6 ms·
Watching people’s accounts go into deactivated status in Slack with no goodbye is sad. The most toxic boss I ever worked for would request access to former emp
by Aurornis 3y ago
Watching people’s accounts go into deactivated status in Slack with no goodbye is sad.
The most toxic boss I ever worked for would request access to former employee’s Slack accounts under the guise of looking for data to transition their job. Their accounts would periodically go green when he logged in as them. Spooky to see ex-coworker accounts go green and know the boss is scouring their private messages.
I know companies can get slack messages anyway, but seeing your boss do it in real time is extra creepy.
- earthnail 3y agoWow, that is creepy.
- economicalidea 3y agoYou can’t get private Slack messages easily if you don’t have direct access to the account. There is an audit feature on the Enterprise version that allows it, and you can appeal to slack to open the messages due to a crime or similar - but AFAIK on the normal plans you are out of luck of you want to read private messages as workspace owner.
- adastra22 3y agoRequest access to former employee’s corporate email and reset the password.
- sillysaurusx 3y agoYep. That’s how it happened for me.
- planede 3y agoOuch. My takeaway is that I should probably delete my slack account before leaving the company.
- exitb 3y agoThe takeaway is that no message on Slack should be considered private.
- wil421 3y agoWhy would anyone consider a company provided messaging service as private? Or even a company provided laptop, cellphone, etc.
- adastra22 3y agoPeople have terrible opsec.
- TimTheTinker 3y agoBecause private messages carry an expectation of privacy. They're different parts of speech from the same root word, after all.
- adastra22 3y agoThere’s no legal obligation of privacy on a work system though. Not in the US at least.
- voidfunc 3y agoThe only expectation of this is in your head. It is a fantasy that doesn't exist.
- TimTheTinker 3y agoI know that legally, employee data has no expectation of privacy. But I'd like to gently push back here. The word "private" means "having privacy" in the normal, everyday sense. Using that word to describe something that isn't private is lying. You and I both know there do exist many people who suffered consequences for not understanding the definition of that word. In my opinion, the ethical thing to do is to use a different word when no expectation of privacy applies. And the upside is powerful: transparency gains trust. Slack did this well: they call them "direct messages".
- morkalork 3y agoHah, that would be the trick wouldn't it. My old manager used to get all of his former employees work emails forwarded to an account he had access to. Ostensibly it was a precaution against accidentally missing anything critical from a vendor or partner.
- the_gipsy 3y agoAnd all but extremely early startups or cheapskate companies have the Enterprise version.
- amenghra 3y agoThe correct mental security model here is “if you used an account on a company issued laptop/phone/any hardware” == “the company technically already has or can get access to the data”. There are so many ways for a company to do that. Granted, some of these ways might be legal or not depending on jurisdiction, but then lots of company will thread or cross the legal fine line if they are happy with the risk/benefit trade off.
- camgunz 3y agoI haven't checked in a while, but I think there's also an API for it too.
- kunley 3y agoFortunately in Europe what the said boss did is illegal and this can end with a criminal prosecution.
- yau8edq12i 3y agoWhat? First, Europe isn't a single country and there are large difference between legal systems. Second, what you said is just plain wrong in at least one. In France (which is known for strict worker protections) the employer can go through any employee's mailbox or files on their work computer/account provided 1. that the messages/files in question aren't clearly marked as personal 2. that the conditions for the access are laid down in advance with proper notice. When an employee is let go, they need to be given time to empty their mailboxes etc of private correspondence or files. https://www.cnil.fr/fr/lacces-la-messagerie-dun-salarie-en-son-absence https://www.cnil.fr/fr/lacces-la-messagerie-dun-salarie-en-s...
- sillysaurusx 3y agoI had some DM’s which were of personal nature that were rifled through after a contract ended. How do you "clearly mark a DM as personal"? It was creepy, and further illustrated that anything you say in Slack can and will be viewed by the whole company. If not literally, then that’s how you should treat it. You might be right that it’s not illegal, but it would be nice to have those kinds of protections. Trying to talk to anyone at work in the WFH era is a field of landmines, because you never know at any given time whether what you say will make it back to the person you’re discussing. Discussions like that are a normal and healthy part of socializing with coworkers, and it happens at every company. Except in the WFH era everything you’ve typed is a permanent record, whereas previously you’d be able to say something to a coworker without worrying that someone else will someday hear it. But, it’s a new era. It’s easy to adjust. Just don’t get personal at work. It sucks, but work is designed to suck, or else it wouldn’t be work.
- Gabrys1 3y ago> anything you say in Slack can and will be viewed by the whole company. If not literally, then that’s how you should treat it. Anyone thought otherwise?
- seer 3y agoOne company I worked for used to have an unofficial “ex-company” slack setup, where people would get invited to by others that have already left and were in there, it was kinda nice since you form bonds with people and suddenly they’re just gone. You might have not managed to connect with them in any other form. But you login to “ex-company” slack workspace and here they are - everyone that went through the company. I mean lots of people would stop responding after a while, but there was enough time “buffer” to allow people to connect with other means.
- itsrajju 3y agoI am a part of one such group! It started as a WhatsApp group for all ex-employees, but has now morphed into a discord server. It's a great way to remain connected to friends you make at work, and recently, it has also become a way to share job openings to your network to help laid-off people.
- nick7376182 3y agoAnybody have connection to the ex-google one if there is? I just left and didn't see it referenced in any of the leaving guides.
- doublerabbit 3y agoLeaving guides? I imagine a pamphlet. "We wish you well on your departure; as you embark on new adventures your about to open your eyes for the first time. This may be a shock to some of you as you may discover that the world is more dystopian than you've may of seen from your altered reality mind-implants. We would like to thank you for your service as a tool at the corporation."
- jasonjayr 3y ago"Handbook for the Recently Terminated" As long as it doesn't read like stereo instructions ....
- 3y ago
- trumbitta2 3y agoI think admins don't need to log into an account to see private messages. Was like that at two of my previous jobs.
- bombcar 3y agoIt’s usually an additional step as admin to access messages, but “login as” can be easier/simpler. Learned that Office 365 now has a “login as” for email which is convenient for setting out of office, deleting calendar invites, or email snooping.
- teeray 3y ago> Their accounts would periodically go green when he logged in as them. The new dystopia will be when an LLM steps in to reply like them.