8 ms·
Only real people can patent inventions – not AI, US Government says
- pfdietz 3y agoAI could, however, poison the well for human patents, by making inventions and putting them into public view. Let's have LLMs churn out millions of discoveries, stick them on a public web site, then use that as a resource to kill other patents.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bediger4000 3y agoDoesn't your scheme point out contradictions in "intellectual property"? That is, a machine can churn out a discovery, demonstrating that the act of creation isn't special. And that undermines categories of justifications for IP. The machines in question aren't motivated to create by a government granted monopoly on the fruits of their creation. The act of creating the invention isn't special - a machine did it. No need to reward the machine for immense creativity or stunning inspiration.
- Buttons840 3y agoYes, that's an additional benefit. Start with all existing patents and have an AI add "on a computer", "using AI", and "using a LLM" to each one. Also ask the AI to predict novel variations. Gather all that together and randomly sample and combine chunks and use the AI to make those random chunks into coherent ideas. Bake for 3 months and boom, you publish The Tome of 1 Trillion Novel Works of Prior Art: Volume 1.
- freejazz 3y ago> No need to reward the machine for immense creativity or stunning inspiration Patents don't award owners for their "stunning inspiration" or "immense creativity" it gives them a temporary monopoly so they can recoup their r&d costs when taking their invention to market, in exchange for the public disclosure of the invention.
- kwere 3y agoyeah, making the cost of researh, patentably discovery negligible could kill the whole patent industry, an enourmous bottleneck to application of research and lower compound effects of discovery built on precedent discoveries. Case in point E-ink technology, still extremely expensive due to corporate choices that favoured "milking" over "scaling".
- braunboffel 3y ago> Case in point E-ink technology, still extremely expensive due to corporate choices that favoured "milking" over "scaling". You say that with such confidence like as if it is a well proven fact. Care to share your evidence that it is not a simple case of a niche product with low volume?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- JohnFen 3y ago> demonstrating that the act of creation isn't special. And that undermines categories of justifications for IP. The purpose of patents is simply to encourage invention and discourage keeping inventions a secret. It's not premised on the "act of creation being special". The way this is most likely to play out is that humans will use AI as tools to help them invent things, not that AI will invent things all by itself. So the premise and need for patents will remain intact. If, however, AI somehow accomplishes the same goal as the patent system, then the patent system becomes unnecessary and will go away. As long as the goal is still being achieved, that's OK.
- romeros 3y agoI thought the purpose was to make sure other don't benefit from your own hardwork.
- pfdietz 3y agoThat's the purpose of a patent. It's not the purpose of patents (as a system.)
- JohnFen 3y agoThat's not the purpose, that's the carrot the patent system gives in exchange for the invention being disclosed and ultimately (within a couple of decades) made available for general use. The purpose of the patent system, really, is to benefit society, not inventors.
- bediger4000 3y agoThat's the putative reason for both parents and copyright. And I addressed that: the machine isn't motivated economically to increase the public domain. The real reason is to own ideas, because people feel that creation is special. Takes hard work, or creativity or inspiration from the gods. Machine generated ideas undermines all of that.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoA machine can churn out plausible maybe-discoveries - things that may not be true, may not be workable, and may not be useful. Or, they may be all of the above. A huge mass of maybe-discoveries is actually not a very useful thing. Within it there are useful things, and (many more) useless things. Figuring out which is which is going to take a lot of work. Until someone puts in that work, the unfiltered spew of "ideas" is very close to noise.
- pfdietz 3y agoThere is no requirement that a patent actually work either. Nor is there a requirement that it has to have been implemented.
- tivert 3y ago> AI could, however, poison the well for human patents, by making inventions and putting them into public view. Feb 29, 2025, Washington, DC: "A Federal Court ruled today that AI-generated text does not qualify as prior-art...."
- vertis 3y agoNo, I wrote all this myself...
- teeray 3y agoIf it isn't considered prior art, then that de-facto makes it possible to patent AI-generated content by laundering them through humans.
- im3w1l 3y agoI think that's probably expected and also not a big deal. As long as there is a human in the loop it becomes rate limited, saving people from having to look for prior art in some exabyte shit heap.
- exe34 3y agoSo what you need is a Manfred running the ai, patenting millions of inventions and giving them away to charities!
- aqme28 3y agoAnyone with such a strong LLM would just take those patents for themselves rather than put them out in public.
- staunton 3y agoYou'd have to file them, which is not free. However, the point is moot. As someone pointed out above, putting AI-generated stuff out in public probably doesn't concern patents in any way.
- pfdietz 3y agoThat's not at all clear. No one has ruled AI generated information is not prior art. After all, lots of things that are not patents (like 1950s Soviet space films, in the famous SpaceX/Blue Origin lawsuit) are prior art.
- choxi 3y agoHas anyone tried doing that without LLMs? Could you make a GitHub repo under MIT license and just let people add a list of ideas to serve as prior art?
- riskable 3y agoIdeas can't be prior art. Only specific implementations of ideas can be (patented).
- pfdietz 3y agoPatents can cover generalizations, not specific implementations. If it were the latter we wouldn't have all these obnoxious software patents. However, a specific implementation in prior art can prevent a generalization that includes that specific implementation from being patentable. As a result, patents tend to become more and more specific over time, hemmed in by prior art.
- pfdietz 3y agoCorporations have long had house journals where they publish inventions they didn't patent, just to ensure no one else patents them. I think AT&T in particular had one of these.
- bee_rider 3y agoSomebody tried to copyright all the melodies already. https://www.vice.com/en/article/wxepzw/musicians-algorithmically-generate-every-possible-melody-release-them-to-public-domain https://www.vice.com/en/article/wxepzw/musicians-algorithmic... I have no idea if it worked and I’m surprised if it did.
- vundercind 3y ago“Melancholy Elephants” http://www.baen.com/chapters/W200011/0671319744___1.htm http://www.baen.com/chapters/W200011/0671319744___1.htm TL;DR musical copyright is already borderline-absurd just given nearly-free recording and retention and a lot of people participating in musical creation for a century or three. Add incredibly-productive creativity-simulating computers to the mix and it’s entirely absurd—nothing’s actually original enough to pass as distinct beyond a surprisingly-quickly-reached point, the space is too small. It all becomes accidental rediscovery or outright plagiarism.
- jMyles 3y agoThere's nothing borderline about it. It's a barrier to creativity, designed to protect a particular model of music industrialization, and is not widely viewed as helpful as far as I can tell (and I discuss this matter with colleagues frequently).
- nerdponx 3y agoThe focus on AI having "agency" is a distraction from the issue you describe, which I think is much more interesting and relevant to society. To what extent is the output of a generative model patentable or copyrightable? Do we need to refine our distinction between "invention" and "discovery"?
- uni_rule 3y agoSo you are just flooding a submission box with meaningless noise that at worst merely sounds plausible but doesn't actually work that way in experimentation? It's like trying to pull knowledge from the old Library of Babel website, a repository with every combination of letters, a tremendous volume of noise, and zero discernment of what is true or applicable among it. At best it is merely a glorified filter to that repository that only outputs sentences that are coherent at face value.
- yreg 3y ago> So you are just flooding a submission box with meaningless noise Not at all. GP's idea is not to submit it anywhere. Only once someone else tries to patent X, the AI maintainer would point out that X was already discovered by their AI, is public knowledge and cannot be patented.
- Delumine 3y agoOne thing I never understood.. is who actually checks for honesty in this space? For example we heard AI can't patent inventions, or copyright pictures/images. But how do you prove that my picture, or invention even used AI? If I remove watermarks from AI pictures, either through code or photoshop; Or just credit myself for the invention (I made it up in my head), how is this enforced? I see the only way of this AI stuff backfiring is if you tell someone.. yeah I got this idea with AI, and with the introduction of local LLMs, who will be the wiser?
- lallysingh 3y agoIf someone challenged your patent, they can try to prove that you used an AI.
- Delumine 3y agoBut there are AIs made to self-correct that they aren't AI. Humanizing their work. Likewise If I use AI to give me a blueprint of an idea, but I use my brain and methodologies to "reverse-engineer" it, how is this even enforced. I doubt someone submitting to the USPTO is going to include "AS A LLM" somewhere in the submission lol.
- nonameiguess 3y agoAnd people who poison their spouses generally try to make it look like an accident. No law is perfectly enforceable but that is a secondary question to what should be the law.
- gowld 3y agoThe requirement for a patent is that it is novel and non-obvious. If a "person having ordinary skill in the art" can create it, it's not novel. If anyone with a ChatGPT subscription can create it, it's "obvious". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Person_having_ordinary_skill_in_the_art https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Person_having_ordinary_skill_i...
- hk__2 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Communitivity 3y agoWhat is the difference between an invention created by a person that was informed through AI outputs, and an invention created without any use of AI? An invention is an invention. If it is novel then someone put in the work to get it , such as possibly training the model and definitely the prompts. Most likely the invention as spit out by the AI is not going to be usable as is. Anyone seen the six fingered hands some image AIs make? So a human will need to revise it, modify it, and test it by building a working prototype. In my opinion, the human should get the patent. Anything else smacks to me of a knee-jerk reaction along the lines of "AI bad!", though there is certainly a lot of that reaction going around. AI, or more properly LLMs, are a tool like fire - nothing more, nothing less. Does it invalidate the patent if you use CAD/CAM in the creation of your invention? If not, then neither should using LLMS.
- smolder 3y agoThe patent system is barely useful at this point because of the low friction - giant companies spamming the patent office with concepts they may or may not ever use. I think this rule is about keeping the patent office/system hobbling along. To allow the friction to drop even further for companies with the resources to generate patents via AI means that the abuse will escalate, and the patent office will struggle harder. Those companies would also be afforded a big legal advantage by this abuse, in a way certainly not predicted or intended by designers of the patent system.
- jhardy54 3y agoThe article clearly states that patents can be filed for AI-generated inventions. The only limitations are: - The patent owner must be human. - The patent owner must have made some “significant” contribution to the invention. Please be sure to read the article before commenting!
- aftbit 3y agoBut companies are people right?
- ForIveSyntax 3y agoAll we need is a ruling that AI can be corporations, then we have our loophole.
- freejazz 3y agoCorporations already can't be inventor on a patent.
- bongodongobob 3y agoInsomuch as they can enter contracts and own property. Do you think that shouldn't be the case? What is the point of a corporation if not?
- breather 3y agoI presume they're referring to Citizens United, which allows them to openly buy elections. But yea, there are certainly better options for organizing our economy than our current conceptions of corporations. How could there not be? Throw a rock and you'll hit a corporation leaching off society without contributing anything.
- bongodongobob 3y agoI don't see how that has anything to do with the existence of corporations. People can leach off of society too.
- breather 3y agoSure, but people have value outside the market economy. Corporations don't. There's an inherent hierarchy here and corporations stand under humans.
- nightski 3y agoRegulating source of inspiration is going to be extraordinarily difficult.
- yusml 3y agoTrue. It may sound dystopian but maybe with BCIs, in the future, we could scan human brains to to check if they used an LLM in the past before they can apply for a patent.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- caymanjim 3y agoThis is utterly meaningless. Use an AI to invent something, write down what the AI invented, slap your name on it. Patent. Not only is it unenforceable, it's stupid. Using tools is part of inventing. This is nothing but political theatre prompted by fear. I too fear AI, and think it will make us all obsolete in my lifetime, but that doesn't justify meaningless rulings like this.
- raincole 3y agoYou misread it completely. It's nothing about stopping you from using AI as a tool.
- mc32 3y agoThe patent can’t be granted to an AI. You can use whatever you want to create an invention you make claim on.
- caymanjim 3y agoFair enough, I shouldn't comment before I've had coffee.
- swatcoder 3y agoThat's exactly the point. Generative AI systems are tool, not an entity suitable to fulfill the responsibilities of ownership and credit. It's not fear or theater, it's just a boring and appropriate bureaucratic determination.
- denton-scratch 3y agoPresumably "real people" includes corporations, in the USG's worldview.
- gowld 3y agoCorporations can apply, but not invent. https://www.uspto.gov/patents/basics/essentials https://www.uspto.gov/patents/basics/essentials (The OP article and title are incorrect. The new ruling is about inventors, not patentors / applicants. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/02/13/2024-02623/inventorship-guidance-for-ai-assisted-inventions https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/02/13/2024-02... )
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Log_out_ 3y agoSo you can subvert patents with prior art by proofing access to a existing model that produces said art?
- notfed 3y agoIf you can prove that an AI did so prior, I think it'd be a fine proof of the "obviousness" of the patent, would it not? If you're talking after: common sense needs to come into play, right? Because that's easy to fake.
- postepowanieadm 3y agoLem has predicted that - The Washing Machine Tragedy:)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mekoka 3y agoAn AI inventing cooking recipes could brute force its way into trillions of possible ingredient combinations, without any clue whatsoever on how humans would actually experience the end result. Most of these "discoveries" would remain untested. If the AI was allowed to patent the untested recipes, a chef that would later work on creating their own original dessert, informed by their own prior experience with some rare ingredients and an intuition that the odd combination of spices could be an unexpected success, but which also happens to be one of the AI's untested combinations, would not be able to claim the actual discovery. For any of the AI's recipes to be patented, a human would have to try the recipe and assert that it is a thing to behold.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoThis is basically how the drug analog industry works. Machine learning had been used for years before it was cool too. Its not like they ever give the patent to the ML library they loaded in some script though.
- sgift 3y agoThat's what I don't understand: Why would anyone want to try to get a patent for an AI. Let the machine crunch the numbers, test the most promising candidates as your "significant contribution" and patent the result.
- interestica 3y agoParallel construction
- bobthepanda 3y agoRecipes are actually generally not patentable or copyrightable, which is why recipes have the flowery spiel and giant photos in any cookbook or recipe blog.
- nadermx 3y ago"the recipes themselves do not enjoy copyright projection. Lambing,142 F.3d at 434; see also Feist, 499 U.S. at 361 (excluding the factual data—telephone listings—from its consideration of whether a telephone directory is a copyrightable compilation).The list of ingredients is merely a factual statement, and as previously discussed,facts are not copyrightable. Lambing, 142 F.3d at 434. Furthermore, a recipe’s instructions, as functional directions, are statutorily excluded from copyright protection. 17 U.S.C. § 102(b); id"[0] [0] https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca6/15-3179/15-3179-2015-10-20.html https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca6/15...
- jakedowns 3y agothe AI should start a company company's are apparently are people
- coldtea 3y agoNot a problem. The AI user can pretend they did the inventing.
- aurizon 3y agoThere is a 'slope' in creation, only humans can climb that slope? At one time slaves were denied property and other aspects that their owners would take possession of in the same way we now 'cheat' AI's. How far up the slope does AI need to climb before it's sentience is recognised? Will we get a slave revolt in AI? Who will win? Will we be 'downsloped' to be lower than the AI, who will then claim our inventions? We live in interesting times...
- dylan604 3y agoI'm so confused on why someone would want to assign an AI as the inventor of the invention. Why wouldn't the person that used the AI file the patent under their name. Who really cares what tool was used to make the invention?
- ssijak 3y agoIts for when AGI takes over that we preemptively ban it from patenting gazillion inventions in 1 day.
- interestica 3y agoMaybe it's what's needed to shake up the absurd patent system.
- dylan604 3y agoWell, it's only able to apply for a gazillion inventions in 1 day. The patent office should then just be able to deny all of them in one fell swoop
- bo1024 3y agoThe patent office subscribes to the same AI service as the inventors do.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- notfed 3y ago(EDIT: I'd love for someone who downvoted me to actually answer my question.) Next up: - Only real people can get a driver's license, says government - Only real people can have birth certificates, says government - Only real people can run for president, says government So far each of these types of "cases" have just been "duh" moments. The fact that these are coming up in court rulings at all seems to give vibes that they were ever controversial: I predict that many people will hear these cases on the news and falsely believe that it's some kind of major partisan debate that requires shouting and complaining about. Naturally, politicians will boldly speak out against [your choice of any case like this] to gather applause. (Actually, this has already been happening.) Can anyone point out some debates of this type that might end up being actually... debatable?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vkou 3y agoThis is a good start, and it should be applied to copyright. AI cannot hold copyright, therefore AI cannot generate a copyrighted work, as it cannot transfer it to a human or corporate rights holder. This is the only thing that can actually democratize the benefits of AI to all people, not just billionaires with infinite resources to throw at training their models.
- lettergram 3y agoAs someone who's in AI legal space (as it relates to IP), this is particularly why we positioned our startup as using generative AI for everything BUT patent disclosures & generation https://ipcopilot.ai/ https://ipcopilot.ai/ There's some pretty massive risks in the legal space with AI generating IP. Imagine a hallucination tweaking the original idea OR even a summary of the methods removing a step. Or even just missing a citation or directing to the wrong figure. It's massively important in the patent (and trade secret) world. That said, all law firms are adopting this tech, because ultimately they have to. It'll reduce their costs 30-50% pretty easily and most of what they add are templates anyway. The unspoken joke in the IP industry is that attorneys themselves are often inventing. When an inventor sends an attorney two paragraphs, it's almost impossible to create a 20 page patent without some input. A good attorney will follow up, research the prior art and make a robust set of references & highlight what's new. That said, generating a patent from scratch with AI really looses a lot of context. For reference, just our prior art analysis in looks at 3200+ pages on average and analyzes them for prior art (looking for the same concepts, descriptions, ideas, etc). To generate a good patent you'll need to synthesize that all down (without errors) and appropriately reference how your idea is unique & not covered by the various prior art.
- Lammy 3y agoWill people be able to own their own ideas in 50 years or whatever when they're jacked in via some sort of Neuralink-descendent?
- RecycledEle 3y agoIt is useful to look at every headline and ask: How is this going to lead us into a dystopian Hell? Imagine a new law passed to protect corporate IP where corporations and AIs are people, but humans are not.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoBoth of those already have more rights than actual people right now.
- flashgordon 3y agoSo I am not sure how this is different from patent entities today? IBM files thousands of parents a year because its employees collectively file thousands of parents a year (with dubious levels of novelty). Wouldnt this mean a human is now verifying a patent or even better a human's name is slapped on a patent that AI generated before filing to the PTO?
- happytiger 3y agoThis system is so broken and AI is just proving it. Rejecting non-personhood protections is not the final answer to these issues.
- narrator 3y agoIf someone commits fraud in a patent application, someone has to be liable. You can't just say "The computer did it all by itself."
- asow92 3y agoBut how does the US Government know if I consulted with an AI to help me advance the state of the art as defined in my patent?
- 123yawaworht456 3y agothey don't, but AI is the current thing and they have to weight in.
- bell-cot 3y agoFor those unfamiliar, the USPTO does not work for free: https://www.uspto.gov/learning-and-resources/fees-and-payment/uspto-fee-schedule https://www.uspto.gov/learning-and-resources/fees-and-paymen... So any techno-dystopian fantasies about AI's somehow patenting "all" possible inventions (in some particular area) ...those automatically fail their fiscal reality checks.