9 ms·
How Lego Became the Apple of Toys (2015)
- Eliav2010 3y ago[flagged]
- cptaj 3y agohttp://www.brick4.com/ http://www.brick4.com/
- berkes 3y agoNot sure if this is yours, but if so: Firefox (android) and Chrome (android) refuse to load the site. Probably due to missing SSL.
- unleaded 3y agoYou have to use HTTP for some reason. It's a database of Chinese lego clones, I've seen it before. Chinese lego is awesome, it's often cheaper than real Lego and there's lots of original sets including things that lego won't make (like tanks and stuff, think I saw a strip club set once). But there are clones of real lego sets too, whether that bothers you is up to you. Check out r/lepin for more
- cuddlyogre 3y agoYou definitely pay for quality too. Chinese building blocks vary wildly in terms of clutch power and overall precision. But if all you're looking for is something to display and not ever touch again, it's probably the best way to go.
- amelius 3y agoApple going against general purpose computing makes it more like Playmobil, where construction options are limited compared to LEGO. The versatility of Linux and the original x86 platform with its openness is more like LEGO in spirit.
- dartos 3y agoI think they’re talking more about market positioning then the technical spirit of the product
- flax 3y agoUntil I have to jailbreak my bricks to make my own designs, Lego is nothing like Apple.
- myspy 3y agoInteresting to read this now. Lego was in a very good position during that time. But in the last years they declined in quality (bad prints, a lot of stickers on AFOL sets), increased the prices and the lack in building fun of the sets. Lots of catering to grown-ups and weird choices in the kids section like the city road elements. The mixed reality sets were not well received. Why give a kid something to do with Lego bricks and then pull them in front of a smartphone again?
- kleiba 3y agoLego is still quite amazing but not quite as cool as it used to be. I suppose the various boxes were always meant to be such that you could build that one really cool building/vehicle/etc. with it. Sometimes with a predesigned variation, too. But today it seems that the purpose of most boxes is to do only that - and then, what, put the object into a display case? Or, more likely, play with it for a while and then forget about it. What I mean is that even though today's lego boxes let you build way more realistic and designy products, there are so many special pieces that it does not spark your own creative fantasy (in my opinion) but limits it. To me, as a child, the appeal was always that there was quite a limited set of brick types - and the creativity lay in combining them in new ways. In comparison, the number and types of different pieces seems to have doubled or tripled today. By implication that means that you end with a few instances of many different types of pieces while before, you'd have many instances of a few types of pieces. I'd argue that the latter lends itself much better to creating new things born out of your own creativity.
- pdpi 3y ago> there are so many special pieces that it does not spark your own creative fantasy (in my opinion) but limits it. Those pieces aren't anywhere near as limiting as you think. The Saturn V model uses the 64951 tub/barrel pieces as thruster nozzles. The LEM uses the 64644 telescope/spyglass piece for the legs. That's the immediately visible bits in the model I have handy, I remember seeing a bunch more of those on my friend's Millennium Falcon, and just in general.
- unfunco 3y agoThe 31129 Majestic Tiger uses a 1x1 pink flower plate as a butthole.
- doctoboggan 3y agoIn thought you were joking but I looked it up and this is 100% true. I applaud their commitment to anatomical correctness.
- deleted 3y ago
- loughnane 3y agoI like lego, but the magic that made them what they are is waning. The capitalized big on partnerships with entertainment brands, but that's feeling played out. When parents pick up gifts for birthday parties they'll get lego star wars or lego ninjago gifts because the birthday boy is into star wars or ninjago, lego is secondary. Lego is still great, but their lack of emphasis on the creativity that has been the promise of lego for decades---think this ad[0]---has been making them less great each year. [0] https://i.pinimg.com/originals/71/ea/f1/71eaf11fd3ade672821be80b7e5fe72e.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/71/ea/f1/71eaf11fd3ade672821b...
- Apocryphon 3y agoWhat happened with Legos? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yVCOAFKjaoY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yVCOAFKjaoY
- racl101 3y agolol. OK, that's hilarious. Is that Community TV show any good?
- RandallBrown 3y agoIt's one of my favorite shows ever.
- travisjungroth 3y ago> but that's feeling played out It gets played out for adults. There’s a new crop of kids every year, and all the time their interests are changing.
- hgomersall 3y agoI'm pretty sure Ninjago was invented precisely to sell more Lego.
- roomey 3y agoOh my god, do people commenting here not realise it is they who are getting older, less cool, less creative? Oh back in my day we had 10 Lego bricks and we were _greatful_ because of it!
- bombcar 3y agoThis is mainly it - though I do remember as a kid having "The Collection" was always important - your little pile of "special bricks" like headlight bricks, anything printed, etc, that were "rare" and you'd want.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- default-kramer 3y agoHaving fewer bricks could be considered a feature. There are definitely situations in which more constraints can increase creativity and happiness. For a long time, I preferred Dragon Quest Builders 1 (a Minecraft-style game) over its sequel for this reason. It's not unreasonable for people to be overwhelmed or put off by the tremendous variety of Lego available today.
- Dig1t 3y agoThere are a few “Apple of X industry” companies out there, I think it’s pretty interesting that you can generalize the things that make them what they are. Disney is the Apple of movies. Nintendo is the Apple of video games. They are usually the types of companies that tightly control almost all of their product, are at a premium price point, and have an “elevated” sort of brand recognition. For example Nintendo is intent on tightly controlling their product experience. They use boring tech in creative ways and charge a premium for their content. Disney is the same, they are the only theme parks with imagineers that custom make all the rides and experiences in their parks, they make their own software for the most part, and tightly control how their characters are used, etc etc The biggest takeaway is that the companies have an intense focus on the quality of their product and that makes them the longest lasting and most elevated brands. LEGO belongs in this group because they have a similar focus on quality I think. At least WRT their toys. I don’t care much for their theme parks..
- hospitalJail 3y agoIts interesting, you find quality with these brands. I'm certain these brands advertise they have quality, but I think they fall far short of the competition constantly. Nintendo? Disney? Apple? When I think of their actual quality compared to the best in the business you are talking B- quality. Sure you never get a C or a D like when I get a random Android phone for $100, but you are never going to get a Baulders Gate 3 from Nintendo. Although now that you mention it, all of these brands have total fanatics that border on cult worship. I wonder if this is natural, or some unethical psychology their marketing departments use.
- smugglerFlynn 3y ago> compared to the best in the business Huh? They are among the best. Disney is among Big 5 major movie studios. Lego is top 4 toy companies, largest by revenue among them. Apple is top-3 company in the world by market cap. Quality is very subjective, but the fact that you personally prefer Baulders Gate to Mario just shows that Nintendo plays it in a different niche, not that latter is somehow objectively worse / has less quality than the former. In my opinion, what sums up all these companies are the things they don’t do: - they don’t focus on “power users” or similar niche segments, unless these segments gain enough popularity - they don’t cater to cheaper segments of mass market - they don’t build their business models around copying competitors - they don’t delegate or outsource critical pieces of their value chain This is what leads to unique and pricey products that sometimes polarize general public. (Although personally I’d narrow Disney down to only Pixar in OPs list, due to Disney’s poor fit with #3 and #4).
- sbecker 3y agoJust to provide some counterpoint to the echo chamber here - as a Dad of a six year old who played with legos as a kid and again now, I can affirm - Legos and the sets they put out now are way cooler now than when I was a kid! You might worry that the less general purpose, specialized pieces might stunt creativity, but guess what!? The 6 year old has no problem taking them completely apart and building something off script. It's the olds who worry about keeping them all together and not losing the pieces so they can still make the thing on the front of the box. The kids don't care and will happily take it all apart and build things we never would have thought of.
- jansan 3y agoHaving two teenage boys I cannot confirm this. They play with other stuff, but Lego is for building once and putting it on a shelf, where it will collect thick layers of dust. My sons never really played with Lego, which I found a bit disappointing.
- racl101 3y agoI remember when I had Legos I had to build whatever my mind came up with using the pieces available. We'd play with it. Then a new idea would pop in our brains about how to improve the design and we'd tear down and build back up only bigger and better. And if we got more legos or new pieces, suddenly so many new possibilities for designs. What a difference a few new pieces made. Now they feel like model Kits. My nephew asks for Star Wars Legos, or some other franchise based legos, builds whatever the structure is according to the manual, but then doesn't take it apart and it just sits on his book shelf. Never to be touched or rebuilt, even just for the heck of it. And why should he rebuild? It's like coding the same program out of a text book in exactly the same way. Been there done that.
- bombcar 3y agoI think this is one of the disadvantages of things like Star Wars Lego - you have something extremely well known to compare it to, and there's not really a point in rebuilding it, because that's the "best it can be". Whereas my early sets, focused mainly around City, were nice, but I could build something else "City-like" out of them and not feel it was vastly inferior. But, I think a bigger part is just kids are different. Some like building and then leave it, others build it and it goes into the pile of Lego quite quickly.
- racl101 3y agoYeah, I'm not sure one way is better than another. What I do think is that Lego has definitely been evolving the way people play with them.
- bombcar 3y agoAnd keeping piece count steady even as prices increase - "ten cents a piece" has been a good rule of thumb for twenty years and only really been broken in the last few, but part of that is the average size/weight of pieces has been dropping. I'm sure someone somewhere has done the math.
- m3kw9 3y agoIf you’ve played and feel knocked off legos, “f this sht” will be a phrased used over and over as you try to read and assemble it. Even the instruction are world class stupid
- dingaling 3y agoI've built a couple of recent Technics kits and noticed a decline in the clarity of Lego's instructions. Instead of clearly showing the 'path' of each part in a step, that is how and where to connect it to an assembly, they now tend to show the assembly with the new parts attached. This leads to a game of 'spot the difference' with the previous step.
- kawogi 3y agoI'm still mad that they discontinued Mindstorms. My school isn't able to replace their components if they break and I cannot get additional motors for my projects any more. Does anyone know how good their "LEGO® Education SPIKE™" stuff is? Is it as open as the NXT-bricks? Are these somewhat compatible? Linux IDE available? I wish someone would offer a replacement for those who have a 3D-printer, rp2040 and some soldering experience. I'd help the school to re-stock their supply. Edit: 35 € for a 2 A USB power supply is definitely Apple-ish. And those peripheral connectors look like they're … unique. Mindstorms just had standard RJ-something plugs.
- wwilim 3y agoThe original Mindstorms connectors were actual bricks, about the size of two stacked 2x2 plates
- kawogi 3y agoAh, yes. Should have been more specific: NXT and EV3
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- joshmarinacci 3y agoSpike is pretty good and seems just as open as NXT. You can even open a shell directly on the MCU brick in Python. Spike does use new connectors, but it's the same one they started using for all of the Powered Up sets. Plus there's lots of people who've figured out how to add arduinos, Pi's, etc.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, they royally messed that up. But as to your query: there are nice alternatives, there is this board+library: https://gitlab.com/jmattheij/rekabit https://gitlab.com/jmattheij/rekabit With a bit of fiddling and some 3D printed parts you're off to the races, controls two motors and four servos and has blinkenlights. You can use the board with the Micro:BIT but you can also use it with some fiddling with an arduino (renesas will probably work best) or a Raspberry Pi 2040. It also has a whole slew of 'Grove' connectors if you want to wire up more sensors and actuators and it exports the bus. I've added links to the 3D printed parts and some links to the originals on thingiverse, it took some modifications to get it all to fit nicely but it really works well. And those boards are pretty cheap.
- bgeeek 3y agoLego will always be cool to me. Without wanting to sound like a cliché, the only limit was your imagination when I was a child, before home computing. Forever grateful for those years.
- joshmarinacci 3y agoWhile I have nostalgia and can talk about how I used to make amazing designs with fewer specialized bricks, the truth is modern Legos can do more and cost less (adjusted for inflation). My 12year old has built things that I couldn't do until I was a junior in college. We're just grumpy because we are old. I don't love how Lego makes all of these specialty sets for grownups, but.. I've bought some and enjoy it. Playing with Lego as an adult was weird in the 80s. Now there's whole clubs for it. I think it's a positive development. And finally, they are not the Apple. Nothing in Lego is locked down. I can 3d print my own bricks. Small companies make bluetooth motor addons. You can even get a Lego HAT for your Raspberry Pi. It's vastly more open than just about any other system.
- Libcat99 3y agoThey cost less even before inflation. Here's a write up I did a few months back. https://news.ycombinator.com/context?id=37657077 https://news.ycombinator.com/context?id=37657077 As far as I can tell, Lego just keeps getting more affordable.
- Libcat99 3y agoI went back and checked the prices. None have changed since my prior update except a Lego friends set which is now on clearance, so they should be evaluating even better against inflation.
- ludgerpaehler 3y agoProbably more like Apple before Steve Jobs returned and decluttered their offering. A few shiny gems of sets amongst a vast sea of overpriced, sometimes poorly designed sets often with color-mismatches, and way too many stickers.
- kazinator 3y agoLego is not the Apple of toys. People who have Lego in their homes also have tons of other toys. People who have Apple computers or mobile devices in their homes do not have tons of other devices. There are Apple households in the way that there aren't Lego households. Oh yeah, and there are cheap, Lego-compatible blocks out there. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lego_clone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lego_clone There used to be Apple clone computers in the 1980s; Apple wiped them out in a way that Lego has not been able to wipe out Lego compatibles.
- yreg 3y agoApple didn't wipe anything out. Hackintoshes exist. It is probably only a matter of time until macOS eventually drops Intel support, but we are far from there.
- kazinator 3y agoThey don't exist in the sense that you can walk into a brick-and-mortar computer store and buy one, or see it advertised in mainstream media, like was the case with Apple clones once upon a time.
- zubairq 3y agoI do think that Lego innovates, so they deserve their top spot!
- WalterBright 3y agoI wanted an Erector set. My mom thought the tiny bolts would be impossible for me, but I pressed for one and got one. Had a great time with it. What I liked about it was the creations were metal and looked like machines. The Lego stuff was all bright primary colored bricks. They often wouldn't stay together like a bolted Erector set creation. Lego was never for me.
- cuddlyogre 3y agoTechnic may have been more to your liking.
- elf25 3y ago[dead]