4 ms·
> defense. it should (at the very minimum) be 50-50 every time What’s the probability of any given indicted person actually being guilty? It’s way over 50%.
by rayiner 3y ago
> defense. it should (at the very minimum) be 50-50 every time
What’s the probability of any given indicted person actually being guilty? It’s way over 50%.
- qingcharles 3y agoI can answer this with some authority. I just did 10 years in pretrial and looked through the cases of thousands of people in detail. I would say 95% of people who are indicted are guilty of something related to the indictment. Often not exactly what is in the indictment (overcharging is rife), but guilty of something. What we need to do is charge people more accurately. Overcharging is used to elicit guilty pleas on lesser charges.
- lumost 3y agoBeing guilty of "Something" in the indictment is also a far cry from being guilty of the indictment. For instance, the difference between possession and distribution.
- qingcharles 3y agoThis is one of the biggest ones. If you are caught with more than a certain amount (say 20 teeny tiny bags of crack) you are assumed to be distributing it even without any evidence of distribution. They say you would not have that much for personal use.
- smrq 3y agoI was on a jury last month for a case with this exact scenario. Dude had a lot of weed and the prosecution tried to use the quantity as the sole proof that he was distributing. Searched his phone, nothing, asked the neighbors about suspicious comings and goings, nothing, et cetera. Then they had some detective expert witness come in and say that in his opinion, the guy was absolutely a dealer based on that alone. The jury decided pretty much immediately that the prosecution hadn't proved shit. But a different jury... who knows?
- qingcharles 3y agoThis guy was a brave soul taking it to trial. Normally the jury believes expert cop witnesses. This is how they get the plea deals :( I know people who bulk buy large quantities of weed because they have to travel out of state to get it and they want to minimize the risks of being caught with it all in transit.
- int_19h 3y agoIn many jurisdictions this is explicitly written into law - a threshold past which assumption of distribution is automatic.
- idle_zealot 3y agoWhat is this assertion based on?
- Dylan16807 3y agoThere is very little to suggest that the prosecutors are so massively incompetent as to only have a 50% hit rate.
- jrflowers 3y agoExactly. There is nothing in the records that prosecutors keep and make available to the public to indicate that. It is trivial to verify this by looking through the meticulous and publicly searchable database of dropped charges and arrest voidings.
- jrflowers 3y agoI like this reasoning. Everyone should be born in jail and then work to get out, not the other way around.
- plussed_reader 3y agoYou should read up on Catholicism and the idea of original sin; I think it'll integrate well with your outlook.
- mminer237 3y agoMost people never get indicted for a crime. Maybe the system should seek out the truth of what guilt can actually be proved instead of just trying to lower the conviction rate to 50% arbitrarily.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- elil17 3y agoCurrently, the prosecution wins the majority of cases because they can get a plea bargain regardless of guilt. I agree with you that this is wrong. But, to me, the prosecution shouldn't take on cases where they don't have good evidence and they should drop cases if it becomes clear they are wrong. If prosecutors did this they'd still have a very high win rate.
- whatwhaaaaat 3y agoWhat makes you think this isn’t happening?
- jaredklewis 3y agoIf the indicted individuals are guilty, prosecutors should use the evidence they have of that guilt to convict. Why should we stack the deck in favor of prosecutors and police, by giving them extra privileges, like being able to intentionally lie to defendants?