5 ms·
US home sales see worst year since 1995
- steveBK123 3y agoDon't forget we have ~25% higher population than 1995 now too, so the current sales levels are quite worse than the even that 30 year low comparison. The good news is rates are slowly heading down to normalish (4-5%) range, but the era of free money (sub 3% mortgages) are unlikely to come back. If those rates do come back, it will not be pleasant as it will be the other side of a fairly large recession.
- HPsquared 3y agoNeed to remember to subtract inflation from any interest rate, though. "Real interest rate" accounting for inflation. Edit: for example this one https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/REAINTRATREARAT10Y https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/REAINTRATREARAT10Y
- nobodyandproud 3y agoInflation fluctuates constantly. Mortgage rates are fixed for 15-30 years, unless one makes the mistake of getting a variable rate loan.
- putlake 3y agoThis chart is based on forward inflation expectation, which is probably lower than actual. Ideally I'd like to see this chart until 10 years ago that compares the rate of interest on a US 10Y t-bond when issued with the actual inflation that occurred over the 10 years until it matured.
- judge2020 3y agoMain issue with taking inflation into account is that wage inflation doesn't exist, companies aren't giving raises every year to 'match inflation', if they do offer raises it's for retention and/or is performance-based.
- antisthenes 3y agoThe reason 2023 year was so bad is that prices are lagging behind interest rates. In a liquid market, they have an inverse relationship, but it wasn't until Q3 of 2023 that prices actually started giving way. There's almost a 1-year lag, which resulted in high prices AT high interest rates. Reasonably, this affected purchasing decisions. Sales will pick back up again by Q2 2024.
- steveBK123 3y agoExactly. RE prices are sticky on the downside. Some of it is logical (selling a leverage asset at a loss when you can just live in it / if you sell you give up your below-market-rate mortgage) and some of it is emotional (people like to win). So as mortgage rates approach 4-5% range (not that far off, we've already dropped from 7.8% to 6.6% in 2 months), homes will start moving again. People need to upgrade/downgrade/move/etc, and the marginal cost will start to compress and make it worthwhile again. As an example - I have a typical 2018-2020 ZIRP bottom barrel interest rates.. So while the apartment upstairs from me which is on sale for 25% more than my apartment purchase price, it would have actually cost me 75% more in monthly payments at peak interest rates. At current interest rates it is 58% higher payments, and at 4.5% it would be about 31% higher payments (pretty close to proportional to price). So I think somewhere in the 4-5% range things get pretty normal pretty quick.
- BLKNSLVR 3y ago> The good news is rates are slowly heading down Interest rates or the inflation rate? Interest rates haven't started heading down yet, whilst inflation rates are easing, they're still higher than desired. https://www.forbes.com/advisor/investing/fomc-meeting-federal-reserve/ https://www.forbes.com/advisor/investing/fomc-meeting-federa...
- steveBK123 3y agoMortgage rates are down from peak https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MORTGAGE30US https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MORTGAGE30US Which is what people buy based on
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoThat's very interesting. Mortgage rates dropped without a corresponding drop of the fed rate. In Australia the big lenders are in lock step with the reserve bank on rate increases, and lag behind on rate decreases.
- steveBK123 3y agoInflation is coming down, Fed is signaling they would cut without a recession in order to hold "real rates" as inflation drops, etc. Mostly a discussion as how many Fed cuts we see in 2024 now, not whether they will.
- caeril 3y agoMortgage rates are tied far more closely to 10y TSY yields than the FFR, and the 10y yield is predicting FFR rate decreases in the future.
- bugglebeetle 3y agoAnd yet in California, it has practically no effect on prices because people selling have absurdly low property tax rates locked in from buying decades ago, thanks to Prop 13.
- dawnerd 3y agoOregon too. People buying new construction get kinda screwed.
- ilikehurdles 3y agoOregon property tax rates are insanely high on older units too IMO. How does this apply to new construction?
- zerbinxx 3y agoMy understanding is that in Oregon, new construction property taxes are higher than on older units
- dawnerd 3y agoOld property gets locked in until there’s something to trigger a change. There’s a couple ways to avoid it a good contractor can work around. It’s not the rate that’s lower on the older property it’s the property value. They have a law that limits how much it can increase per year similar to prop 13 but it can transfer to new owners. Makes old houses worth significantly more than some new homes.
- dawnerd 3y agoJust to add more context here’s the Oregon rules. The linked doc might not be the most up to date but should provide enough info. https://www.oregon.gov/DOR/forms/FormsPubs/maximum-assessed-value-manual_303-438.pdf https://www.oregon.gov/DOR/forms/FormsPubs/maximum-assessed-...
- fred_is_fred 3y ago
- fxtentacle 3y ago"We expect a scarce supply of existing homes for sale to keep home price growth positive this year," or said another way: If young families just hold off on purchasing a house for a little bit longer, prices might go back to normal. I mean do you expect the 40% price hike during Covid to become permanent? I don't.
- Exoristos 3y agoPositive price growth means prices rising, not falling "back to normal".
- vsskanth 3y agoPeople with 3% mortgages aren't going to sell unless they lose their job and can't make the monthly payment. I mean do you expect a large recession in the next year ? I don't.
- enraged_camel 3y agoCan you look at this chart, identify the pattern, and then explain why you think a recession isn't imminent? https://i.imgur.com/pkl8nfq.png https://i.imgur.com/pkl8nfq.png
- kortilla 3y agoCan you look at it and explain why you think employment leads to recessions?
- enraged_camel 3y agoIt's not that employment itself leads to a recession, but that low unemployment has been a 100% accurate lagging indicator for recessions.
- jacobolus 3y agoThere's no limit to how long we can have low unemployment, and no rule that recessions have any particular temporal spacing or severity. All we can see from your chart is that occasionally there is a recession, that these are spaced unpredictably in time but usually no longer than 2 decades apart (but sometimes only a few years apart, and plausibly it could be longer), and then unemployment rises from wherever it happens to be. But that doesn't mean the recession is caused by either low unemployment directly or by the causes of low unemployment, or that the recession is at all predictable from unemployment data.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- amir734jj 3y agoI live in the midwest (Wisconsin), the newer houses are from the 1950s and the older ones are from the 1900s. People prefer to live in specific villages or suburbs because of safety and community. The inner city is ridden with crime. These villages cannot expand as they were (in most cases) already developed in the 1950s. Here, multi-family houses don't sell well. Newer houses cost a lot more than older ones. To make matters worse, usually, families combine their income to buy a house but all of my friends and coworkers that are in their 30s are still single. Additionally, we have apartments here that cost more than single-family and they are usually advertised as "luxury apartments". To summarize, - multi-family houses don't sell well - no new housing development in years - people are single and can't combine their income - house prices have increased a lot more than people's income
- Panzer04 3y agoThis is mostly because US has these crazy 30y fixed mortgages right? Everyone who owns a loan like that is sitting on huge gains and will find it very difficult to sell given the effective loss they would realise - transitioning to another house at a 4 percentage point higher interest rate will cost them a ton of money.
- Spivak 3y agoYes, a lot of my friends are "trapped" (not really they're actually quite happy about it) in their houses because they have 2-3% interest rates locked in which is today is almost free money.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoPrices rose because of those rates, so not always the bargain it may have seemed.
- hyperbovine 3y agoNot if you refinanced.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoFinancing affects the financing part of the payment, unsurprisingly… not the price part.
- kortilla 3y agoIt’s definitely why I wouldn’t sell under anything but duress. Going from my current 3% to 7% would be crushing.
- vb234 3y agoWe’re in the same boat. We live in an apartment building in a neighborhood we love. Recently, a larger apartment in our building came onto the market. The seller is desperate to offload and the size would really suit our family’s long term needs. However, the double whammy of the loss we’d take selling our unit while paying a higher mortgage at a higher interest rate is just too much to stomach.
- arb-spreads 3y agoWorst is an interesting framing - lowest transactions is far better. Obviously all in housing transaction costs decreasing from nearly 10% today to something a lot more reasonable would increase liquidity and transactions. A shift towards more short term rentals is also reducing the demand for homeownership.
- subpixel 3y agoShort term rentals do not reduce demand for homeownership. Quite the opposite, they reduce supply for home ownership.
- arb-spreads 3y agoNicer apartments, more houses are offered as short term rentals. People's preferences adjust. Resulting demand curve for homeownership adjusts Homeownership is a far smaller part of the 'American Dream' relative to a few decades ago.
- JoBrad 3y agoI don’t think this is preference as much as lack of choice. Housing has gotten so expensive that people are delaying purchasing, and renting as an alternative.
- jdksmdbtbdnmsm 3y ago>A shift towards more short term rentals is also reducing the demand for homeownership. Honestly what on Earth are you talking about??? Your logic is not clear at all, and if you're truly trying to claim that less people want to own houses then you need to make an argument because that is an outrageous claim.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoTwo points, demand can be specific to a price point. More people would want houses for $1 than $10 million dollars. Short term rentals specifically drive down demand. No need for a vacation house when you can rent. They drive down supply, but presumably the same number of people what to to live in a house
- osigurdson 3y agoCanada's real estate market seems far more precarious.
- HDThoreaun 3y ago28% of the Canadian economy is real estate. China’s peak was 22% and people been talking nonstop about how unsustainable it was. Canada is absolutely fucked imo
- tbruckner 3y agoHousing prices remaining high because people can't move and people can't buy because of interest rates just shows how stupidly hard it is to build new housing in the US.
- jahewson 3y agoHome builders operate on borrowed money so high interest rates push up their costs significantly. Worse still, with rates expected to slowly come down they’ll be selling into a market where house prices are likely lower (in real terms). Neither are really connected to how hard it is to build housing (though yes it’s too hard).
- tbruckner 3y agoThe financing for home builders would also be a bit lower if housing were easier therefore less risky to build. But agree that higher interest rates hurt builders too.
- tarikjn 3y agoDoes anyone have a good explanation of why the Federal Reserve isn’t able to have lower interest rates for supply creation activities? It appears that would be a useful tool that would work in favor of their inflation and employment mandate.
- Ekaros 3y agoEconomy is doing "good" so there is no need. And there is still large risk of inflation coming back. So it is better to keep rates higher. There is yet no real need to lower rates. So better to wait and see.
- tarikjn 3y agoThe idea is that it could help lower inflation as shelter is a large portion of core CPI. It’s not about lowering the prime rate, but having a lower rate for creation of supply, which would exclude all services (80% of the economy).
- 29athrowaway 3y agoAfter 2008, there's a 600,000 housing unit deficit. Also, an increase in corporate investors buying cash and waiving inspections. The American dream will be rented not bought. You'll own nothing and be happy.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoLess than 1% of single family homes are bought by institutional investors. Post pandemic they’ve actually been selling more than buying
- SeanAnderson 3y agoDo you have a source for this? I don't really doubt you but it runs counter to what I thought was happening.
- asynchronous 3y agoI feel like only way to fix this is with government intervention, and I absolutely hate that idea.
- bombcar 3y agoYou could reduce immigration or the birth rate but there are exceptional problems with both.
- diogenescynic 3y agoI think pandemic created a one in a lifetime structural change (remote work) that is going to take years/decades for supply to catch up with demand. I keep seeing YouTube analysts predicting a housing crash every year for several years in a row... I think they are missing that there are not as many 'local' jobs/wages anymore and a lot of the demand is from those remote/hybrid workers moving into areas that previously only had local jobs and thus housing remained more closely tied to those wages. That paradigm is now broken or forever changed. Instead of living in SF, people moved to Napa/Sonoma/Petaluma/Sacramento/Tahoe/Monterey/Santa Cruz, etc. so now housing prices have gone up in those places. Hopefully the housing/zoning laws that have been passed in California start to have an impact and we see more housing development, but I still think there are legal barriers that prevent that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]