8 ms·
Sports Illustrated implosion shows the ugly, ongoing collapse of U.S. journalism
- bell-cot 3y agoUm, yes? If your society is completely controlled by a tiny Greed-Is-Our-Only-God plutocracy, and nothing is protected from financialization - then what sacred-to-you cow do you really expect to survive, long-term? );
- 1905 3y agoI wonder how much of this is related to the possible decline of mainstream sports? How many young 10 something year olds in this country really follow Baseball or Basketball? They seem to be more into gaming, among other things
- graphe 3y agoFor draft kings and other gambling ventures they get to know moneyball and five thirty eight.
- ThrowawayTestr 3y ago[flagged]
- andrewclunn 3y agoSo a sports magazine that has been renting out its brand for decades is now representative of "real journalism?" I'm not sure "real journalists" would appreciate that conflation. Unless of course the comparison is apt, in which case "real journalism" died long ago.
- ghaff 3y agoRenting out the brand and/or selling their soul for clicks is a pretty common path predating the final implosion in a lot of cases. Forbes, National Geographic, and I'm sure countless others.
- DebtDeflation 3y agoI had to explain to someone at work the other day that Forbes is just a blogging platform now and Newsweek is a tabloid that's been sold to new owners like 4 times over the last decade. These are not the publications you remember from the 1990s. And yes, there are countless other examples.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Waterluvian 3y agoThe state of journalism and politics are a symptom of the epidemic of fear centres running the show and attention spans that are much too short. We’re progressing well on our path to fitting into our new niche as a more globalized, digital species.
- mschuster91 3y agoIt's not just that. A significant problem is monetization: - you got amateurs (bloggers, social media) being capable of running very fast and high-quality journalism on very low budgets (as the barrier to entry is extremely low, all you need for a vlog these days is a basic iPhone) that can be covered by donations, sponsorships (patreon) or merch - you got nation-state actors (aka troll farms and content farms [1]) that churn out tons of content for free - classic print journalism has seen advertising income drastically collapse as ad budgets shifted towards the Internet - the tradition of reading a newspaper at breakfast has gone, either because people have no time for that any more or because they're reading on their phones - people lack the money to spend on newspapers - people are sick of being advertised to all the time, ad blockers significantly impact anything from web pages to Youtube All in all, high-quality long form journalism (especially investigative reporting) takes serious amounts of money, time and legal risk, but the finance base for this has gone down the drain. Some media has escaped the fate of their fellows by being bought up by some rich person, but that carries ethical challenges on its own. [1] https://money.cnn.com/interactive/media/the-macedonia-story/ https://money.cnn.com/interactive/media/the-macedonia-story/
- Waterluvian 3y agoI generally agree. But I see a lot of that as exacerbating symptoms, not cause. I still believe that demand comes before supply for this kind of thing. There’s a mental market for the pablum.
- throw0101d 3y ago> you got amateurs (bloggers, social media) being capable of running very fast and high-quality journalism on very low budgets (as the barrier to entry is extremely low, all you need for a vlog these days is a basic iPhone) What is the definition of "journalism"? Are there particular examples that you are thinking of for these 'amateurs'? How many 'amateurs' have broken stories which involved going into archives, chasing down leads, interviewing the principles involved, etc? As compared to [vb]logs (re-)reporting a story that was originally broken by a 'non-amateur'?
- snide 3y agoSeeing Sports Illustrated fall is a bummer. This was a mainstay, important read for millions back in the day. As a kid I grew up with SI, and the brand was so large there were even offshot magazines (SI for Kids...etc). My childhood was spent pouring over Sports, Nature, and Gaming magazines. While the web has provide a lot of that information in a much easier to search way, the discovery mechanisms that a smaller, but more focused set of media brands created were fantastic. You could rely on people having read / scene the larger touchstones of culture and it led to more connection. There are a lot of great things about the Internet and the specification of news / knowledge, but part of me worries that the division we're seeing in society are a direct result of folks not having reliable sources of shared experience. I don't know how to solve it. I worked in publishing for over a dozen years, and it only seems to be getting worse and worse.
- mlrtime 3y agoI'm not a huge sports fan. I'd rather play than watch but I did have a SI subscription as a kid. As a teen, I thougfhrly enjoyed the swimsuit editions. However, IMHO the article has missed it. Article claims that SI is a failure because "Real Journalism" is dying and SI should have used real writers. I don't think so, SI has been falling (like a lot of print) since the internet. Sports people want to read and talk about sports, SI was that outlet and they've lost the marginal subscriber. Now there are limitless places to go for a sports fix. SI was doomed from the beginning and lack of "Real Journalism" wouldn't have saved it. The real interesting question is does the brand still have value (Maybe not 1M/month) and what to do with it now.
- ghaff 3y agoI don't remember during exactly what period I had an SI subscription (I was much more into sports long ago) but at one point I probably was subscribing to 20 magazines. Today I don't pay for one. (Though I do have a couple of digital subscriptions I pay for.) And I probably dropped many of them before the quality deterioration became obvious. They just didn't fill a real need any longer and they were just piling up on my coffee table.
- tqi 3y ago
- shmatt 3y agoThis has nothing to do with journalism and everything to do with the term “brand recognition” The boomer concept of the 80s that we can’t get rid of. People still think something is high or low quality because some licensed logo of a company that ceased operations 20 years ago is on it That Calvin Klein jacket from tj maxx? No calvin Klein employee had ever even seen its design before. Your Toshiba TV was not made or designed by Toshiba We need to step away from the 80s and start focusing on quality instead of logo playing cards being traded between billionaires
- glitchc 3y agoIt calls into the question the very notion of teams in all professional sports. What does it mean to support a team when a quarter of the players change every year, and the entire roster is brand new every five years? What's left in ManchesterU if you take away the brand? All that means to say is that too much money is tied to branding, and individuals, corporations and countries will continue to ride this cash cow for as long as it lasts.
- frangolino 3y agohow can customers quickly assess quality of a good? brands had a reputation
- joebob42 3y agoThe nice thing about brands is it (used to be) a good standin for quality. Costco is still sort of like this for me. If I need $thing, I can just go get whichever brand of thing Costco is selling. There are usually only a couple choices, and they're generally pretty decent and good value. In the absence of branding like this, I need to go make an informed decision on every purchase, in product areas I'm often not particularly familiar with or qualified to judge. The dazzling array of widgets available in whatever category doesn't help if I can't tell a good from a bad widget, can't trust online reviews, and can't take "made by $brand_i_know" as a badge of it probably being fine. I agree we've lost this to a large degree, but I do think it's more of a shame than you seem to be suggesting.
- 3y ago
- jacknews 3y ago[flagged]
- slothtrop 3y agocommies have been parroting that wishful thinking since the beginning
- brodouevencode 3y ago...and yet so many journalists these days are wishing communism on societies.
- fullshark 3y agoMagazines are dead, go to a grocery store and see what's on display in the checkout line. The most recent iteration of Sports Illustrated was just about squeezing the last ounce of revenue you could from an already dead brand/product.
- mlrtime 3y agoI'd hargue SI has brand value for now. It needs to be reinvented away from print magazine.
- apocalyptic0n3 3y agoEven if they were to reinvent away from print, the market is so congested they'd never find a customer base again. Sports news can be had, for free, from hundreds, perhaps thousands of websites. The big news gets broken, again for free, on Twitter by the likes of Woj/Chams (NBA). Long form sports journalism already has a large, struggling entity: The Athletic. Beyond that, every major publication in the country covers long form sports stories in some shape or form. Highlights and analysis can be found on YouTube (for free) and the websites, podcasts, and social media accounts for each league/team. Not to mention the heavyweights like ESPN and TSN, who also focus more on the entertainment side of it. Then you have discussion, which already freely happens on Reddit, various blogs, Twitter, and other social media. The market is incredibly saturated from every single angle. Even with the brand value of Sports Illustrated, finding a profitable niche would be incredibly difficult.
- rufus_foreman 3y ago>> Long form sports journalism already has a large, struggling entity: The Athletic Struggling? The New York Times paid over half a billion dollars for it in 2022.
- graphe 3y ago> The company began exploring a sale to a larger media company in 2021, following continued unprofitability, driven by high expenses and reliance on venture capital funding instead of operational revenue. As of that time, the site had 1.2 million subscribers and $80 million in revenue, having raised $55 million in venture capital funding. The article on Wikipedia said NYT laid off it's own sports writers. Why would it need to be sold if it wasn't known to be struggling?
- whitej125 3y agoMatt Levine (of MoneyStuff/BBG) covered the events[1] of the oddness that led up to the eventual layoffs. His perspective seems to convey that the layoffs were not a "AI can replace staff" play but more so... there was a lot of shady (or mis-executed) corporate dealing and the layoffs were tied to Arena losing its license. The reason behind that license loss is a contradiction between the two sources. TechDirt seems to imply that it was a renegotiation tactic where as Levine seems to imply that it was chaotic at post-Merger Arena and they were just dropping the ball on their debt and licensing obligations. Maybe a little of column A and a little of column B. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-01-23/sports-illustrated-s-strange-merger https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-01-23/sports...
- dpflan 3y agoThis comment should be way higher, the details by Levine reveal much more about the situation.
- basch 3y agoThere is also the fact that this incarnation of Sports Illustrated is only about 4 years old. The previous company got gutted in 2019. https://www.wsj.com/articles/sports-illustrateds-new-operator-to-lay-off-more-than-40-employees-11570073983 https://www.wsj.com/articles/sports-illustrateds-new-operato... Whatever existed from 2019-2023 was SI in Name Only. The website was absolute trash. I'm guilty of not having picked up the paper magazine in that timeframe.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoIt really is a shame that some random entity can "rent" the brand name from some holding corporation and pretend to be "Sports Illustrated."
- coffeeisgud4u 3y agoSI hardly has been "real" journalism for quite some time. They slowly let journalist go over the last two decades and has shifted its coverage over time to match what internet-based sites were doing. In doing so, it killed whatever advantage they had analyzing sports - you could get season preview articles from other avenues as good or better than SI. Nevermind the disaster of its "Swimsuit" issues (which, honestly, is good riddance, but it was a known part of the brand.)
- MattGaiser 3y agoI am not an avid sports follower, so I only know of the brand from the Swimsuit editions. I am surprised to learn they were once somewhat journalistic in nature.
- basch 3y agoIt was a weekly magazine. Part of its allure was how topical and quick the turnaround was. Transitioning it to monthly was a billed as a blood letting but really a nail.
- cobrabyte 3y agoThe magazine chugged along for decades before changing its identity and recipe to appease a small group of non-customers. It's no surprise it's going away.
- coffeeisgud4u 3y ago[flagged]
- Spivak 3y agoThis seems like a perfect case study of what happens when the actual business, farming eyeballs to sell ads, is at odds with the customer and the core product and enshittification, the act of implementing customer-observable cost cutting and hoping the brand carries you. Clearly a deadly combination as you knocked out both pillars propping the company up. If you keep the quality up you can likely get away with your thumb on the ad button but if you drop the quality at the same time there's no value left.
- eitally 3y agoIt's not at all a collapse of journalism. It's a collapse of the print periodical with a content focus on topical current events. There just isn't a need for that specific kind of journalism anymore, and for the majority of topics that do demand journalistic investment, it makes 100% more sense to focus on online than print anyway (looking at things like The Economist and Foreign Policy, or The Atlantic and New Yorker). I'd argue high quality journalistic work is supremely valuable but it needs to be targeted, and lots of legacy news properties (NYT, The Guardian, etc) have been doing that -- online, often with multimedia and interactive stories. It's the same with scientific journals. Yes, print journals are a thing, but who actually uses them anymore, even in higher ed? The challenge, of course, is convincing netizens to pay for your content, or freeing it in a way that isn't alienating to readers. (fwiw, I subscribe to a couple of print magazines for my 1st grader. I think they're great for kids!)
- rwmj 3y agoPrivate Eye (in the UK) is thriving as a paper publication without very much of an online presence. Audited circulation of nearly a quarter of a million (https://www.abc.org.uk/product/3379 https://www.abc.org.uk/product/3379).
- some_random 3y agoWhat's the consumer base like? I highly doubt that 20-40 year olds are reading it much if that's the case
- s_dev 3y agoThere is a Michellin starred restaurant operating in Greenland that people travel all that way to. Sometimes certain things succeed despite choosing circumstances that work against them and not because of those choices. That same restaurant would be making a lot more money if it moved to New York city but the Chef probably doesn't want that. Private Eye would have more money and more eyeballs if it had a sufficient online presence but the simple answer is Ian Hislop doesn't want that and I would imagine he would say "We're doing just fine, having not invested a lot in to online presence for Private Eye" and he'd be right. What works for Private Eye might not work for the New York Times.
- 082349872349872 3y agoPublishers have never been journalists. For a while, they needed journalists because every genre of print newspaper/magazine had an empirically determined percentage of ads over which subscriptions dropped, so there almost always had to be some content as filler to cut the ads down to that ratio. That equilibrium seems to have gone, in a way René Thom might have predicted.
- ghaff 3y agoContent being the thing you put around the ads (the ad hole as a former boss called it) was a truer description in things like trade rags and Computer Shopper. IMO, it's a bit uncharitable for magazines like SI in their prime although, of course, their revenues were heavily dependent as well--even if they sold subscriptions.
- 082349872349872 3y agoWhen would "SI in their prime" be? It looks like Luce really did care about the editorial side of the house (rather than just grudgingly grant it its independence), but he died in 1967...
- ghaff 3y agoI'm not sure how long I subscribed afterwards but SI in the late 70s/early 80s at least was still pretty good in my memory.
- fortran77 3y agoAll the people here who don't want to pay for news, entertainment, or music are to blame.
- krapp 3y agoAll of the corporations that treated the internet like a wild west gravy train of free money where quality doesn't matter, and that poisoned it with dark patterns, SEO, gimmicks, parasitic advertising and now AI, are to blame for not making their news, entertainment or music worth paying for. Don't offer free lemonade, piss in our mouths then expect payment and a gratuity. That's not how anything works.
- fortran77 3y agoDid the traditional print magazines do that?
- krapp 3y agoNot to nearly the same degree. Having to physically print magazines with a limited run and budget means quality matters more than it does online, where everything is ephemeral, because the costs are higher. Compare the Wall Street Journal when it was in print to the clickbait on the site now.
- CM30 3y agoOr perhaps there's just more competition in each of those areas, and you don't need to pay anymore? If hundreds or thousands of people and businesses are giving something away for free, and your company is charging money for the same thing, it shouldn't be too surprising that it's having trouble competing with the former.
- hedora 3y agoWelcome to the age of zombie copyright holding companies. National Geographic also went out of business last year, in that they now employ zero writers (Disney is the majority owner). Warner Brothers Discovery Corp is performing a similar wind-down of the operations they own (they cut $3B from production budgets last year), and is hoping to apply the same thing to Paramount's holdings after their proposed acquisition is approved. In particular, CNN and CBS will be owned by the resulting company, and there will be plenty more journalists to fire at the resulting conglomerate (WBD laid off a bunch of reporters at CNN last year as part of a pivot to cater to the Fox News audience). The above is an obvious-in-hindsight side effect of having copyrights that basically never expire. Maybe after they've all burned themselves to ash (and stop bribing congress) we'll be able to repeal the Sonny Bono / Micky Mouse Protection Act.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> The above is an obvious-in-hindsight side effect of having copyrights that basically never expire. Shorter copyright was not going to save CNN/CBS’s video news model. It’s an enormously inefficient way to get information.
- dirtyhippiefree 3y agoNews aggregators using video as news is actually on the rise, not the decline…
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThat might be true, but is the revenue from that use offsetting loss of revenue from linear TV advertising (from pre smartphone years)? I doubt it, but I would be interesting in being shown that I’m wrong.
- ProjectArcturis 3y agoThe names of businesses are trademarks, not copyrights. They never expire as long as the business keeps operating. Which is as it should be -- should I be able to open a restaurant called McDonald's just because the real McDonald's has been in business for 75 years?
- hamburga 3y agoMy 11-year-old subscribes to SI and loves it and will miss it. Yes, there are other sources of sports news online, but I don’t want my kids clutching their iPad and Chromebook every waking minute. Print journalism/media is an antidote to the distraction epidemic and our capitalist overlords are actively hollowing it all out. But at the end of the day, we’re the consumers, and we still have the choice to pay for professional journalism if we care about the truth.
- dhfbshfbu4u3 3y ago[flagged]
- dhfbshfbu4u3 3y agoPretty sure that every time this comment gets downvoted, a trust fund brunchlord gets their options poached.
- some_random 3y agoAs someone who grew up past these days, I'm curious how much the swimsuit edition pushed SI subscriptions. I'd imagine that in a world of print, publishing plausibly deniable softcore porn would be a huge advantage that is completely irrelevant now.
- anotheruser13 3y agoIn a past life, I worked for Time Inc. The SI swimsuit issue was a big driver for subscriptions, especially when the premium was an SI swimsuit calendar. The football phone, not so much.
- tqi 3y ago> As a result journalism — sports or otherwise — is steadily being replaced by a parade of automated gibberish, clickbait, well-funded propaganda, and marketing, and it’s getting increasingly difficult to find anybody with the ethics and resources interested in reversing — or even combating — the trajectory. Journalists love to paint themselves as noble victims of technology, as if they bear no responsibility for the polarization and resulting erosion of public trust in authority. Sports journalists where especially guilty of cultivating cozy relationships with their subjects (access journalism), pushing their own pre determined narratives, and blurring the lines between reporting and opinion. It's not hard to understand why people have turned to other sources.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sschueller 3y agoIt's also laziness and pressure to output more and more.
- zdragnar 3y agoLol, the print version barely had any content at all. SI and GQ have been sending me magazines every other month or so for two years between the two of them, trying to get me to subscribe. One upshot here is at least SI will stop spamming me via snail mail.
- infamouscow 3y agoLaziness and financial pressure don't explain why the SI swimsuit issue deviated away from their winning formula just to appease minority groups never interesting in SI to begin with. It doesn't take a genius to know alienating the majority of your audience is bad for business.
- RickJWagner 3y agoBud Light management has entered the chat.
- horns4lyfe 3y agoThe only thing it shows is the collapse of Sports Illustrated. Just look at any of their recent magazines, especially the swimsuit issues to see how far they’ve gone out of their way to alienate their audience. I mean, one of the covers for the swimsuits this year was Martha Stewart. Who is that for?
- mp05 3y ago> especially the swimsuit issues to see how far they’ve gone out of their way to alienate their audience. Horny 11 year olds?
- horns4lyfe 3y agoHorny dudes in general, ya. That’s their audience, guys who like sports and attractive women. Again, who is the audience for Martha Stewart on the cover?
- cogman10 3y agoThe last people to buy magazines, old horny dudes.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> I mean, one of the covers for the swimsuits this year was Martha Stewart. Who is that for? I mean, it'd fit the demographics of anyone still buying Sports Illustrated swimsuit magazines pretty well. Anyone under 60 presumably just... finds porn online.
- horns4lyfe 3y agoOld dudes don’t all of a sudden stop wanting to see young women in swimsuits though. There was also a trans woman on one cover. So again, who is that for, that would actually pay for it?
- tim333 3y ago
- graphe 3y ago[flagged]
- Solvency 3y ago"the propaganda journalists put themselves into" — care to elaborate?
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- graphe 3y agoI've edited it, thanks for letting me know.
- infamouscow 3y agoNYT: "Let me state as clearly as I can: My father was not involved in my business." Hunter: "Let me state as clearly as I can: My father was not financially involved in my business." https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/13/us/politics/hunter-biden-impeachment-testimony.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/13/us/politics/hunter-biden-... --- The NYT only corrected the story because of being called out for flagrant propaganda. It's a shame I cannot legally say what should happen to these people.
- Simulacra 3y agoJournalism is no longer a noble calling, to report the facts and inform the public. The people who are going into journalism, and the companies who are masquerading as sources of news and information, are more interested in propaganda and a specific point of view. Journalist motives cannot be trusted anymore.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- infamouscow 3y ago[flagged]
- PaulHoule 3y agoAround Ithaca, NY the local government is thinking about defunding the daily "paper of record" (which gets paid to run legal announcements) because it has been superseded by weekly papers and online local news. The Ithaca Journal seems to get thinner every week and, besides those legal notices and the spam want-ads to recruit you to cash checks for money laundering, is mostly full of syndicated news. 20 years ago I would always run into reporters from the Ithaca Journal at public meetings but now they are absent. The good news is that there are two weekly print newspapers https://www.tompkinsweekly.com/ https://www.tompkinsweekly.com/ https://www.ithaca.com/ https://www.ithaca.com/ and at least one pure online play http://ithacavoice.org/ http://ithacavoice.org/ not to mention another weekly paper oriented entirely towards entertainment, culture, dining and stuff like that. If you accept the idea that the generation rate of local news in a small city is too low to justify a daily paper than the transition from daily to weekly which improved economics is a good thing. Seen that way we're in a golden age of journalism in Ithaca. I've seen weekly papers be successful in many other locations but usually in the form of the "entertainment, culture, and dining" paper. Here in Tompkins though our weeklies are so good who needs a daily?
- DoingSomeThings 3y agoHere in Texas the Community Impact newspaper has been growing with a monthly print edition. They serve local content with multiple editions per city. ~50% of the content is broader city related and ~50% specific to the suburb / neighborhood. I find it incredibly helpful to keep up with local govt, business development, etc. It's free and ships via mail monthly. I never signed up, it simply shows up. Their website[1] says they currently publish 40+ distinct editions across Dallas, Houston, Austin, San Antonio. I have no idea how their finances work, but they seemingly found a model that could possibly be duplicated elsewhere. [1] https://communityimpact.com/corporate-about/ https://communityimpact.com/corporate-about/
- PaulHoule 3y agoFor one thing I think advertisers get the same amount of value out of an ad in a weekly that they get in a daily.
- mihaaly 3y agoForgive my ignorance towards watching and reading about sports, so being someone for whom the Sports Illustrated broke the surface of attention in the past four decades only when clickbait portals reported about the new year's swimsuit calendar or when it was mentioned - for the very same reason - in teenager movies from Hollywood but this all leads to being very content and a bit bored when the demise of journalism is illustrated by the fate of Sports Illustrated, that is now known for "been tossed around between a rotating crop of dodgy international middlemen for whom journalism was an afterthought". Probably there could be better illustration than Sports Illustrated for the collapse of classic journalism, other than the tired and loong worn out Sports Illustrated? (which feels like being a string of letters only, the aging and drying out milk cow of the expressively named Authentic Brands Group that sounds like a warehouse of famous whatevers for shady whoevers trying to shave pennies off of the memory of once significant things that meant something for people once, but not anymore, not really, stopped having content but still having a nostalgic and fading facade)
- bigtex 3y agohttps://www.si.com/extra-mustard/2023/05/15/kim-petras-featured-2023-si-swimsuit-cover-model https://www.si.com/extra-mustard/2023/05/15/kim-petras-featu...
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoThe concept that sports news constitutes journalism is a bigger sign that there was never anything real to begin with. Might as well say that the decline of seventeen magazine and daily bread (rollerblading magazine) were indications of journalism’s decay. Journalism is about holding powerful interests accountable A popular sports tabloid - even if it does do deep “reporting” isn’t journalism by any stretch
- JKCalhoun 3y ago"The Arena Group", brand renting.... It doesn't sound like "Sports Illustrated" is journalism. Unless they were trying to make the point that brand-name-uber-alles was the decline of journalism it sounds like the publication should just die already. I don't doubt that actual journalism is being eviscerated but they didn't give me any good examples in their piece.
- 6R1M0R4CL3 3y agowhen you start putting half naked chicks on the cover instead of putting women that are real athletes... you've jumped the shark. the world if filled with amazing female athletes. you can do a mix of 50/50 for covers and put real people doing real sports. what did we get as cover of SI ? a freakin kardashian.
- lifeisstillgood 3y agoSome slightly random thoughts I have come to realise that Journalism is best seen as “data labelling” for the giant LLM we call “society”. Society has to have some data points it sees as truth and not truth. Trade journalism seems the sensible level but honestly I Expect to see journalism in larger companies as management gets disaggregated - reporting on the politics and potentially going hand in hand with a rise in democratic workplaces
- milkytron 3y agoIdk about others, but I feel like journalism has gotten even better. For instance, Jon Bois has some absolutely incredibly well researched videos on YouTube that go deep into the history of sports teams, and there are relevant and easy to consume graphics that go along with the story. Just because print journalism struggles to compete and can't capture the majority of the sports media market like they used to, doesn't mean that journalism is collapsing.
- hereme888 3y agoSeems strange that no one has mentioned how SI went the PC route and started adding obese female models. Obviously that would drive men away. It's nature.
- graphe 3y agoHas that ever had a positive impact or is it a death spiral? From what I understand heavier models is more in demand from younger viewers.
- hereme888 3y agoFrom the responses I see in social media, people hate it. I don't understand how younger people demand obese models. Is it a "loud pc minority" making that demand? It's totally against the natural instinct and mating attractiveness of fit vs unfit. Especially teenagers who tend to be fitter than adults.
- graphe 3y agoBoth could be vocal minorities. I'm not sure what the impact of these models are: they're either a throw everything at the wall or giving up. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0042593 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... I've read and noticed that thin women and flat asses aren't popular anymore. Some men like the unnatural physiques according to plastic surgery. Younger people are more anxious, stressed, don't have a future to look forward to with home ownership and social media also hurts many. I have doubts that this helps but it kept being repeated so I thought it might have some benefit. Was it actually the negative reaction for publicity?!
- hereme888 3y agoThat's an interesting study paper. I think they're making a mistake in wording the conclusion with so much certainty based on the tiny sample size though. I'd say big companies that can confidently stratify the age of users in their porn search preferences, or even social media users, would be a good way to get a more valid sample size.