6 ms·
The Downward Spiral of Technology
- tivert 3y agoThe real problem is users just aren't optimistic enough to swallow these dogshit downgrades with enthusiasm. /s Edit: Very good article, though. There are some core assumptions that are part of the belief system of many people (especially technology enthusiasts and software engineers) that need a serious rethink, because they're just not true (or more insidiously, just not true anymore).
- marcosdumay 3y agoThen you just consider those to be a bad investment and finish it.
- bee_rider 3y agoI’m not sure if it is a matter of perspective or what. But I definitely wouldn’t look back at 90’s internet too nostalgically. It was legitimately hard to find things. People made these quirky collections of websites because that was the only way to find interesting stuff. I didn’t know about websites until I heard about them IRL. I was a kid, and scared of all the weirdos on the internet, so maybe it felt harder to explore for me, but I think that was not so uncommon. Decades tend to smear forward a bit, I think. I wonder if people are remembering, like, 200X-201X internet when they think of the 90’s? Google was really good before SEO fully figured it out (or maybe somebody really good at SEO in 200X was actually probably clever enough that you wanted to go to their site anyway).
- JKCalhoun 3y agoI think the point though is that we're heading to where we're no better off than we were in the 90's as modern "search" returns results that are somehow even less than no results at all. Those curated lists are looking better and better.
- tivert 3y ago> I’m not sure if it is a matter of perspective or what. But I definitely wouldn’t look back at 90’s internet too nostalgically. It was legitimately hard to find things. People made these quirky collections of websites because that was the only way to find interesting stuff. I didn’t know about websites until I heard about them IRL. I think it's more complicated that "easier is better" assumption. The 90s internet may have been better precisely because things were hard to find, for instance. It's kind of like a lot of technology, by solving one "problem" it makes worse ones. People might have complained about needing to walk everywhere before cars were invented, but once they got cars they stopped walking and started getting fat. There's probably a sweet spot where both "less solution" and "more solution" are in fact worse.
- tlb 3y agoPart of what made the 90s internet exciting was the sense, whenever I found a useful site, that I too could make such a site. I could probably get v1 going in an afternoon, and it would be (partly) fun. I guess I could also make a 2020s content site, full of ads and signup clickthroughs, but I don't want to. Movies made this transition around the 1940s. It went from "if you could put on a play, you could rent some cameras and lights and make a popular movie" to "you need a 9-digit production budget and 3 years." I salute indie video game developers, who continue to resist this trend, making good 6-digit titles that are often more enjoyable than 9-digit titles.
- jackcosgrove 3y agoThat's the difference between a golden age and a silver age. The golden age has wide open frontiers, low barriers to entry, and low hanging fruit. The silver age is more closed off but also achieves greater sophistication.
- tlb 3y agoIs there a canonical definition of these ages? It seems like a useful way of making analogies between industries/mediums. If there isn't, maybe you could make some sort of website to explain...
- mrandish 3y agoI agree the 90s internet experience wasn't something really worth pining for. It's easy to forget that broadband wasn't, in most cases, consistently broad enough yet (and server response latency was often pretty poor), the software tech stack was still too immature and much of the presentation was still designed around dial-up constraints. While the experience of discovering exponentially more genuinely interesting content on forums and personal blogs was revelatory compared to Usenet, there's even more good content available today, it's just frustratingly buried in vast mountains of click-bait crap auto-generated to deceptively look like authentic content. I think "peak web" was somewhere around 2010 to 2012 and even as late as 2015. I'm still able to mostly put together a fairly useful and minimally annoying daily experience but it does require increasingly more work to sustain. This includes finding, integrating, and, in some cases, writing userscripts and browser add-ons to variously fix and/or de-crapify the web. uBlock Origin (with lots of my own filter rules to hide various crap elements) is just the beginning. Just checking my Firefox ViolentMonkey and Stylus scripts, there are now four scripts just to fix Google (along with a layered set of my own regex-scripted redirects in the Redirector add-on which manipulate Google Search's URL parameters fix a bunch of things and enforce useful defaults). * YouTube: The AdashimaaTube Stylus script makes YT usable and useful again (has >700k users) * Reddit: OldReddit plus the essential Reddit Enhancement Suite along with defaulting the homepage to a carefully curated MultiReddit list of small, special-interest niche subs. * For the rest of the web I have about 30 add-ons in Firefox (and that's after recently culling my add-on list down to what I consider the bare essentials). About a third of them fix things related to websites, a third address issues with Firefox itself, and a third add features to Firefox or specific sites (Amazon: (item price history, fix default sort), Steam Store: comparative pricing, Twitter: fix Twitter layout & defaults, Netflix: add Metacritic, IMDB and Rotten Tom. review scores, etc). * Although it remains the 'least-bad' browser for user choice, privacy and personalization, the current product management of Firefox seems intent on destroying even this last refuge. I can't even use FF without the amazing Lepton userchrome that extensively fixes all the insane things FF's run-amuck designers keep doing to fuck up its interface. Essential: https://github.com/black7375/Firefox-UI-Fix https://github.com/black7375/Firefox-UI-Fix. On top of that I have my own extensive fixes, adaptations and personalizations in UserChrome.css and User.JS. Lepton and my own scripts require an emergency intervention to maintain at least once every three months because they keep getting broken by new Firefox versions. Just the maintenance is getting bad enough that I'm about to switch to the latest long-term version of FF. Frankly, the changes, improvements and 'modernizations' FF has been making the last couple years seem about 90/10 irrelevant/useful. The community at FirefoxCSS is a godsend for crowd-sourcing how to keep fixing, patching and maintaining UserChrome (www.reddit.com/r/FirefoxCSS/). * Lastly, since we're talking about tech overall, it's the same clusterfuck on Windows 10 and Android. Yes, I know Linux is better in many ways but it's a personal preference thing for me. Unlike the other non-linux option, Mac/iOS, at least Windows can still be variously "fixed" and otherwise made usable with sufficient effort and diligent hackery. Tools like Ditto (a sharable macro + multi-clipboard), 7TT, Start10, Groupy, AutoHideMouseCursor, Textify, AlwaysMouseWheel, ShareX, PowerToys, WinAeroTweaker, WinGetUI, a dozen free utility apps from NirSoft and the absolutely essential "Everything" (an incredible, lightning fast whole-system search). Together, these along with an extensive personal AHK script and a few dozen registry customizations (which I now have scripted for new installs) allow Windows 10 to be pretty okay. (Note: I'm not forgetting all the similar work I've had to do to hack, fix, de-ad-ify and de-crapify my television, Android-ish streaming sticks and nearly everything else marketed with the word "Smart". I'm just too tired to enumerate all of that too.) Obviously, this amount of literal per-user work being required to actually experience a reasonable form of the "Better Future" we thought we were building is ridiculous. My whole life I've always believed in the ability of technology to broadly improve our lives. While this belief has proven (mostly) true, I never imagined we'd have to endure these kinds of trivial yet maddening functionality and usability regressions in routine daily activities. It's like a malevolent fairy tale genii granted our wishes for useful AI and routine spaceflight yet perversely doomed us to walk around with sandpaper in our underwear! Maybe I'm too idealistic but I just refuse to give-in, give-up and accept that our technological future is destined to be worse than the past - especially in such mundane ways - and for such trivially stupid reasons.
- clutchdude 3y agoFuck - from an average coder perspective, try getting a working linux DNS server for home lab use in 2005 without having to waste a weekend or two on it. LAMP servers were heralded as the best thing since sliced bread because of how it all just "worked." And then add in maintenance and all the other sucky sucks of having competing binaries screw everything up. Now, when it worked, it felt more accomplished than spinning up a `docker run...` or `argocd app create...` However, I enjoy doing the cool shit on top of this stack now rather than waste my life figuring out why my apache process can't properly invoke php code.
- Gormo 3y ago> Fuck - from an average coder perspective, try getting a working linux DNS server for home lab use in 2005 without having to waste a weekend or two on it I never found myself able to waste time on these sort of projects, because all of the time I spent on them invariably turned out to be a fruitful investment instead.
- fulladder 3y agoYes, I agree about the decades blurring together. A lot of "the Sixties" happened in the early- to mid-1970s, and the 2010s didn't seem to start until about 2015 (and are ongoing today). However, there was definitely a distinct 1990s Internet, and I remember using it in the actual 1990s. A big part of it was just the newness of the whole thing. That was still happening in like 2001 and 2002, but by the middle of the 2000s the Internet was not new anymore and large numbers of people had home broadband.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- JKCalhoun 3y agoAn excellent summary/distillation of all that's wrong with tech today. The post is chock full of good supporting arguments of the decline — loaded with links to other posts that reinforce the same notion. I sometimes wonder if I'm just getting old, perhaps becoming a Luddite, and I just am unable to get it. But then a post like this comes along and reaffirms what I already knew. If it "rings true" for you it's because we're feeling it.
- yifanl 3y agoThe throughline of the blog seems to be that the public at large have uncovered that tech (the industry) isn't about tech (the cool stuff we build) anymore, it's just a vehicle for marketers. I suppose there's a cynical question to follow up: was tech ever about tech? If so, when/how did that change? If not, how did the public get fooled for so long?
- verisimi 3y agoI agree, great article. Its not that you're a luddite - its simply that the internet went from an exuberant, wild representation of reality, to a constrained, extractive. corporate 'shop front'. All facilitated by government, which likes the data corporations provide it. And on luddites, apparently they liked tech (as do I) if it were to help them but objected to knowledge extraction and exploitative labour policies that became known the industrial revolution. There are distinct similarities to AI. I'm sure we'll keep using the internet, but its gone from a place where real value can be found, to some corporate crap. Its equivalent to me, to walking through (pre-Amazon) busy shopping centers as a youth - something you have to do rather than because of the joy you will find there. Its a simulation of the human experience. And this is fine. IMO the real deal has always been one's own lived experience. This is where the value is. The question has always been how to maximise that, even if we were distracted and entertained for a while.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoGood point. And to that point, the shittier the internet becomes, the more it pushes me away.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoAnother take on enshitification. Like the idea of 'useful' tools for 'useless' people. It is little bit more nuanced than just greed is making things crappy.
- justincredible 3y ago[dead]
- angelsbrood 3y agoEveryone out of the economy yesterday please
- chucksta 3y agoI don't think counting "let me google that for you" as a point to ease of use of the internet is legit. I always saw it manifest as another version of RTFM. Meaning stop being lazy/do your own work.
- sophacles 3y agoIt was both. Yes it was "stop being a lazy slob" but also carried with it the connotation of "we literally have a tool that will let you learn about literally anything you want to know by typing your exact question into the freaking box". In fact I said those words many times. It's no longer true - we don't have that tool. We have the ghost of that tool overrun by advertisers and other scumbags, which rarely answers the question correctly, and almost never at a depth beyond what can be surmised merely by observing enough to ask the question.
- tivert 3y ago> It's no longer true - we don't have that tool. We have the ghost of that tool overrun by advertisers and other scumbags, which rarely answers the question correctly, and almost never at a depth beyond what can be surmised merely by observing enough to ask the question. And also offers an interesting parallel to RTFM: when was the last time you got a decent manual with a product?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _oskh 3y agoIt's refreshing to see a story like this make it to the top page on hackernews
- drdrek 3y agoIt mixes good criticism with nostalgia to a past that never was. Don't idolize past successful business people... they are the same in every generation. Don't confuse good communities that you may or may not have been part of in the past with the technologies they used. You can find awesome people in a facebook group or a discord channel today, and you most definitely could have found nice or awful people in a builtin board way back when. If something is shit don't use it. If apple or google are shit don't use them. Google killed Yahoo because it became shit, the next search engine will kill google because it became shit and so on.
- gfodor 3y agoIn general as people get older they become able to see things that are getting worse, since they have a wider frame of reference, and have a hard time seeing things that are getting better, because they imagine the past was better than it was. The result, in many cases, is an articulation of a very nuanced explanation for why the present sucks, but often to me I read it as just a self-rationalization. The truth is, a lot of stuff is amazing now that was far worse in the past. A lot of the things people are making now are being driven by young people. Young people have an ignorance about the past, so miss some of the lessons, but they also lack the cynicism which prevents revisiting things that people have determined "don't work" in the past. I generally see tech as a large ecosystem which is in fact progressively improving, with minor setbacks that often do echo the same setbacks in the past. The error is to pattern match too strongly on these setback patterns as though they contain some kind of timeless wisdom. If there's any industry where past performance isn't indicative of future results, it's technology. (Which is and of itself, is a process of knowledge discovery at its core.) My general approach to thinking about this is I grow older is to guard against the kind of cynicism I see in so many of my peers. Yes, it means I will be wrong on things where the cynic turns out to be right. But given the pull of cynicism, I suspect more likely I will remain cynical in many places I shouldn't be anyway, so I'd rather focus on being right in the places where the cynic is wrong by forcing myself to remain optimistic and give the young the benefit of the doubt. This also has the added benefit of making the process of working on things more fun in general - not just because it leads to actually making stuff (cynicism demotivates this) and it also leads to being surrounded by peers who are optimistic and interested in continuing to make stuff (being surrounded by cynics is generally miserable, and breeds cynicism.) A few years ago, I found myself in a broad peer group of technologists who were deep into the abyss of cynicism, and made a conscious decision to just sever myself from these networks because this kind of negativity was becoming my dominant mode of thinking about technology. I've done some of my best work since then and much of it has probably come about due to the fact that I dove into it due to the counterfactual level of optimism I had due to this one decision.
- TheCapeGreek 3y agoI was thinking about this the other day, from the frame of reference of a middle-upper class person 30-40 years ago. At their time, tech was at its peak. Life was the greatest it could possibly be! And yet with so many problems, conflicts, economic difficulties, and ordinary life stressors. We feel the same today as they felt then. We just have better toys and different problems. Some problems might be more existential (e.g. climate change), but day-to-day is it so different? In material terms yes, in personal terms not so much. The human condition is far slower to change than the world it inhabits.
- jackcosgrove 3y agoCompany cultures can get worse over time. Why couldn't that happen globally? In the past there was always a larger, younger generation coming up that would have enough people to make things better even if locally things got worse. But that's not true anymore. We're already seeing this in places, such as the loss in expertise in certain areas such as nuclear powerplant design, diminished ability to cost-effectively build public works projects, the looming problem of skills shortage for all of these "near-shored" industries, and the inability to keep up with housing demand because there simply aren't enough people in the construction industry. I didn't agree with some of the examples in the article, but I do think it's true that the declining population that's coming will lead to a lot of orphaned infrastructure and lost know-how.
- BriggyDwiggs42 3y agoThe population decline is not dramatic enough for that.
- carlosjobim 3y agoThe population decline is massive in many regions and also compounded by decades of the trend. You also have to account for that the decline in young people is larger than the total population decline, since old people live longer. So if in the past a normal year would have a 20% population increase from births and 15% decline from deaths, totalling a 5% increase, today you'll maybe have a 10% increase from births and 10% decline from deaths, which looks like a standstill, but is actually a -50% decline.
- FredPret 3y agoWe also got a lot better at other things in the same timeframe. There's now a much larger volume of software that, on average, work better, which wouldn't have been possible with the number of software folks back in the day. Yes I know, Javascript frameworks, bloat, etc. In general my computers are much more reliable than before. We've invented entire tech-based industries while old ones are fading away. It's not clear that it's actually a decline, especially since the economy has shown steady exponential growth over the past couple of centuries.
- Aardwolf 3y ago> I recently bought an expensive new computer. And after a few weeks, I went back to my old computer—it ran better than the new model. I'm curious what the specs of the old and new desktop computer were, and how many years old the old one was. I upgraded my desktop PC after 5 years, from a decent Core i7 CPU of back then to a Zen 4 based CPU now, and it's 3x faster for single threaded things (if I measure walltime of things like javascript minification), and has 2x more cores/threads on top of that. Maybe they mean the OS feels slower or something instead? Or made a very uninformed buying decision.
- johngossman 3y agoI went to read Ted Gioia’s original piece to try to figure out why he thought his new computer was a downgrade, but he doesn’t say. There was a period in the 90s where Windows machines were increasingly cheap and loaded with crapware, but otherwise my computers continue to get better and better. I agree Google and social media has gotten worse, but I don’t see a larger trend here. I’ll happily trade any of 90s (or 2010 for that matter) cars, computers, phones, cameras, dentist visits, TVs, video games, etc. etc. for the author’s new “downgrade.”
- anjel 3y agoWhat about dentists is so much better now??
- persedes 3y agoMight be referring to the notion that nowadays dentists are more generous with anesthesia. E.g. it used to be normal to pull out wisdom teeth without general anesthesia. Also their diagnostic tools have gotten a lot better (recent x-rays are insanely detailed).
- jampekka 3y agoIs it really normal to use general anesthesia for that somewhere? Sounds quite risky.
- antisthenes 3y agoIt's only normal in America, as is the tradition of being overmedicated for just about any minor discomfort. I opted for my wisdom teeth to be taken out with local and don't regret it. The worst part is the recovery anyway, not the 20 minutes in the chair.
- al_borland 3y agoWhen I was in high school (late 90s) I remember getting cavities filled without any numbing at all. I just had to deal with it. Maybe it was a bad dentist, because I know that stuff existed then, but I wasn't assertive enough at that age to call out the dentist. These days they numb me up and I don't feel anything, but I still tense up a lot out of habit from when I was younger. They also used to take impressions at the dentist where they'd fill your mouth with some kind of goop in trays. Now they have cameras they can just move around your mouth and it stitches a model together.
- hscontinuity 3y agoThe internet existed in material form before the internet. All the early internet did was make physical locations available non-physically, at first. Once the connection was made (networked) all else unfolded because of now (digital space). What replaced much of the 'connected world' before the internet remained - telephones, newspapers, photography, wires, etc. The advantage over all else wasn't just connectivity; it was a reduction in the time allotted in transmitting that information. From there we realized that we created access to the non-material world whilst remaining firmly planted in reality - transferring much of that material connection into digital connection. What followed isn't fundamentally abstract at all - 1975-1985, '85-'95, '95-'03, '03-'09, '09-'17 and our current period, are all iterations of the same technology being recreated in faster, larger, more accessible ways. However, we humans haven't changed. We haven't evolved in the same time line that technology has. Not that we could or should, but rather we're evolving at a much slower rate that we push technology and in my humble opinion exacerbates the rigid dualities of life changing technologies. We must embrace new ideology in our philosophic approach to technology if we intend to mature new technologies as part of our own evolution. That is, if we truly care about how technology like the internet can and has changed human life.
- max_ 3y agoI am tired of people that complain and don't offer a way concrete forward. This is why the free software movement failed and why the fediverse will obviously fail.
- nehal3m 3y agoLet me turn that around on you; so what is the way forward?
- singleshot_ 3y agoMinimize the use of digital technology in all its forms. Focus on meaningful, in-person relationships. Ignore the 24 hour news cycle and participate in local policy and governance. Buy less stuff, focus on developing the quality, effectiveness, and integration of the stuff you already have. Never, ever work to forward big companies’ goals of infiltrating society with their technology.
- max_ 3y agoBuild new - Social networks - Hardware - Internet UI portals* That are cannot be abused by corporations. * The web is rotten to the core. No amount of regulation or activism can fix it at this point. We need something else.
- sumuyuda 3y agoSystem change was mentioned at the end of the article. Moving past Capitalism will be the way forward.
- al_borland 3y agoThat's an easy thing to say, but not useful as a way to move forward. What does that new system look like? How does the transition happen? If going with one of the traditional replacements for Capitalism based in some kind of Marxism, why should anyone believe it will work this time, when it has failed every other time? The typical, "we'll do it right this time," isn't going to cut it. Simply eliminating Capitalism doesn't put a society on the fast track to peace and prosperity, it simply changes how the few end up with power and control.
- vishnugupta 3y agoThis is a bad take. The author takes a tiny sliver of tech which is internet and within that picks cutting edge products (except for Google) and rants. They should talk to more people outside of their bubble, especially in developing countries. Just about everything around tech has improved incomparably over last 15 or so years. Take health care for example. Cataract surgery is literally a 15 minute out orient procedure thanks to terrific laser surgery. Who would have imagined that something as complex as that could be achieved in our lifetime? I picked just one example, I’m sure there are many many more.
- growingkittens 3y agoAs people age, they experience the difference between: - the future-that-is, and - the future-that-could-have-been, or the future they imagined based on their collective experience as a younger person. Computers completely shifted the potential of the future past the realm of imagination. I was born in the late 80s, and watched the trajectory of technology with anticipation. My father, a programmer, was heavily into technology - and he could not imagine what I imagined. He couldn't imagine basic things in the 90s, like widely available terabyte hard drives in the future, or what they would be used for. I knew they were coming, because quality video files were just too large. When PDAs came out, I patiently waited years for a version with mobile internet (smartphones). These are the things I thought were "obvious" progressions, and they happened. But I also imagined that technology would work as a system. It doesn't. Everything is fractured and isolated.
- mike50 3y agoLooks like a 1995 time magazine article. Author is the meta.
- jocoda 3y agoHave to disagree. Tech is not getting worse, period. >"It’s been a minute since we’ve seen anything new from tech that has truly improved most people’s existence." That's not much to do with the tech getting worse and everything to do with how the tech is being applied. Search sucks! Why? The focus is on profit. Someone connected a thermometer and found that the users are basically stupid, so why bother anything that requires effort. Amazon bad, bad, bad. But nothing to do with bad tech, it's all in how it's being applied. Yes, he does make the same point, even to profit being the driver. But the overriding message here is tech is shit, and that's not so. People are.
- rinron 3y agoThe mistake this article makes is it doesn't consider things outside of their perspective. Before i go into more detail many of the things they think have degraded and gotten worse i never even touched, facebook, twitter, crypto currencies to me they weren't good ideas that degraded. They were defective, degenerate yet mostly inevitable ideas doomed to excite and provide glimpses of amazing utility but will overall degrade and manipulate society as a whole. They didnt get worse they just became fully utilized. but when talking about what i consider legit products: 1. The difference may make something improved to one person but worse for someone else - i find most times the older os's faster with windows and android. part of that reason is the include graphical transitions and animations when doing things. turning them off makes them feel fast like the older versions. there are more features, hardware support, ect one person may dislike not need those new features or animations but most do like them 2. Adapting to changing circumstances - When google started out no body knew or maybe even had a strong reason to manipulate google results. Google itself might be significantly better but the internet and people using it has changed its not the Tech that degraded its the people using and manipulating it creating new challenges that were never faced before. 3. In the past it may have worked better for you but now it is more sustainable/better for everyone - in a extreme example during the dot com boom i could make money ($20-$30) just by having a ad bar at the bottom of my screen for a few hours a day(even when i wasnt on it). But the only way it worked was because a bunch of idiot investors were loosing a ton of money. Has advertising got worse? to me sure but in reality they just went to a reasonable business model as much as i would prefer to get paid good money for having ad's on my screen. All that being said are there companies who make tech worse just for greed and profit absolutely, but its not a black and white situation and there is a lot more factors than people usually realize. one of my "it got worse" but not really experiences is with phones when phones were analog for my normal use case of making local phone calls when there were just land lines calls, were always clear no latency issues and extremely rarely had issues. now with digital and voip there can be delay's and choppiness and audio cutting in and out and really low quality audio and i sometimes complain about how it used to just work. but really i can now call anywhere in the world for free, have cheap and easy to setup phones with amazing features not depend on one phone company and can easily switch between. so ya in the most common calling situation its worse but overall its so so much better.
- Maultasche 3y agoI remember back in the late 1990s, I heard a lot of people pining for the earlier days before the "eternal September" when the Internet wasn't full of clueless people ruining everything for everyone else and turning the Internet into a place of low quality. It's hard for me to take grumbles like this seriously when I've heard the same thing so many times before. Back in the "good old days", there were plenty of loud people complaining how bad it was compared to times before. I personally think that although it is a lot more commercialized, the Internet is way better now.