4 ms·
This Is All Your App Is: A Collection Of Tiny Details
- estrabd 15y agoThis would not work in a multi-dog household.
- bconway 15y agoHaving owned both of those cat feeders, for all the improvements made, the new model has a fatal flaw not readily apparent from the pictures shown: The edges of the hopper are not at a steep enough slope to move all the cat food downward (depending on size/shape, I imagine). This allows significant amounts of food to pile up on the sides and not be funneled into the dispensing mechanism underneath. Worse than just causing the unit to have a much smaller usable volume that expected, it gives the appearance of still being full when, in fact, the cats are starving. I'm not sure how any of that figures into his analogy, though.
- bostonvaulter2 15y agoWith that said do you still prefer the new one to the old one?
- adrianhoward 15y agoA vaguely related point to this is how the problems with getting details right are related to the simplicity or complexity of the product. The more complex the product, the more details it has, and the harder it is to get all of those details "right". Sometimes it's impossible to get all of them "right" because different market segments have different ideas of what "right" is. That's one of the core reasons I recommend that people start with smaller, simpler products. The easiest way of avoiding getting details wrong is to not have them in the first place. It's much easier to delight a customer with a small simple product - because there are far fewer things for you to foul up :-)
- danielmiller 15y agoHold on a second, Jeff! > Your software, your product, is nothing more than a collection of tiny details. If you don't obsess over all those details, if you think it's OK to concentrate on the "important" parts and continue to ignore the other umpteen dozen tiny little ways your product annoys the people who use it on a daily basis – you're not creating great software. Someone else is. I think the true moral of his story contradicts his conclusion. He and his wife had a problem: They didn't like manually feeding their cats. So they bought a couple of automatic cat feeders and enjoyed owning them—despite several small, annoying flaws. In fact, he and his wife dutifully employed those feeders for five years until he noticed (and purchased) the company's newer, improved version! I liked the essay, but I suppose Jeff and I disagree on what the story teaches us. This story is about a company that identified a pain point (manually feeding cats is annoying) and created a product that alleviated the pain (an automatic cat feeder) despite several flaws (a bad color, an annoying button guard, and a difficult to clean food bowl, to name a few). Over time, the company resolved those flaws, but they didn't wait until all of the flaws were resolved before initially shipping their product. Instead, they shipped a useful, albeit imperfect product, and earned themselves at least two repeat customers.
- j_baker 15y agoThere's a world of difference between "imperfect" and "merely adequate". Not having all the details squared away makes your product imperfect. Not having all the important details squared away makes your product "merely adequate". The key is knowing which details are important and which aren't. Using "We can't be perfect" to dismiss the details is a cop out. I mean, the company that made these things could have decided that the first version shouldn't include the timer. This is the imperfect first version. Time it yourself, and we'll add a timer to the next version! After all, that's all you need to feed your cats on a schedule, isn't it? Sure! This product is adequate. Why get distracted with unnecessary timers? Of course, the product would probably have languished because there are plenty of other bowls you can fill on a schedule. The lesson? Get the right details squared away ahead of time, and get the less important details squared away later.
- melc 15y agoumm.... i think he focuses on the merits of the new product and the fact that the company eventually paid attention on the details, otherwise he would probably go for something else
- codeka 15y ago> We never changed the actual feed schedule, but just changing the time for daylight savings was so incredibly awkward and contorted we had to summarize the steps from the manual on a separate piece of paper as a "cheat sheet" Not really related to the point, but should you be adjusting the time for daylight savings at all? I mean, the cats don't care about the arbitrary 24 hours we humans use to divide up the day, so wouldn't adjusting the time for daylight saving just seem like an arbitrary change for no good reason to a cat?
- guynamedloren 15y agoHa, this is interesting! Didn't even cross my mind, but makes a lot of sense.
- terenceponce 15y agoI'm pretty sure you meant to say that in a serious tone, but I couldn't help but laugh because cats.
- Produce 15y agoI'm not a cat and it still seems like an arbitrary change.
- keithpeter 15y agoI am not a cat either, but I do live 52.5 degrees North and quite often visit 57.5 degrees North. Daylight saving is not arbitrary for daylight liking non-cats
- duncanj 15y agoBut daylight saving occurs during the time when you already have more daylight than the vast majority of habitable landmass does. You aren't "saving" daylight at all during the daylight poor months when you're inside at work during the entire daylight period.
- 15y ago
- dsr_ 15y agoNobody's mentioned the most important point here. The improvements to this product were so substantial that all of Jeff's audience now has some degree of brand awareness and a positive bias towards it. When was the last time an upgraded product -- one that you didn't even get discounted -- made you so effusive?
- diminish 15y agoOr, Your app is the single function it does the best Or, your app is the fundamental philosophy it its design, or, or, or...
- jroseattle 15y agoI get where Jeff is going with this post, and I agree and disagree. It may seem like splitting hairs, but I find a big difference between details and decisions. My version: your app is a collection of decisions. The details (and implementation) of an app flow from those decisions. Include or exclude a feature? That's a decision. Buttons on the left/right, top/bottom? Decision. Add a pluggable architecture? Decision. Look at a rather successful product like the iPhone. Much of its success can be traced to getting lots of details right. But understanding what was going into the iPhone -- the decisions made about how to create it -- led to those details. Touchscreen, app store, glass cover, all of it were active decisions. Executing details are absolutely critical, but making the decision of what to do (or not to do) is where it all starts.
- hellerbarde 15y agoThat is a very good point, coming from the developer's view. I think that Jeff's point is more valid if you look at it from the customer's view.
- jroseattle 15y agoA great clarification as well. And a customer certainly is not going to be aware of the decisions made around trade-offs, direction, etc.
- amirmc 15y agoAnd from the customer's point of view, the first product did the single most important thing properly. Feed the cats with minimal human input. That's still a decision on the creators' part i.e the creators could have sat down and bickered about colour options but they (presumably) took a decision to fix the customer's problem. The fact that Jeff used the same feeders for five years is a testament to how well the original designers were able to address the core problem well enough. Edit: They also functioned well enough that he bought the updated version on faith.
- nocipher 15y agoThis reminds me of the EVE Online player revolt. Those details your customers care about are the most important parts of your product.
- MortenK 15y agoToday I was designing wireframes for a web application, using a little prototyping app called Balsamiq mockups. It is a little, very focused application, and the detail level is nothing short of amazing. Typing a few letters and hitting enter will create a new control and add it to the canvas, already focused and ready for positioning. Creating a text paragraph and then writing the word lorem, will automatically create 3 lines of lorem ipsum text. There is a filterable icon gallery. One click export to PNG, and all other kinds of little nuggets. I agree with Jeff Atwood, that it's those little details that makes makes an app enjoyable, where before it might have been merely tolerable.