13 ms·
If your core business product is content contributed by users... I'm turning to the opinion that you need a C-level ombudsman- / dean of contributors-type role.
by ethbr1 3y ago
If your core business product is content contributed by users... I'm turning to the opinion that you need a C-level ombudsman- / dean of contributors-type role.
Whose sole job it is to (1) figure out what contributors are thinking and want & (2) advocate for them inside the company.
Every contributor-driven platform has eventually jumped the shark, and all in exactly the same way.
Management begins to take contributions for granted. Stops caring about attracting contributors. Then focuses on revenue. Then makes changes to the platform that kill contributions, in pursuit of revenue.
And they miss so many obvious ways to placate and delight their contributors. "It'd be nice to have a mod tool that does X" shouldn't be a 3-year back burner ask.
Maybe make it harder for your company to footgun your golden goose?
- jfengel 3y agoQuora had one, William Gunn. He was laid off, along with the entire human moderation staff and practically all of the user-facing developers. Quora had been going downhill for quite some time before that, as they realized they had no idea how to monetize the content and were grasping at straws. But that was the point where they appear to have pivoted entirely towards AI and continued the human generated content side on minimum life support.
- RajT88 3y ago> they realized they had no idea how to monetize the content This sort of thing should be a nonprofit. When it was good, it was literally making the world a better place. Possibly the Library of Congress would be a good steward for such a platform. Something to make it resistant to enshittification.
- fullshark 3y agoHow about Wikimedia?
- ivanmontillam 3y agoWikimedia is a non-profit that operates like a for-profit when the yearly round of donations comes around. They literally hoard money[0]. I will get downvoted for this, but it's my perception. -- [0]: https://www.makeuseof.com/tag/wikipedia-millions-bank-beg/ https://www.makeuseof.com/tag/wikipedia-millions-bank-beg/
- _Algernon_ 3y ago>I will get downvoted for this, but it's my perception. I will always downvote a comment when someone writes something like this. It is irrelevant to the conversation and screams insecurity.
- njharman 3y ago100%
- SantalBlush 3y agoIt's also tinged with a "People can't handle the based truth I'm laying down" attitude, which is annoying to read.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gn4d 3y agoBased. It is r*ddit-tier passive aggression. This place is not much better, but we should still resist this type of crap when we can.
- coldtea 3y agoDownvoted your comment immediately, as unnecessary and hostile. Parent just made a comment that knew would be unpopular and expressed that.
- egberts1 3y ago
- allenrb 3y agoAgreed re: being a non-profit. My great hope was that Elon might do that with Twitter. Needless to say, I was… not right about that.
- ethbr1 3y agoArguably, prelon Twitter was not-for-profit.
- marcusb 3y agoPost Elon, they are not-turning-a-profit.
- prepend 3y agoAre their losses greater or less than pre purchase. I know revenue is down, but I wonder how the cost cuts affected margin.
- simonw 3y agoThey made a profit in 2018 and 2019 ($1.2bn and $1.45bn according to SEC filings) but not in any other year.
- Aeolun 3y agoPresumably they could have done Elon’s massive firing spree at any point in time and become profitable overnight?
- StackRanker3000 3y agoDon’t forget the massive amount of new debt that needs servicing.
- miohtama 3y agoThey will, but it would likely need restructuring the debts and the cap table, and would not be Elon's Twitter anymore.
- boringuser2 3y agoYou're going to entrust making the world a better place to... the US government?
- stevage 3y agoSure. Much better than to VC backed startups anyway.
- boringuser2 3y agoWe're going to have to agree to disagree. The US has done terrible things in the too-recent future in the explicit name of making the world a better place. At least, that rationale triggers my gag reflex.
- Aeolun 3y agoIsn’t a lot of what the US government does decided by capital anyway?
- boringuser2 3y agoKind of. There is a lot of money in lobbying for certain things. Companies generally don't want political outcomes per se via lobbying outside of their own niche interests. Much more impactful are dedicated lobby groups. For exmaple, there's a particular country that I'm not allowed to mention here under duress of being banned that has a lot of moneyed lobbying.
- Solvency 3y agoLike when the sugar industry lobbied and the US government told everyone fat is bad for 50 years?
- ruszki 3y agoDid the government say that sugar is good?
- edgyquant 3y agoHow exactly was quora ever making the world a better place?
- choppaface 3y agoMarc Bodnick was the original “community manager” and frequent contributor. He’s now working on his own social net, the first-ish of which (Telepath) already flopped.
- kiba 3y agoPerhaps VC backed businesses aren't really ideal for these type of sites.
- manquer 3y agoYouTube does very well ? .
- Kye 3y agoSo well it had to sell to Google because it didn't have a funding model.
- manquer 3y agoThey got a billion dollars for a year old company i don’t think that can be characterized as selling because they didn’t have a funding model. Fine, Facebook , TikTok , Reddit and myriad others have found how to moderate and monetize user generated content if you need better examples
- mrd3v0 3y agoPerhaps VC-backed businesses aren't really ideal for any kind of sites.
- asveikau 3y ago> Every contributor-driven platform has eventually jumped the shark, and all in exactly the same way. Do you think Wikipedia has jumped the shark? Obviously not perfect, but it's certainly a lot better than Quora in terms of accuracy. It's been around for a very long time and it doesn't seem to me like quality has decreased. Edit: to be clear and re-iterate, I never said Wikipedia was perfect, just that it has a certain baseline, generally above where Quora is, and hasn't seemed to decline over the years.
- b112 3y agoIt's only accurate if the view espoused in the page, matches what the gatekeeping moderator believes.
- throw310822 3y agoA lot of Wikipedia entries have become extremely partisan, and kept that way by moderators who are deeply invested in certain narratives. I find it very disappointing that no countermeasures have been taken- afaik Wikipedia still works exactly like 20 years ago, a barebone wiki governed by a lot of obscure, complex and unstructured politics. Granted, it might be the best possible way for an open-source encyclopedia to work. It is after all an incredible success. It's just pretty bad in some parts.
- apexalpha 3y agoCould you point to some examples of partisan entries?
- throw310822 3y agoAs one example, I wrote this comment a few weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38974614 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38974614 But to expand a bit, for example I'm annoyed at many of the entries calling their subject "conspiracy theory/ theorist". Not that conspiracy theories and their believers don't exist, but at this point it has become a highly pejorative and judgemental term to frame ideas and narratives that need to be stigmatized rather than explained. Passing judgements should not, in my view, be the primary focus of an encyclopedia entry.
- samstave 3y agoIts almost as if user-created-content sites are un-MBA-able... in the way that MBAs are cloned to measure only certain metrics in a soulless gaze toward a self-exit from the growth hocky stick launching pad they are attempting to build on bad faith and anti-patterns... Reddit is a cluster that manages to ONLY keep going because of how agressive mods can be about their positions, but as we have seen time in, time out, MODs positions get molested by ADMINs and ADMINs posing as MODs. MODs on the take. The point being that when Reddit IPOs - there are undoubtedly mods who have/are/will-be compensated/profit when IPO hits.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoWhat would be a platform that is NOT contributor-driven ??
- ethbr1 3y agoFacebook: social over random content. Streaming services: commissioned content. Arguably non-monetized YouTube: where its used simply for its utility of serving video.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoYes, but all of this "content"* comes from contributors, who else ?? Streaming services (you mean 5he likes of Netflix ?) are arguably not platforms, because they are much closer to distributors or even publishers (rather than just editors, sometimes), with all the extra legal issues and contract-signing that come with that. *"content" is really corporate-speak, I would hate my works to be called that : https://craphound.com/content/Cory_Doctorow_-_Content.html#1 https://craphound.com/content/Cory_Doctorow_-_Content.html#1
- kevinmchugh 3y agoNetflix. The New York Times.
- 1905 3y ago> Every contributor-driven platform has eventually jumped the shark, and all in exactly the same way. The one exception would be Craigslist
- throw__away7391 3y agoI have no experience running a site centered on user generated content, but it seems to me that the biggest problem/threat to any of them is the people who start showing up once it gains traction and becomes more popular. Early users are a different band of the population, on every successful platform from StackOverflow to Uber they create a particular culture which is impossible to maintain as the general public arrives in large numbers.
- meowtimemania 3y agoIn what way were early users of Uber different from the current users? Are you saying the drivers used to be better?
- throw__away7391 3y agoTo me personally, no, not better, but at one time the phrase “ride share” had a lot more meaning than it does today. People would creatively decorate their cars for example.
- anigbrowl 3y agoA car ride isn't 'content'.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoIt can be. Have you been in cars that have small snacks, karaoke, or some other sort of entertainment setup?
- tomjakubowski 3y agoNot sure about what OP was saying but, for a brief time when Uber was still new, before UberX launched in mid-summer 2012, their only service was black cars. Drivers had limousine licenses, and were merely filling time in between other gigs they had booked traditionally.
- jonathanyc 3y agoA StackOverflow question I asked 13 years ago (and which someone else answered 13 years ago!) was deleted just last month for being off-topic. All the mods’ accounts were years younger than both the question and answer. Even weirder, the mod who initiated the deletion first tried to answer the question. He only voted to delete it after I commented that the question already had had an accepted answer for 13 years.
- binkHN 3y agoSounds a lot like Reddit.
- scoofy 3y ago>Maybe make it harder for your company to footgun your golden goose? As someone who has started a "content contributed by users" website recently (golfcourse.wiki), I've thought long and hard about why the enshitification creep happens. I really think it happens because most of the people who start these businesses either need to take venture capital to survive, or are looking for a way to sell the business to retire rich af. I thought long and hard about a monetization strategy, and I've got a few in my mind that don't suck. However, to achieve those goals, the project has to stay a side project and it has to run on a shoe string budget. Call me an optimist, but in the long run, I think we will replace our enshitified websites with more open ones, the slow but steady growth fediverse shows this is happening, it's just that it won't happen fast enough for most of us to be satisfied consumers. I just think we are looking at this through the lens of consumers, not generous creators. I occasionally help edit Wikipedia, and it looks like about 10,000-to-1, at best, people who contribute to my dumb little site. If we're all willing to waste a bit of time we can build some pretty cool sites, but there always needs to be a way for users to capture that good if the company turns evil instead of the company trying to capture the users for profit. I see it as, well, a sort of mexican-standoff relationship that Wikipedia has built for itself (for lack of a better term). Basically, we won't enshitify the website because you'll just copy-paste it, but you won't copy-paste it because you know it's a waste of time right now. If you don't need to squeeze revenues, that's a very good relationship for long-term success.
- physicles 3y agoEveryone is talking about enshittification these days, but hardly anyone is doing anything about it (including myself). Thanks for doing something about it. Do you have a blog post with your thoughts on monetization?
- scoofy 3y agoI have a blog, but not a blog post about that: https://golfcoursewiki.substack.com/ https://golfcoursewiki.substack.com/ That's a good idea though. The main idea, since it is a golf wiki, is to provide tournament services to clubs. My understanding is that most of the cost of operating tournament services is due to licensing agreements with the the governing bodies, but if clubs are willing to provide their data themselves, that's not necessary, and I can charge orders of magnitude less than the competition.
- raydev 3y ago> Every contributor-driven platform has eventually jumped the shark, and all in exactly the same way. Reddit seems to be the exception to the rule. I and millions of others still spend a ton of time there. People have loudly griped about ads and API pricing, meanwhile I'm still finding new interesting subreddits. They seem to have monetized without destroying the UX. I hope the forthcoming IPO doesn't ruin this comment!
- edgyquant 3y agolol, lmao even. Reddit is literally the worst website on the internet and has slid so far downhill as to be nothing but a place to see the latest astroturfed memes. Any interesting discussion is buried underneath regurgitation and repetitive comments and all subreddits converge to be differing shades of r/politics. The users are actually the worst, they are the most argumentative people I’ve seen on any platform and I’ve been on Internet forums since the late 90s.