4 ms·
The rise and fall of the standard user interface
- graemep 3y agoThe Register has also published articles claiming (incorrectly because it ignores customisability) that Linux desktop environments are too much like Windows and not innovating. I agree about the lack of standard key bindings is a problem. It is definitely a problem with things like text editors. Even worse between modal editors, or a mix of modal and modeless - I generally use Helix and occasionally using vi (or nano, or anything else) is a pain.
- jwells89 3y agoTalking about out-of-the-box configs (which are important because a lot of users run default or near-default), the argument that Linux DEs that ship with distros have a heavy bias towards the Win9X desktop paradigm holds up pretty well. The only odd ones out are GNOME which is iPadOS-like and Pantheon which is like iPadOS with an OS X 10.9 theme applied. There aren’t any DEs that for example mimic macOS (modern or classic) and the few that do something different (e.g. GNUSTEP, CDE, etc) don’t ship with distros. As far as I know there haven’t been any recent DEs that were designed from scratch based on research from new user trials and usability studies (which is unfortunate; most of data in this realm dates back 20 years or more and could probably benefit from addition of new data from a modern context).
- graemep 3y agoOut of the box configs need to be familiar, and most uses are accustomed to Windows. Doing otherwise is a barrier to new users. I cannot tell how well the distros that do mimic MacOS do it, but from what you say it is not well enough (at least not Pantheon).
- jwells89 3y agoThe problem with Pantheon is that it only captures the skin-deep aspects of macOS. Power user features and progressive disclosure thereof (which are a big reason why macOS has a technically capable userbase) are mostly stripped. Like GNOME, it doesn’t support minimizing windows for example and not only doesn’t have a global menubar but eschews menubars entirely, with functions that don’t fit in hamburger menus either getting buried or cut entirely.
- jrm4 3y agoAbsolutely; recently I realize I wish I'd never learned vim. I use too many other programs that are at least CUA-ish ( http://zim-wiki.org http://zim-wiki.org is the most important app I use ) and now I kind of want out. I haven't yet tried Modeless Vim, but that looks like my next experiment. https://github.com/SebastianMuskalla/ModelessVim https://github.com/SebastianMuskalla/ModelessVim
- IshKebab 3y agoProbably the most annoying inconsistency in any UI - no matter the platform - is which mouse button / modifier keys do you use to pan, rotate and zoom. Both in 2D and 3D there's zero consistency across programs.
- hgs3 3y ago> Linux desktop environments are too much like Windows and not innovating. If we're talking the files+folders paradigm, then there's not much innovation remaining outside of cosmetic changes. Desktop computers are "done" much the same way automobile interfaces (steering wheel, foot peddles, etc) are "done". I think true Desktop innovations would require a paradigm shift or new hardware, like eye-tracking or a BCI.
- adamzochowski 3y agoThe question is what drives consistency. 80s 90s and early 2000s it was the OS. All apps running under a specific OS would look similar to each other. Behave same way. File menus looked same. Preferences was in same location. But somewhere in 2000s this reversed and OS was no longer driver of consistency. App developers stopped following OS UI guidelines and decided that it's not important for OS to be cohesive. The goal was that app, no matter where it is running, should have consistent look and behavior. And now we are in application centric world where application dictates UI and there is no OS level consistency. Additionally Microsoft and Apple did not help the situation by themselves breaking the OS UI paradigms with media players, or in MS case MS Office.
- hulitu 3y ago> The goal was that app, no matter where it is running, should have consistent look and behavior. Microsoft is still working hard at Office 365. They are nowhere close. Java had, at some time, achived this.
- marius-sw 3y ago> Additionally Microsoft and Apple did not help the situation by themselves breaking the OS UI paradigms with media players, or in MS case MS Office. Indeed - I remember this situation very clearly. Back when Office 2007 came out, there was no first-party way to create applications like that, and after a year or two, only few third-party libraries that were lacking in quality and polish. This was the turning point. Clients asked us for it, we tried, but ultimately we decided to ditch the bad libraries and do our own thing - then the clients decided they might as well define their own UI design language if they're paying for UI component development.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoThe Ribbon was a travesty. Organized menus were replaced by a giant bar full of incomprehensible icons. If you were decent at Office, then your muscle memory was screwed up. (If you were excellent, then maybe you had all the shortcuts memorized and it didn't matter, but most of us are in an in-between state.) If instead you were completely new to Office, then your consistent, discoverable indication of keyboard shortcuts (in the menus) also went away -- no more skill ladder. The only winners were preliterate toddlers, I have to assume. This was justified with, "I am an HCI expert, trust me". Which is garbage: I'm the user of the tool; don't try to pretend you know better, like some colonial governor. Also, it started getting slower. A process that only got worse and worse. My assumption is that it was really all driven by internal politics within Microsoft, specifically some manager's need to Change Something.
- kens 3y agoAn article about the history of user interfaces that ignores the Xerox Alto? The article has the WIMP interface and graphical desktops emerging from the graphics of 8-bit home computers. The article also ignores that TUIs came from terminals like the VT100 that had cursor positioning, instead claiming that home computers were the source of moving cursors around the screen. The article goes into plenty of obscure details (e.g. where Bucky bits came from), but the history is very strange.
- pvg 3y agoIt's really an article about CUA, the slug is a better title than the actual title.
- zwieback 3y agoI lived through everything this rambling article poorly articulates. What I realized for myself is that I have two modes: 1) Frequently used applications: doesn't matter if I have to ctrl-alt-right-double-tap a weird key or click on some invisible UI element. I'll learn what it takes and use it without complaint 2) Casual use of a new environment or app: endless complaining about the weirdness until I either cast it aside or use it everyday (see 1 above)
- lproven 3y ago[Author here] It is overlong, sadly, yes. It was written in some haste, despite considerable planning -- see my docs uploaded to the Internet Archive, for instance -- because one of my planned, agreed interviewees for Retro Tech Week dropped out at the last minute and left me without an article, and I had to rush this. Je n’ai fait celle-ci plus longue que parce que je n’ai pas eu le loisir de la faire plus courte.
- zwieback 3y agoBummer about the rush, lots of good stuff in the article, hopefully you'll get another chance to condense it. Definitely brought back a lot of memories for me, my OS/2 phase was a lot of fun and I was sad when it ended.
- lproven 3y agoThanks! > my OS/2 phase was a lot of fun and I was sad when it ended. Same. I have been playing around with eComStation and ArcaOS recently. They are amazingly fast on elderly Core 2 Duo era kit where any modern Linux distro is sluggish... but I can't get wifi working. https://www.theregister.com/2023/01/19/retro_tech_week_arca_os/ https://www.theregister.com/2023/01/19/retro_tech_week_arca_... https://www.theregister.com/2023/09/04/arcaos_51/ https://www.theregister.com/2023/09/04/arcaos_51/
- kevinsync 3y agoUI definitely shouldn't have to be standard, but if it deviates, it should be good! Intuitive, memorable, easy to navigate, etc. There are as many bad user interfaces out there as there is bad graphic design, although I often think that the majority of "egregious" examples of graphic design (signs, etc) are actually quite functional and informative, just arguably visually-offensive -- they do their job well enough, they're just tarted up like toaster pastries. Bad UIs on the other hand are genuinely unusable and can make or break an otherwise-brilliant program or service.