13 ms·
Higher vehicle hoods significantly increase pedestrian deaths, study finds
- stjuma 3y agoLarge trucks are safer in intra-vehicle collisions. Imagine RAM vs sedan or average SUV. It’s completely rational to purchase the largest car you can afford, as long as you’re concerned about the safety of your family and yourself
- CRConrad 3y ago> as long as you’re ONLY > concerned about the safety of your family and yourself . There, FTFY. And yeah, most people are only concerned about that. That's why regulation is needed, for the common good.
- 082349872349872 3y agoInterestingly, agricultural tractors have evolved to have better sightlines. Could that be because for these machines, the pedestrian deaths are usually members of the tractor drivers' family? https://www.profi.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/8/2020/06/25._john_deere_7r_350_dsc0355_tech.jpg?w=900 https://www.profi.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/8/2020/06/2... vs https://bigiron.blob.core.windows.net/public/items/72b53c753cc94c36a0d3a178ee255bd8/johndeere7200tractor_881324e1fbd9457394a9c36e73aabffc.jpg https://bigiron.blob.core.windows.net/public/items/72b53c753...
- porphyra 3y agoChildren keep getting killed by their own parents' SUVs though...
- mtoner23 3y agoSome SUVs even have front cameras now to help see children
- kayodelycaon 3y agoMine also has cameras and radars on the sides. Makes parking easier and backing out safer. The radars can see speeding cars in the parking lot before I can. :)
- Swizec 3y ago> Could that be because for these machines, the pedestrian deaths are usually members of the tractor drivers' family I have a different guess after seeing tractors in use as a kid: Driving tractors is a high precision affair. You're moving around expensive equipment that you don't want to bump. You're plowing next to all sorts of hazards you don't want to fall into. You have to park within an inch of attachments before hooking them on. Good sight lines help with all this.
- riversflow 3y agoAlso, tractors are built to do work, not keep their occupants safe in a crash.
- trgn 3y ago> not keep their occupants safe in a crash. perfect expression of the tragedy of the commons. Until there's top down government intervention, people choose to be either part of the problem or part of the solution.
- NikkiA 3y agoNot totally true, tractors gained roll bars and roll cages 40 or so years ago for a reason, and it was safety.
- alan-hn 3y agoOne could say that navigating a large vehicle through streets populated by humans should be considered a high precision affair, or is the difference expensive equipment vs human lives?
- Swizec 3y ago> is the difference expensive equipment vs human lives? The difference is in safety margins. You really shouldn't drive a vehicle to within 2cm of any object on public streets. Not even while parking. 0.5m (2ft) is about the closest you should ever drive your car to anything really. Whereas for a tractor getting within 2cm is normal operating procedure. You won't be able to grab a 500kg (1100lb) attachment and drag it over to your tractor because you stopped too far away.
- trgn 3y agoOne of the reason I'm holding on to an old car, apart from out of spite, is the big windows and fantastic visibility. It's like stepping into a sunroom compared to new cars.
- kube-system 3y agoAgricultural tractors aren't made with any consideration for pedestrian safety. The reason they have good visibility is because that makes them easier to use, and there is no other competing reason not to surround the driver with a lot of glass. Passenger vehicles have other requirements that complicate this: 1. They must be attractive enough to sell in volume to the end buyer 2. They require large A-pillars to absorb crash impacts You could make an SUV that looks big fish bowl, but it would be difficult to simultaneously achieve safety targets and be a commercial success.
- alan-hn 3y agoI'm sure you could achieve safety targets with a vehicle that was safe for those outside of it as well, perhaps safety for your children crossing the road should be attractive to consumers?
- kube-system 3y agoSedans, hatchbacks, and wagons are those vehicles. They are slipping in sales compared to SUVs despite having better pedestrian safety. People have many priorities when buying a vehicle, and most people simply don't think they're at risk of running over their own kid, until they do.
- alan-hn 3y agoPeople are really good at being wrong about things, especially as evidenced by how many people do run over theirs and other peoples kids
- matsemann 3y agoLondon has enforced a Direct Vision Standard [1 example image] for big vehicles. I hope my city will soon as well. Having large trucks, trailers etc. in the city with no visibility to pedestrians is a death trap. My city's new trash truck [2]. Instead of the standard "high" trailer seating above the engine, it's now down on a pedestrian level and can see clearly in what's normally a "blind spot" when turning right. [1]: https://fncdn.blob.core.windows.net/web-clean/1/root/direct-vision-standard.jpg https://fncdn.blob.core.windows.net/web-clean/1/root/direct-... [2]: https://storage.googleapis.com/smallstep/sites/33/2022/02/Renovasjonsbil-som-star-parkert-pa-VF47_Mars_2020-9-of-7.jpg https://storage.googleapis.com/smallstep/sites/33/2022/02/Re...
- astrolx 3y agoNo sh*t sherlock! As a pedestrian who found himself on the receiving end of a hood and survived via a last-second jump to end up on top of the said hood, I certainly concur.
- porphyra 3y agoVans are a lot better for both transporting people (more spacious compared to SUVs) and goods (easier loading and protected from the weather compared to pickups), plus of course having vastly better visibility. It always seems odd how trucks and SUVs are seen as status symbols in the US whereas in, say, Hong Kong, it is the MPV that is the status symbol. I suppose certain tax and emissions regulations in favor of trucks also contribute to their popularity.
- RangerScience 3y agoAFAIK, exactly this - something about how trucks and SUVs are classified differently and so have different emission standards, which results in other effects that are then appealing to consumers. Plus, of course, marketing.
- toast0 3y agoMinivans are light trucks for fleet purposes, so they can also get bigger engines and what not, if that's what people are looking for.
- riversflow 3y agoVans are not better for goods as a universal rule, they are better for certain classes of goods. I do not want a yard of manure/dirt/gravel dumped in my van, but thats a common use of a pickup in my neck of the woods. Like extremely common. > Hong Kong Hot take: The Americas just aren't developed to the level of Eurasia, and we should stop pretending like they are.
- mlinhares 3y agoI think this is an incentives game, Americans have much more land and money to pay for expensive development (like suburbs) that just do not make financial sense in the EU or Asia in general, as they either lack land or it would be too expensive to pay for the infrastructure needed to make it all work. I also haven't met an American that has been to a high quality of life and walkable city in the EU and didn't come back with a changed perspective on what life could be like. Once you visit places like London, Paris, Barcelona, Berlin, Amsterdam and the like and stay there for a while you rethink the suburban life. I'm in the burbs because having small kids in big US cities is super shitty and expensive but as soon as they get older the goal is to find a nice city to move to. Either here or in Europe.
- baggachipz 3y agoYeah but the drivers get to cosplay as Rugged Men™. The only thing that'll reverse the trend and stop this from getting worse will be government regulation. Then come the cries of "Now they're taking our trucks!"
- KennyBlanken 3y agoEvery time I see someone behind the wheel of the absolute largest SUV a company offers, it's a small woman. Even as far back when SUVs first became a thing, I noticed that the smallest moms at school at the biggest SUVs. They love the "might" that a huge vehicle gives them.
- beretguy 3y agoSo… Rugged Women™, then.
- practicemaths 3y agoTBF Trucks and SUVs are relatively easier to drive in certain regards. Such as being able to see over parked traffic when making a turn. And I've found driving taller vehicles more comfortable for my back coincidentally.
- arwhatever 3y agoUntil the parked vehicles also become taller
- mecsred 3y agoWhen you become the parked traffic, how does anyone see over you? Guess they need an even taller vehicle.
- practicemaths 3y agoYup. There's certainly a feedback loop. Just stating things that make these larger vehicles more easier to drive, especially for women whom on average are generally shorter so, even with pumping the seat up it's still considerably harder to see around traffic.
- somedude895 3y agoDid we really need a study for this? What's next? A study to find out whether a hammer to the head or torso is more lethal than a hammer to the legs? What a total racket to spend money on something like this.
- anotherhue 3y agoYou may enjoy "Parachute use to prevent death and major trauma when jumping from aircraft: randomized controlled trial" https://www.bmj.com/content/363/bmj.k5094 https://www.bmj.com/content/363/bmj.k5094
- SECProto 3y agoIf one wanted to make a regulation regarding hood height, having a study like this as evidence would be critically important. Gut instinct alone wouldn't suffice
- tempestn 3y agoFirst, things that are obvious aren't always correct. It's better to rely on actual data than intuition alone. Second, the study not only gives the qualitative result that higher hoods are more dangerous, but also begins to quantify the effect, and can give an idea of the specific height at which the pedestrian danger begins to spike.
- tasty_freeze 3y agoI'll take your question seriously. Why do people do studies like this when the answer seems obvious? (1) It quantifies the seriousness of the problem. Does it increase the chance of death or significant injury by 1%, 10%, 50%? Without reading the article, what is the "obvious" answer to that question? (2) People believe many "obvious" things that aren't true. They are trivial to find simply by finding two groups with opposite beliefs on a subject and both think their conclusions are obvious. Eg, did the COVID-19 vaccines reduce or increase death rates? It seems obvious to me that it was a great benefit, but there are people going on TV claiming the vaccines killed millions of people. (3) Even in areas that aren't contentious, there are many widely believed but untested assumptions. If someone didn't spend the time and effort to validate those things, we might never find what is really true. 50 years ago it was unquestioned that stress is what causes ulcers. Almost nobody questioned that except for the one guy who did the experiment that proved it was bacterial in origin. Had his result been negative, you'd be here to mock him.
- asylteltine 3y ago[flagged]
- u32480932048 3y agoProjection from people who never leave their basement is my favorite.
- leotravis10 3y agoRelated: Vehicles with higher, more vertical front ends pose greater risk to pedestrians (iihs.org) | 322 points by yours truly | 463 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38267588 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38267588
- youngtaff 3y agoWe’ve known this for years…
- jiveturkey 3y agoArticle is current but the data is from 2021. I can easily find a deep journal-esque writeup dating to aug 1 2022. (JPHSC). https://doi.org/10.15586/jphsc https://doi.org/10.15586/jphsc. v1i1.47 > Currently, it seems unlikely that NHTSA will move to regulate hood heights on new vehicles. That's quite interesting statement. Hood (or is it bumper? -- which implies hood) heights are already regulated. Too low of a height has been determined to result in more injuries (not fatalities I guess), so the height has been forced to increase over the last decade or decades. Because of that you will never see (eg) a Lambo Diablo design again. Very very hard to find information about this imposed minimum height requirement because search results are flooded with this new finding since approx Nov 2023.
- jiveturkey 3y agocan't understand the downvote but i found the reg. FMVSS (not sure if this is written by NTHSA or what) requires bumper to be 16-20in for passenger cars and max 28in for light trucks. This then effectively dictates the minimum hood height. I additionally found a voluntary program in Eu called EEVC around bumper, hood and windshield design factors to reduce ped injury. NHTSA also has pubs around it but in the time I'm willing to invest I couldn't find if these are required or even voluntary or what in the US. Nice, brief summary article with diagrams from 2002: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1123098/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1123098/
- tfourb 3y agoI honestly do not understand, why regulators have not mandated limits on front dead angles (space occluded from view by the hood) and max vehicle hood hight by now. Well, I understand why it hasn't happened in the U.S. (how could any regulator curtail the manhood of the truck aficionados?), but in the E.U. regulators usually are more on top of these things.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoAre you saying that trucks with high hoods are prohibited in the EU?
- havblue 3y agoThere are definitely polls that show women find men in trucks more attractive in the US than, say, vans. If you want to signal wealth and refinement get a luxury vehicle. If you want to signal utility and masculinity get a truck.
- 0xdde 3y agoOf course studies showing anything are out there. Much less likely that they are properly set up and therefore believable.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoSeriously? There are polls that show anything you want. And if you have trouble finding one, you just create your own. Polls are essentially meaningless.
- grecy 3y agoI would be very shocked to learn those polls were funded by the makers of large SUVs and trucks. /s
- francisofascii 3y agohonestly, I believe it. I would blame the truck ads that have brainwashed Americans into thinking that driving a truck makes you more masculine or tough.
- havblue 3y agoI'd go even earlier though. Frederick Jackson Turner "The Significance of the Frontier in American History". Americans have different views on rugged individualism than Europeans do, so I didn't think it's surprising that we want to project cowboy country onto urban environments. Advertising is just tapping into the rugged lumberjack ideal.
- actionfromafar 3y agoGreat. Tax the trucks more and driving one will be an even better signal!
- beretguy 3y agoWhoever injures - or knock on wood kills - somebody with a truck with such a high hood should serve a mandatory prison sentence.
- dingnuts 3y agovehicular manslaughter is already a crime, and these trucks have been regulated INTO existence, not out of consumer desire and a lack of regulation. Consumers preferred small trucks until they disappeared due to CAFE standards. If you want the government to intervene, their first step should be to remove the regulations that encourage this growth in vehicle size to begin with, rather than going after consumers who have very little choice in trucks
- acdha 3y agoThe average American truck buyer picked it as a lifestyle accessory - it’s not like there was a huge shift in the percentage of trades jobs over the last few decades! Liability would be one way to encourage expressing that fashion aesthetic in other ways.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoLiability already exists. what next?
- acdha 3y agoNo, not effectively. Drivers are given extreme deference by law enforcement and in lawsuits where it’s usually assumed that the victim was at fault unless video evidence exists and is immediately available, and concepts like contributory negligence are often used to reduce legal responsibility without regard for the relative damage levels. Insurance is required, but the coverage levels are low so it’s common for the people who do successfully sue often get less than they need for ongoing treatment and support. We can’t change everything all at once but requiring more comprehensive coverage in general and especially for the most dangerous vehicles would be a good start.
- cbondurant 3y agothe current pavement princess trends have left me doubting that any more regulation of any kind will happen in the US.
- alistairSH 3y agoNot just the pavement princess stuff - Congress is simply doing less period.[1] Through most of the 20th century, 1000+ laws/year was common. Since 2000, that's dropped to <500 laws/year. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_federal_legislation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_federal_...
- mensetmanusman 3y agoPages of laws passed is a better metric as the laws have become more bundled due to partisanship.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoEven then, one era might write more tersely than another.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoHard to measure between eras with the evolution of pork barrel politicking and other recent cultural practices.
- Havoc 3y agoAfter the cybertruck my working assumption had been that US regulators had just given up on pedestrian safety.
- iknowstuff 3y agoThe cybertruck has not been shown to have lower pedestrian safety than other trucks. Ironically, you’re commenting on an article about higher hoods, and the CT has one of the lowest hoods among trucks on the market.
- Havoc 3y agoI'm commenting on pedestrian safety & regulators absence. Sharp edges and rolled steel instead of crumple zones is absolutely a bad time if you're a pedestrian. High hoods isn't the only possible risk.
- iknowstuff 3y ago1) It seems you are confusing crumple zones (which the ct definitely has lol) with cushioning the impact for a pedestrian. 2) sure, but the only research we have says higher hood = much more deadly. Cybertruck has a lower hood with a better angle. So why single it out when the jury is out on what’s more important for safety
- u32480932048 3y agoCybertruck Man Bad.
- CRConrad 3y agoYou probably thought you were being Edgelord-cool-sarcastic, but yes, he is.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3y ago
- jetrink 3y agoMy proposed regulation is to introduce a hazardous vehicle license for large trucks and SUVs. Everyone is automatically granted one alongside their normal drivers license, but if you're caught driving recklessly (weaving through traffic on the highway, aggressively tailgating, speeding through residential or urban areas), you lose it and you have to drive a normal-sized car. Perhaps there's a way to earn it back through paying a fine and taking a safe driving course. The classification of vehicles as hazardous should be based on factors known to increase pedestrian and vehicle collision fatalities to encourage safe designs.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoI like the spirit, but don't like the unintended consequence that it would create a stigma around sedans -- "oh, those are the cars for the bad drivers". We need to do something that makes SUV drivers feel ridiculous and humiliated. Or, failing that, just make it expensive: Weight and size dependent tolls, say (using the fourth power of weight, possibly, to match road wear equations?). Or just fewer lanes in which those vehicles are allowed. "You don't get the elite lane."
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y ago> We need to do something that makes SUV drivers feel ridiculous and humiliated Oh, that couldn't possibly have any side effects.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 3y agoHopefully it would have an effect. 95% of the people in these giant walls of steel have no reason to be driving them.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoI see. And how have you determined that?
- tasty_freeze 3y agoThere is another angle here besides the immediate impact (pun intended) of getting hit by a big truck. I'm nearly 60, but I can remember what it was like learning to drive back in 1980. Before SUVs and huge pickup trucks became common, and before tinting windows to near opacity became a thing, it was possible to see road conditions three cars ahead -- you simply looked through the windows of the car or cars in front of you. I found it unnerving to drive behind a delivery truck because all I could see of the road was the back of the truck, so I'd change lanes so I could have more advanced notice of what was ahead of me. These days that is mostly over: windows are too opaque, and very often that is moot because the vehicle immediately before me is well above my Corolla's vantage point.
- aidenn0 3y agoNon-trucks attempting a right-turn-on-red next to trucks are also more likely to hit a pedestrian, though if they are driving in a sane manner, it's unlikely to be fatal. I cannot see a pedestrian over the hood of a truck stopped just short of the crosswalk until my bumper is already well into the crosswalk.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoNot nearly as bad as hitting someone, but it's also annoying when a person is honking behind me and I'm thinking "Dude, I can't turn right until the light turns green because I can't see oncoming traffic since the truck/SUV in the left lane pulled forward.".
- Zancarius 3y agoOh, I've been honked a few times in the past few months right after pulling up to a light just after it turned red and the cross traffic has a green light. It's like... "you really expect me to pull out INTO traffic because you're so impatient?!" The first time it happened the person kept hitting their horn until they saw the cross traffic. Amazing.
- stefan_ 3y ago
- bradgranath 3y agoNo duh?
- sf_rob 3y agoI got in an argument with the Ford CMO on Twitter about this. He said that the F150 has maintained the overall footprint for years, which is true. However, if you super-impose an image of older F150s and newer ones (which I did) you find that the hood is much more "cubic" leading to a higher edge and much worse viewing angle. I believe this is entirely stylistic.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoAnother big difference between a new one and a 50 year old one, is the cabin on the old one is basically like driving in an aquarium tank in terms of visibility with the lack of a or b pillar obstruction and low belt lines. Suspension is also generally lower on smaller tires from the ones I still see around town from the 70s. Sometimes their hoods aren’t much taller than a sedan but that could be from the suspension setup.
- renewiltord 3y agoYeah, that makes sense. But lots of people pointed out to me that "right of way won't matter when you're dead" and that "cemeteries are filled with people who had the right of way". That's true and taking that to heart means buying a big truck because then right of way doesn't matter and it's the other guy in the cemetery. After all, "I'd rather be judged by 12 than buried by 6" or whatever. Yield to gross tonnage.
- quadyeast 3y agoThe opaque tinted side windows make it hard to tell if the driver sees you at the pedestrian cross. I'm often forced to wait till they leave and they sometimes wait for me so ...
- sporkland 3y agoIllegal but not enforced in California. I say we let these people run a few more years and then basically revoke the license of anyone that has done this for a year. The front dark tinted window is nearly 100% correlated with reckless, aggressive driving for me.
- tomaskafka 3y agoIt seems that no one has yet posted the famous article linking SUVs to immaturity and low self esteem, so here we go. > Car companies managed this remarkable feat because they ran—and continue to run—quite possibly the most sophisticated marketing operations on the planet. They knew what people really wanted: to project an image of selfish superiority. And then they sold it to them at a markup > Who has been buying SUVs since automakers turned them into family vehicles? They tend to be people who are insecure and vain. They are frequently nervous about their marriages and uncomfortable about parenthood. They often lack confidence in their driving skills. Above all, they are apt to be self-centered and self-absorbed, with little interest in their neighbors or communities. https://www.vice.com/en/article/m7q7eb/electric-or-not-big-suvs-are-inherently-selfish https://www.vice.com/en/article/m7q7eb/electric-or-not-big-s...
- Nifty3929 3y agoJudgement and condescension are unlikely to change minds or behavior, or add anything else of value. It will only make people wonder who really has an issue with immaturity and low self esteem.
- tomaskafka 3y agoThose words are the characteristics that the actual SUV marketers see in their data and user behavior :).
- TacticalCoder 3y agoThey're also do not seem aerodynamic. Note that many cars now have features meant to protect pedestrians a bit if there's an impact: the bonnet shall rise with springs, instantly (not unlike an airbag) and then the springs shall absorb the impact a bit. Some bonnet even have airbag outside the car that are supposed to protect pedestrians. But, yup, these huge, tall, flat hoods don't seem that great. Drive a Porsche guys, not a RAM ; )
- pants2 3y agoAmericans love to buy 6,000lb tanks with the aerodynamics of a brick and then complain about high gas prices. It's the American way.
- ChrisLTD 3y agoThe US government is completely MIA on this issue. There’s no reason people need these monster trucks to drive to and from their job every day or to and from the grocery store.
- amai 3y agoThis should be a surprise for nobody. See for example this great video by NotJustBikes: https://youtu.be/jN7mSXMruEo?si=o8JKltCiITzISK8d https://youtu.be/jN7mSXMruEo?si=o8JKltCiITzISK8d
- hateful 3y agoEvery single time I see a huge SUV being backed into a spot instead of just parking I think about how dangerous this is. Starting in 2016 all vehicles have backup cameras so that you don't accidentally run someone over. The backup cameras have wide angle lenses. But now you'll have to pull forward with no such camera and a HUGE blind spot.
- fennecbutt 3y agoDidn't we know this decades ago? Back when we also stopped allowing pop up headlights (even though I think they're so cool). I think we should have banned or restricted sales of SUVs and "trucks" as Americans call 'em, a long time ago. When I was growing up, cars were a very reasonable size, even for a family. Now the streets are full of giant SUVs, mostly driven by a single occupant, and usually with a driving style that the confidence and apathy of being in a larger vehicle gives them. Too late now, I guess.
- tim333 3y agoThe US has some dumb legal incentives for people to drive the big stuff like >The “light truck” loophole for pickups and SUVs that allow them to pollute more than other cars. https://www.vice.com/en/article/3abk7b/bidens-new-fuel-economy-standards-still-allow-cars-to-pollute-more-if-theyre-not-called-cars https://www.vice.com/en/article/3abk7b/bidens-new-fuel-econo... They should in any sane world go the other way - have a benefits for small safer cars and a bunch of tax and regulation on the monster ones.