5 ms·
If you want something to happen, pay people to do it. If someone wants there to be more babies, they need to pay for them. At least the baby shortage will help
by immibis 3y ago
If you want something to happen, pay people to do it. If someone wants there to be more babies, they need to pay for them.
At least the baby shortage will help with the teacher shortage.
- hirako2000 3y agoBut who's to pay?
- hirako2000 3y agoI observe there isn't a clear answer as to who's to pay. Let me help there. Everyone's to pay. But let's make that clear as the statement implied whoever is demanding higher demography would fund it, by some miracles. I'm not myself against funding the future of the civilization our lineage built. But we are already taxed significantly, more so to fund wars from what I see. already gave up properly financing a solid health care and education system.
- gedy 3y agoThey could just not tax (or refund previous year) new parents. This will never fly because blah blah reasons blah blah inequity, etc. But seems would help incentivize productive parents.
- al_borland 3y agoWhen certain people don’t need to pay taxes, someone else still has to pay. Either taxes need to go up for others, or the deficit grows accordingly, which is kicking the can down the road for future generations to deal with.
- gedy 3y ago> the deficit grows accordingly, which is kicking the can down the road for future generations to deal with. So, the same as today basically? It's been this way nearly my entire life and I'm middle aged. I’d personally rather fund more children and new families, then whatever the hell happened in the past five years with the deficit. More people means more future tax payers as well.
- acdha 3y agoWe had a balanced budget at the turn of the century. What produced the deficit we have now was rich people deciding that their past tax cuts weren’t enough and several wars of choice with expensive occupations, not investing in future citizens.
- IshKebab 3y agoI guess the money should come out of state pensions because that's who's going to benefit most!
- okamiueru 3y agoWhy make procreation appealing through economic safety and optimism, when you can just make contraception and abortion harder to acquire or straight up illegal? Something, something, America.
- mc32 3y agoOn the other hand Iran, Indonesia and Nigeria have no problem with reproduction.
- borissk 3y agoIn Muslim countries/societies there's usually a very strong pressure to have a lot of kids from the religious authorities.
- kelipso 3y agoAnother reason is they just get married earlier. Probably a plot of average age of first marriage and TFR would be negatively correlated.
- t-3 3y agoDifferent family structures as well. It's a lot harder to take care of children with two adults rather than in a multi-generational household with grandparents, siblings, cousins, etc. Communities and expectations of childhood autonomy are also different - people won't call the cops if they see kids playing without adult supervision in most non-US countries.
- revscat 3y agoPolitically this is the more palatable choice, as well. Conservatives love the idea of limiting access to contraception and abortion, and abhor the idea of giving people who aren’t corporations any kind of financial benefits.
- freedomben 3y ago
- mc32 3y agoDon’t Singapore and Japan have some kind of incentives for couple to have babies with limited success? It’ll be interesting to see what China does when their demographic crunch comes. Mao famously claimed any decimation by the USSR, would be countered by Chinese women pumping out massive amounts of new babies to compensate.
- rgblambda 3y ago>Don’t Singapore and Japan have some kind of incentives for couple to have babies with limited success? From what I understand, the success has been very limited. The Mao claim sounds like classic Mao logic. Did he plan for toddler division to spearhead the counter attack?
- sk11001 3y agoPaying people directly to have children seems like a horrible policy because it will have disproportionate effect on people who are less likely to be good and responsible parents.
- pton_xd 3y agoInstead of paying cash directly, give large tax breaks or other incentives that encourage staying productive members of society.
- aswanson 3y agoFacts. I remember daycare costs almost equalling mortgage payments back in the early 2000s, for 2 kids. It's wildly expensive to have kids in the US.
- etimberg 3y agoIt still does. Close to $3000 a month where I am
- tombert 3y agoI own a house in NYC. My mortgage payment is almost exactly $2000 a month, and that's with taxes and insurance already added to it. $3000/month for daycare is utterly insane.
- acdha 3y agoEven with employer-subsidized daycare, it was more than our mortgage. Watching what people who couldn’t make that work had to do really pushed me solidly into the camp of seeing free government-provided daycare as a basic right. Even if you’re a total sociopath who doesn’t care about the stress, there’s like a century of research showing that things like stable & supportive early years set children up to be more successful for the rest of their lives, and the challenges of finding and paying for daycare put a ton of stress on most parents, hitting the poorest the hardest.
- 3y ago
- borissk 3y agoPaying people to have kids has some interesting side effects. Raising a kid in a big city costs a lot more than raising a kid out in the country. So if the government offers a fixed subsidy per kid the insensitive to have kids is a lot stronger in the country. People out in the country vote differently than people in a big city.
- dreen 3y agoI kinda agree. Some countries already do that (eg Poland), but I really think it ought to be a tax relief instead of actual direct payment.
- al_borland 3y agoI can’t speak to the accuracy of this, as it was just something I was told from a co-worker (in the US), but he had 9 kids and told me he paid 0 income tax and got $15k back on his taxes, due to his kids.
- jquery 3y agoHe (probably) wasn't doing that for $$$ reasons, he (probably) was doing it for religious reasons. It's not a rational trade at all. As religiosity dies down, the government will have to rely on making it rational to have kids again instead of relying on priests pounding their pulpit and telling young people it's their duty.
- ren_engineer 3y agojust increase the tax credit for kids, even make it progressive so you get bigger tax credits for more kids so higher income families have more reason to have more kids. The welfare cliff as it currently stands will doom our country, in my friends and family group the ones who are unemployed or work low income jobs have more kids than the rest combined and no reason to strive to do better because unless they make 6 figures they are better off doing the minimum. systems are about incentives and our current system in the US has us in a death spiral, immigration is used as a short-term stopgap to reduce impact of low birth rates but just accelerates the death spiral in the long term
- spacephysics 3y agoWe basically do that now with dependent tax incentives
- trealira 3y agoInterestingly, something like this was proposed by a group of radical feminists in the 1970s [0]. You'd have to pay a lot of individuals to have babies and then become full-time parents. Not only is that expensive, it seems inefficient. Our society structures childrearing like that only because women used to have a lower status and had to perform unpaid labor and bear children whether they wanted to or not (edit: and then later, it was still unthinkable not to have children; only now has that sentiment been becoming less common). It reminds me of how the American South had an economy that was inefficient because they relied on slavery. They wouldn't have been able to pay all those slaves the full value of their labor anyway, so after slavery ended, they had to find some other ways to get that labor (e.g. sharecropping) and also restructure their whole economy over the course of a hundred years to become more industrialized. I predict that either we'll find some way to make people want to have babies and raise kids intrinsically again, or we'll restructure the whole economy to pay people for the labor of childrearing and bearing children, integrating it into the market-based economy somehow. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wages_for_housework https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wages_for_housework
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoBlack Death led to a great leap in productivity, freed the serfs, and eventually led to the renaissance.
- trealira 3y agoCould you elaborate? Are you implying that depopulation will spur the next economic upheaval (again)? It seems plausible, but I'm not sure if I fully understand you.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoYes. It’s a very common topic in European history, see https://clas.ucdenver.edu/nhdc/sites/default/files/attached-files/entry_147.pdf https://clas.ucdenver.edu/nhdc/sites/default/files/attached-... It’s a bit controversial, since there was at the same time an opposite effect in central/Eastern Europe: > The decline of serfdom in Western Europe has sometimes been attributed to the widespread plague epidemic of the Black Death, which reached Europe in 1347 and caused massive fatalities, disrupting society.[2] Conversely, serfdom grew stronger in Central and Eastern Europe, where it had previously been less common (this phenomenon was known as "second serfdom"). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serfdom https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serfdom
- al_borland 3y agoThis will just lead to more people having kids for the paycheck they provide. Parents who view their kids as a source of income, instead of as a life they are responsible for nurturing, are generally not great parents. A bunch of bad parents with bad motivations leads to a generation of dysfunctional people.
- acdha 3y agoHow many people do you think actually do that? Please cite sources.
- thriftwy 3y agoSo you expected to find a way of increasing quality of kids while increasing quantity of kids at the same time? People saw kids as a source of income through all the history. It's just that the modern ethical liberal sees somebody else's kids in that role.