6 ms·
Before he was George Orwell, he was Eric Blair, police officer
- jhbadger 3y agoI haven't read the novel, and yes, Theroux is generally a good writer, but I'm not really seeing the point of writing a novel about Orwell's time in Burma. It's not like Orwell hid this part of his past -- he wrote a novel of his own (Burmese Days) influenced by his time there, and some of his more famous essays e.g. Shooting an Elephant deal with his time as a colonial police officer.
- dcist 3y agoI came here to write precisely this! You're not alone in your thoughts.
- hulitu 3y agoThe purpose of propaganda is to create an alternate truth. Orwell is a good target because of its writings.
- grugagag 3y agoPropaganda in whose favor though?
- matrix_overload 3y agoNah, the purpose of propaganda is to control which subset of infinitely complex reality will get remembered. Make enough people associate Orwell's works with the dark pages of his past, and the focus will shift from the ideas of the works to the identity of the writer. Then use it to attack those who still dare to bring up those ideas, and you have driven them off the public's attention span for good.
- confidantlake 3y agoFantastic book. Enjoyed it more than his more famous ones.
- zever 3y agoI highly recommend Orwell's Roses by Rebecca Solnit for a broad view of Orwell's life, and a really enjoyable read in general.
- lawlessone 3y agoIf George Owell was alive today, he'd be very old.
- pinkmuffinere 3y agoThis comment reads like a Mitch Hedberg joke
- fuzztester 3y ago>If George Owell was alive today, he'd be very old. O well ...
- alliao 3y agoLiterature's power lies in it's low cost and broad viewpoints. And whatever topic became popular because they reflect the times. We must be in trouble, given Orwell became so popular. Extra so if powers that be deemed worthwhile to character assassinate someone who writes "All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others". It should have never gotten as popular as it did.
- moate 3y ago[flagged]
- AlbertCory 3y agoCorollary to Betteridge's Law of Headlines: Any time a comment goes, "So you're saying...<ridiculous explanation>" the commenter is unable to say anything more intelligent.
- xkcd-sucks 3y agoi.e., fascism is a necessary precondition of anti-fascism
- mistermann 3y agoIt is not necessary for beliefs or stories about it though!
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y agoI believe the observation is that a counterculture is preceded by a culture to be countered. OP is drawing observations that this is a counterculture which is rising in popularity. As such, they claim that one or more current prevalent cultures must be those of which Orwell has written in opposition. At least, that’s my interpretation.
- mistermann 3y ago
- verisimi 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20240000000000*/https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/05/books/review/george-orwell-burma-sahib-paul-theroux.html https://web.archive.org/web/20240000000000*/https://www.nyti...
- carlosjobim 3y agoJust finished his "Down and out in Paris and London"[1] about life in extreme poverty as an unemployed man, as a low-wage worker and as a tramp in the 1930s. A good read and a short book. [1] https://annas-archive.org/md5/6486c7cb2f83f4a97cc02728ff77c207 https://annas-archive.org/md5/6486c7cb2f83f4a97cc02728ff77c2... (Public domain)
- cryptoz 3y agoI've read this 3-4 times and can't state enough that it's my favorite Orwell book (haven't read them all, but you know).
- jacobolus 3y agoIn my opinion it's much better than any of Orwell's fiction.
- rodgerd 3y agoOne of his most crucial, but under-appreciated, works.
- pilingual 3y agoI concur. This was on Chris Beiser's "Alpha List" (he asked Twitter what books no one else would recommend that would yield alpha; so far it's a good set of books).
- fuzztester 3y agoWe had it in English Literature class at some point. Also Animal Farm by him. His 1984, I think I read on my own. I heard from older people that when 1984 rolled around, many people bought the book, thinking the date was meant literally.
- swayvil 3y agoIt's called "dogsbody". Savor that term.
- vinceguidry 3y agoThis takedown of 1984 and Orwell in general was really good IMO: https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-most-overrated-novel-of-the-20th-century/answer/Alex-Johnston-39 https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-most-overrated-novel-of-th...
- OkayPhysicist 3y ago"Really good" is a baffling take on a post that accuses Orwell of being "extraordinarily uninterested in socialism" despite voluntarily joining and fighting in a socialist revolution. If picking up a rifle and traveling to a foreign country to participate in their socialist revolution isn't enough to bury any accusations of not being a true believer, I can't imagine what is.
- Lacusch 3y agoNo true Scotsman in action.
- mhitza 3y agoWhile I haven't read yet Orwell's Ode to Catalonia, I highly recommend the movie Libertarias, a fictional movie based on same period, focused on a feminist militant anarchist group https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarias https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarias
- cassepipe 3y agoKen Loach's Land and Freedom is worth mentionning too. Loosely bases on the book
- antod 3y ago> If picking up a rifle and traveling to a foreign country to participate in their socialist revolution isn't enough to bury any accusations of not being a true believer, I can't imagine what is. I had the impression that he went more for fighting fascism than fighting for a socialist revolution.
- 3y ago
- echelon_musk 3y agoHaving read Burmese Days, this comes as no shock whatsoever.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoShooting an Elephant; Really made me cry.
- echtroipolemos 3y agoThe material for Down and Out in Paris and London was due to his disgust and self-loathing which arose from his time serving as a lapdog of the Colonial Raj. Following his time as a dishwasher (plongeur) in Paris and the ensuing poverty - which he characterised as an intensely boring endeavor - he moved to the UK and lived amongst the tramps - following them from spike to spike and writing travelogues. In Road to Wigan Pier - to the decry of mainstream Marxists - he noted that blind opposition to landlords is nuanced in working class coal mining communities. Generally the property would have been the only source of income for an old widow. I believe that's the project in which he remarked that, "The working classes smell."
- amiga386 3y ago> Generally the property would have been the only source of income for an old widow. "Ideally, the worst type of slum landlord is a fat wicked man, preferably a bishop, who is drawing an immense income from extortionate rents. Actually, it is a poor old woman who has invested her life's savings in three slum houses, inhabits one of them, and tries to live on the rent of the other two — never, in consequence, having any money for repairs."
- arminiusreturns 3y agoSome of my favorite quotes of his: “[A] world in which it is wrong to murder an individual civilian and right to drop a thousand tons of high explosive on a residential area does sometimes make me wonder whether this earth of ours is not a loony bin made use of by some other planet.” George Orwell (31 December 1943) “Take away freedom of speech, and the creative faculties dry up.” “Every war when it comes, or before it comes, is represented not as a war but as an act of self-defense against a homicidal maniac.” “The further a society drifts from truth the more it will hate those who speak it.” “The primary aim of modern warfare is to use up the products of the machine without raising the general standard of living.” “Totalitarianism, however, does not so much promise an age of faith as an age of schizophrenia. A society becomes totalitarian when its structure becomes flagrantly artificial: that is, when its ruling class has lost its function but succeeds in clinging to power by force or fraud. Such a society, no matter how long it persists, can never afford to become either tolerant or intellectually stable. It can never permit either the truthful recording of facts or the emotional sincerity that literary creation demands.” I guess welcome to the age of schizophrenia. For those who are interested, his membership of the Fabian Society is key to understanding how he was so spot on about today's world (eg: planned). Wolf in sheeps clothing indeed. https://modernhistoryproject.org/mhp?Article=FabianSociety&C=2.0 https://modernhistoryproject.org/mhp?Article=FabianSociety&C...
- geye1234 3y ago"All propaganda is a lie, even when it is telling the truth" "War against a foreign country only happens when the moneyed classes think they are going to profit from it." "It is the same in all wars; the soldiers do the fighting, the journalists do the shouting, and no true patriot ever gets near a front-line trench, except on the briefest of propaganda-tours." "It is sometimes a comfort to me to think that the aeroplane is changing the conditions of warfare. In the next great war, we may see that sight unprecedented in all history, a jingo with a bullet-hole in him." "Serious sport has nothing to do with fair play. It is bound up with hatred, jealousy, boastfulness, disregard of all rules and sadistic pleasure in witnessing violence: in other words it is war minus the shooting." "To see what is in front of one's nose needs a constant struggle." I strongly recommend the four-volume Penguin edition of his collected journalism and essays.
- zogrodea 3y agoReaders who appreciate Orwell's work will also likely appreciate Darkness at Noon by Arthur Koestler. The latter's novel inspired Orwell on how to highlight dystopian ideas, and convinced Orwell that fiction is the medium best suited for this. It's a good read (and so is his research-oriented book "The Sleepwalkers" giving a history of physics/cosmology up to modern science - modern in Koestler's time).
- nonrandomstring 3y agoNice. Will check out Koestler. On this idea that fiction is the most powerful medium for approaching ideas around the authoritarian/dystopian mind-set, I some time ago discovered the corollary that literature like Shelley, Forster, Wells.. is the perfect entry point into cybersecurity for non-technical people. Most of the subtleties of hacks, scams, power grabs, manipulations, come alive through literary idioms.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoJust put it out there, If you love Orwell then Christopher Hitchens on Orwell is like the whole pudding, coffee and after-dinner mints. He's my fave Orwell scholar and throws a lot of light on the life, thoughts and implications of the writer.
- norir 3y agoHitchens had an arrogant and chauvinistic side that spoils his writing for me.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoIndeed, The chauvinism is ugly and a real turn-off. But even as a Christian I loved his ballsy bitchynes, coining things like antitheism - because just not believing in god isn't enough... shame he left the stage too young.
- nortonham 3y agoHitchens is pretty awful imo. Tried to paint himself as some type of lefty, as he got older agitated for war and just drank himself to death. That, and the weird new atheist sthick....he was a good writer when he was younger, but he was a careerist more than anything else.
- keiferski 3y agoEasily the most overrated writer of the last twenty five years, whose fame seems sustained by his chumminess with journalists and his preference for making loud, uninformed, combative statements that don’t hold up under much scrutiny. A man fit for the times, it seems.
- coldtea 3y agoArrogant, chauvinistic, and know-it-all, when he was just of mediocre education at best (compared to much more substantial public intellectuals - yes, he went to Oxbridge, but he just had a run-of-the-mill degree and grades, like thousands of others every year). His takes on literature and other subjects were too shallow. He did put on a good show, which TV and the press loved.
- photochemsyn 3y agoThe British colonial recipe that Orwell was immersed in seems to have been: (1) gain entry to a country via stablishing trade relations with the local economy, (2) identify likely ethno-religious groups that can be armed and encouraged to overthrow the ruling power, (3) establish leaders from those minority groups as the new political power, while (4) ensuring that those new leaders are reliant on British Empire for their continued grasp on power. At its worst the result was the rise of slave-trading outfits like Britain's Royal Africa Company. The opposing view is that Britain's ex-colonial possessions should count themselves lucky to have been colonized by the British, who built trains, schools and hospitals, as compared to the French, Spanish or Belgian versions, so it was all okay. The British, they say, would have loved to have been colonized by a superior culture, only one wasn't available. In Burmese Days, the only character who seems to really understand the system and thrive within it is one of the story's villains, U Po Kyin. He might have served as a template for Napoleon in Animal Farm: > “No one believes more firmly than Comrade Napoleon that all animals are equal. He would be only too happy to let you make your decisions for yourselves. But sometimes you might make the wrong decisions, comrades, and then where should we be?”
- nortonham 3y agohttps://exiledonline.com/big-brothers-george-orwell-and-christopher-hitchens-exposed/ https://exiledonline.com/big-brothers-george-orwell-and-chri... "That’s the thing about Orwell’s Imperialism: it’s perfectly ordinary stuff, distinguished only by the socialist persona he invented to speak it. As an example of literary dissembling, Orwell belongs with the great forgers. But as a man of ideas, he is truly beneath contempt. His ideas are simply the hatreds of his nursery, hidden by an elaborate self-glorifying backstory."
- pydry 3y agoOrwell writes through the eyes of an imperialist because he was born and grew up one. Your article's main thesis is "how dare he do that!" (before rejecting imperialism).
- bardan 3y ago"Ah, but what about Spain? Orwell put his life fighting for POUM in the Spanish Civil War. He got himself shot in the neck-pretty high risks for a phony socialist. How do I explain that one? Actually, it’s simple. Orwell went to Spain to fight for his most deeply held belief, yes. Unfortunately, that belief wasn’t socialism but the nastiest, most puerile of the tribal hatreds English babies learn in the cradle: anti-Catholicism." I just couldn't keep reading after that. I like John Dolan's analyses in the War Nerd podcast but this essay seems unhinged. Did he write this at the time the Exiled staff were smashing each other in the face with horse semen pies? Seems like a lot of edginess and projection.
- nortonham 3y ago> Did he write this at the time the Exiled staff were smashing each other in the face with horse semen pies? Seems like a lot of edginess and projection. Chronologically I think this comes after the horse semen pies. It's not a stretch to think a middle class Englishmen from the early 20th century hates catholics, and that this bigotry (along with his other pet hates) pop up in his writing. As far as Orwell being a socialist....don't forget he ratted out British socialist to British intelligence.
- 3y ago