7 ms·
EVs won over early adopters, but mainstream buyers aren't along for the ride yet
- kozak 3y agoMainstream buyers are waiting for EVs that are not "weird cars", but simply normal cars that just happen to have EV drivetrains. We are getting there, but still slowly.
- joezydeco 3y agoAnd you'd think that would be the quickest and easier thing to do, but the automakers got distracted by Tesla and went into making new platforms. The only company I've seen that didn't go this route at first was Volvo. The XC40 Recharge is a nice product.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- barbazoo 3y agoThere are tons of boring EV out there, all the old ladies where I live drive Hyundai Kona. Doesn’t get any more boring than that. I think people are waiting for cheaper EV.
- sseagull 3y agoI was looking for a new car and recently and gave serious thought to an EV. I found out that there aren't really that many EV sedans, but lots of SUVs and whatever you call the in-between-sized vehicles. I wasn't too impressed with the selection, and they were pricey (like the Hyundai Ioniq). On the other hand, there's some nice hybrids that generally look like any other sedan out there, and not much more expensive than ICE.
- LoganDark 3y agoI wonder if this has anything to do with the size of the battery pack? It's harder to get a sufficiently sized battery pack to fit into a sedan form factor. SUVs have an excuse to be large.
- pornel 3y agoI think the size helps, but there's Renault Zoe with an ok-ish 52kWh battery. ID.3 has up to 77kWh, and is still relatively small compared to SUVs.
- pedalpete 3y agoSedan sales have been dropping over the last few decades, the market is all in SUVs, which is why that gets priority. Look at Tesla Model 3 sales over Model Y as an example. Basically the same car, but the Y has a taller body (more SUV like). So with the number of EVs being sold, it makes sense to focus on SUVs for now for most companies, unless they are trying to make a statement car like Lucid.
- nothercastle 3y agoInfrastructure is still a major problem. Tesla charger standard in the USA will help but capacity and coverage still needs to double before it’s decent. For dual car households an ev should be a great option as range is a non issue
- idiotsecant 3y agoCost is much too high still, so it's not surprising. I can go on Facebook marketplace and buy 3 or 4 good ICE vehicles for the cost of an EV. Most people don't have the luxury of purchasing based on ideology.
- thebruce87m 3y agoIdeology? Mine costs 3p/mile to run vs 12p/mile on a high mpg diesel. Preheated/defrosted every morning. All my journeys are less than 200 miles so never have to use public charging (or stand at a pump). Save both time and money.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 3y agoThe car was free and you only pay running costs? Who is giving them away please tell me!
- mass_and_energy 3y agoI think they were referring to the TCO. The total cost of ownership, or TCO, represents the net cost of an item based on all aspects of its use and ownership (gas, insurance, maintenance). Whether or not the math checks out is a whole other can of worms but TCO is an important concept that YSK, friend
- JumpinJack_Cash 3y ago> > TCO is an important concept that YSK, friend Maybe more important, but it's not real, it's aleatory and involves predicting unknown unknowns such as the future state of technology, roads and even simpler if you end up with a lemon of a car or not.
- thebruce87m 3y agoWho said anything about a free car? In the UK there are lots of deals on second hand EVs. You can get a second hand 3y/o TM3 for £24k-ish. Kia Niros etc are a bit cheaper.
- frankbreetz 3y agoCan you buy an EV, that doesn't connect to the internet and is reasonably priced? I know that is what I am waiting for.
- maury91 3y agoI got a Renault Zoe and even if I complained with the dealer doesn't connect to internet and doesn't have an app ( in Lithuania )
- JohnFen 3y agoYes, this is why I won't buy any EVs on the market in the US. But it's not special to EVs -- it's why I won't buy any recently manufactured ICE cars either.
- shiftpgdn 3y agoMy Audi e-tron now sells for $25-35k used (from the original $80k+USD MSRP!) I did not pay for the internet package, and therefore my car is now completely offline. I use apple carplay so the MMI/computer is mostly useless anyway. I believe on Teslas you can outright remove the SIM that provides internet, and the car would function mostly fine. Used model 3s are in the sub $20k range now.
- JohnFen 3y ago> I did not pay for the internet package, and therefore my car is now completely offline. Are you sure? Most (all?) newish cars that I know of phone home whether or not you have user-facing internet connectivity.
- ragnese 3y ago> I believe on Teslas you can outright remove the SIM that provides internet, and the car would function mostly fine. Used model 3s are in the sub $20k range now. A friend of mine had his Tesla's radio/modem/whatever chip die, so his internet connectivity stuff didn't work. He told me that most things continued to work just fine and he continued to drive it for a few days while waiting for his repair appointment. So... add a "friend of a friend" confirmation to that.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoEVs are a great daily driver for a family in the Sprawl that has a garage where they can charge the thing overnight at residential electricity rates, and that also has a second ICE car for their occasional longer trips. If you live in a city, rely on street parking, and have to charge at the elevated rates of public chargers (which nevertheless are still barely profitable), then forget it. If you're in certain kinds of rural areas, then maybe. Maybe you can charge with your own solar, mostly. Maybe there's enough charging infrastructure at gas stations near you, for Plan B. And say you're still within comfortable EV range of a small/medium city. Then I could sort of see getting an EV. A lot of rural areas east of the Mississippi are like this. But if you're way out in Montana, or if you need to cross long stretches of desert highway in New Mexico, or something like that, then forget it. I'd do it once or twice with white knuckles and a careful plan; I wouldn't rely on it regularly. Basically, EVs are tailor-made for suburban sprawl. Which admittedly does describe the majority of American civilization, such as it is. But if you're not part of that, then they're probably not for you. And that's assuming that prices become affordable, which they haven't become yet, apart (only recently, and probably temporarily) from used Hertz Model 3s.
- JohnFen 3y ago> If you live in a city, rely on street parking, and have to charge at the elevated rates of public chargers (which nevertheless are still barely profitable), then forget it. Even if privacy wasn't a dealbreaker for me, this is what would kill the idea dead. I would have no option at all to charge an EV at home, so I would be entirely dependent on driving to a commercial charger in order to do that. Aside from cost, having to hang out at a public charger for so long every time would be hard to put up with. There's also the issue that I very much prefer to buy my cars used rather than new, but I have trouble with the idea of trusting a used EV. Replacing those batteries is very expensive.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI’ve never had much time to do very many things when using an L3 charger. 20 minutes is enough time to run into a grocery store and grab a few things, but not to do lots of shopping.
- TheLoafOfBread 3y ago1. EVs are more expensive to buy compared to ICEs. But Chinese EVs... can I buy them in Europe for that price? No? Then they are irrelevant. 2. EVs are taking more time to "fill up". Yeah, yeah, you can charge at home, but most people can't and will be charging on public chargers, where times are absurdly inferior compared to a gas pump. 3. Public charging infrastructure is overcomplicated. No I don't want your application. I don't want to create an account. Let me use my debit card and don't ask me on anything. 4. Public charging is often more expensive than gas - Ionity 0,69EUR/kWh Enel X 0,89-0,99EUR And I am saying that as owner of BEV. If you want to reach masses, you need to offer better deal than ICE, this is just a joke.
- matthewdgreen 3y ago> No I don't want your application. I don't want to create an account. Let me use my debit card and don't ask me on anything. I agree about this. But we now have a direct-to-car billing standard (as part of the CCS/NACS standards) that should solve this, it's just a question of manufacturers and network operators getting their crap together and deploying it.
- JohnFen 3y agoDirect-to-car billing would be even less acceptable. Chargers should let you use a credit card without having to involve an account anywhere, be it on a phone app or on the car.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoThat still involves the credit card account. It's not really "not involving an account" until you can pay cash.
- JohnFen 3y agoTrue, but that's an account you already have and is independent of the products and services, so using it for this doesn't make anything worse.
- steelframe 3y agoI have owned EVs -- including PHEVs -- for 12 years now. They've included two different LEAFs, a 2011 and a 2017, a Tesla Model X, a Volvo XC90 T8, and a Jaguar I-PACE. Based on my own experience with these cars, I would insist on two things for any car I buy. First, the manufacturer should have an established reputation for building quality cars that are reliable. If they already know how to build reliable ICE cars, I think they are able to apply their acquired engineering acumen and culture to do a better job with an EV. I think you know where I am going with this. Both the Tesla and the Jaguar have had major issues, and neither the LEAFs nor the Volvo have had significant problems. The Tesla was in the shop maybe a dozen times before I finally traded it in for the Volvo. The final straw for me was when the half shaft started shuddering due to an engineering flaw and Tesla tried to pass that off as "normal." The I-PACE was actually pretty good for about 4 years until now. It was in the shop the least of any ICE I've owned, except when it failed, its failure mode was catastrophic and extremely dangerous. It started up and engaged drive just like always with no indications of a problem, except once I pulled out into traffic, the accelerator just stopped working. No forward force at all, and I only got to maybe 3mph before that happened. It was only then that I got battery error notifications on the dash with a warning to "stop safely." Except before too long the 12v battery got completely drained, and then the brakes stopped working too. Then the emergency brake applied, and the car died completely. No way to shift into neutral and push the car or anything. It was just a dead brick in the road that couldn't even be towed by anything but a flat bed. I'm generally pretty tolerant of technology blips from immature tech, but what if that had happened when I was driving my family on the freeway earlier that same day? Porsche had a similar "loss of power" issue with the Taycan at first, and they had to do a recall early-on for that. Oh, and remember that Chevy Bolt battery flaw where the cars were exploding? Yeah, so Jaguar installed those same flawed LG Chem battery packs in the I-PACE. So far Jaguar's response has been to give me a battery control module firmware update that's supposed to detect when the pack is about to explode and then do something to stop that from happening, I guess. This experience literally has me now looking at manual transmission ICE cars with emergency brake levers that attach to cables and springs. You know, things I can fix on the side of the road with a jack, some tools, and maybe a hardware store nearby. Or at least something almost any auto mechanic can fix for me in a few hours. Regardless, I'm done with early adopter stuff for the machine I entrust my family's life to. It was fun while it lasted, but the failure modes must be better than "Surprise, now you can't accelerate or stop!"
- asdefghyk 3y agoThere has not been widespread battery replacement yet ( after the first battery needs to be replaced ) - which is significant cost. Also ICE have much greater towing ability.
- brewdad 3y agoI have never, in my 50 years on this planet, needed to tow anything. Most people don't.
- thegrim33 3y agoOne other reason to add that I haven't seen mentioned yet: I'm waiting on solid state batteries. They solve pretty much all the limitations of the current battery tech (temperature issues, charge times, max charge cycles / battery degradation). Whenever EVs with solid state batteries start rolling out the value of vehicles with legacy (current) battery tech will just absolutely plummet. I would also hate to drop tens of thousands of dollars on a vehicle that's vastly inferior to the next gen offerings. I buy cars for life so I don't want to trade up to the latest thing when it becomes available, I want to buy something great to begin with.
- snakeyjake 3y agoI wish someone, anyone, would make a driver's EV. Correction: an affordable driver's EV. $100k minimum for a Taycan isn't affordable. I've driven every model of Tesla from a base-model 3 to an S Plaid. They do not handle well and have poor vehicle dynamics. Anyone who thinks they handle well has never driven a car that handles well. Even the most charitable review could be summed up as "the computer does a valiant job at hiding the car's shortcomings when it comes to handling". All of the crossover SUV EVs and Korean EV sedans are even worse. As a point of reference, I've only ever owned four models of cars in almost 30 years of driving: multiple MX-5s, an MR2, an S2000, and a Fiat Spider and those are the only kinds of cars I want to drive. To me a car that handles a curvy road well is better than a car that can accelerate to infinity within Planck time. Every single other issue most people have with EVs is irrelevant to me: I never drive more than 150 miles per day, don't care about recharging overnight, and have 50 amps of 240V in my garage ready and waiting. The only think keeping me from buying and EV is that all affordable EVs drive like trash. I know I'm not a mainstream buyer and I know I'm shit out of luck when it comes to the future of automobiles. Eventually all that will be left in the market is crossover SUVs that numb your soul to the point of despair and supercars that cost a million dollars. I just wish someone would make an affordable driver's EV. I would buy a $50k EV that didn't handle like trash, tomorrow.
- reverius42 3y agoTry the Mini Cooper SE?
- saltcured 3y agoWithout more battery breakthroughs, I think you would almost have to do some kind of aftermarket/custom conversion. To get the kind of lightweight car you prefer, you need to limit the battery weight too much. Meanwhile, the mass market still has range anxiety. Look at some of those EV cars setup for famous hill climbing races, where they plan out the amount of charge they need for one short race. Then, work backwards from there what tradeoffs you would make to extend range beyond this one sprint. More battery weight for more stored charge? Less power to optimize the motor and electronics efficiency? Aero optimized for low drag instead of downforce/stability? Tires optimizes for low rolling resistance instead of sticky cornering?...
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoI would get one today if I could afford one.