6 ms·
Japan will no longer require floppy disks for submitting some official documents
- ape4 3y agoHow could that possibly work!? (joke attempt, I read the article)
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoAre they upgrading to Iomega ZIP drives? /s
- mattl 3y agoSeems too common as a format. Better stick to Iomega Clik/PocketZip instead if you want something obscure.
- HPsquared 3y agoNow, now... they're not that antiquated! CD-R at least... or DVD-RAM
- RalfWausE 3y agoMore fitting would be Sonys Memory Stick...
- themerone 3y agoSony has the worst case of not-invented-here syndrome. If they released a great mp3 player before Apple we could be living in a very different world. Instead they forced you to convert your MP3s to ATRAC.
- pezezin 3y agoNo, in Japan the popular system were the magneto-optical disks. Also MiniDisc, my car still has a MiniDisc player
- kalleboo 3y agoThe direct-debit form for my daughters school fees had the option for the school submitting the information via MO (Magneto-Optical) (along with paper, floppy, dvd and data transfer) https://bitbang.social/@kalleboo/111821793740460988 https://bitbang.social/@kalleboo/111821793740460988 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magneto-optical_drive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magneto-optical_drive
- Taganov 3y agoJapan is insane on the paperwork front. The amount of stuff my wife has to deal with (because my Japanese is frankly terrible) for basic processes is mind numbing. Things like having to write out your address and contact info on five different forms for one appointment, visiting multiple offices to submit paperwork in for the same process, etc.. Moving apartments (heaven forbid it is to a different city government) involves weeks of straight up administrative work from one person in the household.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Japan is insane on the paperwork front. Worse than Germany?
- lukan 3y agoWhat legal battles do you have to fight, to move apartements? I remember, I had to file one paper from the landlord and my ID and that was it. Took 5 minutes.
- JD557 3y agoI think you just need the Wohnungsgeberbestätigung from the landlord and fill the registration paperwork at the Bürgeramt (which, depending on your city, might be a bit hard to get an appointment), you might also need to take care of the TV bill stuff. While not awful, comparing to Portugal, where I just need to register in a website an then wait to get a confirmation code by mail, it feels like going back to the stone age.
- ghaff 3y agoAnd then there's the US where is no legal requirement to have a permanent address even if, as a practical matter, you sort of need at least a quasi one.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoWhy do you need to "register" your address? Why do you need any of this? I've found that's the question to ask with paperwork. For instance, France is also extremely bad regarding paperwork and administrative red tape and people are so used to it that many can't imagine that many of it is not actually needed for society to function. I noticed when I moved to the UK: Suddenly all that was absolutely necessary to protect civilisation and the Republic (I only exaggerate a little bit) did not even exist and everything still ran smoothly. Telling example: During the Covid lockdowns, the French administration decided that people had to fill and sign an official form to keep on them every time they left home. Basically "I swear that I am only doing my daily excercise. Date, signature" to be shown to any police officer who might ask, or "zut alors" you're nicked.
- ramshanker 3y agoIf it isn’t broken, don’t fix it. Until the definition of broken changes.
- psychoslave 3y agoWell, something can be functional only as long as the hypothesis made on the operating environment are relevant. After what it becomes broken by obsolescence. If a device relies only on fundamental physical hypothesis, surely it can certainly go pretty far. Look how pyramids are still great landing facility to this days. Too bad that the hi-erratic art of building the matching spaceships was lost since then — but that’s how it goes when you run for the high sophistication in your design.
- zitsarethecure 3y agoI wonder if you can still fax them over?
- mavhc 3y agoDuring the pandemic people in Japan had to travel to get documents stamped
- raverbashing 3y agoSounds like there should be a use case for high density qr codes instead
- ho_schi 3y agoHaha! I’ve ordered yesterday an unused old external floppy-drive (IBM) and a set of floppies (Sony). More for fun than on purpose. By the way you need them everywhere where stuff remains a long time usable e.g. the older B747-400 or trains, plants and heavy machines and so on. I hoped that SD-Cards replace them because the slip into a slot (other than USB-Thumbsdrives), have defined speed-classes and you can write on their outside what is stored on them. Cars, cameras, bike-computers and so on use them everywhere but computer manufacturers failed to built them in or connect them properly via USB (I refer especially to Lenovo which connected the card-slots via PCI which prevented booting from them…). Honestly. I don’t like optical disks. They allowed for higher capacity but they were like multiple steps backward and a huge waste of material. Mostly one time writeable, a lot of material required, big form factor and writing them was also complex. Optical disks are like technology which should have skipped over? I even myself bought once a mini-disc player…wasted money.
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> . I don’t like optical disks. They allowed for higher capacity but they were like multiple steps backward and a huge waste of material. Oh no, optical disk is superior - I can backup family photos to M-disk and shove it in a bank vault, and in 100 years it will still work. Just like photos, I have family photos that are 60 years old. Digital photos of 10 years old are lost How are you gonna store a video for 50 years? flash memory discharges, hard disks rust, upload to google drive and hope they don’t kill the service?
- ho_schi 3y agoI don’t care here for long term storage but let it us pick up? As far as I know flash memory should last at least ten years. After that period of time I would either copy the data, erase and write again or look for other tech. So this requires manual intervention. Which other? Magnetic tapes are often used for this purpose. Microfilms shall be much better. Paper is really resilient. I would avoid any cloud, Google has a bad track record. The online access and requirements make it unreliable. In best case the don’t try to search the data or delete it by accident. As they did already. As far as I know CDs last only ten years. DVDs maybe 30 years. I’ve it is a -ROM it last likely 100 years. But therefore you need special equipment. The M-Discs you mention are new for me but this sounds good. Are regular drives guaranteed to read it? The most problematic thing isn’t just keeping the data. We also need to be able to read it again. Maybe we need to use good old stones ^^
- pilaf 3y agoI recently went looking for floppy disks in Akihabara, Tokyo. I needed them for a photography project and I didn't want to buy an entire box off Amazon (yeah, they are still available) since I only needed 2 at most. Despite Akihabara having no shortage of retro hardware junk stores, even many with floppy disk drives for sale, finding actual floppy disks was surprisingly difficult. I did eventually find some, but only after asking multiple shop owners who swore they had seen some around their shop to then fail to find any. The last guy went digging behind the counter and eventually produced a dusty box of floppies with only about half remaining.
- kmlx 3y agodidn't they have them at yodobashi?
- pilaf 3y agoThey may have them, it just didn't cross my mind so I went straight for the junk hardware stores. I had an afternoon to kill anyway and had fun looking at all the weird Japanese retro hardware.
- kmlx 3y agoyeah, it’s quite an experience what you’re describing. i loved it last time i was in akihabara. going back to yodobashi, seeing all the current gen electronics ever under a single roof spread out across x storeys was something i haven’t seen in the west in quite some time. it was tiring (there’s so much stuff), but equally impressive.
- merrywhether 3y agoThis is the kind of intractable bureaucratic inertia people were worried about regarding the EU’s USB-C mandate. It remains to be seen how that plays out (partly given that the current state of USB-C implies it could Frankenstein forward for quite some time), but this is definitely a useful cautionary tale. The floppy mandate was probably a really progressive take at the time it was introduced.
- etrautmann 3y agoIs there no way to have the best of both via some specified revisitation of the spec, or sunsetting of the original provision? It seems like a sunset period of 5 years would enforce the global switch without a permanent lock-in. Potential downside is that it might hamper development of alternatives, but that’s also the point.
- deelowe 3y agoThat all sounds well and good until you're the department head of the 1000 person floppy processing division and it comes time to cut the entire division.
- nonethewiser 3y agoPerhaps in a really broad sense of "bureaucracies can be slow which make narrowly focused laws inherently risky because they might become outdated." But the actual constraint is quite different: "the government needs data in this format" vs. "your consumer device must provide this specific power delivery format". The damage of the former is entirely contained to the act of producing the floppy disk. It sucks for each business when they have to make the 1 floppy disk but then the damage is done. With the USB mandate, the party producing the millions of devices is constrained going back to the design of their core product and then every person using it is constrained.
- renegade-otter 3y agoBureaucracy has absolutely nothing to do with this. Japan likes its traditions to the point where it does not know when to stop and re-evaluate. The "bureaucracy" just follows the culture. After all, the bureaucracy is the people. No one is enforcing the use of old-school fax machines, for example - businesses just have been reluctant to give it up.
- post_break 3y agoAre floppy disks still being manufactured or are they like the Japanese population? Aging and dying off. Next on their list should be fax machines over there.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[flagged]
- cm2187 3y agoIt's a pitty. A floppy disk requires you to remain concise, 1.44MB, that's barely above 140 characters in a docx file!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]