8 ms·
> 2,000,000 installs is a minimum of $45k in fees, even with $0 USD revenue > this seems obscene This is why I never cared about the 30% take: it was combinin
by ben_w 3y ago
> 2,000,000 installs is a minimum of $45k in fees, even with $0 USD revenue
> this seems obscene
This is why I never cared about the 30% take: it was combining all the costs you'd have anyway into one simple number. People just acted like those things were all free just because Apple wasn't explicitly listing them.
Could you optimise your expenses better by splitting them?
Probably.
And that may even be worth forcing the issue from a competitive PoV, because it means some customers will be effectively subsidising others: A weekly updated 2 gigabyte app that's free in the app store gets its bandwidth paid for in part by a 30 Mb app that charges a $10 monthly subscription and gets an update every 3 months.
But even then, companies are expected to make profits. What's the level where it's fine for Apple to say "we want this much extra just for us"? For a lot of people the answer seems to be "zero!" — while this probably would not disincentivise Apple from making iOS given they also profit on the hardware, it would almost certainly disincentivise Google from bothering with any updates to Android.
- pcammeraat 3y agoAnd if your revenue is under the 1 million per year you can apply for only 15%. That is well worth it what you get back for it.
- mjburgess 3y agoLet's see where they find their 30% if browsers were required to provide (essentially) 100% features of native apps, and if they were required not to charge for them. Maybe iPhone costs would increase a few percent, probably not. This is just egregious rent seeking.
- skydhash 3y agoThat would just require browser devs to maintain a whole new OS. Native API are much more complicated than what is available on browsers
- littlestymaar 3y agoFun fact: they already do. (Or at least Mozilla did, but given their massive engineering power it would be surprising if Google wasn't doing it as well). From what I heard at a Mozilla meetup a few years ago, the only thing that prevented Mozilla to ship the actual Firefox to iOS back then was Apple ToS banning apps with their own JIT compiler built-in.
- dlivingston 3y agoChromium targets iOS already: https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/main/docs/ios/build_instructions.md https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/main/docs/i...
- ensignavenger 3y agoDoes Google charge a .50 per install fee for Android apps not installed via the Play Store? Does Microsoft charge a .50 per install fee for Windows apps not installed via the Windows Store? Apple is just making these charges up, because they think they can get away with it. It doesn't cover any real costs to Apple, above and beyond what you already pay for when you buy an Apple device.
- lwhi 3y agoFeels very much like a punitive charge to me. If that's the case, hopefully legislation will catch up.
- ensignavenger 3y agoI am wondering how the EU market will react. How many businesses in the EU have free apps that have more than 1 million users? Will businesses start charging for their apps in the EU just to recover the cost, or pull out entirely? Maybe more will offer fully featured websites and drive customers there instead. I don't know, but it seems like a stupid move on Apples part, a big game of chicken.
- eastbound 3y agoHow many will sell Safari1 with 999,999 users, Safari2 with 999,999 users, Safari3…
- threeseed 3y agoNobody is forcing developers to adopt the new model. So EU businesses will simply have more options to choose from.
- lwhi 3y agoIf Apple are able to make the options that aren't beneficial to their business, less attractive .. isn't this just another example of profiteering?
- 3y ago
- macNchz 3y agoI don’t see why smartphones inherently have to be a special case of computer where the manufacturer or OS developer gets to keep their finger in the pie after the sale. I can install any software I want on my desktop or laptop, and nobody gets a cut of it unless both the seller and I freely choose to use an app store.
- lokar 3y agoThe vast majority of consumers prefer and benefit from aspects of this control. Despite all the horror stories (both fp and fn) they keep the App Store much safer then mass direct installs would be.
- fsflover 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39137917 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39137917
- johnnyanmac 3y agoOkay, and they can keep that control while some minority choose to host elsewhere. Androids Play store (pending some anti-trust issues, ironically) still has the majority of apps there and it'd be doubtful that any android alternative store can steal that mindshare away.
- judge2020 3y ago> Androids Play store (pending some anti-trust issues, ironically) still has the majority of apps there and it'd be doubtful that any android alternative store can steal that mindshare away. If so, why did Google feel the need to bribe developers to keep their apps on the Play store? https://www.theverge.com/2021/8/19/22632818/google-project-hug-game-developers-play-store-millions-epic-lawsuit-complaint https://www.theverge.com/2021/8/19/22632818/google-project-h...
- refulgentis 3y agoObjection, argumentative: being doubtful of X, and a company wanted to move X to 0 probability, aren't in tension.
- mattmaroon 3y agoWhat costs that are rolled into Apple’s 30% are you saving on? Payment processing is let’s say 3% (including chargebacks). Delivering updates is just pushing bits, practically zero. What else are they doing? If Apple features you, then I guess it’s pretty fair to say you’ve paid a marketing expense, but they feature a tiny percent of apps. Most of us get nothing but buried in the app store. 30% is a lot.
- threeseed 3y ago> What else are they doing? The exact same thing Epic is doing with their games engines. Building and supporting the SDKs that developers use to make money.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoYes, and Epic charges a lot less for their support. We say how Unity was eviscerated for a much cheaper runtime fee, I can't imagine Apple gets away with triple the pricing.
- threeseed 3y agoThe SDKs that Apple provides are far broader and more lucrative than Epic's game engine.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoIs it? Epic doesn't only provide and engine to make a game with. Online services, access to extremely high fidelity assets (meta human, Quixel megascans), photogrammetry. And of course it's working on its own store. All of these have a lower cut even if you don't negotiate.
- qwytw 3y ago> Building and supporting the SDKs that developers use to make money. You're implying that this is a somehow onesides transaction and Apple is doing developers a favour while Apple always needed third party developers as much as developers need them (with iOS of course this balance changed a bit which allowed Apple to become a lot more exploitative than they were before/still are if we're talking about macOS)
- kwanbix 3y agoFor me, the problem is that the 30% is crazy high. 1/3!!!! Had they charged 10%, nobody will be complaining.
- sholladay 3y agoI don’t think that’s true. People complain about tipping culture, which generally demands about 15-20%, sometimes less (e.g. for whatever reason, hotel housekeeping only gets a few dollars even if the room is $100 per night). If tipping 10% was the norm, you think there would barely be any complaining? The buyer always wants the transaction to be more affordable and the seller always wants the transaction to be more profitable. The exact numbers don’t change that. I think the thing that angers people is that the cost feels hidden, even if it’s common knowledge. You look at menu prices and see a price but tips, taxes, and credit card processing fees aren’t included. It can take you by surprise if you’re not thinking about it, even if you’ve been through the same dance many times before. If I were running Apple, I would instead find a way to charge for developer accounts, code signing, etc. Things that are set up ahead of time and can have a known value, charged for upfront. I believe this would feel more fair, no matter the cost.
- azinman2 3y agoIt drops after the first year
- kwanbix 3y agoStill, for a year, they got keep 1/3 of what you make, and then you have to pay taxes. How much is it after a year?
- azinman2 3y ago15%, and apparently now 10% in the EU. I think people forget what it cost to sell and market software before the App Store. There’s plenty written about this…
- Ringz 3y ago>A weekly updated 2 gigabyte app that's free in the app store gets its bandwidth paid for in part by a 30 Mb app that charges a $10 monthly subscription and gets an update every 3 months. I've been wondering for a long time why there are no delta-updates at Apple...
- sroussey 3y agoIf you have $1B in revenue, your costs to host the app yourself are nowhere near $300m, lol.
- agsnu 3y agoThis is nonsense. Apple executives have repeatedly claimed that the 30% fee was a good deal compared to retail boxed software which they say was the norm in 2005 or so, but really there were large numbers of small independent software vendors making good money through specialised e-commerce vendors like DigitalRiver or the original Kagi with fees in the 8-15% range iirc, or just selling direct with payment processors like PayPal for ~5%. Bandwidth was not a big cost back then and still isn’t today unless you’re doing something like 4K video streaming.
- ben_w 3y ago> Kagi with fees in the 8-15% range iirc, or just selling direct with payment processors like PayPal for ~5%. Bandwidth was not a big cost back then and still isn’t today unless you’re doing something like 4K video streaming. That's untrue, from my experience using Kagi (payment processor and marketplace/in-app SDK) to sell shareware in c. 2010. Kagi had fixed fees in addition to a percentage, so anything sold for $5 had close to 30% just from Kagi, and my bandwidth also independently ended up close to 30% of my post-marketplace fees.
- agsnu 3y agoHmm, perhaps my memory is from more like the $15-20 price point. Lower sale price would result in greater percentage being eaten by fees for sure. I remember using eSellerate c. 2005 and it was much less than 30%.