11 ms·
VirtualBox KVM Public Release
For the past few months we have been working hard to provide a fast, reliable and secure KVM backend for VirtualBox. VirtualBox is a multi-platform Virtual Machine Monitor (VMM) with a great feature set, support for a wide variety of guest operating systems, and a consistent user interface across different host operating systems.
Cyberus Technology’s KVM backend allows VirtualBox to run virtual machines utilizing the Linux KVM hypervisor instead of the custom kernel module used by standard VirtualBox. Today we are announcing the open-source release of our KVM backend for Virtualbox.
- ImPleadThe5th 3y agoI'm quite inexperienced with Virtualization. Are there benefits to kernel based virtual machines beyond (what I assume is the primary benefit) performance?
- blitzclone 3y agoThe name KVM is a bit confusing. It doesn't do anything fundamental different than VirtualBox. The difference is that KVM comes by default with any Linux. VirtualBox ships it's own Linux kernel module for that. That has drawbacks. You typically can't use the newest Linux or the newest features. KVM also always has the hottest new (performance-relevant) features, because Intel and AMD will always build their hot stuff into KVM first.
- WhyNotHugo 3y agoYou can’t use virtualbox’s kernel module and kvm at the same time. This basically means that you can’t use virtualbox and qemu at the same time. If you use virtualbox with this new backend, you can use it concurrently with qemu (and a few other virtualisation tools). KVM is also part of Linux itself, so there’s a lot less haste with setting it up.
- dijit 3y agovirtualbox drivers are/were a constant source of kernel panics on MacOS and Linux too, so that should not be underestimated. IIRC they also disabled ASLR kernel wide. Additionally, and perhaps less important: USB3 is a commercial feature of virtualbox, there are stories of companies getting C&D letters (or Audits/Invoices) from Oracle because a developer had installed the virtualbox extensions..
- gonzodaruler 3y agoStarting with VirtualBox 7, USB3 no longer requires the commercial extension pack but is part of the OSE release. See https://github.com/cyberus-technology/virtualbox-kvm/blob/dev/src/VBox/Devices/USB/DevXHCI.cpp https://github.com/cyberus-technology/virtualbox-kvm/blob/de...
- treffer 3y agoI wouldn't call it kernel based. It's not like this is an in-kernel emulation. I would stick with hardware virtualization. KVM is a userspace API, and kvm-intel/kvm-amd are the drivers for the hardware. You will be using hardware features. That's also why it is in the kernel: nothing but the kernel should have full unlimited access to the CPU to set this up. So you could say it must be in kernel to keep the kernel secure. And the performance benefit is "just" exposed hardware features. The kernel does not provide additional things. As far as I understand: you set up a dedicated memory space and handle traps that halt the execution e.g. when the VM talks to the PCI bus. (It's been a while since I looked this up) But you need the pieces, especially virtual PCI devices. That's where qemu or VirtualBox enter the scene (or minimalist systems like firecracker). They provide a repository of virtual hardware and all the auxiliary methods to boot a virtual machines. You also need to emulate something like a BIOS or UEFI. You can think of it as your CPU removing the need to emulate the very same CPU (and a memory controller). You still need to emulate the rest though! But running on the same CPU removes most performance penalties. You run at native speed. Newer generations can even nest this. Having virtual machines in virtual machines. That's mostly useful for cloud environments so that the cloud provider can run kvm based VMs and you are still able to run VMs inside that VM.
- ImPleadThe5th 3y agoThat clarifies some things and gives me some tails to chace after! Thanks for the detailed response!
- tryauuum 3y agoif in the past they already were using a kernel module then your reply doesn't explain anything. So they went from using hardware virtualization (provided by intel/amd) with their kernel module to the KVM one. I don't know which benefits it brings
- i80and 3y agoWithout being at all up to date on the current state of things, the Virtual Box third party kernel module was historically of famously poor quality[1], even putting aside the general pains of third-party kernel modules. [1] https://www.phoronix.com/news/OTk5Mw https://www.phoronix.com/news/OTk5Mw
- unleaded 3y agoIf you go into VM settings > system > acceleration > paravirtualization interface you can select KVM, what's the difference between this and that?
- gonzodaruler 3y agoWhat you can configure in the GUI is an enlightenment that the guest will see. This is usually done to improve guest performance. You can sill select these PV interfaces with VirtualBox-KVM, but the underlying hypervisor is different (kvm vs vboxdrv).
- AnssiH 3y agoThe paravirtualization option affects the interface presented for the guest operating system for dealing with being virtualized. This new code is about using different virtualization technology on the host system.
- 4ad 3y agoToo little, too late. VirtualBox is completely obsolete. And the fact that it is owned by Oracle doesn't help.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Y-bar 3y agoI have ever only heard KVM in the context of a Keyboard Video Monitor-type device but somehow I can't fully fit that into the concept of a virtual machine. Does it mean something different here?
- viraptor 3y agohttps://linux-kvm.org/page/Main_Page https://linux-kvm.org/page/Main_Page
- nonrandomstring 3y agoIs there a connection to User Mode Linux (UML) from around the same time? Or are these completely unrelated projects? I get that running a kernel in the user space provided by another kernel is not really the same as a proper hypervisor, but have never really dug deep into why and what the various tradeoffs are.
- blitzclone 3y agoThere is no real connection to UML here. Hardware virtualization (Intel VT, AMD-V) are much faster in practice and also don't require the guest operating system to be heavily modified. So besides as curiosity or test vehicle, approaches like UML are pretty dead.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoThanks. So, slow as it may be, the win for UML (which seems to still have a heartbeat) is that it can run on uP without any specific virtualisation capabilities, right? If I could run Linux on a Z80/6502 then in theory I could run a virtualised Linux on a Z80/6502.
- mark_undoio 3y agoYes - plus the original win of UML was also being able to run virtual instances on a kernel without proper virtualization capabilities. In the early 2000s people used to use UMLs as a hosting platform - they didn't have the same security isolation as a proper VM (or even, necessarily, of a container) though.
- frankjr 3y agoAny chance this gets upstreamed?
- codemusings 3y agoI mean it's Oracle we're talking about here.
- ilogik 3y ago"What you think of Oracle, is even truer than you think it is. There has been no entity in human history with less complexity or nuance to it than Oracle." Bryan Cantrill https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zRN7XLCRhc&t=1980s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zRN7XLCRhc&t=1980s
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- metanonsense 3y agoThanks. This is pure comedy gold. In particular, that part about the acquisition by Oracle (from minute 33)
- blitzclone 3y agoOracle already had an unfinished and broken KVM backend in the code that was not exposed. Whether they incorporate this polished KVM backend is anyone's guess at this point.
- bionsystem 3y agoHow is it broken ? I used it for a day recently (from ubuntu repo, windows guest) and it worked ok.
- blitzclone 3y agoThe KVM backend in vanilla VBox cannot be activated without changing the code. If you tried it, you tried the vanilla VBox hypervisor (vboxdrv) instead of KVM.
- bradwood 3y agoWhat does this give me that I don't already get from KVM and virt-manager on Linux? Not getting it.
- kiney 3y agoA decent UI and hopefully support to use virtualbox appliances
- blitzclone 3y agoThe out-of-the-box performance of Windows in VirtualBox is very good and usually better than virt-manager (Qemu). You can tune Qemu to great performance as well, but it takes some fiddling. VirtualBox is in general very user friendly. Guest integration (drag'n'drop, clipboard), USB passhthrough and audio support is also top-notch in VBox.
- prmoustache 3y ago> The out-of-the-box performance of Windows in VirtualBox is very good and usually better than virt-manager (Qemu). You can tune Qemu to great performance as well, but it takes some fiddling. VirtualBox is in general very user friendly. I haven't found a significative difference but if you have found one and can tune qemu to same level,why don't you share the xml template of your machine to the world and to upstream's virt-manager project? > Guest integration (drag'n'drop, clipboard), USB passhthrough and audio support is also top-notch in VBox. These things works well with libvirt too provided you are using the spice-guest-tools.
- bonton89 3y agoNot sure about drag'n'drop. Also I've noticed that even when you're aware of the way USB passthrough in virt-manager GUI works that it seems to have some bugs. I'm mostly interested in if I can use virtualbox accelerated video with kvm because virgl3d seems well behind in that area.
- prmoustache 3y ago
- davb 3y agoThe blog post mentions an open source license but I can’t immediately see it in the post or the repo (perhaps I’m just missing it). Any idea what license this is released under?
- ylere 3y agoIt seems to be a fork of VirtualBox under the same dual license as the original project.
- Daviey 3y agohttps://github.com/cyberus-technology/virtualbox-kvm/blob/dev/COPYING https://github.com/cyberus-technology/virtualbox-kvm/blob/de...
- davb 3y agoThat appears to be the VirtualBox OSE license, copied from the original Oracle package, not the license for this specific release. It’s unclear how this new derivative or work is licensed.
- blitzclone 3y agoThe intention is to have this under the same license as the VBox open source release. If there is a way to clarify this more on the Github page, please advise. :)
- davb 3y agoThanks for the clarification, that’s really helpful. I think a paragraph under a “License” header in the README just reiterating what you said in that reply would be pretty clear. I’m sure some people would make the assumption that it’s under the same license as the upstream package but in some environments absolutely clarity around licenses is really appreciated.
- blitzclone 3y ago
- sph 3y agoFinally! Every time I need to run a virtual machine, I choose libvirt because it's more performant and easy to deal with than Virtualbox (no kernel module, etc.), but the GUI choices are pretty terrible. The "best" libvirt GUI is virt-manager and it's very, very buggy and lacking features (i.e. doesn't play nice with HiDPI screens, no way of configuring IPv6, etc.) Many times I have caved and chosen VirtualBox simply because at least it feels nice to use, even if not as performant as libvirt/kvm. Not anymore!
- blitzclone 3y agoGreat! What guests do you typically run where you see better performance with libvirt/kvm?
- sph 3y agoMostly Linux, but also Windows when I had a VFIO passthrough setup. I don't think it's even possible to set it up with Virtualbox to have decent enough performance.
- blitzclone 3y agoYou can also setup VFIO in VirtualBox/KVM. We haven't polished it yet though. You can check the video here to see GPU virtualization in action: https://www.cyberus-technology.de/products/hypervisor https://www.cyberus-technology.de/products/hypervisor (Don't mind the English, we are not native speakers. :)
- madushan1000 3y agoI'm really curious about this, is it gpu para-virtualization or actual VFIO requiring built in support from the gpu hardware?
- blitzclone 3y agoWe have used this with recent Intel GPUs that support SR-IOV. This is what you see in the video on the cyberus website. Intel hasn't managed to upstream the drivers for this yet and you have to piece together things, which is very unpleasant. But we are there to help, if someone wants to use this in a professional setting. We used to have support for Intel GVT-g GPU virtualization as well, which was more of a software solution. This doesn't work with modern Intel GPUs anymore.
- stephenr 3y agoSo can this run/import existing vbox VMs?
- blitzclone 3y agoYes, we are switching between vanilla VBox and KVM VBox during development quite often and the VMs are fine with it.
- moondev 3y agoWoah.. does this mean OVA/OVF support for kvm?
- blitzclone 3y agoYes.
- moondev 3y agoAwesome! Building this now, super excited to try it out.
- wtf_is_up 3y agoI think this should solve a current issue I have with virtualbox dealing with nested VMs. For example, nested QEMU VM running in a Virtualbox Linux guest causes the guest to lock up. According to virtualbox forum thread, only virtualbox-in-virtualbox nesting is supported, so to get around this I use virt-manager. But I think this kvm backend should solve it.
- blitzclone 3y agoThe KVM backend doesn't have nesting enabled just yet. We're on it.
- gonzodaruler 3y agoRunning VirtualBox-KVM in a QEMU-VM with enabled nesting should work though.
- prmoustache 3y agoFailing to find the interest over the various libvirt based GUIs
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- solarkraft 3y agoThat's impressive. I find QEMU and libvirt quite cumbersome, so this looks like it may be a worthwhile alternative now!
- tamarlikesdata 3y agoHow does it enhance security and performance of virtualized environments compared to the standard VirtualBox kernel module?
- blitzclone 3y agoWell, KVM is used by Google and AWS and others for their clouds. As such, there are a lot of eyes on KVM code. The vboxdrv kernel module that provides the same functionality in vanilla VBox definitely has fewer people looking at it. It also has anti-features, such as code upload from the userspace VirtualBox process to the kernel. This is also the largest security issue with vanilla VBox, because a lot of emulation code runs directly in the kernel. From a performance perspective, it's a bit more complicated. KVM has support for modern virtualization features (Intel APICv, AMD AVIC, etc) that vanilla VBox lacks. You get these in the VirtualBox/KVM version. On the other hand, vanilla VBox emulates most devices in the kernel (see above). So SATA emulation in vanilla VBox is very fast compared to KVM/Qemu or KVM/VirtualBox for a bit unfair reasons. Modern devices, such as virtio or NVMe, are not as impacted by that. tl;dr So the performance you get depends on your workload. If it's very interrupt heavy, VirtualBox/KVM will win. If it uses antiquated virtual devices (SATA), vanilla VirtualBox (with vboxdrv) will have an edge.
- peterhull90 3y agoAnd could one swap between the two backends with the same VM image (.vbox +.vdi) to see which one gave the better performance?
- blitzclone 3y agoYes!
- garaetjjte 3y agoeBPF for in-kernel device emulation, then? EDIT: That was a joke, but actually it is a thing https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nTMls33dG8Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nTMls33dG8Q
- Throw73747 3y agoDoes it support extra features from VirtualBox (machine snapshots, suspend&resume, multiple monitors, shared clipboard...)?
- gonzodaruler 3y agoIt does.
- bonton89 3y agoI do all of those things daily with virt-manager already. Except multiple monitors, although I believe it is supported.
- Throw73747 3y agoThanks, it seems to support it (even through it is a bit DIY). Will look into it.
- Manozco 3y agoI've contributed in the past to libvirt in order to support some Virtualbox features because some of our customers used VBox. It would have been handy to have this in the past, and have all of our customers use some KVM VMs ;) Congrats for the work!
- blitzclone 3y agoThank you!
- Faelian2 3y agoI am really curious about this. As a pentester, I run use Linux on my laptop and I spend a lot of time working inside a Kali VM with VirtualBox. How much performance improvement can we expect with the KVM backend ?
- blitzclone 3y agoIt depends on your setup and workload. On a recent Intel CPU, our performance dashboard shows +10% for some benchmarks. It's hard to make a general statement though.
- NanoCoaster 3y agoIf you don't mind, I have a specific question regarding this setup. I've been looking into getting into pentesting, mostly for fun. I decided on messing around with HackTheBox as a starting point. Seeing as you need to connect to their VPN, it seems like a good idea to me to separate this activity from my personal network. Which networking setup do you use for your pentesting VM? Ideally, I'd want a setup where the VM can access the internet (and therefore the HTB VPN), but not anything inside my local network. But I don't quite know how I could achieve that, at least in a way where I'd trust it to be reliable. Maybe the whole idea's a bit too paranoid to be practical in general, I don't know, so I'd love an expert opinion on this :) Usually, I'd be using QEMU, but I'd be fine with using VirtualBox for this case if it includes something that makes this easier.
- Manouchehri 3y agoYou can probably do this for VirtualBox (and any Linux program) by using tun2socks to create a network interface that routes through a proxy (SOCKS5 if you want UDP support), and then moving that network interface to a new namespace. You can run VirtualBox or any other programs in that new namespace, they don't have to be aware of the proxy at all (since they just see a regular gateway). https://github.com/xjasonlyu/tun2socks https://github.com/xjasonlyu/tun2socks
- mrAssHat 3y ago
- znpy 3y agoHonest questions: How does this work in licensing terms? If VB foss enough? Do you expect Oracle to merge this? If oracle doesn’t merge this, will you keep on maintaining it, potentially forking VirtualBox?
- blitzclone 3y ago>How does this work in licensing terms? If VB foss enough? It's as FOSS as the VirtualBox open source edition. > Do you expect Oracle to merge this? That would be nice, but I wouldn't hold my breath. Oracle gonna Oracle. > If oracle doesn’t merge this, will you keep on maintaining it, potentially forking VirtualBox? We don't intend to fork VirtualBox. VBox has a somewhat modular architecture where you can plug-in different hypervisor backends. That's what we did. It's not as modular, but our changes to core VirtualBox code is very small. As far as our plans go, we are pretty open at this point. We are very interested to get to know people that find this useful!
- stevemk14ebr 3y agoThis would be useful for anyone who needs to run bleeding edge linux kernels. Most other hypervisors have poor support when you're pinned to testing distros (For security reasons). KVM and virt-manager are uh not exactly user friendly, so being able to use the KVM backend and always be compatible with the new kernels while having the UX and UI of vbox is actually a very huge deal. This is one of the main reasons I really really hope you all manage to upstream this. I built and tried this, it worked great, so excellent work there. I found the processor CPU core counts being grayed out unpleasant, it's not clear to me how I am supposed to adjust my core and ram values now, maybe document this?
- parthy 3y agoThat's odd about the core count. I only get that behavior if my host system only has 1 CPU to begin with (tested in qemu/KVM with nesting). Could you comment on your host system parameters a bit?
- justinclift 3y agoAs a note, the first character of your COPYING file in the repo seems to be typo-d. ;)
- blitzclone 3y agoOoops. Will fix. :) Thanks!
- blitzclone 3y agoThat's already b0rken in the Oracle sources.
- justinclift 3y agoOops. I probably should have checked before mentioning it anyway. ;)
- jthemenace 3y agoIf I already have a headless debian hypervisor using KVM / QEMU in place running multiple debian VMs, can I now use Virtual Box to manage / tweaks the config on those? And if so is there anyway to do it without having to install a window manager, etc. on the hypervisor?
- qwertox 3y agoSo this basically turns VirtualBox into a replacement for virt-manager and virsh? AFAIK VirtualBox does not support PCI passthrough (like GPU), how is this case handled? Since I've moved to QEMU/KVM on Linux I've never looked back at VirtualBox, but I use the latter on Windows and there I'm always remembered of how much nicer and friendlier the GUI is. Edit: I just noticed that VirtualBox has experimental PCI passthrough via the extension package [0], could this be used with the KVM backend? [0] https://docs.oracle.com/en/virtualization/virtualbox/6.0/admin/pcipassthrough.html https://docs.oracle.com/en/virtualization/virtualbox/6.0/adm...
- gonzodaruler 3y agoThere is experimental support for VFIO PCI pass-through with VirtualBox-KVM, even for GPUs. Please have a look at https://www.cyberus-technology.de/products/hypervisor https://www.cyberus-technology.de/products/hypervisor
- gonzodaruler 3y agoYou can use `VBoxManage --attach-vfio` if you want to experiment with pci passthrough. This is different from the Oracle `pciattach` call and does not require any support from the extension package.
- mkesper 3y agoPlease evaluate the license of the extension package carefully before using!
- organsnyder 3y agoAnd don't download it from your employer's network if Oracle thinks they might have deep pockets.
- bonton89 3y agoIs it possible to use virtualbox's accelerated video adapters with the KVM backend?
- gonzodaruler 3y agoYes. Don't expect too much though. 3D acceleration with Virtualbox is rather flaky (independent of using KVM).
- bonton89 3y agoSure, VMware's is better but even that isn't really a replacement for GPU passthrough unfortunately. What I'd really like is to just get GPU accelerated video decode in the guests.
- tyilo 3y agoDoes this enable you to use Hyper-V in a guest Windows VM?
- blitzclone 3y agoNot yet. Nesting support is on our list. But the performance will not be great.
- londons_explore 3y agoWith this setup, what is providing the emulated hardware devices? (emulated USB host controller, emulated interrupt controller, etc) Is it still the original set of emulated hardware provided by virtualbox, or is it now whatever KVM provides?
- gonzodaruler 3y agoThe emulated hardware is basically the same as with stock VirtualBox. Only the interrupt contoller (local APIC) is emulated by KVM.
- guerrilla 3y agoWhat took so long? Isn't this like 15 years late? How do people even use the thing without KVM?
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoKVM is the one built into Linux. VBox has it's own module for hardware virtualization all along
- polski-g 3y agoWhy? How does this generate revenue for CyberusTech? What is the long term goal?
- blitzclone 3y agoWe're offering commercial support. We can also help with graphics virtualization and other topics (e.g. performance tuning and automated testing in real world scenarios).
- flo123456 3y agoThose are good questions. I don’t understand why you were downvoted. To answer: We are offering service contracts and contract engineering services around virtualization, KVM and a couple of other topics. The long term goal for this specific project is to support the security goals our customers have and to enable a couple of KVM features in Virtualbox as well. We plan to keep this updated with upstream Virtualbox and KVM.
- stevemk14ebr 3y agoPlease upstream this code. That ensures this work will live forever with better maintenance without you all having to chase upstream vbox AND will be easier to justify use if it's an included vbox component. I would find it difficult to justify using this to my bosses "lets just go use this custom fork of vbox" isn't going to fly for most.
- oohffyvfg 3y agoso, the plan is to take on docker hub? edit: nevermind. i assumed you were a team inside oracle.
- tejohnso 3y agoI'm running a Ryzen5600G on Arch and recently switched from VirbualBox to QEMU/KVM and couldn't be happier. Webcam, USB drives, Hardware Video Acceleration, all working without issue (after a pretty tough learning curve getting it set up).
- orthecreedence 3y agoYes, I recently had to compile some stuff on Windows (I'm on an AMD Linux host) and VirtualBox just wouldn't start Microsoft's Windows dev VM (the one they provide for free for Virtualbox). I ended up learning how to use qemu and it works great...and as a bonus I was able to run a hackintosh (via https://github.com/kholia/OSX-KVM https://github.com/kholia/OSX-KVM) and it works near flawlessly, which was something I was never able to accomplish with Virtualbox (granted I haven't tried in a few years). I'm pretty happy with Qemu now, even if it's jsut a CLI interface. I was tempted to try the virt-* stuff, but honestly it seems like one more thing to learn so I'm going to hold off until I need something like copy/paste between VMs and can't figure it out in qemu direct.
- curiouslinux333 3y agoIs bridged networking easy to setup? It's the main reason i use VirtualBox.
- SubiculumCode 3y agoCan someone break this down for me? I gather this is not included in VirtualBox itself. Is it a plugin of some type? Is it useable? Edit: Apologies. The answer is in the article itself: Compile VirtualBox with this Release from source[1]. [1] https://github.com/cyberus-technology/virtualbox-kvm https://github.com/cyberus-technology/virtualbox-kvm
- zare_st 3y agoPractical thing is not having to recompile 3rd party drivers (vbox ko) every time kernel gets upgraded. Tho DKMS tries to take care of that without admin intervention, it's not always bug free. On the other side VirtualBox the software application is designed to integrate with the desktop well, VNCing into the guest is not an alternative to this. I hope efforts will be made in FreeBSD world too against its bhyve hypervisor. The terminology issue is curious but it has been already covered here lately in a topic about Linux direct rendering manager, DRM. The acronym was used in a narrow circle of people compared to "the whole ICT", as were keyboard-video-mouse devices. Less than 1% of professionals deal with Linux internals on that level, and less than 1% of professionals are server room on-site engineers. There wasn't collective consciousness about these terms so they got reused. Also LVM is taken by something else (storage) and LKVM would be confusing.
- k8svet 3y agoI cannot even imagine using a distro that can't manage to get DKMS/kernel module updates to be reliable. I don't think I've ever had a problem with DKMS in NixOS ever; not a single time. edit: downvoting me won't make your distro any more competent.
- progman32 3y agodkms has worked fine for me in Gentoo, Debian, and Ubuntu. I think the backlash has more to do with the comment's tone.
- flo123456 3y agoDoing this for FreeBSD would be a great project. Unfortunately it is also big enough that we couldn’t afford to do it without some kind of funding.
- lenerdenator 3y agoWhen Apple Silicon client? WHEN!?
- itvision 3y agoThis is awesome and great news, thanks a ton! The biggest issue however is that many Linux distros just refuse to build and distribute VBox kernel modules despite them being open source. Thank you for your work regardless. Do you intend VirtualBox to pick up your work and integrate it? I'm really looking forward to it. Have you already talked to the company? I really don't want this to be a one off work to potentially become decrepit and unusable going forward. Secondly, some VBox features belong to a separate closed source extension pack: USB2/3 support, PXE boot, VM disk encryption, webcam/camera support. Will they work with KVM VirtualBox after installing the pack?
- gonzodaruler 3y agoThanks. You can indeed use the extension pack with KVM Virtualbox, just make sure that you don't violate any license agreements.
- mypgovroom 3y agoThis is cool! However maybe I'm just old and grumpy now, but this seems like something that would have been awesome 10 years ago. Now does anyone really care though?
- dschuetz 3y agoVirtualBox, as absurd as it is, needs a proprietary, licensed "extension pack" for basic things like today standard USB2/3 drivers, encryption and webcam. I don't care about backends as long VirtualBox frontend has "Oracle" slapped on it. So, kudos! for perpetuating Virtualbox' existence!
- gonzodaruler 3y agoA lot of this has changed in recent VirtualBox versions. USB3 and Webcam support is now part of the OSE release.
- nodesocket 3y agoFirst time hearing about Cloud Hypervisor. What's the use for it? I recently built a Windows 11 Pro machine (mostly for gaming) but would like to run a few VMs on it. What's the recommended VM platform these days? Still Hyper-V? I'm a macOS and Linux guy, but begrudgingly using Windows because of games.
- password4321 3y agoHyper-V is a good option for VM servers but AFAIK it doesn't do user-friendly stuff like USB or graphics card pass-thru.
- markfeathers 3y agoAnyone using VitualBox please be careful about the extension pack. Oracle is very litigous. https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/147k6az/oracle_is_demanding_money_for_vbox_extension_pack/ https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/147k6az/oracle_is... https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/d1ttzp/oracle_is_going_after_companies_using_virtualbox/ https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/d1ttzp/oracle_is_... https://www.theregister.com/2019/10/04/oracle_virtualbox_merula/ https://www.theregister.com/2019/10/04/oracle_virtualbox_mer... We banned virtualbox in our organization since vmware workstation (or virt-manager) is way cheaper than dealing with oracle.
- politelemon 3y agoExactly what I came to comment. Same thing here, they seemed to hyperfixate on the extension pack which most VBox users would need. We had to get everyone off that as soon as possible. Of course this isn't limited to VBox, but their database as well. Just avoid.
- tech234a 3y agoJust noting that USB 2.0/3.0 support no longer requires the extension pack, and the list of features [1] that require the extension pack has been gradually decreasing. It may not be as necessary as it once was. [1]: https://www.virtualbox.org/manual/ch01.html#intro-installing https://www.virtualbox.org/manual/ch01.html#intro-installing
- chungy 3y agoUSB was the only reason I ever had it. I need nothing from the current list.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dheera 3y agoWhat if you just ignored Oracle? Do they even have teeth? If they made a download free it should be free. You can't hand someone a banana on the street and then come back 3 months later demanding $1000 for it.
- downsplat 3y agoReminds me of the bad old days when I regularly had to open a crappy windows 7 in a VM because some minor piece of software would not run on Linux or on the browser. Thankfully I haven't needed to do that in years. On a more constructive note, this might be really useful for kernel developers, and for big companies using desktop virtualization.
- dehrmann 3y agoCrappy? Windows 7 was the last good Windows.
- orthecreedence 3y agoYou don't like being plastered with ads and news articles about Trump every time you open your start menu??
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoI use Win10 and I don't get ads in my Start menu. Is it maybe because I'm using Win10 Pro, not Home?
- nineteen999 3y agoNope, I started with Home and upgraded to Pro later and I've never had ads in the Start Menu or anywhere else. My machine came preinstalled though and whoever installed Windows obviously had a clue and turned all that crap off before they shipped it to me.
- downsplat 3y agoYeah, any other Windows would have been worse. For me it was crappy because no-one wants to be maintaining a second hardly-used OS on their laptop. You randomly need it once in a blue moon, have to deal with two UIs with their conventions and feels on the same computer, and with copying files between them, and then and of course the first thing it wants to do is download tons of updates. Makes for a crappy experience.
- Fervicus 3y agoCan someone ELI5 what this is and does it benefit someone like me who occasionally spins up VirtualBox VMs for various OSes?
- jkrshnmenon 3y agoThis only affects anyone that wants to spin up VirtualBox VM's on Linux hosts. I'm not an expert in this field, but my best TL;DR is that VirtualBox and other VMM's (virtual machine monitor) used to ship with their own hypervisors (the thing that let's you run virtual machines). However, now Linux has its own hypervisor/framework (KVM) and now VirtualBox can use KVM to do all the functionalities their own hypervisor used to do. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong
- Fervicus 3y agoThanks! Appreciate it.
- nani8ot 3y agoThis makes me consider using VirtualBox again. Having to install and update a kernel module is annoying. Especially on some immutable/image-based distros like Fedora Atomic.
- coppsilgold 3y agoWhen it comes to linux-in-linux virtualization of GUIs you can do much better than virt-manager/vmware/virtualbox nowadays. With crosvm you can share Wayland through shared memory buffers and obtain opengl & vulkan acceleration for the guest while at it. This way guest applications appear through the host's Wayland compositor seamlessly.
- blitzclone 3y agoYes, this is indeed nice. I have a Chromebook as well and the integration with Linux apps is super seamless. The major usecase for VBox is mostly Windows, though.
- mwcampbell 3y agoI'd like to know more about this part: > A lot of the security features that get built into Windows rely on virtualization. In cases where Windows is already virtualized, additional support from the Hypervisor is needed to enable those features. KVM provides a lot of the needed support to improve Windows’ security in virtualized environments. What specific features does KVM provide for this? I gather this isn't talking about nested virtualization.
- cuddlyogre 3y agoI'd love a realistic alternative to virtualbox on Windows for running Debian as a development environment. I've tried hypervisor but I can't get networking to work, and trying to set up another adapter gives me a bsod on every computer I try it on. Wsl2 almost works, but I can't really use Intellij to its full capacity. I'm under the impression that GUI application support is coming so maybe that will change. I'd really love for this to work so I can learn docker, but virtualbox performance is non-existent when wsl is turned on. Qemu feels incomplete or at least overly complicated compared to Virtualbox.
- Geisterde 3y agoTested on ubuntu 22.04 with an amd 5800x and amd 6800 gpu. It seems to work flawlessly, the gui seems to respond as quickly as the desktop its run on, it even has the same timeout errors clicking through the "welcome to ubuntu" setup. This is my first time running virtualbox on my desktop/linux, so I am not sure what I should expect, but I certainly have nothing to criticize here.
- ma2307 3y agoi have gpu use in vfio, success passthrough to qemu vm using virt-manager. Can i add vfio to virtualbox?
- ma2307 3y agoCan use vfio passthrough gpu like qemu ?