7 ms·
Google search is losing the fight with SEO spam, study says
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rschiavone 3y agoAnd whose fault is that
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- datadrivenangel 3y agoKagi and DuckDuckGo are viable search engines! Often as good as google, sometimes better given all the SEO spam!
- bamboozled 3y agoDuckDuckGo no. Kagi, yes.
- dazc 3y agoDDG still often returns results that closely match the exact search term, something Google seems increasingly determined not to?
- bamboozled 3y agoLast I checked DDG is Bing. So if you think DDG is good then I guess you think Bing is good. I personally don’t.
- 8organicbits 3y agoCan you sell me on Kagi? I took a look at the results for "best laptop" [1] and I'm underwhelmed. I see Reddit at the top (but many people here suggest adding "site:reddit.com" to the search) and most other results are from the same sites (but different order). It's hard to tell which order is better because the query is poorly written. Best laptop for what? I was also surprised to see that it recommends a site that uses affiliate links, its hard to trust those as being unbiased since there's profit motive. Is there a better example? Re-ordering search results doesn't feel worth paying. [1] https://kagi.com/search?q=best+laptop&r=us&sh=MuemT1_yBcwqyxpG7OsKvQ https://kagi.com/search?q=best+laptop&r=us&sh=MuemT1_yBcwqyx...
- bamboozled 3y agoI’m going to say that you do need to adjust to it. It won’t give you “personalized results” like Google so you might have to adapt to that.
- Departed7405 3y agoThose are metasearch engines though. Take the Google/Bing output and filter it, maybe add some nice features and Voilà. It's nice but doesn't solve the underlying problem, at least if you rely on Google. A Duopoloy is somewhat better than a monopoly.
- dkd903 3y ago[dead]
- jan_Sate 3y agoYears ago I gave up on DuckDuckGo because Google returned better result. Lately I gave DuckDuckGo another shot. It isn't better than before but with the deteriorating quality of the result coming from Google, now that DuckDuckGo's quality apparently isn't any worse than Google.
- crote 3y agoPersonally I'd say DDG is okay. It's not exactly a good search engine (early Google was definitely better), but at least it's not complete crap like 2024 Google.
- speedgoose 3y agoFrom my understanding, Kagi uses Google Search as a source, probably using residential IP proxies, and filter and reorder the results based on a few metrics such as the amount of ads and the domain blocks by the Kagi users. It’s fine but I went back to DDG/Bing with uBlacklist.
- eddyzh 3y agoWhat makes you think that kagi uses Google? To my understanding that is utterly incorrect.
- carlosjobim 3y agoThey use Google and are completely open about it, you can easily confirm this.
- speedgoose 3y agoIt’s written on their website: https://help.kagi.com/kagi/search-details/search-sources.html#external https://help.kagi.com/kagi/search-details/search-sources.htm...
- thiht 3y agoI've never had a single valid result with DuckDuckGo, every single time I've used it I had to fallback to !g. And years after, I still hate the stupid name and logo. Kagi was much more impressive than DDG when I tried it. I'll probably give it another shot in the coming month, hoping that I can completely replace Google Search this time!
- caldarons 3y agoI would also add Brave search. It returns decent results and has a very nice way of displaying reddit posts relevant to the search (saves you from having to type reddit at the end of the query :) )
- wetpaws 3y ago[dead]
- TexanFeller 3y agoDDG seemed Ok, but I kept going back to Google. For me Kagi is worlds better than both.
- alentred 3y agoI have been using DDG exclusively for more than 10 years now. Because of that I cannot really compare it to other search engines, but this is also to confirm that so far I have been able to find everything I needed. I know there are some negative reviews here about DDG. I don't know, maybe it is more about getting used to it? I remember that I definitely had to adjust quite a bit, but now I almost always get what I need in the top 5(ish) entries. I'd argue it also got better recently, as I rarely see the SEO-spam as of late. The only thing I am still not using DDG for is searching for local shops, etc. I use Maps or Tripadvisor. Same goes for some other specific topics - it is sometimes easier to use a dedicated app. Anything else, meaning some generic search on an arbitrary topic - DDG is OK, does its job. Not more, not less.
- edgyquant 3y agoGoogle lost the fight years ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nubinetwork 3y agoGoogle caused the fight when they started allowing things that would rank pages higher than others, other than actual content alone. Things like meta text overloading, or hiding gigantic walls of text in the HTML code, etc.
- davidmurdoch 3y agoSo, 1998?
- raverbashing 3y ago"losing". I mean, are they even fighting back at this point?
- revskill 3y agoSame question.
- sjwhevvvvvsj 3y agoGoogle played both sides and lost. They took a cut of all the SEO trash display ads, and all revenue from the search ads. It seemed like a great way to make endless cash, but they double dipped and ended up breaking the web by hyper incentivizing trash content. As predicted by many, DoubleClick killed Google. It took longer than people predicted, but you can’t play both sides forever. Now what?
- netruk44 3y agoTangentially related, I’ve noticed on the google search console that they aren’t crawling or indexing my personal blog at all, basically. I have to manually request indexing in order for my months old blog posts to show up on Google. I went from 1 appearance in search results every few days to 15 per day just by manually requesting indexing on my recent blog posts. But what I find confusing is that even when I do this, Google won’t follow any links it finds when it eventually gets around to crawling my posts. I submit my site map and it won’t index anything new. I have to manually ask Google to index every new blog post I make. It seems like small blogs like mine just aren’t what Google is interested in finding and presenting to users.
- dazc 3y agoMaybe with so much linking being reliant upon social media these days it is becoming increasingly difficult to trust new sources? I notice even regular sites that do link out are increasingly using nofollow as a default.
- jsemrau 3y agoThey do the same thing with substack and medium. Content like this doesn't really show unless you specifically search for it. While I understand where this policy is coming from, i.e., to distinguish proper outlets from blogspam. But it feels that in 2024, a lot of serious longform content has moved from traditional media to sites like the ones aforementioned.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoBacklinks probably matter. Like most of my blog is findable on Google, despite being pretty far away from being a "proper outlet". In general it's hard to for a search engine to understand the context of a website if there are few or no organic links to it. That hasn't really changed the last 30 years.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- omoikane 3y ago
- tussa 3y agoHow is it affecting Google's profits?
- gumballindie 3y agoYeah it’s not even spam that concerns me, i can filter those websites out. Literarily searching for one term and getting results for a different term is what bothers me. Shows that there is a fundamental flaw lurking deep in there.
- jan_Sate 3y agoAgreed. Clearly they're using some kind of fuzzy text matching, which isn't quite working correctly. They need to bring back keyword-based matching. At least provide an option to enable that.
- topicseed 3y agoThe option to enable that is using double quotes for the most part, no? e.g., fuzzy text matching => "fuzzy text matching"
- BobaFloutist 3y agoNo, that's also broken. You need to go to tools, and select "verbatim", and then often also enclose it in quotes.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dazc 3y agoUsing the example given 'best headphones, I didn't find the results to be so bad as I expected. That said, can anyone suggest an alternative method of providing a viable result for such a query that is not monetized and biased in some way or another?
- gherkinnn 3y agoFinding product reviews is next to impossible. Only a few people like DC Rainmaker fill a very specific niche. It's back to good old word of mouth for me.
- f1shy 3y agoYou mean honest real ones. I find lots of fake reviews with affiliate links
- vbernat 3y agoAdd "reddit" to the search query.
- thfuran 3y agoPlease let me know where this unbiased, monetization-free version of Reddit is.
- justech 3y agoReddit itself is monetized, but the people writing the review or suggesting products most likely weren't paid to recommend stuff. Not that there aren't paid shills on reddit, but as long as your BS meter is decent, a quick peek at the poster's profile can confirm whether the suggestions are legit. It's a bit of work to weed out real testimonies but if you can collect a bunch of reviews and use your own judgement as a final filter. I think that's better than just clicking any of the "Top 10 <product>" sites that google shows on the first page.
- dageshi 3y agoReddit works absolutely fine for this query so long as you dig a little, in the same way you once had to dig a bit for this kind of query on google search, back when it was good. You just have to review enough threads on the subject to build up a picture and refine your search. I did just this for noise cancelling headphones before Christmas and reddit was invaluable.
- HlessClaudesman 3y agoBard is a quixotic pipe dream. If Google's managment are sacrificing the Search golden goose in order to tilt at windmills they deserve to fail and be replaced.
- 7e 3y agoSearch is already dead, or soon will be. Bard is their only hope, but of course, Bard hides the ads that content providers put on their websites. So, Google is fecked royally, and all of their entitled, dysfunctional employees are in for a rude awakening.
- bwb 3y agoReally easy to show context ads based on conversation. Either in line or next to it.
- LightBug1 3y agoI'm as rubbed-up-the-wrong-way by Google as anyone ... but I'm currently having a better experience with Bard than with chatGPT. User experience is absolutely better. Results: yesterday I had an important query so tried different models, Bard came up with the most helpful answer. I can only imagine that the free Bard version is running at a decent clip, whereas the free chatGPT may be substandard (as I hear good reviews of the paid version). Possibly a strategic mistake by openAI.
- gtirloni 3y agoBard is better than GPT3.5 (ChatGPT free) and, IMHO, worse than GPT4 (ChatGPT paid). I find the ChatGPT's interface much better. Bard is really barebones and heavy. Now with GPT store and whatnot, OpenAI is not making it easy for Google at all.
- solardev 3y agoWe need a meta AI that will query all the other AIs and improve their prompts and summarize the good results
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoMonocultures are bad. SEO spam is the human/digital equivalent of potato blight spoiling results of our Google monoculture web-index.
- akagusu 3y agoGoogle is losing nothing. Google has no incentive to fight spam because every time someone clicks in a spam link, this link is full of ads served by Google
- jsheard 3y agoIs there a reason why Google doesn't allow you to block specific domains from your personal results like Kagi does? Is it a performance thing? Simply being able to block low quality domains from showing up again would go a long way to cleaning things up.
- ketanip 3y agoI think it may affect their ad revenue adversely, as users will just block website from which they see too many ads, in some cases people may just began to use it like a in-build ad blocker.
- dazc 3y agoBecause they tried that already and it was gamed to death.
- jsheard 3y agoGamed how? I can see how feeding users blocking decisions back into the ranking algorithm would be abused, but they don't have to do that.
- dazc 3y agoFeeding results back into the algorithm was indeed the reason it was abused. 'They don't have to do that' is correct though, I don't know the reason for that.
- amelius 3y agoGoogle: We need all your personal data so we can give you a better experience. Me: Ok, please block Pinterest, W3schools, ... Google: Sorry, can't do that.
- codegeek 3y agoWhat's wrong with w3schools ? They have come a long way since the w3fools days and their content is really good in my opinion.
- jsnell 3y agoDupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39013497 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39013497 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39031691 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39031691 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39040559 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39040559
- dang 3y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Google Search Has Gotten Worse, Researchers Find - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39040559 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39040559 - Jan 2024 (23 comments) Researchers confirm what we already knew: Google results are getting worse - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39031691 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39031691 - Jan 2024 (66 comments) Is Google Getting Worse? A Longitudinal Investigation of SEO Spam in Search [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39013497 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39013497 - Jan 2024 (271 comments)
- nhggfu 3y agorelated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39031101 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39031101
- jeffbee 3y agoIf I was researching Google search quality, I would do searches on Google. I guess this simplistic view is why I'm not an academic researcher.
- renegade-otter 3y agoI effectively stopped searching Google as is. It's become completely useless. Recently I got FIVE sponsored results before even getting to the SEO-gamed results. I have to: * Add "reddit" to get any sort of non-promoted human-driven knowledge * Select "Past Year" from Tools Recently I started getting really old search results. Not sure if I just never noticed, or they finally totally screwed up their algorithm.
- alexdunmow 3y agoI have definitely noticed that the search results are often old now. I constantly have to set "past year". Something that was otherwise rare not even a year or two ago. I would like to pay for Kagi. But with this economy I'm belt tightening and adding another subscription seems crazy. Even if the experience is 100x better than Google's.
- freediver 3y ago> I'm belt tightening and adding another subscription seems crazy. Even if the experience is 100x better than Google's. Search is one of the most complex and sophisticated products in the world. Genuinely curious, what other subscriptions are more important than access to high quality information that makes you even just 2x more productive and competitive in the world?
- AlbertCory 3y agoIf you asked this in court, lawyers would stand up and say, "Objection! Leading!" That's an argument, not a question.
- freediver 3y agoFair, I was interested in whether the argument was overlooked or already acknowledged and there is no way? to probe without inserting it.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rthkljlkrj 3y ago[dead]
- indymike 3y agoGoogle no longer cares about search. It is open for disruption.
- jsemrau 3y agoI am using more often bing chat now compared to google. Mainly for the GPT integration. Yes. Bard exists and is comparable. But I don't like where Google is going culturally as well as technologically. Starting with the weird firings lately to the incognito tracking.
- Ensorceled 3y agoGoogle search losing the SEO battle and Gmail is losing the SPAM battle. Alphabet has taken its eye off the battle.
- 6nf 3y agoIs there a search engine that actually and consistently looks for what you search for now? Once in a while I try Google but very frequently it completely ignores some of my keywords and I have to click the 'include XXXX' and try again. WTF GOOGLE WHY DO YOU STILL DO THIS
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dpkirchner 3y agoI'm a little embarrassed to admit that I mumble "I typed it for a reason" and "I even made it the first term" more than once a day. Terms with low cardinality should never be automatically removed, or at least results without those terms should be sorted to the bottom of the result set. And "verbatim search" is no answer as long as there is no way to enable that mode for all future searches.
- TexanFeller 3y agoKagi works like how Google used to a few years ago if they had just kept improving what’s useful to users. You can pry my Kagi subscription from my cold dead hands.
- orangesite 3y agoAs long as your search engine is reliant on ad revenue you will not be able to win this fight.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoOne odd thing I notice from TFA: > "the majority of high-ranking product reviews in the result pages of commercial search engines (SERPs) use affiliate marketing I say odd, because when the associate/affiliates program was started at amzn (1995), this was precisely the outcome we expected and anticipated and even desired. It's not clear to me that it is a huge issue if the affiliate marketing is via a "neutral" 3rd party. If I honestly review Sony MDR-7508's as the best headphones, and I get my X% cut from amzn or wherever should anyone buy a pair using a link from my review page, it doesn't seem to me that anything particularly undesirable has happened. Now on the other hand, if Sony pays me some negotiable sum to rank them the best whenever a sale occurs from my page, or even worse, just outright pays me to say that, then we're in a distinctly bad place. Assuming you accept my framing, then we face the difficulty of being able to differentiate these two conditions, which is non-trivial to do.
- dchuk 3y agoNot related to the actual topic here, but I’d been eyeing those exact headphones for years but never bought them because I thought they were for musicians or something. I recently got them (and a cheap DAC for my desk hooked to my MacBook Pro) and just…wow. With the right equalizer settings, you can hear whole new parts of songs you didn’t/couldn’t know were there. I still travel with just AirPods because they’re so compact and easy, but I’m in love with those Sonys.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoMy problem with those headphones is that I don't find them comfortable for long periods of wear, mostly because they are too warm/hot. The sound is awesome, but I can't do much more than 30 minutes with them. I suspect there are some Sennheisers that may be better in this regard, and roughly as good acoustically. I also have a pair of Sony noise-cancelling headphones, and ironically those are not only more comfortable, but their tech specs at least match the MDR-7508's.
- TexanFeller 3y agoI don’t think they’re losing the fight, I think they’re not fighting it because the spammers that bubble up are profitable to them in one way or another. I switched to Kagi and no longer have this problem.
- blindriver 3y agoGoogle’s problem is that success isn’t being measured by quality, it’s being measured by revenues. And revenues keep going up and to the right. Everyone that says Sundar is a bad CEO, Google quality has gone down, etc have no quantitative proof besides their “feelings”. The overwhelming proof in terms of revenues is that everything is going well for a multi-trillion dollar company. Globally ads spend keeps increasing. Until the revenues start going down and subsequently the stock price, then the people who would do anything to change things don’t care.
- theedwood 3y agoRecently started looking in to GPT/LLM based search tools like perplexity.ai for this very reason. I've not used perplexity enough yet that I feel I can form a solid opinion one way or another yet, but I have yet to receive sponsored results or SEO spam from it. Sometimes I have to tailor the query a little differently than I would on a traditional search engine (using more natural language, for example) but it almost always returns useful information and cites it's sources for me so I can read more if the summary wasn't sufficient. I think Google has divested enough of it's profit from search that it's no longer the cash cow it once was and we're likely to see the quality of the product continue to decline. I would not be surprised if most people have replaced it in the coming years with one of the emerging LLM augmented competitors unless they choose to get on that bandwagon. The ultimate irony would be to see Google, ever the killer of products, kill off their original product at some point down the road.
- bobthepanda 3y agoThe problem is that SEO and spam make money for those using it, so it is basically an arms race vs whatever search engine is dominant. The moment something else other than Google becomes popular it will become their problem.
- engineer_22 3y agoThey outsourced page ranking to SEO professionals, who have developed new tools faster than Google. They are not in control of their own product right now.
- the_third_wave 3y agoUse a meta-search engine like SearXNG [1] and point it at Google/DDG/Brave/Bing/... and you'll be spared the mediocrity that is all those sponsored results, the profiling, the personalised results (which I consider to be a good thing to leave out, others may disagree) and you'll also start noticing which engine remains quiet on certain queries. You can easily run SearXNG yourself on that same SBC which you got to run your own mail and XMPP server [2], it doesn't take much (if any) maintenance and can - with the Recoll engine - also be used to search your own network. Source: I've been doing this for years and made the Recoll engine for SearX. [1] https://github.com/searxng/searxng https://github.com/searxng/searxng [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39052731 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39052731
- mazingo 3y ago[dead]