6 ms·
I've wondered many times why a radar-directed machine gun isn't used to protect against drone attacks. The drones the terrorists used are rather slow moving, so
by WalterBright 3y ago
I've wondered many times why a radar-directed machine gun isn't used to protect against drone attacks. The drones the terrorists used are rather slow moving, so the gun doesn't have to be that sophisticated. And it should be relatively cheap.
- icegreentea2 3y agoThey are to some extent? One issue of radar-directed machine guns in the context of the Red Sea is that machine gun range is limited, so they can only provide point defense. This means that a warship can only protect itself, and any commercial ships that are -very- nearby. Yes, you could probably figure out a way to rig up a lot of these onto smaller ships to escort individual ships/convoys through, but hey you go to war with the navy you have. Unironically, the LCS's might be useful in this role. More generally, you see stuff like the army's new M-SHORAD having missiles (Stinger+Hellfire) and 30mm + 7.62mm guns.
- WalterBright 3y agoI was thinking of the recent drone attack on a military base, where three soldiers were killed.
- icegreentea2 3y agoOh. Yeah, I mean there's nothing preventing such a system - land based Phalanx is a thing. We also don't know what air defenses were even at the base (maybe they already had land based Phalanx...). Sounds like the base was caught by surprise.
- swagasaurus-rex 3y agoThere was a friendly drone returning to base, so their defensive systems were turned off.
- giantrobot 3y agoThere is such a system, it's called C-RAM and is basically a Phallanx mounted on a trailer. You can find videos of them working at bases in Iraq recently. There's also smaller systems in development like M-SHORAD and MADIS (Army and Marines respectively if I remember right). Whether stuff like that is deployed to a particular base is a question of them being available and the particular location being well supplied enough to use them. The M-SHORAD and MADIS systems are designed to mount on light vehicles so they can be deployed more readily and to smaller forward positions.
- wolverine876 3y agoIsn't it the same problem - you need complete sensor and shooter coverage of the entire perimeter. Bases are pretty large - much larger than ships. Also, as Hamas did, an attacker can try to overwhelm one point of defense, which means your sensors, targeting computers, and shooters need lots of extra availability (extra equipment and soldiers) everywhere. I don't think you'd want the perimeter of a base covered with auto-targeting/firing guns. And also, on what does all that metal (bullets) land?
- NavinF 3y ago> on what does all that metal (bullets) land? The Phalanx CIWS uses explosive incendiary tracer rounds on land. They self destruct after missing the target to avoid collateral damage
- wolverine876 3y agoThat's an interesting technology. Could it be used by everyone, in civilian guns? It might prevent a lot of bystander casualties from stray bullets, richochets, etc. OTOH, perhaps for bullets that hit, explosions occur on the target? That would not be good. (Tracers would be useful for bystanders and law enforcement. Self-detonating or not, maybe all ammunition should be tracers?)
- Arrath 3y agoCareless recreational shooters[] regularly start fires when using tracer ammunition. There would definitely be downsides to mandating that all ammunition be tracer rounds. []Also routine training exercises on military ranges.
- jasonwatkinspdx 3y agoIn that specific attack there was a problem where it coincidentally happened at the same time a US drone was landing, so there was some confusion over the threat.
- numpad0 3y agoI suspect it has to do with western military industry shifting towards premium low volume products since the end of the last war, perhaps because making weapons of war had been weird to some people lately. They don't make hand portable or vehicle mountable 7.62mm or .50cal or 14.5mm mini-CIWS, only the multi-trailer ship-sized versions that are total overkill for drones.
- envalid 3y agoIf a target is moving slow enough it can be difficult to track. Similar to how you can defend against radar missiles by 'notching' aka flying perpendicular so the relative velocity of the target is near zero. Radar typically relies on the dopplar shift caused by the target moving to eliminate clutter.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe solution then would be to have two radars a distance apart, so they can triangulate.
- jcrawfordor 3y agoLocating the target isn't the problem, you don't need a Doppler shift to calculate range by time of flight. The problem is detecting the target at all. Radar in these sorts of defense environments will pick up an enormous number of returns off of the carrying vessel and sea surf, which is actually a rather difficult problem for radar because it reflects in myriad directions, it moves, etc. By far the easiest way to select an "interesting" radar return is to use Doppler shift to find something that is moving very quickly. That can't be just a wave, it has to be a missile. The problem is that rotary wing drones are very slow (compared to missiles) and so they don't present an obviously different shift from the background. A lot of R&D is going on right now into better ways to select slow-moving, low-cross-section objects like drones from the background. This sort of thing is much more difficult for missile defense than the more conventional radar application of airspace surveillance, because for several reasons (including the fact that this makes radar detection hard) missiles tend to come at you from close to or below the horizon. This means you're getting a huge amount of clutter (radar returns from the environment) around them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- icegreentea2 3y agoNot to minimize the challenges, but I think it's worth pointing out that a lot of the drones of topical interest are -not- quadcopters. The Houthis (for example) have been using UAVs (Samad and Qasef) are prop driven fixed wing drones with total mass in the 50kg+ class (and warheads in the ~20kg class). They have max speeds of 200+ kph, wingspans in the 2-5m range. The Samad has ranges in the 1000km+ range. Obviously, they could slow down in terminal stages of attack, and I have no idea what their stall speed would be like. These are more akin to the Shahed class drones that Russia has been deploying in Ukraine (though still much smaller), than the FPV drones we see attacking tanks/trenches.
- tyingq 3y agoMaybe hard to sort out small drones from large birds?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- antoniojtorres 3y agoThat space is currently littered with all kinds of new projects given the urgency. One that has stuck with me is the German Rheinmetall Skynex which works the way you are describing. It’s like a really high tech flak cannon. There are neat videos of it on youtube.
- ranger207 3y agoRadar is essentially a searchlight shining up into the night sky. If you have a radar-directed machine gun pointing into the sky, it's relatively easy to triangulate where the emitter is and direct artillery to take it out.
- Aeolun 3y agoGot it. Need one that can take out artillery rounds as well then.
- mrguyorama 3y agoIf that radar is within range of enemy artillery it's already been destroyed.
- ianburrell 3y agoThe US has Mk38 canon on lots of ships. The Mod3 added radar. Its primary focus is against small boats and could probably work against USV that Ukraine has been using against Russia. I hope the Navy is working in modifying to work against small and medium drones. The other thing that might help against drones are the automated weapons stations hat are on lots of vehicles. I think I read about project to add radar and automated targeting of drones.
- avar 3y agoI'd think the primary defense against drones on a naval vessel would be that the ship's made of metal, and doesn't have squishy humans wandering around (unless it's a carrier). IOW a very small drone also means a very small payload.
- windexh8er 3y agoThe size of the payload is still a significant problem if your enemy is close with many drones. This video [0] shows a Russian missile cruiser being sunk by Ukrainian drones recently in the Black Sea. The problem these boats have with drones is that they are slow all around compared to a rather nimble drone which can react to its operations. As can be seen in the video multiple drones are used to sink the large ship. Edit: A better article around the situation and effectiveness of the drones is at [1]. [0] Video Russian missile cruiser "Ivanovets" destroyed by sea drones at January 31/February 1 in Black Sea - https://v.redd.it/hevs3v05hyfc1 https://v.redd.it/hevs3v05hyfc1 [1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/feb/01/ukraine-sea-drone-hits-russian-warship-near-occupied-crimea https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/feb/01/ukraine-sea-dr...
- lazide 3y agoI think they were referring to aerial drones, which tend to have limited capacities for cheap ones. Those were seaborne (naval) drones carrying about 1000 kg of explosives each if I remember correctly.
- foofie 3y ago> I've wondered many times why a radar-directed machine gun isn't used to protect against drone attacks. You mean something like Germany's Gepard? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flakpanzer_Gepard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flakpanzer_Gepard
- jasonwatkinspdx 3y agoThey are. In Ukraine German Gephard[1] systems have taken out a variety of drones. The older soviet systems can do some of this as well. There's also a ton of newer smaller projects in development, aimed at something you can put on a truck to counter low cost consumer drones. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flakpanzer_Gepard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flakpanzer_Gepard
- BlueTemplar 3y agoThey have been widely deployed for decades. But also, for decades (since WW2 ?) they seem to have been effectively useless (so far ??) : in all cases that I've been able to find (please correct me if I'm wrong), either the ship (and/or nearby friendlies) were on alert and the guided bomb never even made it into machine gun range, or the ship was caught unaware and that defense system was never even turned on. (Not counting cases where radar would have been useless because the guided bomb moved under water.)