7 ms·
Dean of Engineering at University of Nevada wrote a paper that’s bad
- em1sar 3y agoOutrage over a single low-quality paper, of which there are thousands across academia, misses the larger point. The real issue is the systemic problem within academia, where creative thinkers are often stifled early in their careers. Researchers find themselves forced to align their work with the direction of funding sources or their superiors' interests, resulting in a significant misallocation of resources. Annually, billions of dollars are buried in research that lacks true innovation or independence. This is a far more critical issue than the work of this literal nobody dean. What's even more funny is that the same individuals quick to criticize such low-hanging fruit often do everything in their power to avoid scrutiny themselves, especially regarding the inefficient use of tax dollars and the insignificance of their research areas.
- UncleMeat 3y agoThis isn't just a low quality paper. It is two paragraphs long. Its very last sentence is a sentence fragment. It just says "Rest may be important for train operators. Rest is also important for this particular kind of fly species." I've seen low quality papers get published before, but they are enormously better than this. Even the very worst papers I've ever seen in peer review and given strong rejects to are enormously better than this. This wouldn't even cut it for a poster proposal at a conference. I would expect a 6th grader writing a science report that they were given two weeks to complete to produce better writing than this.
- em1sar 3y ago[dead]
- fabian2k 3y agoThe title does sound very much like clickbait, but the "paper" is certainly bad enough that I wouldn't even consider it a scientific paper at all. It's about twice the size of the abstract of a typical paper, and has essentially no content at all.
- bemmu 3y agoWow, at first I thought that was just the first page, but it really is the entire paper.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoIt was an exciting read. I was not expecting the conclusion to suddenly talk about trains!
- itishappy 3y agoWow. Here's the meat of it: > Our recent study has the premise that both humans and flies sleep during the night and are awake during the day, and both species require a significant amount of sleep each day when their neural systems are developing in specific activities. This trait is shared by both species. An investigation was segmented into three subfields, which were titled "Life span," "Time-to-death," and "Chronological age." In D. melanogaster, there was a positive correlation between life span, the intensity of young male medflies, and the persistence of movement. Time-to-death analysis revealed that the male flies passed away two weeks after exhibiting the supine behavior. Chronological age, activity in D. melanogaster was adversely correlated with age; however, there was no correlation between chronological age and time-to-death. And by "meat of it" I mean literally everything that's not background. In conclusion: > of these age factors when considering these options supply chain procedure for maintaining will be beneficial. That's not a fragment, that's the entire last sentence copied exactly, including the lack of capitalization. https://isctj.com/index.php/isctj/article/view/250/250 https://isctj.com/index.php/isctj/article/view/250/250
- staplung 3y agoMaybe the author just needs some sleep. To “exhibit the supine behavior,” as we say in the business.
- W-Stool 3y agoI used to work at the University of Nevada, Reno - the institution cited here. The current president of the institution is a former Republican governor without a Ph.D (something nearly all university presidents have). The current VP of Finance is a former Reno city manager who left his job due to a series of sexual harrassment and hostile workplace scandals. After leaving his Reno city job he went to work for the Republican govenor who is now the UNR president. I think you get the idea of what kind of institution UNR is morphing into.
- Nifty3929 3y ago"former Republican governor without a Ph.D" - Are these traits disqualifiers for some reason? In particular, maybe NOT having a Ph.D. could be considered a good thing in this case. Is there anything else to say about this person's qualifications or lack thereof?
- dleeftink 3y agoIs a general without combat experience fit to lead?
- thomquaid 3y agoOf course.
- duxup 3y agoI think that’s plausible.
- gnfargbl 3y agoA better analogy would be a general who had never been a junior officer.
- nradov 3y agoIt's possible in theory. Someone with unique skills can be directly commissioned at the O-4, O-5, or even O-6 ranks without ever being a junior officer. After commissioning they can eventually be promoted to O-7 (brigadier general or equivalent) just like any other officer. https://talent.army.mil/direct-commissioning/ https://talent.army.mil/direct-commissioning/
- mkoubaa 3y agoI doubt that this paper gets a passing grade as a middle school science research project
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jacknews 3y agoWhat's this for? OK there are probably plenty of not-really academic institutions who hire not-really academics, not to mention administrators, but this just seems like some very specific personal grudge.
- laidoffamazon 3y agoIt does seem strangely personal, though I'll admit it is confusing to publish as a n engineering Dean. My theory is this author, Andrew Gelman, is an MIT and Harvard trained academic that is incensed by the fact that a state-school educated, industry-focused individual would be a lead administrator at a University. I don't think he has a particularly high opinion of people that weren't precocious youth.
- spencerflem 3y agoThe paper is extremely embarrassingly bad. It would be lame as a middle school science fair project.
- wwirklich 3y agoThe students I worked with at UNR were not from privileged backgrounds and picked the school because it is affordable. I loved working with these students. They were smart and hardworking, and you could see the positive impact of higher education on their lives. It is a betrayal of these students to hire someone like this that will harm the reputation of their degrees.
- laidoffamazon 3y agoI'm very skeptical that the reputation of a state school is really influenced by a single Dean of engineering no matter how silly their recent publication record is. I'm also noticing a red flag in this comment by stating that they picked the school because it was affordable - while that is true, shouldn't the same grace be applied to students that went to this school because it was the best school they got into and didn't get into any better ones? I've noticed a lot of people justify their attendance at lower-ranked schools by saying the institutions are affordable, but in reality you shouldn't need to justify not getting into elite schools to begin with.
- Dachande663 3y agohttps://archive.is/EZr39 https://archive.is/EZr39
- wwirklich 3y agoI worked for the previous Dean and the guy mentioned in the article. After a conversation with him, it was clear that the college's mission was inverted. Rather than serving the students, the college was there to serve him. Basically, everyone in the Dean's office quit after he started. It is sad because the previous Dean was a civil engineer and spent 30 years at the institution building it up.
- goalieca 3y agoDevil’s advocate but most research universities seem to serve the prestige and egos rather than students, especially grad students.
- Gualdrapo 3y agoEven if that were true, it should not be the purpose of a university
- wwirklich 3y agoThe process was so flawed with this search. Initially, they didn't even provide a curriculum vitae to the college faculty. We were literally told to 'Google him'. The whole process was rushed and condensed into a single week with minimal interaction with faculty. Typically, these university leadership searches are very public because if they go wrong, they result in reputational harm, which is a huge disservice to the students.
- neilk 3y agoNo paywall, but it’s not loading for me. https://archive.ph/EZr39 https://archive.ph/EZr39
- shusaku 3y ago> The thing I still can’t figure out is, why did Jones publish this paper at all? He’d already landed the juicy Dean of Engineering job, months before submitting it to his own journal. This was my first reaction as well. We always hear about publish or perish, but eventually you get pretty perish-proof.
- fabian2k 3y agoMaybe he just wants to brag with his h-index. Or he uses the citation metrics to appear more prestigious when applying to grants or presenting himself in general. Or he has some bonus tied to publication numbers. Or he siphons off the publication fees as he owns the journal.
- dev_tty01 3y ago>Maybe he just wants to brag with his h-index. Who is going to cite this paper?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CyberDildonics 3y agoThis title is so bad I can't believe it.
- billyhoffman 3y ago* The entire paper is 278 words, excluding references * There are 9 references, but no footnotes to show where a referenced work is actually being used. * The paper provides no data. * The paper mentions correlation between data that was taken, without providing statistics or graphs to prove said correlation. * The paper's single photo, of a Drosophila Melanogastert fly, was copied from Pixabay, without proper attribution (Per reverse image search) * The authors neglected to use a properly licensed image of a Drosophila Melanogastert fly which exists in Wikicommons. * The paper's last sentence is neither a valid English sentence, nor an accurate summary of the paper. The sentence is "of these age factors when considering these options supply chain procedure for maintaining will be beneficial." That is not a typo. It literally starts with a lowercase letter. Link to paper: https://isctj.com/index.php/isctj/article/view/250/250 https://isctj.com/index.php/isctj/article/view/250/250 Image on Pixabay: https://pixabay.com/photos/fruit-fly-fly-insect-animal-6831034/ https://pixabay.com/photos/fruit-fly-fly-insect-animal-68310...
- moralestapia 3y agoWhoa, GPT3.5 is already better than that.
- engineer_22 3y agoOh wow, I thought we were just seeing the poorly written introduction. Nope... It's the whole paper! Good grief
- dullknuckles 3y ago“…there was no correlation between chronological age and time to death.” Umm…
- josh_cutler 3y agoWhen you think about "research" like this in the context of LLMs, I worry that the source (a journal) will start codifying some of this nonsense as known fact that the ChatGPTs of the world start regurgitatiing...
- tokai 3y agoWorking with research support and documentation, I can certainly belive it. Folks would be surprised what clever people with long resumes sometimes tries to pass as 'research'.
- swader999 3y agoThis is the whole western civilization now. Moving away from merrit to something else. And of course it was never a perfectly merit based system but it was to some better extent than it is now.
- Throw73747 3y ago[flagged]
- solarpunk 3y agoExtraordinary.
- boopeep 3y agoFlorida and Texas state universities, behold your future!
- moconnor 3y agoThis looks like a journal article not a paper. It's not a good one but framing it as a paper seems disingenuous.
- chockablock 3y agoThose terms are synonyms (at least in US academic parlance)
- gotoeleven 3y agoThere are people at places like this who want to do a good job. They want to do rigorous academic work and hold their students to high standards but the incentives are arrayed against them. Among other problems, there are tides of clownish administrators whose only goal is to gather more money so they can hire more administrators and give themselves higher salaries. Having academic standards of any kind doesn't help with this. Federal loan dollars are tied to enrolled warm bodies, not enrolled warm bodies that are also doing useful work or learning anything.
- SubiculumCode 3y agoThis is so bad that I cannot even comprehend it. No one in my department could or want to ever get away with something like this; absolutely appalling. Scary, I considered applying to a faculty opening there at UNR.
- RugnirViking 3y agothats kind of incredible - on the linked comments they are discussing other submissions to that jounal of supply chain management and they're all like that. A page with two paragraphs or so, a picture, and three citations. how bizzare!
- ultrasaurus 3y agoIt's paywalled, but Noahpinion had a good summary of the situation: https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/how-much-of-modern-academia-is-waste https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/how-much-of-modern-academia-is.... The key points are that breaking disciplines into tiny subfields essentially makes it easier to build citation rings (even if you don't intend to, the same reviewers see most papers and let through ones that cite themselves). With citation counts rather than quality working as karma in a competitive field (getting tenure) we shouldn't be surprised that some people supply a low quality but technically "peer-reviewed" journal.
- geor9e 3y agoAlso funny is how many Wikipedia accounts exist only to edit his personal article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Student350 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Student3... , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Ecjones2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Ecjones2 , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Bkp8677 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Bkp8677 , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Raidrfid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Raidrfid , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Beronlee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Beronlee , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/UNREngineering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/UNREngin...
- mcyc 3y agoThe Dean responded in the comments of this post. https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2024/02/06/its-bezzle-time-the-dean-of-engineering-at-the-university-of-nevada-gets-paid-372127-a-year-and-wrote-a-paper-thats-so-bad-you-cant-believe-it-i-mean-really-you-have-to-take-a-look-at-t/#comment-2315912 https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2024/02/06/its-bezzle...