6 ms·
The question of poverty vs. instability
- mrangle 3y ago[flagged]
- cheschire 3y agoYou've had the thought of, and conveyed the thought to others, the intent and meaning of the phrase "shit show", so why shy away from writing it?
- mrangle 3y agoThe same reason that anyone might choose another phrase or word short of one considered to be a less-mannered.
- pattmayne 3y ago[flagged]
- MathMonkeyMan 3y agoWhat would a shit show even look like?
- psynister 3y agoIt's disheartening to see such drastic disparities between foster kids and their peers in terms of both education and incarceration rates. It really highlights just how important having a stable home life is to shaping the future outcomes for kids and how big of a disadvantage it is for those who don't have this privilege. Sad that we live in a society where we can't provide a healthy, stable environment so many kids.
- bluetomcat 3y ago[flagged]
- majormajor 3y agoI don't agree in general, but I wonder why you blame it on sexualization of culture and the effect of that on women instead of hyper-masculization/glorification of scams/violence in culture and the effect of that on men? All those "risk-taking macho [men]" you refer to could be easily blamed on a mass media system that glorifies such behavior, yet you focus your comment on sexualization and women, who seem to be less of the principal actors in your story compared to the men taking risks and leaving people in the lurch.
- bluetomcat 3y agoTeenage girls in particular fall prey to that mass conditioning. In recent years, platforms like TikTok incentivise their early sexualisation. Before that it was teen pop and MTV videos. You just don’t see a 20-year-old woman imagining herself as a housewife and cooking meals anymore. Her biggest asset is her body and she uses it as a tool to manipulate men.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Teenage girls in particular fall prey to that mass conditioning. Bold of you to assume only teenage girls do. I know guys in their late 20s to early 30s (with university degrees!) who follow and agree with the likes of Andrew Tate or other such scammer nutjobs of the manosphere. From what I saw, my take is that such people are like that due to lacking support. They lack a supporting family unit(poor relationship with their parents), they lack a caring social group(isolated, introverts, very few friends), they lack a caring mentor to show them the way on how to get out of a rut and improve their situation, so end up pray to easy manipulation of these fake gurus who help them fill that void.
- dawatchusay 3y agoEvidence please
- Xeoncross 3y agoThe same is true of adults. Not having a loving support network is not good for humans. We don't do as well. The benefits of a network is well known in the business world. Being a "force-multiplier" is more important than being a lone "rock-star".
- pattmayne 3y agoYep, humans are social creatures.
- shermantanktop 3y agoAnd sometimes they are antisocial creatures, which is also rooted in the same impulse, at least for some people. Being truly asocial—attaching zero positive or negative value to social connection—seems very rare. (That’s my own invented definition of “asocial”, which I think is more neutral than the dictionary version)
- harveywi 3y agoBetter yet, be a force multiplier who is willing to relocate. Then when times get tough you have your abelian group to lean on.
- em-bee 3y agocan you elaborate how you mean that? i don't quite follow how relocating comes into play here.
- dash2 3y agoThe article gives some very good counter-examples to the overinterpretation of twin studies to claim "family environments don't matter". (Self-promotion: I and a friend wrote something similar here - https://wyclif.substack.com/p/no-wait-stop-it-matters-how-you-raise https://wyclif.substack.com/p/no-wait-stop-it-matters-how-yo....) Still, it is fair to say that some of the underlying differences captured by being in foster care may be genetic.
- firesteelrain 3y agoThis article presents intriguing research on how poverty and instability in childhood impact future outcomes. It finds that while poverty itself isn't significantly linked to negative outcomes, environmental unpredictability during childhood is. This is evident in the reported correlation (r = .40, p < .01) between early instability and adult criminal behavior. This challenges common perceptions about poverty's role in shaping life trajectories.
- pattmayne 3y agoThat's really interesting. I had poverty and instability growing up, and I tend to treat the instability as an effect of the poverty. And I blame many of my adult problems on that poverty. But in truth, if I had to get rid of one then I would keep the poverty and get rid of the instability. Except for one thing: poverty forced us to live in the forest because we couldn't afford to live in town. That social isolation was hands-down the worst and most long-term harmful thing that I ever experienced. Poverty can also be poison.
- firesteelrain 3y agoIt does seem that families that are impoverished are more likely to be unstable. At least to a degree
- em-bee 3y agowhich is the downside of living in a country without good social support and also not having any family support. i have been though this. in the early years when my parents didn't have the support they would have needed (or didn't want to accept it) we experienced years of instability. once that support arrived (or my parents figured out what they needed to do to get it), things stabilized. but the damage was already done. in my case it affected my ability to make friends which didn't get better until university where i was at least able to meet some like-minded people, which helped.
- foobarian 3y agoThis is something I saw a lot of with certain immigrant families. The incoming generation would generally be quite poor, but there was some other property they had that made a big difference: they were educated, stable, capable, loving, etc. It's as if you transported a well-off family somewhere else while only taking all their money away but leaving everything else. They would live modestly but then the first generation would end up quite well off.
- loganfrederick 3y agoI have no direct connection to Rob Henderson but he's one of my favorite writers just from his Twitter and Substack because he dives into issues that are very close to my heart and life experience. I've written past comments on HN about how I was raised by a father who was a professional con man who committed credit card fraud, drove family into bankruptcy, then ghosted on my mother and I. The depths of that process was deeply chaotic and disruptive at a formative time in my life (high school and college). I've ended up having a solid career, but I have no doubt I'd have been able to make a bigger impact if the family drama hadn't dragged on my time and focus for years (basically in supporting my mother through the experience). Society's answer (at least in America) is basically to say "you could cut out your family if they're destructive" but that goes against one of the strongest aspects of human nature (to have a family). Choosing between chaos and isolation is a terrible dichotomy and a big job of society should be to ensure individuals have other warmer options. Also identifying earlier and stopping those chaos agents like my father is an area of study that is under-researched compared to the upside for society in solving that problem. There are folks like the Mind Research Network (https://www.mrn.org/ https://www.mrn.org/) working on this but IMO should be getting 10x the funding they currently do.
- rayiner 3y ago> Society's answer (at least in America) is basically to say "you could cut out your family if they're destructive" but that goes against one of the strongest aspects of human nature (to have a family). It’s also not really an answer, because non-chaotic families are a source of added stability. My sister in law lives with us, and my parents live 10 minutes away. So for my kids there’s never any uncertainty—someone will always pick them up from school on time and take them to their after-school activities even if mom and dad get caught up at work unexpectedly. This is very different from my wife’s upbringing, where her parents divorced and had shared custody, so there were missed handoffs, changes to extra-curricular schedules to accommodate different living situations, no consistent place to leave her things, etc.
- Ozzie_osman 3y agoIt's also not always an option. If you're a child or a teenager you don't have a lot of options. If you're a romantic partner that is financially dependant you also don't have a lot of options.
- thatguysaguy 3y agoThe point about twin studies only showing heritability in reasonably well-off families is one I haven't seen discussed before. That seems like a huge asterisk on all the claims based on twin studies I've seen.
- xhevahir 3y ago> Crime skyrocketed in 2020. Did genes transform overnight? No. Lawlessness became easier to get away with. So more people committed crimes. This article is an odd mixture of careful argumentation and bald assertion.
- nox101 3y agoit's all over the place. It starts talking about foster care but the actual study followed mothers, not kids. They didn't check if kids are in foster care, they checked if the mom switched jobs, addresses, etc.... At the bottom they also go from grandparents with stable life made stable kids who became parents unstable kids ... not sure what causation they are trying to show there
- thex10 3y agoHaving grown up in the bottom decile of poverty in the USA I can believe it. I credit my childhood's stability for much of my success in life. Sure my life, especially at home with my family, was broke, boring, uninspiring, not the least bit enriched... but it was incredibly stable thanks to living in public housing and being on welfare. It's much easier to find your way out if you don't have to process and respond to chaos :)
- cool_dude85 3y agoI think the point of comparison of high school graduation rates, the lowest income quintile, really undersells the kind of traumas many children in foster care have faced and the exceptional needs they may have. I think these statistics are best explained by Simpson's paradox. Some confounders not studied that are likely very highly correlated with dropping out: things like being a victim of sex trafficking, serious physical abuse, drug addiction, gang membership, the list goes on. I suspect if these types of factors were adequately controlled for, that graduation and incarceration rate gaps would narrow significantly. Goes without saying but I agree with the author on the genetic mumbo jumbo, except to say that some serious mental illnesses that have genetic predisposition could also explain some of the issue.
- abeyer 3y agoWas kind of disappointed to see what was mostly a well-reasoned and supported article veer off into anecdotal "kids these days" rant mode at the end.
- renewiltord 3y agoThis guy uses weak studies to confirm positions on things. Some fail replication. He blocked me on Twitter for pointing something like this out. I'd link but the whole API kerfuffle on Twitter killed my Slack bridge and so I can't find the tweet easily anymore. It's mostly like pop sci stuff. Setting himself up to be next Gladwell.