairing-sort-of-dyson-fan-rem...). I did make a backup of the NFC card that I use to charge my car because it's super useful to have a duplicate, although even that I barely use because I'd need to carry the Flipper Zero around with me.
- 2024throwaway 3y agoCloned various remote controls (treadmill, ceiling fan, floor fan) into one interface. Also the article isn't wrong, it's cute!
- jgrahamc 3y agoAre these all infrared? Because I've done that and it's handy, but I could also have done that with a universal remote.
- 2024throwaway 3y agoOnly the floor fan is infrared. The rest are radio.
- wil421 3y agoOr just get a few smart home products, connect your devices, and automate everything from you phone. Easier than carrying around your Flipper Zero at home.
- 2024throwaway 3y ago"Replace your ceiling fan and treadmill" is certainly not easier than having a small device sitting on my desk.
- wil421 3y agoWhy on earth would you do that? An IR blaster costs $25 and will connect to Homebirdge so you have it in Apple Home (or Android whatever). I made 2 dehumidifiers and 2 floor fans “smart” by buying the cheapest possible smart plugs on Amazon, an Amazon branded smart plug cost me $1 during a sale. BroadLink RM4 Mini IR Universal Remote Control, Smart Home Automation Wi-Fi Infrared Blaster https://a.co/d/8GnOVRU https://a.co/d/8GnOVRU
- 2024throwaway 3y agoThat covers the floor fan. Now I need a radio blaster to control the ceiling fan and treadmill. So two extra devices, plus having to set up new automation integrations. This all sounds WAY more complicated than just cloning the remotes like I've done. Would it be more flexible/powerful? Absolutely. Do I need any of that? Absolutely not.
- abnry 3y agoFrom what I understand, it is magical in the sense that it makes everything easy to do, even for people without much knowledge.
- ghostpepper 3y agoIt makes some things magically easy to do, but stealing cars is not one of them.
- Reason077 3y agoDepends very much on the car. Do you own a Hyundai or Kia?
- Astraco 3y agoMaybe we should ban Hyundais and Kias until they fix their security holes. Just an idea about banning things
- hnav 3y agothe whole debacle with hyundai/kia is that they shipped cars where you can physically start it without electronics
- Reason077 3y agoThere’s an electronic attack too. This apparently affects many late-model Hyundai/Kia vehicles up to 2023 or so. https://www.reddit.com/r/Ioniq5/comments/17lksic/increase_in_ioniq_5_thefts_uk/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Ioniq5/comments/17lksic/increase_in...
- mholt 3y agoInstead of banning game boys with radios, maybe fix the swiss cheese cars.
- op00to 3y agoAs a Hyundai owner, TTTHHHIIISSS!
- Reason077 3y agoWas going to mention Hyundai/Kia. (Background: many pre-2023 or so Hyundai, Kia, and Genesis models have a catastrophic security flaw that allows thieves to open, start, and drive affected vehicles without needing any access to the key fob at all. This is far worse than a signal cloning or relay attack and has resulted in skyrocketing theft rates and spiralling insurance costs in many countries…)
- op00to 3y agoThat catastrophic security flaw? That the US Gov't didn't require immobilizers on cars until way too late. Funnily enough, Canada DID require immobilizers, so I think they're not subject to the same BS my car is subject to.
- Reason077 3y agoNothing to do with immobilizers: that was a separate issue that was apparently fixed in 2021. It’s a wireless attack that affects late model cars with proximity-based keyfobs (ie: ones that do not require a button to be pressed on the fob for the car to detect it), including 2022 and 2023 models such as the Ioniq 5 EV: https://www.reddit.com/r/Ioniq5/comments/17lksic/increase_in_ioniq_5_thefts_uk/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Ioniq5/comments/17lksic/increase_in... All countries seem to be affected, not just US models.
- op00to 3y agoI guarantee you that issue was not fixed for everyone in 2021, looking at my car without a software update. :)
- WhatsName 3y agoFor me the page briefly loads and then quickly gets replaced by 404 in large letters. Anyone else got that problem?
- LinuxBender 3y agoI am not seeing that, but here [1] is an archive if that helps at all. [1] - https://archive.is/0Hc1l https://archive.is/0Hc1l
- xvector 3y agoSame issue here. Maybe adblocker or VPN related.
- ijhuygft776 3y agoThe Flipper Zero is a nice device but are there any cheaper alternatives?
- happytiger 3y ago(Ok, I’ll remove them as they aren’t helpful. Thanks.)
- ganoushoreilly 3y agoNone of these are the same class of device. They're all specific hardware for specific tasks that are handled by the small handheld flipper. While the flipper may not be as great of a device as each of these, none of these are smaller and definitely not cheaper. What OP was looking for was more along the lines of the Arduino / ESP projects build much like the flipper.
- neom 3y agoI mentioned this last time it came up[1] but I'll mention it again, if anyone is directly affected by this precedent being potentially set, please reach out to me. A little more context, I'm the founder in residence at a very large Canadian law firm, and we have a government relations group. I'd be willing to use a bit of my budget to see if we can't push into this somehow. [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39310369 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39310369
- happytiger 3y agoBless you for doing this. I’ll point some friends to your post.
- pierat 3y agoI would suggest you also look into potential illegalization of things like SDRs like the HackRF portapack, and other SDRs. My kit can easily do a LOT of naughty stuff. JUst because I can, doesn't mean I do. But again, this won't just be a flipper zero ban, but a SDR RX/TX ban. (Im aware the flipper0 is not a SDR, but using the chip Texas Instruments CC1101 chip, but is functionally able to record/playback IQ-ish data.)
- Dalewyn 3y agoBefore anyone asks "Why is a Canadian law firm concerned with the USA?", the headline by Vice is hideously misleading: "Feds" as in the Canadian federal government, not the US federal government. Writing like this is one of many reasons I despise "journalism" now.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoThat all headlines are not contextualized to the US is why you hate journalism?
- tdb7893 3y agoJournalism has its flaws but my experience is that some people just want to hate on journalists and will use every excuse. Edit: it's also a little funny to see people who work in tech throwing stones at journalists
- sgerenser 3y agoWent ahead and ordered one of these last week after hearing stories about a potential ban. No idea what I’m going to do with it, but not being able to get one made me want to have one just to play around with.
- happytiger 3y agoThey are super great for teaching kids. Absolutely brilliant little device.
- megiddo 3y agoDamn, I've been trying to sell mine. Is there a used market place for them?
- Zircom 3y agoDrop me an email(on my profile) I'd be interested possibly.
- user_7832 3y agoThere might be some variant of a r/hardwareswap. Side note, if you/anyone in the Netherlands is trying to sell one I'm interested.
- dbrueck 3y agoSold mine for $300 on ebay.
- stronglikedan 3y agoThat's nuts considering they're available for $170, unless it was one of the sold out transparent ones.
- dbrueck 3y agoWell, it was soon after they really got their shipping rhythm going. I got mine in the mail, it sat on my desk for a few weeks because I was busy with other stuff, and it made me sad to just have it sit there unused. I wasn't completely sold on getting rid of it, so I put it on ebay for what I assumed to be an outrageous price, and it was gone within an hour. I shoulda bought 2!
- colpabar 3y agoI don't know what I'd do with it, but the fact that it's going to be banned makes me want one.
- rabbitofdeath 3y agoThis. What better publicity could you ask for?? (I love mine and use it for harmless things)
- shakow 3y agoCrazy idea – what if we just got back to physical keys for car? Simple, cheap, ecological, durable – what's not to love?
- cobbal 3y agoFor one, we never quite managed to convince people that the wiggly bits of metal were an important secret that should not be photographed. Cryptography can in principle be harder to duplicate/impersonate. (If, and big if, it's implemented correctly)
- munk-a 3y agoPor que no los dos? I mean - why don't we just integrate the dongle signal being necessary to unlock the car into the existing process and still require a physical key. As a bonus the key could be designed to interface with the car to communicate any signing tokens over a wired connection in the key socket instead of having any radio/wireless capabilities at all.
- kube-system 3y agoMaking duplicate keys from a photo is almost entirely an academic exercise. Criminals break locks much more quickly by using force.
- pnutjam 3y agoI hated the idea of push button start and wireless keyfob; until I got one. Now I feel put out every time I have to dig my keychain out of my pocket.
- rvnx 3y agoDo they really need something extra ? It's made to operate like a non-certified radio device, is there even new laws needed to cover the case where you emit radio waves without licence ? + at risk of being coerced in following Russian laws: https://www.reddit.com/r/flipperclub/comments/13b6emd/flipper_zero_firmware_hosted_on_russian_servers/ https://www.reddit.com/r/flipperclub/comments/13b6emd/flippe...
- kj4ips 3y agoThe flipper zero is ISED(CA FCC equivelant) conformant/certified. In stock configuration, it transmits only in bands where no license is required, such as the ISM bands. However, the operator is ultimately responsible for the emissions of their devices.
- Symbiote 3y agoI wasn't aware of the Russian link. Does anyone have links to public statements from the founders? They appear to live in London, so silence isn't good enough in my book. Though I've long ago stopped buying toys from China, so this is probably ruled out for me on that basis.
- nickthegreek 3y agoprevious discussion (2/8/24): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39308731 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39308731
- segmondy 3y agoI have one, and I occasionally drive to Canada. Definitely need to be aware not to have it on me anymore. :-/
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoThe term that we're looking for here is "moral panic".
- Sparkyte 3y agoIt certainly is a scape goat, the law should be trying to prevent the misuse of technology rather than the ownership of technology. Like guns it is the misuse that kills not the ownership. Most people being killed by gun are from unlicensed and unregistered firearms and it is a misuse. Same should be said about technology as well.
- mgarfias 3y agoYou mean illegally owned firearms. In most of america there is no registration or licensing requirement
- eindiran 3y ago> registration If you purchase a firearm from an FFL anywhere in the United States, you are required to fill out an ATF form 4473 and do a NICS background check. There isn't a giant database of all firearms in the US indexed by owner and serial number, but those 4473s do exist and are handed over to the Federal government pretty regularly by FFLs. > licensing In most places (eg those with "Constitutional Carry"), the only license you need is to not be a prohibited person (not mentally ill, a felon, no violent misdemeanors involving stalking or domestic violence) and old enough to purchase a gun in the relevant state. But if we just go by raw population, most people in the US would need to go through a more substantial process.
- calvinmorrison 3y agonot to mention you don't need to use a FFL at all in many (most?) cases.
- int_19h 3y ago15 states have mandatory background checks (which in practice means going through FFL) for all firearm purchases.
- 3y ago
- office_drone 3y agoIt is a scapegoat, and banning it is theatre. The current government of the Trudeau Liberals knows what actual steps it could take to combat car theft, involving dismantling organized crime controlling the ports, and does not want to do it. Instead, they create a scapegoat, ban it, and pretend that they're doing something.
- dmonitor 3y agoI kind of hate the Flipper Zero on principle. It's basically a script kiddy device for hardware. People use them to essentially DDOS cell phones with BLE connection requests. You can do it with any micro controller with a 2.4ghz radio, but this thing makes it easy for annoying people to just pull a script from the internet and make it everyone else's problem.
- ganoushoreilly 3y agoScript kiddies aren't new, they will always be around regardless of the tools. The response is build better tools to mitigate their rudimentary attacks.
- anigbrowl 3y agoThat works OK if you can deploy through the net. But many devices are not net connected (eg garage door openers) and we've seen the many problems with trying to make every electrical appliance net connected - surveillance, data leaks, remote shutdowns, device bricking when then IP connectivity goes down. Technology shouldn't force consumers into endless upgrade cycles in the name of better security.
- techplex 3y agoWhy not hate the cell phone manufacturers for not making secure devices?
- pierat 3y agoIt's OK. We hate your apple devices too. BTW, wanna connect to the Apple TV? :D
- jwr 3y agoIt's also a pretty useful device if you are into electronics. Or need backups of your access cards. Or of your silly garage key fobs. There are many great uses of this thing. I'm also annoyed by the script kiddies, but I do like the device. A lot.
- deleted 3y ago
- sylware 3y agoSaw the news sometime earlier about a brand new and similar device, but better :) It's RISC-V.
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoI assumed from the title that the American feds wanted to ban the Flipper Zero. Canada is a small country, and "Feds" in English almost always refers to the national government of the United States. The previous discussion title used "Canadian government" to refer to these particular Feds: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39308731 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39308731
- int_19h 3y agoThe United States is not the entirety of the world. There are many other countries that are federations, and some of them have English as one of their national languages. I can assure you that in those countries, colloquial use of "feds" does not refer to the American federal government.
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoThe United States is the majority of the English-speaking world with a federal government.
- int_19h 3y agoEven if that were true, that doesn't mean that it gets to be the default in any context. But you're wrong, because the largest English-speaking country with a federal government is actually India.
- AlanYx 3y agoIt's definitely a scapegoat, but aren't some of the statements in this article false? For example, I thought it can be used in NFC relay (not replay) attacks with an app. I also thought there are alternative firmware options that you can use to precompute values to roll forward codes.
- evilbob93 3y agoI got the black Kickstarter-only version. I got interested in coding in C again. My (now) ex broke up with me over this thing on the mistaken notion that I was messing with her somehow electronically. I got told i had to leave. Tonight. And take all my electronics with me. She cited having her "black hat friend" looking into it and he said it was pretty evil. I am sure she is reading the recent news with some level of satisfaction. I bought another a couple months later and if I can get over my ADHD, I still hope to make the radio chat useful.
- pierat 3y agoSounds like you dodged a bullet there. She sounds crazy AND stupid. My SO was like, "Wheres mine?"
- Havoc 3y ago>the mistaken notion that I was messing with her somehow electronically Let me guess...via 5G?
- fransje26 3y agoNo, it's interfering with the nano antennas injected with the Covid vaccines..
- fransje26 3y ago> She cited having her "black hat friend" looking On the first pass I read it as: "She cited having her tinfoil hat friend looking into it"..
- whalesalad 3y agoI bought one specifically due to a concern that they would get banned. Haven't even booted it up yet, but glad I possess one.
- aaronbrethorst 3y agonamed after the virtual dolphin from the movie Johnny Mnemonic The dolphin was named Jones not Flipper. And Jones was also a part of the short story that predated the film adaptation by several years. Check out "Burning Chrome," William Gibson's collection of short stories, for this and others. Well worth the read.
- jhbadger 3y agoYes, Flipper was the name of a dolphin in a 1960s TV show of that name (that has had various TV and movie reboots since). That's the reference they were going for.
- Havoc 3y agoAnyone serious about causing chaos is probably not using one anyway. On the other hand there is a similar device that can spoof GPS. When I saw that I was more along the lines of OK that maybe we should ban.
- hnthrowaway0328 3y agoSadly it was sold out in Canada already. The price point is HIGH though so maybe I should just learn electronics to build one.
- aftbit 3y agoDum dumb dum. Tools aren't the problem. Don't criminalize tools, criminalize behavior.
- screenothethird 3y ago[dead]
- scrps 3y agoPresumably having a flipper in your pocket, if the ban happens, will subject you to legal liability and something tells me the penalties will be less than stealing a car. So the people who are trying to use the flipper zero to commit a greater crime will simply not care and carry on because who cares about a misdemeanor when you are about to commit a felony. Organized criminals can get bespoke hardware simply by hiring skilled labor overlooked or outcast by industry. Skilled tech-based criminals can build their own kit. This hurts mostly people who want to get into some form of security or hacking and at best maybe stops high school antics but threatens to upend the entire way hackers have always honed their skills by doing and tinkering and also upending the small industries that support them and the security professionals who use the gear in production. Edit: typo
- ihumanable 3y agoI wonder if this ends up being more like lockpicks in practice. It's legal to own lockpicks but some jurisdictions consider possessing a lockpick to be prima facie intent to commit crime.
- scrps 3y agoThat at least heads toward rationality. Something along the lines of if you are caught with a flipper zero during the commission of a crime AND the flipper zero was used to further it then it becomes a "burglary tool" or some such classification. Edit: typo... Again