18 ms·
Russian troops use Starlink licensed and imported from Dubai
- weatherlight 3y agoHow is this legal? Can Starlink get in trouble from EU and the US?
- nottorp 3y agoI'm sure the precogs employed by Starlink can predict which terminals sold in other countries will be "illegally" moved to Russia and stop the transaction before it happens. So yes, it's all Starlink's fault. I'm also sure they can distinguish between terminals used by ukrainians and russians on a front line that probably changes daily. Again, it's their fault. Musk can be blamed for a lot of things, but for this, not really.
- weatherlight 3y agoWhy doesn't Musk's Company just turn off the Starlink panels , you know operating in Russia, just like he did over Crimea?
- potatototoo99 3y agoWhy would he? Is the US at war with Russia?
- dsr_ 3y agoNot yet.
- ceejayoz 3y agoBecause sanctions issued by the country he lives and does business in apply, and his most lucrative client is that country’s government.
- threeseed 3y agoUS is currently imposing sanctions on Russia. And so if Musk were to be providing material support he could see Starlink placed on the export control list. Which if it happened would then open Musk up to severe criminal charges if he didn't take steps to prevent devices being used by Russia. So I suspect he might want to do the right thing ahead of time given the US government is a pretty important customer for SpaceX.
- oneshtein 3y agoRussia is at (undeclared) war with US and NATO. Russian propaganda currently says that they started the war to counter NATO expansion.
- itsoktocry 3y ago[flagged]
- sgift 3y agoBecause NATO did not expand. Countries decided to join NATO. You may think this is the same with other words, but it isn't. In the first version there's only two actors in the world, who can make decisions: Russia and NATO (or rather USA, for they argue NATO is basically the USA with another name). In the second version countries are free to decide who they associate with. There wasn't some empty space that NATO moved into. The countries who were there said "hey, NATO. Russia has been attacking and oppressing us for a long time and we fear they will do it again. We'd like to join." To answer your second question: Exactly what Russias neighbors feared is the reason. Russia is unhappy they couldn't oppress their neighbors anymore since 1990 and they want to do it again. They cannot really do it to the countries that already joined NATO, so they did it to the country that was late to the party.
- ImJamal 3y ago>Because NATO did not expand. Countries decided to join NATO. You may think this is the same with other words, but it isn't. In the first version That is sort of a weird argument. Do you believe that is the case for the US as well? The US did not expand into Indian areas those areas just decided to join the US..
- khzw8yyy 3y agoJust to clarify: the "we" who would like to join is a government that was installed by the USA in a coup. What kind of "attacking and oppressing" happened before the coup?
- nottorp 3y ago> Why doesn't Musk's Company just turn off the Starlink panels , you know operating in Russia, just like he did over Crimea? I'm also sure they can distinguish between terminals used by ukrainians and russians on a front line that probably changes daily.
- threeseed 3y agoStarlinks are associated with a user account. So it should be trivial to determine who is Ukrainian and who is not Ukrainian.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoHow so when lots of them are paid for with foreign cards?
- garblegarble 3y agoLots will be paid for by the DoD, for the others: ask the AFU - the users could supply their account details up through the chain of command (or directly via GIS Arta). Actually, I'd hope this is already happening regularly anyway so they can cut off any terminals captured by the enemy
- inemesitaffia 3y agoThat effort must come via Ukraine. Accusations and antagonism will lead to a more abrupt solution. Service termination for currently unverifiable equipment
- CoastalCoder 3y agoDoes StarLink NOC have the ability to listen in on conversations?
- inemesitaffia 3y agoYes and they know where you are
- trickstra 3y agoThat's exactly what they have been doing since the start of the invasion, and that's how they explained the cut-off when Ukraine was using the Sea Babies for the first time. So either something changed, or the article's claims are bogus. Starlink definitely has the exact location and ID of every ground terminal and can easily refuse the connection.
- nottorp 3y agoAre you sure those weren't registered to the ukrainian army?
- inemesitaffia 3y agoThis equipment operates where Ukrainians operate theirs
- trickstra 3y ago> can predict which terminals sold in other countries will be "illegally" moved to Russia That's not how starlink works. At all.
- swarnie 3y agoIf i manufacture a truck and sell it abroad, and eventually it ends up with a weapons mount in the Syrian desert, am i to blame?
- weatherlight 3y agobut he can remotely turn them off and has done so in the past..... so...
- inemesitaffia 3y ago[flagged]
- RNAlfons 3y agoThis is not a truck. If your truck would have an extension cord going back to your factory so it can run and running the truck would be sanctioned, you could be blamed if you don't cut the cord.
- willsmith72 3y agoit's not that simple export and re-export laws, especially from the US, are extremely complicated
- bigfudge 3y agoThis comment states the obvious, but it isn't adding anything. Must has expensive lawyers for this kind of stuff, but in the worst case (there is no legal route to stop Russia using starlink in this way) I would want to make it very clear that that was a problem and use my substantial voice to have something done about it.
- willsmith72 3y agoexactly comment i replied to was acting like you would not be legally at fault in reality, it's way too complicated to say. at best it's ethically shady, at worst it's a mega fine and jail time
- severino 3y ago[flagged]
- codetrotter 3y agoI don’t think that’s what they meant. Starlink is a US company. The US have imposed some sanctions against Russia. Likewise EU have imposed sanctions against Russia too. So the question I think they are asking is if Starlink is in violation of any US or EU sanctions here.
- seydor 3y agoi don't think that calling the police in the middle of a war is very consequential
- DecoySalamander 3y agoCurious to see if Musk is willing to step in and disable them or if this treatment is reserved for UAF only.
- luciusdomitius 3y ago[flagged]
- yakshaving_jgt 3y agoThis is completely untrue. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/sep/07/elon-musk-ordered-starlink-turned-off-ukraine-offensive-biography#:~:text=The%20biography%2C%20due%20out%20on,attack%20on%20Russian%2Doccupied%20Crimea https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/sep/07/elon-musk....
- petre 3y agoWhy disable? They're useful to launch attacks on Russian troops by giving away their positions.
- yakshaving_jgt 3y agoThe point is that he's done this before in order to disadvantage Ukraine. He is quite clearly on the side of russia.
- Traubenfuchs 3y ago> He is quite clearly on the side of russia. I wonder if that's true: Maybe he just wants to be a controversial contrarian and always tries to be on the "non-woke" and "non-mainstream" side. Doesn't change much in this instance, but still.
- actionfromafar 3y agoSo, temporarily on the side of Russia until Russia becomes woke and mainstream, then.
- a012 3y agoThe terminal and/or account isn't geo locked? By this news I can register a Starlink account in a country and then move to my not-supported country?
- londons_explore 3y agoSome plans have worldwide coverage. I believe starlink is deliberately allowing the service to work in places without licensing [1], because they want to follow the precedent of other sat-phone and sat-TV operators who just have worldwide service without getting permission from every government first. (and in many cases don't have the ability to geoblock, because the signal beam covers entire continents) [1]: https://www.itweb.co.za/article/icasa-takes-note-of-illegal-starlink-services-in-sa/KzQenqjyWJGMZd2r https://www.itweb.co.za/article/icasa-takes-note-of-illegal-...
- lakpan 3y ago> don't have the ability to geoblock I don’t think anything is stopping them from triangulating if they wanted to, right?
- hoseja 3y agoPhysically impossible if you just have a couple satellites in GEO.
- Thlom 3y agoThere is a GPS in the terminal and I can guarantee the gps data is transmitted to Starlink noc/hub in real time. It's trivial to geoblock terminals.
- hoseja 3y agoIt's also fairly doable to spoof GPS if you care to. And I'm talking about the earlier satellite communicators, not Starlink, which can indeed easily triangulate.
- numpad0 3y agoDo Starlink not have to follow Ukrainian radio laws within 2014 or at least 2022 Ukrainian territories? If they have to, wouldn’t they be required to reject authentications from terminals not tied to payment account for Ukraine or US DoD, if not by law at this point, like starting yesterday by Ukrainian Presidential order?
- kramerger 3y agoSo you mean Ukraine should request these to be disabled i aide the occupied territories and if Musk refuses he has basically taken side with Russia in annexation of Ukraine? :) :)
- watwut 3y agoDidn't he already taken that side?
- Etheryte 3y agoMusk has already taken that side, on numerous occasions if memory serves well.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoUkraine has been asking for activation in these areas.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoUkrainians buy equipment on sale in western Europe and activate in Ukraine
- fbn79 3y agoHaving to rely on a hostile technology that could be remote disabled in any moment is not a good indicator for good shape of army in battlefield
- schiffern 3y agoStarlink doesn't offer service in UAE, so this must refer to diverted use of Starlink Maritime. Starlink Maritime is offered through (among others) Dubai-based maritime supplier ELCOME.[0] The ToS for Starlink Maritime isn't available, but this partner brochure[1] says: "Starlink Maritime is available for use in waters around the globe. Coverage in Territorial Waters is contingent on government approval." (italics in original) "* Starlink Maritime service is provided on a best effort basis; stated speeds and uninterrupted use of services are not guaranteed." So yes, Starlink will have ample reason and cause to shut down any ELCOME (etc) terminals found operating inside Ukraine or its territorial waters. Starlink terminals all have built-in GPS, so from a technical standpoint this is trivially easy. [0] https://www.thenationalnews.com/business/technology/2023/01/08/elon-musks-starlink-and-dubais-elcome-join-forces-to-provide-internet-to-maritime-sector/ https://www.thenationalnews.com/business/technology/2023/01/... [1] https://www.speedcast.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Speedcast-Starlink_Maritime-Brochure-Feb2023.pdf https://www.speedcast.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Speedca...
- swores 3y agoForgive me if I'm thinking like a TV writer since I don't have the scientific knowledge, hence the question: can GPS signals not be spoofed, if you are in possession of the device you want to trick? I.e. Couldn't they have fake GPS signals right next to a Starlink terminal that's not strong enough to have a wide-reaching effect, but enough for the terminal to believe it's somewhere it isn't and report that false location back to the satellites? (And/or finding a way to hack the terminal itself to send false coordinates?) I guess even if that's possible, it would be feasible for Starlink to triangulate from their satellites to estimate terminal locations and spot which ones are lying?
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoI assume a working gps is necessary for good signal since orientatiin matters in starlink.
- inemesitaffia 3y ago
- matthewfelgate 3y ago[flagged]
- inemesitaffia 3y agoFor what exactly?
- pastacacioepepe 3y agoIt takes comments like this to realize how quickly fascism has spread from Ukraine to the rest of the world. A couple years of propaganda supporting "valiant heroes" like Azov and here we are pointing fingers on the traitor to be arrested.
- actionfromafar 3y agoIt spread from Ukraine? ... How?
- Ekaros 3y agoTime for Ukraine to start shooting down satellites? What is the most efficient way to do it?
- belter 3y agoNo need to shoot down, just blind them. "US Wants to Defend Satellites From Laser Attack" - https://www.universetoday.com/14614/us-wants-to-defend-satellites-from-laser-attack/ https://www.universetoday.com/14614/us-wants-to-defend-satel...
- DoItToMe81 3y ago[flagged]
- 6c696e7578 3y agoThe Yanukovych bailout?
- alde 3y agoUkraine might economically collapse under the weight of the war machine of one the biggest military powers in the world. You could do better than spinning classic Russian propaganda tropes of "Ukraine is the most corrupt country on Earth". There is corruption in Ukraine, more than in the EU but about the same level as other non-EU countries like Moldova, Serbia, Kazakhstan etc.
- grugagag 3y agoRussia could economically collapse as well though it’s true that they have a longer runway. But as far as corruption goes I think Russia is far more corrupt than Ukraine, US or China. Russia is literally a mob state in its current form.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoThe same sats they use for connectivity?
- fuzzbazz 3y agoInstead of obtaining the enemy coordinates or sniffing their transmissions you're suggesting to waste ammo on shooting down 5000+ LEO satellites?
- axegon_ 3y agoSomething to note: I would not trust a single sentence coming from this site, knowing who is running it - he is no way affiliated with the Bulgarian military or army and is likely on russia's payroll.
- itsoktocry 3y ago>he is no way affiliated with the Bulgarian military or army and is likely on russia's payroll The sheer number of people - Americans, mostly - who consider Russia this omnipotent boogeyman is both hilarious and scary. Everything is Russian propaganda, you can't believe anything a Russian says, all Russians are evil. I mean, where does this mentality come from? It's insane. In some circles you can literally dismiss anything by mentioning it could be Russia. Even the politicians do it. Take this article: what is the big Russian conspiracy, on some obscure site, some of which can be confirmed on X? Wouldn't someone on Putin's payroll be better served not publicizing that they are using Starlink?
- willcipriano 3y agoLook its all well and good to bring up the objective and obvious fact that Russia isn't a threat to the United States, but have you considered the impact on the families of defence contractors? Haliburton's share price is correlated with the amount of global conflict, but did you know that same share price determines executive compensation? Do you know how much it costs the producers of child killing weapons to hire a twenty something to cheat on their wives with? A lot, therefore we need to keep the stock high and people very afraid otherwise how will the child murdering members of the professional managerial class be rewarded?
- inemesitaffia 3y agoImagine this. SpaceX solves this by terminating every dish bought outside of Ukraine due to antagonist comments
- throwaway44023 3y agoPlease, don't. That would disconnect dozens if not hundreds of Ukrainian units.
- drjeep 3y agoSouth Africa won't allow Starlink unless it meets local BEE requirements. As a result several ISPs are importing and registering Starlink in neighbouring countries, allowing us to stay online during almost daily load shedding caused by our crumbling, government owned power utility Eskom. For those of us who want to minimize our reliance on a corrupt, incompetent government Starlink is invaluable as it allows us to go completely off-grid. Power and water is one thing, but without Starlink our mobile and fibre networks can still go down when the backup batteries inevitably run out. Where there's demand, the market will find a way.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoSo many people here showing they know nothing about satcom or wireless networks
- vardump 3y agoHigh bandwidth phased array LEO satellite internet is a relatively new concept. Give them some time.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoThe SpaceX cells are small enough. All they need is a whitelist of nearly 100k devices. They'd rather antagonize the cheapest satcom supplier
- jjulius 3y agoPerhaps you could expand beyond that flippant snark and help people understand what they're missing? Otherwise, your comment doesn't really contribute much beyond making you feel better than others.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoIf for example you live in a country that doesn't register sim cards with authenticated information (e.g Ukraine) anyone can use the service. That's why Russian soldiers are using Ukrainian network sims in Ukraine. The same is true of starlink. The equipment (analogue of sim and phone together) is easily acquired. There's no whitelist . And service is available to anyone that can get a valid payment card. So just like the mobile network, Russians can use it. SpaceX used to mitigate this by limiting areas service is available. But that helps with places 20+km from the frontline. Not somewhere opposing soldiers can see each other. And Ukrainians complained about this. They had partisans and SOF they wanted to communicate with. Now it's done and we have a new narrative l You won't see Reddit level comments for such mobile networks. We know the reason for the difference in sentiment. The solution is device whitelisting at the frontline and beyond visual range. Maybe for some people limiting movement might be enough. But our anti work crowd will rather blame the supplier
- _heimdall 3y agoI'm surprised I haven't seen anyone propose the possibility that allowing Russia to use Starlimk is an espionage play. I have no idea if that's actually what's going on, but if it would give Starlink information on troop locations and open a door for listening in on all Starlink-based communications, you would want the public and Russia to believe the CEO is on their side. It would also align with the fact that Russia's big military pushes to secure and advance the front have largely failed or ended in stalemate. Tie that to the number of Russian ships attacked and again, if Russia is using Starlink Maritime that would track as well. By no means am I proposing this as the likely scenario, but it does seem possible and one that gets buried by people piling on to hate on Elon.
- EdwardDiego 3y agoMusk, Elon Musk, Agent double oh four twenty.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoThere is of course the reality that they actively helped the Ukranians with internet connectivity when early in the war they lost most of their satellite connectivity due to Russian hackers disrupting that. Distinguishing Russian users from Ukranian ones in Ukraine is probably not that easy.
- gruez 3y agoCan't they look up the subscriber information? Presumably the Ukrainian ones would be registered to the Ukrainian government, but the Russian ones would be registered to some random UAE company.
- throwaway44023 3y agoMany, many Starlink terminals and service subscriptions used in war zones by members of the UA army are donated and/or fully or partially paid for by private people - ukrainians and many more nationalities (including UAE). I personally helped stuff a van full of Starlink terminals and drones and my friend drove it to the UA border (though this was a much larger group effort than just us - especially the finance and sourcing). The UA army command is doing everything it can, but it's not unlimited and everywhere. The war effort relies on help of private individuals and groups a lot. Many soldiers are using equipment sourced entirely from private sources - all they got officially was a uniform and gun. All the drone videos you see on the internet - these are almost 100% bought privately.
- sunshine_reggae 3y agoJust like bankers - always funding both sides of the war.
- throw0101c 3y ago> Just like bankers - always funding both sides of the war. Ferengi Rule of Acquisition 34: War is good for business. Ferengi Rule of Acquisition 35: Peace is good for business. * https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Rules_of_Acquisition https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Rules_of_Acquisition
- dragonelite 3y agoWhy would they use star link given away their position to US and EU intel?
- shakow 3y agoNaive question; but given all the other intel channels of the US, from satellites to EW planes over the Black Sea through on-the-ground info from the UAF, would StarLink teach them something they don't already know? And if it did, would it be more valuable to the Russians to hide and drop a good 3C tool?
- qxfys 3y agoFlipping the perspective. Isn't it an advantage for the US intelligence? Much information can be extracted from the transmitter.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Throw73747 3y agoSo is starlink military technology, and if yes, are its satellites military assets? Ukraine has technology to shutdown this network!
- AlgorithmicTime 3y agoAt the core, it's all military technology. Canned food was invented for Napoleon's Grand Armee.
- mdw 3y agoIsn't this free intelligence? Monitor the communications from Russian locations and around Ukraine.
- tim333 3y agoAlthough both sides know the others locations pretty well anyway from drones and informants. And presumably the communications are encrypted.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- qaq 3y agoThe biggest problem for UAF is the pause in flow of ammo and weapon systems from US.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoThey'd rather blame SpaceX even though HIMARS wasn't available to use in Crimea over a year after arriving
- seydor 3y agoI can see a lot of potential for sabotaging the russian forces there
- Eransbens 3y ago[flagged]
- randomNumber7 3y agoIt's pretty cheap to call musk a pro russian. He is the one private person that helped ukraines war effort the most by providing them starlink in the first place. Is it so hard to understand that there are reasons for him to not allow the usage for deep strikes, besides him beeing on putins payroll?
- rbetts 3y agoShould a private individual be able to limit a sovereign nation's battle plan to defend itself from an invasion? Specifically, in the US, should a private individual or a public company be able to compete with the federal government over foreign affairs policy? (Presuming that allied war support, materiel, and rules of engagement qualify as elements of foreign affairs.) Are Elon's choices a mercantile challenge to democratic decision making that dilutes the sovereign powers of the US?
- inemesitaffia 3y agoOnly to the extent it's okay to send any equipment at all
- randomNumber7 3y agoThe US itself doesn't even allow ukraine to use their weapons for deep strikes. The US intentionally did not deliver the long range version of ATACAMS. I also think its questionable that a business person can influence a war. But you know, it was actually in favor of ukraine.
- api 3y agoIf you build a global thing like this it’s gonna be damn hard to keep anyone anywhere from using it unless you hard geofence.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoUkrainians complained about geofencing. Now it's seemingly gone and they have something new to complain about
- api 3y agoWell hey, if you sell stuff that gets used in a war you're gonna have one both sides pissed at you. Only way to avoid would be to geofence the entire region and nope out on the whole thing.
- InCityDreams 3y agoLike a two-year war?
- dist-epoch 3y agoPreviously Ukraine wanted to use Starlink in Crimea, but Musk geo-disabled them saying that Starlink is forbidden to provide business to sanctioned regions. > Musk said on the podcast that Starlink had been turned off over Crimea originally because of US sanctions on Russia. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-09-14/elon-musk-s-denial-of-ukraine-s-starlink-request-prompts-senate-query https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-09-14/elon-musk...
- inemesitaffia 3y agoThey've been lobbying for access. Now it's here and suddenly accusations of supplying Russia
- kaiwen1 3y agoWhy would the Russian military use a US satellite communications service to direct their operations in Ukraine? They would expect US intel to capture everything and share it with Ukraine.