11 ms·
Senator Wyden Letter Confirms NSA Is Buying US Persons' Data from Data Brokers
- deadbabe 3y agoCan we buy our own data from a data broker?
- gorbachev 3y agoI think I'd rather buy data about data brokers' executives.
- NegativeK 3y agoHave a business address, get visited by a data broker rep to prove that you're actually a business, and then pay something like $10/person. Pentest firms do this to show their clients the concerns around data brokers.
- miga 3y agoWhile upsetting civil rights, one cannot leave commercial data brokers unmonitored by agencies. If only because they should be able estimate risk of and prevent criminal activity on home soil.
- lettergram 3y ago> one cannot leave commercial data brokers unmonitored by agencies That’s a feature haha. The largest lobbies are banks and organizations using those data brokers. The government leaves them alone, so they too can use them. It’s a way around laws.
- jrmg 3y agoI don’t really understand why it’s so much more controversial that agencies are buying commercially available data than that the data is being collected and made available to anyone that will pay in the first place.
- treyd 3y agoBecause Americans are so terrified of government that they can be completely okay with something terrible as long as it's private corporations doing it (and so, theoretically, you have the ability to not be a customer of that corporation) and not the government. Even if in practice your data is still being collected by that corporation indirectly or all of their competitors are also collecting and selling your data.
- RobRivera 3y agoOh am I?
- anon291 3y agoPrivate corporations in America regularly go bankrupt, lose tons of money, go out of business, go defunct, etc. The government does not. It's just not the same thing at all. Private corporations can be dissolved by government action. They can be handled much easier than the government.
- treyd 3y agoWhen was the last time a large and entrenched corporation did something terrible to the American public and was forcibly dissolved by the government?
- anon291 3y agoNot forcibly dissolved, but as we've seen with COVID and the recent 'woke' stuff, the public collectively punishes corporations they don't like. Even facebook is seeing a mass exodus from the platform after the election fiasco in 2016 and the ensuing controversy (which was around data privacy).
- macspoofing 3y ago>Because Americans are so terrified of government that they can be completely okay with something terrible as long as it's private corporations doing it That's not it. I think it is perfectly reasonable to set up a government with constraints and a culture of respect for the citizenry. It isn't about trust or no trust in 'government', because government is made up of individuals, and individuals have all kinds of motivations. I generally trust the government, but I am aware that any specific policy or decision can be a corrupt action for the benefit of some individual within the beurocracy.
- lettergram 3y agoHasn’t that been pretty open since Snowden like 10 years ago? Also, if anyone ever wonders how insidious the government is here’s food for thought — why does the US have such a crazy tax code? Quite literally all your life’s details give you small breaks on taxes - who you donated to, when you donated, why you donated. What property you own, what you did with it, new car? Is it an EV? Does it have power steering? Etc. It would be far far easier to pass a flat tax or remove most breaks. Interesting enough, they want to track all transactions now to increase tax revenue https://www.npr.org/2021/10/25/1048485043/irs-banks-taxes-fight-explainer https://www.npr.org/2021/10/25/1048485043/irs-banks-taxes-fi... https://www.cnbc.com/select/irs-600-reporting-rule-delayed/ https://www.cnbc.com/select/irs-600-reporting-rule-delayed/ But again, you don’t keep some of these $50 savings on taxes, then monitor all transactions. Unless it’s for something else
- rayiner 3y agoBecause the US tries to micromanage people’s behavior through the tax code. E.g. it offers EV credits because they want you to buy an EV instead of a gas car.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoThis. A lot of people don't understand this, but taxes shape behaviors.
- xyzzyz 3y agoI mean, I get why they would not understand it when the government micromanages companies by targeted tax breaks (called “tax loopholes”): they just hate companies and markets, and so they blame them for doing the exact thing the government wants them to do. But how can you not understand that the purpose of EV tax credits is to make people buy more EVs? That’s the whole point!
- rblatz 3y agoThe issue is that it’s the NSA, they’re not supposed to be investigate US citizens. They are supposed to be foreign signals intelligence. I’d fully expect the FBI or CIA to do this. I’m not even sure it’s wrong for them to do that. At least no more wrong than anyone else that buys it in order to advertise you.
- BurningFrog 3y agoThat the NSA spies on Americans on a massive scale was revealed by Snowden in 2013. There is no excuse to be surprised by it in 2024.
- snarkyturtle 3y agoWhat does "foreign" even mean in the internet? It's not like there are clear lines between plots of land. Everything is everywhere.
- austin-cheney 3y agoThat’s not completely correct. The CIA has the least reason to access this data as they are only charted for intelligence collection outside the US. The FBI is law enforcement so they cannot touch or view any of that data without a warrant else they could invalid all manners of data collection in many open cases. The NSA is chartered to collect data on communications entering and leaving the US. Decades ago that was completely unambiguous but less so now. Their collection of data on Americans is not illegal depending upon what they do with it. That was the most revealing part of the Snowden releases: insider threats misusing NSA data collected on Americans for personal use.
- willcipriano 3y ago> The FBI is law enforcement so they cannot touch or view any of that data without a warrant else they could invalid all manners of data collection in many open cases. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction
- 3y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoI think it would actually be a dereliction of duty if they did not buy the data. If the data is available for purchase, they should buy and analyze it, if for no other reason than to know what everyone else knows. Making the NSA intentionally blind to available data, seems like a bad thing.
- ikjasdlk2234 3y agoI mostly agree. If I were them, this acquisition would be to augment building a baseline of traffic and patterns of life so they can better identify anomalies in the future.
- NegativeK 3y agoIt seems like a dereliction of duty for the NSA not to go to Congress and scream about needing to close this gaping flaw in the security of our nation.
- jensensbutton 3y agoI cannot imagine being upset over this instead of the fact that data brokers can sell all this info in the first place.
- uncletammy 3y agoI cannot imagine not being furious about both, simultaneously. That being said, one of these is the culmination of tens of thousands of tiny consent violations made by hundreds or thousands of immoral, largely anonymous villians. The other is one enormous and brazen violation of the constitution, made by a government organization which is funded by citizens to protect and serve them. Both violations warrant the strictest repercussions.
- Andrex 3y agoI'm at a low simmer of jaded yet annoyed with all of it.
- flandish 3y agoWhat I don’t understand is how they tie data to a specific human in meatspace. Like my car - I own it but if you drive it, you get the speeding ticket. But with data - sure this post is from a meatspace device registered in my name / but does not indicate I am the actual meatspace person using it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hn_acker 3y agoConsider public IP addresses. Geolocation can link an IP address to a region as imprecise to a country to a more precise region such as a city. Combining rough location to a few other data points can greatly narrow down meatspace candidates for a particular account [1]: > According to one landmark study, these three characteristics are enough to uniquely identify 87% of the U.S. population. A different study showed that 63% of the U.S. population can be uniquely identified from these three facts. If you have a significant online presence, your gender or age might be revealed by the way other users address you on some website. If a website happens to collect gender or birthday, then the website might share/sell the info to data brokers. If police manage to narrow down the location of a potentially incriminating online action to a household, then the police could physically show up with a warrant and ask about who was using which computer in the house at that time. [1] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/11/debunking-myth-anonymous-data https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/11/debunking-myth-anonymo...
- flandish 3y agoOh for sure. I don’t disagree - it’s just so.. easily “faked” too. Nothing is anon but also nothing short of me showing a cop looking over my shoulder is proof positive.
- dogman144 3y agoCorrelation across multiple signals, described here https://restoreprivacy[.]com/rtb-data-leveraged-for-user-surveillance-by-non-state-agencies/ https://restoreprivacy[.]com/rtb-data-leveraged-for-user-sur...
- lumb63 3y agoIt seems to me that the government accessing, even if by purchase, information of citizens without probable cause is a violation, if not in letter, then in spirit, of the fourth amendment. I’d like to see an amendment to the Constitution to update the fourth amendment for the modern era, where a huge amount of information can be gathered about people without “searches and seizures”. The general issue of data collection is obviously one of the largest of our time, but I think most people would agree our own government should not be using our money (or debt) to legally circumvent our rights.
- cyanydeez 3y agoseems to me, the upstream problem is data brokers.
- zer00eyz 3y agoYou're not wrong, but the implied solution of no data brokers is gonna be a bad thing. The information is out there, it's stupid easy to correlate and collate it. It's even easier to use that to do something profitable. Getting rid of data brokers, making them not exist just makes a gray market for the information, one that is just as lucrative and is going to be untaxed and unregulated. 641a was the moment privacy died. We're not getting it back. We need to come up with a better method/idea...
- candiddevmike 3y agoWe need data collection laws similar to HIPAA breaches that render data collection akin to storing nuclear waste. I'd like to see this apply to aggregate data mining too, so we can get rid of things like the Topics API.
- GartzenDeHaes 3y agoHIPAA allows your medical information to be widely shared without your consent. It just requires the many holders of the data to implement some security controls. https://www.healthit.gov/topic/interoperability/how-hipaa-supports-data-sharing https://www.healthit.gov/topic/interoperability/how-hipaa-su...
- onionisafruit 3y agoThe article says this about the NSA: > It’s completely capable of engaging in domestic surveillance. And, indeed, it often does! So why would it need to purchase something it can obtain (more legitimately[?]) from its own dragnets and risk having part of its collection techniques exposed? I don’t think the NSA needs to worry about adversaries learning the technique of exchanging money for information. Hacking the data brokers would cause more potential exposure of proprietary techniques.
- kingwill101 3y agoThe irony here is that it's not been done by China or Russia. Why does it seem there's much less outrage if any when it's been done my local agencies?
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoBecause your tax dollars do not pay for the Chinese surveillance apparatus. Of course they're spying on you, that's their job. Our country is ostensibly different than theirs precisely because we don't treat our citizens like enemies... as much.
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoHN should maybe try engaging with this with the same urgency and focussed outrage as they would if they were told the perfidious, unreconstructed Brits were doing it. Something something US citizens something something unaccountable governments something something secretly breaking laws.
- SEJeff 3y agoThis is not new. As an example, the US Department of Homeland Security has been known to use Web of Science to help them identify foreign born researchers working in the US tied to their home country militaries.
- dhx 3y ago"For example, such information is critical to protecting the US Defense Industrial Base" is not an overly convincing argument for purchasing "NetFlow"[1]. The US State department Exchange Online hack is an example of where "NetFlow" being purchased could be more interesting as an example. IP addresses such as those registered in Russia and to OVH data centres logging into State Department executive mailboxes at 3:00AM in US time zones should be laughably easy to detect.[4] Rented US virtual servers and AWS/Azure/GCP servers outside federal government availability zones would also be trivial to detect as suspicious source locations. The question that purchased "NetFlow" would help answer is what is connecting to those suspicious IP addresses, what is connected to those, what else do the chain of IP addresses found communicate with, etc.[5] - Worst case there was no one was watching that attack as it occurred over ~4 months through use of "NetFlow" that may have been available and useful to use. - Controversial case is someone was watching (possibly including attacker's use, if any, of US servers) and decided that it was better to keep watching and following the attackers than to immediately prevent a few State Department emails being leaked. - Best case (not implemented) would seemingly be to fix terribly configured government systems so they can only be accessed from trusted locations and not random rented virtual server IPs, and "NetFlow" analysis is then probably not required. Security features such as "We've noticed your account is accessing this system from a new ISP--confirm this is really you?" aren't new. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NetFlow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NetFlow [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DShield https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DShield [3] https://web.archive.org/web/20010205010100/http://dshield.org/top10.html https://web.archive.org/web/20010205010100/http://dshield.or... [4] https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/security/blog/2023/07/14/analysis-of-storm-0558-techniques-for-unauthorized-email-access/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/security/blog/2023/07/14/ana... [5] https://blog.torproject.org/traffic-correlation-using-netflows/ https://blog.torproject.org/traffic-correlation-using-netflo...
- skywhopper 3y agoNot surprised in the least, and yet I probably trust the NSA with the data more than literally any other customer of those data brokers. Not that I trust the NSA all that much.
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y ago1. What can the average person do to avoid having their personal data collected and sold? 2. How would one go about creating fake data that gets collected and sold?
- eszed 3y ago1) Nothing. 2) This is a wonderful "Hacker-ish" approach to the problem: Pollute the Database! My fear is that in the real (ie non tech-hacker) world, whatever false data my dbPollution script put into the table dedicated to me would be used to target me, and that the argument "No, I didn't make [suspicious searches 1, 2, and 3] - this tool designed to make Law Enforcement's job harder did!" would not be a winning argument with a) Judges, and b) a jury of my normie "peers". In theory I love it; in practice, it scares the shit out of me.
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoI'm thinking there needs to be more tools like this https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/google/google-bans-adnauseam-from-chrome-the-ad-blocker-that-clicks-on-all-ads/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/google/google-bans-adn... Maybe it would be easy to sort through, but maybe not
- WhackyIdeas 3y agoWhat are Apple and Google doing to protect their Android and iOS devices from these data brokers? Or are they just allowing and making it easier for them? Why give apps the power to do these things, why not give the power to the person who bought with their hard earned money these devices - why not let them choose whether to allow an app to grab all the data they can?
- mark_l_watson 3y agoI wish in the US we had some form of privacy protection as in the EU. What the EU has is not perfect, but I wish we had it. My understanding is that one man, Senator Chuck Schumer, blocks any meaningful privacy legislation in his committee. A one man privacy wrecking ball. I read somewhere that his two daughters have high paying jobs at, I think, Meta and Microsoft. EDIT: my point is that if we had better privacy, then corporations would have less information to sell.
- shutupnerd0000 3y agoHow are his daughters relevant to the point?
- pnt12 3y agoCould be a bribe: defend the interests of the companies, get some cozy jobs for your family in return.
- nashashmi 3y agoThis is what Facebook was also doing. They were buying data from any website they could. (They made data buying a profitable thing because they knew they could use that for ad serving.) If the US govt, if intelligence agencies are doing the same, are we calling this "illegal" or wrong? If so, why? If the US govt were to be doing this with a healthy dose of govt reach, then it would be a violation of law. But they are buying what is already available.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoMaking selling personal information illegal solves this problem. If there is no profit motive to collecting the data most companies will just not collect it.
- pphysch 3y agoTrading illegal drugs is illegal, but entire black markets still exist for that purpose. Monitoring illegal transactions that have no physical footprint (unlike drugs) is very difficult.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoIf it is illegal to sell then ostensibly the government cannot legally purchase it.
- pphysch 3y agoDoD black budget. Some highly classified CIA/NSA project needs $10M for data collection, and no one bats an eye. Snowden revealed that CIA spent $10Bs on "data collection" per year.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mass_and_energy 3y agoThis is why Clearview AI and things like it are such a major threat to our privacy and security.
- 0xbadcafebee 3y agoThis isn't a surprise, is it? It's not illegal, and this is the NSA we're talking about. The people who hacked domestic corporations for chuckles. If it's not illegal, and it's surveillance related, they're doing it. Wyden's demand that companies stop selling our data "without consent" is political bullshit. It just means the companies have to stuff a "you consent to X" in their ToS. Which nobody reads, so nobody will push back on. Business as usual.
- joloooo 3y agoHasn't this been accepted with things like the Five Eyes alliance? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes
- mcny 3y agoThe question we should be asking is with what money and on whose authority? Defund the NSA.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoWhy is this a surprise? If the NSA et al is willing to break the law or at least bend it (a la Snowden revelations) why wouldn't they do something that is well within the law? Are we really still this naive?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[Dupe] again from techdirt, wasting our time OP Last week's news: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39136770 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39136770