6 ms·
A Nigerian professor who makes more money welding
- drewcoo 3y ago[flagged]
- tomlockwood 3y agoA person who says thinking isn't work must only ever have thoughts that are worth nothing.
- simonw 3y agoNot to mention... https://www.espn.com/espn/story/_/id/27593253/why-grandmasters-magnus-carlsen-fabiano-caruana-lose-weight-playing-chess https://www.espn.com/espn/story/_/id/27593253/why-grandmaste... > "Grandmasters sustain elevated blood pressure for hours in the range found in competitive marathon runners," Sapolsky says. > It all combines to produce an average weight loss of 2 pounds a day, or about 10-12 pounds over the course of a 10-day tournament in which each grandmaster might play five or six times.
- walk_donttalk 3y agoUsing Nota Bene for a single-liner in parenthesis next to another single-liner is overkill, and stylistically, it seems like you’re just using it because of the uncommon nature. Following that, you’ve asked me to pay specific attention to the idea that “thinking isn’t work” — can you list a few projects and tasks you complete without any thinking? Can you make that list without thinking Or was your post made without thinking?
- earthboundkid 3y agoMost American university instructors are adjuncts. Yes, any welder would easily earn more than let’s say 85% of instructors.
- mrits 3y agoEven in software a lot of more interesting jobs pay less. Look at Haskell and Rust jobs. They might have some of the most highest paying but most of them get paid less than being a below average SQL developer.
- losteric 3y ago> Look at Haskell and Rust jobs. They might have some of the most highest paying but most of them get paid less I would bet that's because there are a large number projects that got written in Haskell/Rust by someone looking to learn on-the-job, for a highly non-technical business. Now anyone hired to implement new business capabilities is inherently locked in to "low-ROI" work, short of convincing the business of a big rewrite in a new language (unsurprisingly impossible)... and they'll probably get someone else looking to learn the language on the job :) Then there are HFTs with valuable and effective software, which can fully exploit the skills of an advanced engineer to quickly make the company 10x+ their wages - naturally such jobs pay a bit more. Jobs basically pay based on the rarity of the skill set and the profit capital owners can extract from the laborer. Don't "invest" in a rare/difficult-to-acquire skill set which is not profitable (but also, don't assume life needs to be an investment - we only have the one :)
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoI am not sure I understand the stigma. It is a ridiculously cool and useful skill to have. I am only reading up on it now ( with plans later to bamboozle wife to let met attend local community college classes to learn it in practice ). Is it just the perception that it is not proper 'mind job'?
- medion 3y agoWe’ve drunk the koolaid that work with one’s hands is not respectable. Meanwhile the trades are mostly killing it and watching white collar workers with their hunched backs and lattes have their work slowly eroded by language models.
- mlhpdx 3y agoSo as a CTO, why do people think it’s extra cool that I build wooden boats, too? One of my role models is a retired Chevrolet mechanic who has never had to worry about money. The stigma is just one more tragic falsehood that echoes around us.
- renewiltord 3y agoGuys, guys. There’s no stigma. I literally have ironworker friends. It’s just job to normal people here in the Bay Area. You guys are the only ones doing this. This always happens on HN. Someone will go “Despite what people think, left handed people are not idiots. Some of the smartest people I know are left handed. I think it’s bullshit that everyone thinks they’re morons”. But nobody thinks that. WTH it’s normal stuff. I’m literally in software here in San Francisco. My wife is in marketing. We don’t think this. Nobody I know thinks this wtf.
- operatingthetan 3y ago>I’m literally in software here in San Francisco. My wife is in marketing. We don’t think this. Nobody I know thinks this wtf. I find people usually perpetuating that attitude are the blue collar workers themselves.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoAssuming he's able to be good at both jobs, I really envy what he's got going. Going all-in on one's academic area can make for a narrow life.
- medion 3y agoWhy is this even surprising? Like most trades, they can be lucrative if you work hard and do quality work - none of the side benefits of a professorship though, like retirement, sick leave, holidays, physically easy work, and in many cases probably intellectually easy work too.
- em3rgent0rdr 3y agoWelding may also provide a feeling of satisfaction in that you actually made/fixed a physical tool that satisfies a customer's real need, who thanks you and appreciates your handiwork.
- mlhpdx 3y agoThe trades seem like a great gig these days.
- renewiltord 3y agoSome 15-20 years ago I was traveling in Egypt. Like good tourists we stopped at a papyrus store. Proprietor was a medical doctor. Why selling papyrus to tourists? Pays more. Just supply and demand, guys.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 3y agoSupply & Demand - it's the law!
- shiroiuma 3y agoAnd where is Egypt in the global hierarchy of nations? Not very high. This should tell you something.
- weweersdfsd 3y agoYes, supply and demand matters a lot. In my country becoming a doctor is particularly lucrative even by Western world's standards, because a combination of our broken healthcare system (and doctor's association's successful lobbying to keep numbers of doctors being educated too low) creates an artificial shortage of doctors. Many of them choose to work 3-4 days a week in private sector and still live very, very well. The public sector is forced to buy services from private with very inflated prices, again allowing those companies offer excellent salaries. At the same time professions like engineering are actually underpaid here, not to even mention nursing.
- colinmegill 3y agoYeah, well, I happen to know a union leader for teachers in NJ who is losing tenured staff to COSTCO. So. I reject the clickbait headline and the implications.
- jfim 3y agoCostco pays well for retail though.
- jacobolus 3y agoPeople with years of preparation and expert practice are giving up a demanding high-skill job to do a retail clerk job that requires no special skill or pre-service training at all. For individual workers this is fine, and people should do what they like; at scale, for society, it is incredibly wasteful: high-quality teaching has incredibly high leverage. We should get our collective shit together and fix it.
- mattmaroon 3y agoIt does require training. You have to watch several videos in the break room.
- shiroiuma 3y agoThis reminds me a lot of the fall of the Roman Empire: Romans abandoned the cities and their highly skilled professions so they could move to feudal lords' farms and work the fields. Apparently the society had deteriorated so much that it was more lucrative to work as a field laborer than live in the city doing specialized work. And of course, without skilled people to keep the city's advanced economy going, it fell apart over time.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoNote that the result of this was a large drop in total agricultural production. It wasn't so much that people left the cities to work the fields as that the people who lived in the cities died. Cities have never replaced themselves, by the way - urban population has always come from people leaving the countryside. When the inflow shrinks, the city will shrink even if no one leaves.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoRe-onshoring of manufacturing means that all these trades will be in ultra high demand. AI LLMs can't weld.
- grow2grow 3y agoI mean, AI's (robots) weld on assembly lines. It's all about the context. They do have indoor assembly line welding robots. But, they don't have welding robots for outdoor, ground-breaking construction job sites yet. I mean, do they?
- defrost 3y agoNot all welds are equal, tacking a frame together isn't the same as a pipe weld. We're not far off having adaptive autonomous pipe welding in-situ. https://www.thefabricator.com/thefabricator/article/tubepipefabrication/how-ai-helps-make-autonomous-pipe-welding-a-reality-for-fab-shops https://www.thefabricator.com/thefabricator/article/tubepipe... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tLx3oDt9Who https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tLx3oDt9Who
- beezlewax 3y agoOnshoring manufacturing is a given why?
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoMostly because China's leadership is getting totalitarian, corrupt, ineffective, and warlike ... I've seen projections on some combo of all of the above, but really none that are even "everythings fine!" except those that have tinges of totalitarian psychology. China isn't that cheap anymore either. They have machine tooling and economies of scale. The US is basically in a cold war with China since they are now the principle global rival. China's population is set to decline by a massive amount from one child policy. This combined with other supposed economic boondoggles will collapse the system. The world learned that ultra extended supply lines aren't a good thing in COVID, and the world just seems to be going to a more chaotic era with likely lots of wars over resources, population displacement from global warming, and lots of other not-fun stuff. Finally, the United States is becoming more isolationist. With the shrinking geopolitical importance of oil, the US might stop enforcing Pax Americana on the high seas. The primary function of the navy was to secure petroleum, and now with EVs, alt energy, and the Bakken Shale we don't need to do that for us, or the rest of the world. So... take your pick
- spacecadet 3y agonot surprising, weldings dope. I have this antique book that has photos of early welding setups... those dudes had to have been paid well too!
- throwaway0665 3y agoWelding takes an enormous physical toll on your body. It is dope but not something you want to be doing all day every day.
- spacecadet 3y agoYeah I know. My father has been a welder on ships (shipfitter), tugs, and subs his entire career. My brother and Cousins followed. I mig and tig auto shit at home, mostly stainless manifolds. Was trying to be supportive but yall come at me with his unhumble comment about welding like you know me! lol
- cloudbonsai 3y ago> He opened up a mini workshop in Zaria around two decades ago. > He has 10 apprentices - aged between 12 and 20 - at the workshop where he is teaching them the skills of the trade. Seems more like a successful small business owner (not just being a part-time welder). Considering that he has been running his shop profitably for 20+ years, he may well be richer than 90% of his academic peers.
- jamal-kumar 3y agoSmart guy but in my experience in parts of the world which aren't graced with the dollar or euro as their home currency really gotta be deft like that in order to get by comfortably. Small chance you may be surprised how many people out there are living on less than 5$/hr
- monero-xmr 3y agoA lot of them are switching to Bitcoin, or some dollar-equivalent like USDC / USDT
- golergka 3y agoNot sure why are you getting downvoted. I'm in Argentina right now and its happening in real time right in front of my eyes.
- sakjur 3y agoIt’s half an argument. Just bringing up cryptocurrencies is tiresome. How does that change the amount of people living on less than the equivalent of $5 per hour or day?
- monero-xmr 3y agoThe parent comment said you need to be “graced” with the dollar or euro, but with crypto every person on earth can have a dollar wallet now. That’s why I said it.
- grow2grow 3y agoUnfortunately, there is not enough demand for knowledgable humans, to keep up with the overwhelming supply. Typical universe. I've run out of sympathy for those who can't distinguish their survivorship bias from actual success. (pullyourselftogether) The reality is companies go through cycles of hiring and firing, something to do with interest rates. Times like these is when new small businesses are supposed to form, and I fear downsizing businesses let their best and worst go during these times: their star performers know how to survive and are least likely to come back with a wrongful termination lawsuit....and their worst are easily shown to be inadequate for the role anyway. An "intelligent person" knows not to keep their eggs in one basket anyway. Such as our Professor in the story.
- teddyX 3y ago> academic snobs Root issue and an unfortunate reality
- iancmceachern 3y agoLots of my profs were this way. They made much more from their patent and other royalties in the Mining and Oil and Gas fields than they did from their teaching gigs. One told me once that the money he made from teaching didn't even pay his income tax. I went to a school that is one of the top for those industries, for context.
- nicolas_t 3y agoSame with one of my teacher in France. He had a few patents used in the automotive industry and nade more from that than from his salary.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- delichon 3y agoThere's a retired welder who lives down the street and a retired professor across the street. The welder has a large beautiful custom built home, six horses, on about a half dozen merged rural lots. The professor lives in a double wide mobile home on a small lot. That's not very surprising in the US, why should it be in Nigeria?
- WalterBright 3y agoWelding looks easy. I've tried it many times, it's really hard. There's a very small line between not fusing the metal and burning a big hole in the work. Welding is very rare in aircraft because of the difficulty in verifying a correct weld.
- fhub 3y agoI assume Friction Stir Welding is getting more popular in aircraft partly due to easier verification.
- namibj 3y agoIt's also capable of handling very thin material and it's very repeatable. The https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GTW_Generation_15 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GTW_Generation_15 trains also rely on it, as the weight limit stems from the track (to passively bank in curves, the cabin is underneath the rail (and there's only one rail as this arrangement is stable and just acts like a pendulum), so the track needs to be a bridge).
- daniel-levin 3y agoDifficulty is relative and practice makes perfect. People love to compare difficulty of processes, metals, positions etc. They’re all hard without practice. They’re all easy with a lot of practice. If you just want to fuse some metal it can be very frustrating to fight with the welder and get nowhere. But if you’re deliberately practicing, getting hundreds of hours under the hood, you will get good. The other crucial component is that other humans have worked out how to weld metals effectively and have documented it. There are tons of handbooks and manuals, detailing which techniques and consumables you should be using for a given weld. Combine that with lots of time under the hood, and you’ll be making phenomenally good welds without difficulty.
- cupcakecommons 3y agoThis is really great
- litoE 3y agoI was a tenure-track professor at a major US University (whose name I do not wish to remember). I was good at it too. But, because of my pay, I also qualified for financial assistance from the Federal and State governments. I quit when I was offered triple my salary by a private company. I gave the University two weeks notice, and finished teaching my course for that semester pro-bono.
- squokko 3y agoIs there some first-principles reason why this is surprising? Why shouldn't welding pay more than teaching?
- infoseek12 3y agoThat’s awesome! Though, I think the headline underplays what he’s doing and done Having a part-time job as a welder for a private company would be awesome and no doubt useful in a variety of ways. However, he’s not only helping his countries technical industry as an individual contributor, he’s also running a small business and educating quite a few future welders Many public-private partnerships between academia and industry, that were far better resourced, have a accomplished far less
- bmicraft 3y agoThat's not awesome. He's paying his staff about 20% of what they're earning him and keeping the rest.
- freemanofthewan 3y agoWhen they bring nothing but unskilled labor to the table, how much do you feel they are entitled to? 50%? I would call that a partner and expect them to bring their own tools and skills. That is not the situation described here. So, how much should they receive?
- bmicraft 3y ago50% would probably be fair. Remember that he'd be keeping 50% _per employee_, which means he still makes 10x compared to them.
- nabilhat 3y agoNot as a welder, as a welding workshop sole proprieter with employees, including children. > He has 10 apprentices - aged between 12 and 20 - at the workshop where he is teaching them the skills of the trade. > "Even as apprentices, he gives us 10,000 naira every month and a daily stipend for food." That's $11.36 per month. How much does the owner keep if retained earnings meet or exceed a normal salary for an academic in Nigeria? > Academics in Nigeria have long struggled on modest salaries, most earning between 350,000 naira ($390; £305) and 500,000 ($555; £435) a month More than about 80%, if there are no other costs. This is a story about entrepreneurship, not a recognition of manual skill, or an expose of underpaid academics.
- whamlastxmas 3y agoThanks for saving me the click. People act like the BBC is some bastion of flawless journalism but it’s still full of dumb crap like this
- Glemolo 3y agoHe actually didn't. He left out plenty of interesting details. And not sure why you are randomly hating on BBC? Who said that this article is a must read because of BBC?
- boxed 3y ago> This is a story about entrepreneurship, not a recognition of manual skill, or an expose of underpaid academics. It can be all three. A story doesn't need to be about just one thing.
- otabdeveloper4 3y ago"Nigerian" here is redundant. Making more as a welder than a professor is standard everywhere. (To be honest, welding is a harder job and requires more stringent qualifications.)
- thaumasiotes 3y agoWhat's the rate on welders going blind as they age?
- Modified3019 3y agoI would imagine the metal fumes are also likely to be a statistical hazard over the long term as well.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoWith proper welding masks, it isn't really an issue. Backs, knees, lungs and hearing are though.
- zubairq 3y agoI loved this story about the Nigerian professor who also works as a welder and employs people to make ends meet. Here in the West we often see 9-5 jobs as the norm to survive, but in many places around the world people have to be entrepreneurs and inventive just to put food on the table.
- toss1 3y ago>>"Unfortunately I found out engineering here was more theoretically based and I needed a place to express myself" Not only is it more fulfilling to do both, but we can also be confident that the hands-on welding experience also makes him a better engineer. Great to see it.