7 ms·
Dutch Police regularly force people to give up footage from doorbell cameras
- rusk 3y agoYou can be certain they’ve dotted their eyes, crossed their tees, all oversight has been sought and nobody’s rights have been violated. I’ve worked with Dutch firms before and there’s no short cuts where privacy is concerned.
- berkes 3y agoI'm not sure -honestly- if this is sarcasm or truly how you feel it is.
- rusk 3y agoLived experience bro. Sorry if maybe you’ve some sort of a counterpoint behind all that sarcasm that I’ve offended.
- belter 3y ago"Some Dutch companies invading their workers’ privacy" - https://www.iamexpat.nl/expat-info/dutch-expat-news/some-dutch-companies-invading-their-workers-privacy https://www.iamexpat.nl/expat-info/dutch-expat-news/some-dut... "Dutch companies also collected tweets and violate privacy law" - https://malwaretips.com/threads/dutch-companies-also-collected-tweets-and-violate-privacy-law.120212/ https://malwaretips.com/threads/dutch-companies-also-collect... "Dutch National Police violated data privacy in using European information system" - https://nltimes.nl/2023/12/20/dutch-national-police-violated-data-privacy-using-european-information-system https://nltimes.nl/2023/12/20/dutch-national-police-violated... "Political parties violating privacy law with tracking cookies" - https://nltimes.nl/2023/11/08/political-parties-violating-privacy-law-tracking-cookies https://nltimes.nl/2023/11/08/political-parties-violating-pr...
- yurishimo 3y agoFrom my experience, a lot of companies will pay lip service to privacy, but when it comes time to comply, things can drag on. Just enough plausible deniability until someone holds your nose to the grindstone.
- berkes 3y agoI'm Dutch and my liberal and even anarchist background makes me angry about these trends. But this is what Dutch people want. Increased and more heavy handed Police enforcement, less oversight, and broader duties is exactly what voters have voted for. Dutch elections have moved the political landscape to the far right. And in the Netherlands (and many EU countries), "far right" goes hand-in-hand with increased and heavier police presence (though often without increased funding). Edit: this has been an actual "promise" to voters by parties who were voted in place on a.o. this exact promise. So I'm not suprised. And also think "this is exactly what we asked for".
- 127361 3y agoThe media is scaring them into accepting these measures, which is standard practice in totalitarian states, by the way. Create a climate of fear, and introduce draconian measures which the public will then accept. And that is how a democratic society slowly becomes authoritarian, it plays out very slowly over decades.
- berkes 3y agoIs it "the media" though? In the Netherlands, "the Media" and "far right" are often direct opposites, at least, that's how the far right wants it to look. Data shows that "far right" gets more media time than many other parts of the political spectrum, yet they keep saying this media "censors" them. https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=wSKV99EAAAAJ&citation_for_view=wSKV99EAAAAJ:u5HHmVD_uO8C https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&h...
- account-5 3y agoThis is a non story. Of course the police are able to collect evidence during criminal investigations. Brexit aside I'm sure the Dutch have this enacted in law like the UK. The police are obviously going to ask nicely and if that fails force you by legislation they are empowered to use. And if they're sending you legal speak forms that's more likely procedure to keep things above board rather than something malicious to scare you. Get a grip!
- Someone 3y ago> And if they're sending you legal speak forms that's more likely procedure to keep things above board rather than something malicious to scare you Google translate of the original article (https://www-bnr-nl.translate.goog/nieuws/juridisch/10538281/deurbelcamera-maakt-burgers-tot-doelwit-dwangmiddelen-politie?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=nl https://www-bnr-nl.translate.goog/nieuws/juridisch/10538281/...) says “There is a legal reason why the police use coercive measures so liberally. “The police must make progress,” the Public Prosecutor's Office indicates. If the police voluntarily requests images, they may not be usable as evidence.” So, yes, there seems to be a legal reason. Not that I understand it, but it may be because it’s not entirely legal, maybe even fully illegal for citizens to video the street in front of their house because of privacy laws.
- account-5 3y agoI'm unsure of the legal side here but in the UK the police are required to provide proof of where the evidence came from and it's provenance for it to be admissible in court. This can mean the person in control of the evidence becoming a witness to speak in court to the veracity of the of the evidence, especially if only a copy was taken from the owner so as not to leave the owner without the original thing (ie, a phone used to record something).
- crote 3y agoIt's not a "non story". As the article states, refusal can result in a fine or three-month prison sentence. If you film a crime, the defendant will be provided with your full name and address. Considering that Dutch gangs have gotten quite trigger-happy over the last few years and routinely assassinate lawyers, (assumed) whistleblowers, and witnesses, if your camera happens to be recording at just the wrong time you might have too choose between either 3 months of jail time or getting killed.
- duxup 3y agoOne thing about this topic is that while I worry about these sorts of things... I also suspect that most people willingly hand over footage. I just don't think your average doorbell camera owner cares quite like some of us do about the ramifications. The email in this case(s) sounds off but I wonder if most folks would have sent in the video anyway. Also: How often is this footage "useful" for anything? I have some family where they outfitted their house with a lot of cameras. There is a fairly high level of crime in their area, and a moderate amount of serious crime. The local cops ask for footage fairly frequently and they're happy to give it. I just wonder if it is useful all that often. I see some footage show up once in a while but it's hardly ever the kind of evidence that proves much at all.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI’ve got a couple of cameras and while they are useful for knowing something is immediately up, the footage isn’t useful since the police aren’t interested in going after petty thefts these days. The footage would only be part of an investigation that isn’t going to happen. Since a lot of our problems are just people high on drugs looking for porch booty, I wish I could have some verbal message go out when it spotted someone (like “get off my lawn!”). It just has to take the place of me yelling out my window at 2AM to ward someone off.
- the-dude 3y agoIt is called a dog.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI don’t feel like I have the resources to keep a dog humanely, so I’d rather not. This is a problem easily solved by tech.
- toast0 3y agoIf your "get off my lawn" is anything like the talking car alarms of my youth, it's going to attract more negative attention than positive results.
- thriftwy 3y agoI wonder if there is a FlightRadar24 for CCTV sharing.
- crote 3y agoSomething similar exists in The Netherlands. It's called "Camera in Beeld". Basically, private citizens can register their camera with the police so they know who to ask when looking for footage.
- thriftwy 3y agoIt should be a two-way street: As long as I am contributing, I should be able to access other citizens' footage.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fjfaase 3y agoIn the Netherlands it is not allowed to make recording of public spaces in the manner that these doorbell cameras can do when they view a public space. At least not with a permit, and, probably, also not without a sign that a camera surveillance is active. Neither are you allowed to store those recordings. The solution seems to be to use a doorbell camera that does not record (store) any footage and that is shielded and/or focused such that public spaces are not included.
- warp 3y agoHas that changed recently? (I haven't lived in the Netherlands for 10 years). AFAIK it is perfectly legal to do that if you believe you need it for security. https://blog.iusmentis.com/2019/12/18/voor-de-laatste-keer-de-openbare-weg-filmen-met-je-securitycamera-mag-als-dat-nodig-is/ https://blog.iusmentis.com/2019/12/18/voor-de-laatste-keer-d...
- fjfaase 3y agoThanks for your addition. I understand that you do not need a permit, but you do need to make clear that the camera is needed for some security reason. I think that many people who buy a doorbell camera are not doing that for a security reason and probably do not have a good security reason, but just install it because it is handy, for example, to talk with people delivery goods or answer strangers ringing the bell without having to leave the living room.
- Vinnl 3y agoThe actual solution that people go for, of course, is to do it anyway.
- the-dude 3y agoIn The Netherlands ( this is where Dutch people live ) it is not legal to point a security camera at the public road/space. The link is in Dutch, sorry about that. https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/overvallen-straatroof-en-woninginbraak/regels-cameratoezicht https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/overvallen-straatro...
- Vinnl 3y agoIn theory, at least (and there's an exception if there's no other option, I believe). In practice, there are camera doorbells everywhere, and they're pointing at the street.
- yourusername 3y agoYou know that law is barely enforced. So many houses with cameras obviously filming the public road.
- jonasdegendt 3y agoI'm in Belgium and we have the same law, so I'm willing to assume the nuances of this law are also similar: Not being allowed to point at public space only applies to always-on security cameras, which a video doorbell technically is not. We've had video doorbells for a good while and this was never an issue until Ring and the likes came along with cloud backups that essentially make a video doorbell a security camera. I'm afraid this is one of these laws that'll never get enforced or reviewed, especially considering it's turning out to be in law enforcement's advantage.
- Fradow 3y agoIt's not only in the Netherlands, but in the European Union, as this stems from the GDPR. That particular principle of data minimization regarding cameras filming public space seems to be mostly enforced in Spain, according to https://www.enforcementtracker.com/ https://www.enforcementtracker.com/ (search for "camera")
- turquoisevar 3y agoThe source article the English article is based on actually touched on this. It seems that enforcement of the privacy law is purposefully lacking so that the cops can white wash, what would otherwise be illegal, through seizure.
- CursedUrn 3y agoI'd be more concerned over the massive amount of cheap Chinese cameras that have flooded the market and are likely sending video to the CCP.
- severino 3y agoThe same claims can be made about cameras made in the west, and as somebody living in the west, I prefer to have my video streamed to some random Chinese guy than to somebody from my government.
- bobdvb 3y agoIt's a good point about paranoia, the random Chinese guys don't give a shit about you, you're generally insignificant. To your own government you are slightly insignificant but they may take more of an interest.
- ta1243 3y ago> The same claims can be made about cameras made in the west They can, and those are valid claims.
- hcfman 3y agoScare mongering
- berkes 3y agoI've always found "Chinese state surveillance" a strange argument. As long as I don't visit China, why would I bother more about chinese databases that I end up in, through my Huawei router or Ali-express electronics (non of which I have. It's purely fictional), than about national, Europol, or American databases that I end up through my American-synced google photos/docs/contacts/gmail, or European agencies filming me on the street? Put differently: The CCP getting my data is creepy, but hardly a problem in practice, whereas the EU or America getting that data has direct and practical implications. (TBF: I replaced my Huawei router with a Fritz! Box because I'm afraid of leaking to the CCP. I don't use TikTok but instead Youtube/Reddit/etc for the same reason but if I think about it: did I really improve my privacy and security of my online data?)
- jacknews 3y agoIt could be worse: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crocodile_(Black_Mirror) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crocodile_(Black_Mirror)
- eythian 3y agoI'm surprised it's not mentioned that doorbell cameras that record are of dubious legality. It's not permitted (afaik) to record public spaces like that, https://www.bnnvara.nl/kassa/artikelen/de-slimme-deurbel-rukt-op-hoe-zit-het-met-camerabeelden-en-privacy https://www.bnnvara.nl/kassa/artikelen/de-slimme-deurbel-ruk... "Je mag alleen het privéterrein van je eigen woning filmen met de camera van de slimme deurbel" / "You can only film the private space of your own residence with the camera on a smart doorbell"
- anonzzzies 3y agoYep, I had the police ask to check if my camera wasn't filming the street. So feels at least in my hood they check.
- stronglikedan 3y agoConsidering where I live almost every front door faces the street, and the doorbells are next to the doors, that is a very strange proposition to me.
- incomingpain 3y agoIf you have a security camera that likely has footage of a crime. Then you should give it up willingly to punish the criminals. Here in Canada, police have the opposite viewpoint: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12953465/Canada-warn-videos-package-thieves-violation-privacy.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12953465/Canada-war... So your package is stolen, you have video of the criminals. you post it online for the police to catch the criminals. The police punish you for violating the criminal's rights? lol what?
- master-lincoln 3y agoSeems fair. Right to privacy seems more important than a package. Police could still investigate if you hand the video to them and not the public.
- incomingpain 3y ago>Seems fair. Right to privacy seems more important than a package. Police could still investigate if you hand the video to them and not the public. Doorbell cameras are in public recordings with no reasonable expectation of privacy. They made the news because they are incorrect.
- ta1243 3y agoYou haven't linked to a reputable news source, but even they are not asserting there is a problem with recording and sending it to the police. The problem is posting it to everyone. That's the law in the UK too, not that anyone follows it.
- hcfman 3y agoFrom memory. And this could potentially be wrong, but I thought that a police officer explained to me once that for video evidence to be valid in court it had to be seized and not volunteered. So that this means in this context is that it's not personal, they just want the evidence to be usable in the end therefore it has to be technically seized, i.e. forced from you with an order. Even if you were volunteering it.
- hcfman 3y agoHowever... there are many more things in the Dutch criminal justice system to be worried about. They invented this word called "undermining", which is supposed to say that the criminal underworld is undermining society. It's really just inspired from the rights grab that the word "terrorists" gave after 9/11, and fact this seemed to have been formed around the same time and have been inspired by it. Anyway, they formed a way to deal with this "undermining" and that was by using a co-ordinated approach where there is an intelligence agency called "The RIEC" which is deliberated formed without a human legal representative which puts the whole structure outside of the law. You can't take them to court. They co-ordinate the activities of the police, the council, the tax department, a large list of entities that simply do as they are told from this organisation. And to go along with this they invented a concept called "An intervention", which is a activity by the co-ordinated parties that is supposed to "interfere" with organised crime. They have given up on actually finding evidence and convicting criminals they want to interfere with them. However, they also don't need evidence and who they target don't even have to be criminals, a hunch is good enough apparently. In order words whoever they wish, or perhaps anyone that sleighted or upset them as well. However, what an intervention can be and who it can apply to is very broad. So they can commit a series of criminal offences against innocent people and others (Colateral damage) with impunity. And they do... For years at a time, with no oversight and no consequences.
- ta1243 3y agoI'm more concerned with megascale foreign companies having access to them. At least the police are accountable to the government which is accountable to the people.
- two_handfuls 3y agoAnd that’s why we can’t have nice things.