12 ms·
Relearning math as an adult
- UncleOxidant 3y agoSo... basically an ad for Math Academy? How about some free resources like Khan Academy?
- juunpp 3y agoThat's basically what it is. There is nothing to learn from this post other than "smash that beta sign-up button". Has anyone tried that course? Is it any good?
- AlchemistCamp 3y agoI did a year and a half ago before getting too busy with work. I found it to be a bit spartan, but still the most efficient tool for math study I've used. I was a math major long ago, so it was more a case of relearning than initial learning for me but the built-in SRS helped a lot and so did the granularity of the lessons. It's head and shoulders above Brilliant, IMO. If it didn't exist or I couldn't afford it, I'd probably go the OpenCourseWare approach. https://ocw.mit.edu/ https://ocw.mit.edu/
- viraptor 3y agoIt's really good for its goals. I've used it for a few months and was really happy with the results. The spaced repetition aspect worked perfectly. The courses are still being worked on - already 99% there with quality, but you can report any issues and they get fixed. Just keep in mind that the target is largely students, (at least at the moment) so the aim is mastery of the subject - if you're interested in learning the concept but not actually doing a lot of practice of using it, then it may not be the right service. And there are magic internet points / leaderboards if gamification is something that works for you. The exercise sizes are also very small almost all the time. That means instead of a whole topic at the time and figuring out where you left the last time, you can do as much as you want at a time and not be restricted by artificial "chapters".
- eps 3y agoYes, it's very good. Math Academy is much more dense and on-point that Khan's. You don't have to sit through 15 minutes of video when 2 minutes worth of text explanation does it. It uses spaced repetition for topics that you aren't good at, and for recently learned subjects. The topic dependency tree and automatic progressing to "unlocked" topics is obvious in retrospect, but here it's done very cleanly and unobtrusively. The initial evaluation test is worth its weight in gold. It eliminates the need to grind through things that you already know, but still covers any gaps. I had kids on Khan for few weeks and it was a hassle. The pace was too slow, too much time sunk into trivialities and they were bored most of the time. With Math Academy they sit down, they do their 20-30 min of focused hands-on effort and they are done for the day.
- juunpp 3y ago> Math Academy is much more dense and on-point that Khan's. You don't have to sit through 15 minutes of video when 2 minutes worth of text explanation does it. This is precisely what bothers me about KA. I guess they're trying to ease into the topic, but I find that kind of repetition annoying and distracting.
- bambataa 3y agoI have been doing the Math for ML course and would recommend. I have UK A level math but not Further Math, so up to basic calculus. But I forgot most of it and so Math Academy has me going through a lot of the Math Foundation units along the way. I was initially put off by the monthly price, as it is quite steep. The clincher is that about a year before starting Math Academy I had gone through the Open University’s MST124/125 textbooks (covering the same stuff as Foundations). Except even after a year I’d already forgotten most of it. Math Academy learning feels much more robust, since it includes spaced reviews and regular tests. I record things in Anki but it’s useful to have regular practice questions too. I also use ChatGPT to spell out things and find it works well at this level. Some things I’d like Math Academy to have: - ability to skip lessons (I don’t want to spend ages going over symbolic integration again) - a reference page to track unlocked material, maybe with Anki integration - fewer multiple choice questions and more in depth problems - proof-based math. I’m told this is coming but the degree-level courses have missed their estimated due dates. I will definitely finish Math for ML and then do linear algebra and multivariate calculus. You’d still need a good textbook to do them rigorously, but I think Math Academy sets you up well.
- Math-Ninja 3y agoHi, I'm Alex, curriculum director at Math Academy. Thanks for your comments. In response to the things you'd like us to have: "ability to skip lessons" - we plan on introducing "mini-diagnostics" sometime soon, hopefully within the next few months. This will allow students to "place out" of certain content they know. The primary diagnostic assessment will have done most of the grunt work here, but mini-diagnostics can be used for fine-tuning the knowledge frontier. "a reference page to track unlocked material" - This is an interesting idea that we can discuss. "fewer multiple choice questions" - We're actively introducing "Free Response" across the entire curriculum. Complete coverage across all courses will likely take several months, maybe over one year. Many of our lower-grade students should be seeing lots of free-response questions already. "more in-depth problems" - we have multipart problems in most courses. We plan to add many more. Introducing "challenge problems" into the curriculum is also something we have planned for the near future. "proof-based math" - We plan on launching our "Methods of Proof" course within the next 6-8 weeks. This course is designed to introduce students to all fundamental concepts related to proof building: sets, logic, functions, relations, cardinality, proof by induction, direct proofs, counterexample, contrapositive, contradiction, and trivial and vacuous proofs, to name a few. Most of the content is already ready. We have a few technical challenges to overcome before it can be launched due to our new "proof" question format, but we have a clear idea of how these challenges are to be resolved, so 6-8 weeks is certainly realistic.
- dheavy 3y agoIt's very good. I've tried it after hesitating a bit because of the price tag compared to Khan Academy — no regrets. K.A. is great and I still use with my kid, but M.A. is more condensed and to the point for my needs. I was properly guided through the first program choices according to my profile, and the diagnostic exam you start with was perfect to highlight what I actually need to work on given my limited time. Explanations and courses are super condensed, with the right amount of example and pedagogy that clicks for me.
- juunpp 3y agoReplying to myself since I can't edit: thanks for the feedback. I am compelled to look into the course after reading all the replies here.
- pmdulaney 3y agoThis is inspiring! I think your realistic, keep-plugging-away attitude will lead to continued success. The cost is $49/month/student.
- topologie 3y agoAs a Mathematician who worked in Theoretical Physics for a bit, I'm happy to hear that there's people out there interested in the area. Maths often get a bad rep, but at their core they are probably the most interesting thing to learn, on par with music in my opinion. I encourage anyone interested in Mathematics (regardless of your level) to check out Roger Penrose's The Road to Reality. I know it's technically a physics book, even though Penrose was originally a Mathematician, but trust me, he explains things in a way that open up your mind, even for seasoned veterans. He begins with basic calculus, but ends up covering Groups, Topology, Complex Analysis, Differential Geometry, etc etc etc. And, on parallel, check out John Baez's guide on how to learn Maths and Physics: https://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/books.html https://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/books.html I love all of Baez's pages and work, he does some really interesting mathematics: https://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/ https://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/ I'm also a big fan of Tai-Danae Bradley's work: https://www.math3ma.com/ https://www.math3ma.com/ Anyway, I hope people find these recommendations interesting or useful...
- balavalda 3y agoWould be cool if they had a parity paymant. For a third wolrd country is a hight to pay 49 dol :(
- boxfire 3y agoI may be biased as I am a trained Mathematician, but I always feel when someone says "Math is Hard", that is because they had bad teachers. Math is easy if you build up from fundamentals, not like physics education where you say "but lets delete everything before because it had an oversimplifying assumption", rather if you build your knowledge entirely sequentially from things you know or assume, you build up a toolbag that applies literally everywhere. So math isnt hard. Learning random bits of math out of context is hard. Climb the ladder once, you have it for life. Hopefully for this person that sticks.
- cloogshicer 3y agoThis assumes that climbing the ladder comes easy. To me at least, it doesn't. It requires tedious labor, and lots of repetition for every single step. That's the main difference I keep noticing between me and people who say they like math or find it easy. They just look at each step of the ladder once, and immediately "get" it, sometimes even skipping steps. In contrast, I need to repeatedly step up and down the ladder multiple times, until I can take the next step.
- dcw303 3y agoMy theory is that people who like math have a reward system that responds well to gaining an understanding on empirical concepts. I have that, and it does drive me to keep studying math. Not that I find it easy though, I don't think I'm able to skip steps, and I often have to repeat things I've already done before they sink in. The difference is that I find this process enjoyable, so I don't mind spending the time. If I can compare to another activity, I've always wanted to be an artist as well, and have spend quite a bit of time trying to build up the skills. The problem is that, if I'm honest with myself, is I just don't enjoy the process of creative expression, it doesn't trigger any reward system that means anything for me. I wish it did but there's just nothing there. It was a hard pill to swallow, but I realized I like the idea of being an artist, but I don't enjoy the process. Hence my ultimately crummy artwork! Sorry, I realized I'm talking about myself more than you, but I hope it's some help. The point I hope it makes is that everyone has a different personality, and from that different reward systems. It sounds to me like yours doesn't align with math, and that's fine. I wouldn't try to force yourself to study something which you don't love, at least if it's optional self study. Find subjects that you love learning, and the results will come naturally.
- 6d6b73 3y ago$49/student/month? That's excessive.
- hnbad 3y agoIt's not cheap. Given that it sounds like this is something you want to deliberately spend time on rather than just an app to use when you're bored it might be worth it but probably not so much if you can't use the knowledge professionally somehow.
- AlchemistCamp 3y agoCompared to what? They have a track-record of students not even old enough to be in high school yet passing AP Calculus BC exams. Here in Taiwan, where I live, it's not that uncommon for people to pay 5x that price per month on supplementary math courses for their kids. https://twitter.com/_MathAcademy_/status/1708542077695574292 https://twitter.com/_MathAcademy_/status/1708542077695574292
- KallDrexx 3y agoCompared to Kahn Academy, which also has a proven track record, is free, and has been around for a long while.
- AlchemistCamp 3y agoIf your time is worth even $1/hour, the "free" Kahn Academy option will be far more expensive than this program. I respect what Sal Kahn built, especially in the early days, but it's just not anywhere near as time-efficient.
- KallDrexx 3y agoIs there any data to back that up? Just because it's a paid resource doesn't mean it's better.
- mhss 3y agoThe tool might be good but there’s also strong selection bias due to its price.
- TotoHorner 3y agoCan anyone help me with some questions about this program? (I assume the founders will see this thread once they notice the HN hug of death) 1. How exactly is AI being used here? Is there an AI chat-bot that I can ask for help? Do you generate problem-sets with AI? Check answers with AI? Is it GPT-4? 2. Do you utilize Spaced-Repetition in any way? Have you found that to be useful? Thank you
- JustinSkycak 3y agoHi there, my name is Justin Skycak, I'm the Director of Analytics & Algorithms at Math Academy, I developed all of our quantitative software, and I'd be happy to answer your questions. 1. The AI is more like an expert system that emulates the decisions of an expert tutor with regard to what tasks a student should work on at any given point in time (what should the student learn next, what do they need to review). There's a knowledge graph that encodes structural relationships between thousands of math topics (such as prerequisite relationships, but also other types). And then there's an algorithmic reasoning system that looks at a student's answers, overlays them on the knowledge graph, figures out what the student knows (and how well they know it), and decides what learning tasks are going to move the needle most given their personal knowledge profile. The decision-making is inspired by cognitive learning strategies such as mastery learning, spaced repetition, interleaving, minimizing associative interference. 2. Yes, spaced repetition is a core part of the system. Each student has a personalized spaced repetition schedule that adapts to their performance on each topic, and when choosing what topics a student should review or learn next, we're always trying to implicitly "knock out" as many due reviews as possible to maximize learning efficiency. (For instance, if a student is due for a review on one-step ax=b equations, we can implicitly "knock out" that review by having them learn two-step ax+b=c equations instead.) From a quantitative standpoint, the spaced repetition model was one of the more challenging (but equally fun) parts to build. You normally think of spaced repetition in the context of independent flashcards, but in a hierarchical body of knowledge like mathematics, it gets really complicated because repetitions on advanced topics should "trickle down" to update the repetition schedules of simpler topics that are implicitly practiced (while being discounted appropriately since these repetitions are often too early to count for full credit towards the next repetition). Our spaced repetition model not only accounts for implicit "trickle-down" repetitions but also minimizes the number of reviews by choosing reviews whose implicit repetitions "knock out" other due reviews (like dominos), and calibrates the speed of the spaced repetition process to each individual student on each individual topic (student ability and topic difficulty are competing factors).
- dcw303 3y agoI've been doing similar for about a year. My target is to learn the math needed to make 3d games, so basically algebra, geometry, calculus and linear algebra. I started with brilliant.org, and while I liked the level of polish in the interactive lessons, I found the lesson structure to be out of sequence, often referring to things that haven't been covered yet. They didn't seem to have put as much thought into pedagogy as Math Academy as described in TFA. So I gave up on that and instead have been shipping several kilograms of dead tree across the pacific in the form of The Art Of Problem Solving series of textbooks. They are great, the lesson structure and building up of complex ideas from first principles is outstanding. They will humble you though, as the exercises are tough. They're also quite expensive but IMHO worth it. Math Academy does look interesting, If I was not halfway through my series I would probably take a look. But I do enjoy having reference books on hand. Many times I've jumped back to brush up on a topic that has slipped from memory. I solve my exercises with the most low tech solution possible, but I like the freedom it gives me to try new approaches, and nothing beats the latency between idea to ink on paper. edit: also wanted to add that I've enrolled Chat GPT4 as my tutor. Contrary to many other's experiences that I've read, I find it to generally be very good at reasoning in this level of mathematics. It's helped me many times when I've gotten stuck. And on the occasions where it bullshitted its way to an incorrect answer, I always challenge it if I don't understand, and we ultimately find out if it hallucinated something (rare, can usually be fixed by restating the problem), or I gave it the wrong input to start with (unfortunately more common than I'd like)
- AlchemistCamp 3y agoI totally agree with you on the value in using Chat GTP when stuck. What's the scope of The Art of Problem Solving? How far does the series go?
- dcw303 3y agoAOPS audience is gifted high school kids, so it doesn't get up to the college level. The core texts are: - Prealgebra - Intro to Algebra - Intro to Counting & Probability - Intro to Geometry - Intro to Number Theory - Intermediate Algebra - Intermediate Counting & Probability - Precalculus - Calculus
- hintymad 3y agoIt looks how do do proofs is at university level in the US. I wonder why other countries start to teach kids how to do proofs from grade 7. They start with rigorous proofs in Euclidean geometry, the move to solid geometry, then to proofs in elementary functions, sets, number theories, and etc, then to polynomials and simple discrete maths and analytic geometry. By the time a kid graduates high school. using things like proof by induction or by contradiction is like a second nature. And no, I'm not talking about elite kids, but curriculum requirements for all the STEM students.
- redcobra762 3y agoWe did proofs in 7th grade as part of geometry, in a semi-rural United States middle school.
- hintymad 3y agoGood to know. I guess education in the US has local standards? I have this impression of the US not teaching proof because in a number of introductory math classes in my college, the profs dedicated chapters to teach basics of induction, how to write proofs, and etc.
- Jtsummers 3y agoEvery state sets its own curriculum, with varying degrees of freedom for the districts and schools within the states. The federal level has standards, which students are generally tested against in various standardized tests, that are tied to federal funding. Multiple curricula can satisfy the same standards, at least on paper if not in practice. So states are, more or less, free to teach things how they want. However, they're also strongly driven by the textbook industry, which turns on the two biggest textbook purchasers: Texas and California. So a lot of the textbooks (and associated curriculum material) available for purchase in the rest of the states are driven by whatever those two states are pushing.
- redcobra762 3y agoI would have still appreciated that refresher in a college class on content I learned 7-8 years prior.
- SuperNinKenDo 3y agoWell, it's essentially an ad/shout-out for the mate's product, but if the value is there, the value is there. I can't afford the subscription price and don't care much for subscriptions these days anyway, but I'd love to found my own education company in the future, so wishing nothing but the best, and happy to see someone hopefully being able to make some money in the spacez even when free alternatives like Khan Academy are already established. Edit: The original post has no value in explaining how the author is learning maths other than to say that they're using the Math Academy platform, and taking notes. Useless to anybody not interested in a $49/month subscription to a semi-open beta. I would almost characterise the title of the post as a bait and switch after further consideration.
- fiforpg 3y ago> but I needed a good reason that would justify the time investment It should be understood though that there are cases when math(-like) language is abused, leading to overcomplication and obscurantism [1]. In mathematics, there is always the temptation of formalizing for formalization's sake. Indeed, 99% of pure math is non-constructive ("there exists a group such that", "the algorithm converges in O(N) steps"), as opposed to the practical CS and applied math ("here are the runtimes on real world data") which are likely the primary concerns of the HN crowd. None of this can diminish the sheer impractical appeal of pure math and pure CS, not unlike that of poetry, but I would rather not oversell either of the two. [1] A good illustration is a rant by Cosma Shalizi at http://bactra.org/notebooks/nn-attention-and-transformers.html http://bactra.org/notebooks/nn-attention-and-transformers.ht..., recently posted on HN.
- bsdpufferfish 3y ago> leading to overcomplication and obscurantism Mathematicians attempt to express ideas in the most readable and clear way possible. It's actually code that must be obfuscated by the constraints of the language and computer. Mathematicians have no constraints preventing them from presenting something in the way that makes the most sense. The part that can be called "Obscurantism" is when they use a high-level abstraction you are unfamiliar with. This is mostly driven by the audience. > Indeed, 99% of pure math is non-constructive Citation needed? > the algorithm converges in O(N) steps That doesn't sound non-constructive. Even the group example is usually done by constructing such a group. Also the best part about math is you can use it to approach the problems you want with constraints you want. Knuth uses math to solve real CS problems.
- davorak 3y ago> Mathematicians attempt to express ideas in the most readable and clear way possible. I buy this from the mathematicians and scientists that I know and have interacted with. I also think mathematicians spend more time trying to discover/play with new math than optimizing the communication of what already exists and is communicable. My speculation is that this naturally leads cruft that needs to be worked through by people entering the field. The cruft can not get too big or people don't enter the field so people are motivated to keep the cruft below a certain level but not the minimum. The cruft makes it harder to enter the field and once you have over come that hurdle you move on to do things in the field not reduce the cruft. Other things that make it hard to reduce cruft 1. not everyone is going to agree what is cruft 2. Person X spend time on reducing cruft in sub field Y may find out that Y is no longer hot topic so while there is less cruft there are not many people taking advantage of the reduced cruft in Y. 3. Mathematicians and scientists are reward more for new and interesting things than better pedagogical practice/techniques. 4. Optimizing for communication/pedagogy is mostly a different skill than science/mathematics so you have to split your focus or not dive as deeply into one or both. 5. I am sure there are others. This seems reasonable to me. It is s system where most everyone is well meaning and want to improve things and where things do improve over time, but where it is still easy to find areas that would benefit from substantial from improvement.
- maroonblazer 3y ago>> The ‘Foundation Series‘ is what I’m starting with. It’s for adults to help streamline learning (it skips the stuff that kids need, but adults don’t) and work back up through college-level math relatively quickly (emphasis on relatively ). I'm curious to know what 'stuff' he's referring to. And what about it makes it such that kids need it but adults don't. And if that's true, are we SURE kids need it? I had horrible math teachers growing up and always thought "I just don't have the 'math gene'." I eventually disabused myself of that thought and set out on my own (re)learning journey. Could it have been less arduous had I skipped the stuff I didn't need to know because I was an adult?
- JustinSkycak 3y agoHi there, my name is Justin Skycak, I'm the Director of Analytics & Algorithms at Math Academy. I can speak a bit as to the stuff that's skipped in the Foundation Series. After developing a curriculum that covers all the standards for 4th grade through AP Calculus BC, as well as plenty of advanced university courses (many of which are still under construction, but the structure is mapped out pretty comprehensively), we found that roughly a third of 4th grade through AP Calculus BC topics were not actually prerequisites for university math. So, we created a streamlined Mathematical Foundations course sequence that cuts out those topics. Those topics are necessary to check the box on grade-level / common core standards, but they're not really necessary for adult learners who want to pursue advanced university courses as soon as possible but lack the necessary foundational knowledge. I'll also send your question to my colleague Alex Smith, our Director of Content, who designed the Mathematical Foundations courses himself and can elaborate more on the specifics.
- ramblenode 3y agoThanks for responding. What are some examples of topics that you cut out from the high school math curricula? I have seen modern Algebra II courses remove conic sections in order to make more room for probability and statistics.
- Math-Ninja 3y ago
- BOOSTERHIDROGEN 3y agoCan OP now understand the decoder architecture? I would be interested in a follow-up post.
- gmays 3y agoNot likely yet, I'm still working through the Mathematical Foundations courses before I earn my way up to the Mathematics for Machine Learning course. I would love to do a follow-up post at some point.
- jorgesborges 3y agoI’m a thirty-something with an arts degree who decided to learn math. Basically I was tired of reading popular science and being fed metaphors to understand concepts. I wanted to “see” it for myself. I spent time online at Khan Academy and friends for a year or so on and off. It was fine but meandering? So I enrolled in community college! It’s great. I have a clearer path, immediate feedback, teachers, and an obligation to do work that keeps me on it. Ultimately my plan is to get enough transfer credits for university and spend this decade slowly working toward a bachelor of science in physics.
- paulpauper 3y agoVideos are good to get some barebone knowledge, but are too superficial or unstructured to replace classroom settings, with graded exams and homework.
- javchz 3y ago100% Agree. Im a big proponent of developing self-thought skills and making the best of e-learning, but I think math (alongside languages and other) are one of those areas where the real time feedback makes traditional education still worthwhile. It's hard to replace it with just books and online courses. Not impossible but harder.
- jacobolus 3y agoFunny. As a college student I found face-to-face interaction was much more important to studying social sciences and humanities than to studying math or theoretical physics or computing which could pretty effectively be studied in a book.
- jambutters 3y agoI actually find the immediate feedback from khan academy exercises better than school actually. The feedback loop is much more tighter instead of waiting an entire week later for results and not really getting another go at it. I also tend to zone out or miss something in the lecture, and that missed thing is what builds the entire foundation for everything else and then the entire lecture is pointless. With video based lectures, I can pause, go back, play 2x speed, look at multiple well produced explanations, etc. Ultimately I don't find face to face all that valuable a various amount of subjects.
- juunpp 3y agoThis is basically an unsolicited ad post. It communicates nothing of substance and the entire thing amounts to "click the sign-up button". It doesn't even cover the course contents. How this makes it to the HN front page is mind-boggling. Goatse would at least be more entertaining.
- xupybd 3y agoThank you for bringing that visual memory back. Why do I struggle to remember my anniversary date but have that image burned into my brain.
- kirubakaran 3y agoYou need an AI art of your anniversary date in the form of a goatse
- ChainOfFools 3y agoGoatse set up shop on a plot of mental real estate nothing else would go near. its in a bad part of town, but acts as a kind of landmark being the only object anything like its kind for miles in all directions. edit: removed the unintentional reference to the url; I did not expect it would still be active!
- ngneer 3y agoOn a very apt topic for HN readers, though, who likely enjoy math to some degree and have heard of LLMs. What if the post inspires someone to look into revisiting actively learning math as an adult? Is that so bad?
- sarchertech 3y agoWhen I went back to school for CS, I used this book https://a.co/d/7hlRdnK https://a.co/d/7hlRdnK to relearn math. I couldn’t recommend it more. It starts with algebra and works through calculus. There is a pretest before every section, so you know what you need to focus on and what you can skip.
- harrelchris 3y agoHere is a non-ref link: https://www.amazon.com/dp/0521017076 https://www.amazon.com/dp/0521017076 Maths: A Student's Survival Guide: A Self-Help Workbook for Science and Engineering Students 2nd Edition by Jenny Olive ISBN-10: 0521017076 ISBN-13: 978-0521017077
- rck 3y agoTangential, but: the notes that this post refers to are probably not the best way to learn how transformers work. If you want mathematical precision, those notes are based on this paper from DeepMind: https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.09238 https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.09238 The paper provides mathematically precise definitions of all the parts of a transformers, though it's showing its age (ha!) in that it doesn't include some formalizations that are common in, for example, Llama.
- gmays 3y agoThanks for this. What I included was just one of the ones I came across while researching. But given my lack of proficiency I couldn't tell up from down. I will bookmark this and dig in after I get a better handle on the fundamentals.
- jacquesm 3y agoBefore you look into paid options for your tuition needs I'd look into the Khan Academy first. It's free, very high quality and it's more than just math if you want it. Sal Khan is one of the greats and the Khan Academy, together with WikiPedia is one of the best things to come out of the internet.
- eps 3y agoKhan Academy is good and free, but it is inferior to Math Academy in many aspects. It's more tedious, takes more time and, most importantly, it's not as streamlined, as guided and as fuss-free as the MA. The latter got the process and the UX absolutely nailed down. All the praises you read and hear are 100% deserved.
- __loam 3y agoI've got an engineering degree but I've been thinking about trying to relearn this stuff. Sometimes it felt like I was just surviving rather than getting any of the skills to stick.
- jrnichols 3y agoKhan Academy worked for me and has a bunch of other fun classes too.
- daguava 3y ago[dead]
- ginbazinga 3y agoIf OP still wants to learn the mathematical foundation of transformers, I built a free alternative learning tool: https://afaik.io/nebula?mode=nebula&category=blueprint&id=ed0mb7N4rYw3 https://afaik.io/nebula?mode=nebula&category=blueprint&id=ed... It's also based on an underlying knowledge graph, connecting concepts across various subjects like maths, machine learning, physics, etc. You can check the graph for transformer here: https://afaik.io/nebula?category=brickset&id=VLlOnZLl&mode=dagre https://afaik.io/nebula?category=brickset&id=VLlOnZLl&mode=d... (only available on desktop... Basically, it frees you from learning maths from scratch and just learning the prerequisites required to grasp the concept, and there are free resources attached. Don't get me wrong, I can totally relate to the desire to relearn maths. One of the reasons that I'm building this tool is for me to relearn physics and know how to get there with my maths and cs background. I just feel in this specific scenario there might be more effective ways to learn in depth and have fun at the same time.
- galaxyLogic 3y agoI find the concept of "underlying knowledge graph" interesting. What does it mean? I assume it means such a graph connects the topics together as "pre-requisites". To understand A you need to already understand B and C, and to understand B you need to understand D and ... etc. But the thing about such a graph is that really it must be a tree, not just a directed graph. Why? Because there cannot be cycles in it. If to understand A you need to understand B, and to understand B you would need to understand A, you could never understand either of them. Right?
- ginnungagap 3y agoIf to understand D you need to know both B and C, each of which requires familiarity with A, the graph is not a tree
- galaxyLogic 3y agoRight, but if it is not acyclic, in which order should I try to understand them all?
- instaheat 3y agoThis post couldn't be any more timely. I dropped out of school years ago (16 years ago to be exact) to take care of my sick mother when she was dying. I never went back. I just started working. I am happy to report I am back in school and will be FINALLY finishing my Computer Science degree but I have a very long 4 years ahead of me. Math is going to be hard. What is encouraging is the thrill of when I get the answer right and most importantly knowing HOW I got there. It's (almost) better than sex.
- dvko 3y agoThis is inspiring to me, as I'm in a similar boat and while I'm pretty okay at my job in practical terms, I often feel as if I lack a certain mathematical foundation. May I ask how old you are, whether you are enrolled in a full-time course (w/ much younger other students, I suppose?) and how that has been for you?
- instaheat 3y agoI'm 39. I'm enrolled full-time. I'm taking (mostly) online classes. However, I start a math course that meets two days a week in person soon. I look relatively young with a hat on, that will keep me from feeling insecure about my appearance. I'm bald as Dwayne Johnson. Remains to be seen but I won't let anything stand in my way of finishing. Just going to put my head down and do the work. Not socialize.
- j7ake 3y agoI'm curious how many days before author can read a mathematical description of an algorithm (let's say expectation-maximization algorithm) into code?
- rtpg 3y agoSelf-learning is the sort of thing where you really want to be pointed to the right books. Some books are really good if you have people you can ask questions too, but those might not work at all without that. Meanwhile, others truly are a "lock yourself in a room for a couple of weeks and process it" thing. One side thing I've been thinking of to try and tackle this is an autodictact's version of letterboxd: have people talk about books and resources they're using, offer help to one another, and maybe help people discover interesting things to poke at. At the very least it would help me track my own in-progress material
- paulpauper 3y agoThere is so much interest in self-learning math or physics. We're in something of an autodidacticism boom. The amount of work to even have any hope of being proficient at this is substantial. For some reason it's always self-learning math or physics, which are among the two most difficult subjects. You got your work cut out. Even if you understand the basic concepts, understanding papers is another level above that.
- gsdgsdfg 3y agoPeople here mention KhanAcademy and AOPS series for self learning. I've used both when relearning Math as an adult. But there is one more resource which is absolutely terrific: Henry Sinclair Hall's books. Not only they are good (way better than the aforementioned ones), but being published in the 19th century, they are in public domain now and can be downloaded from the Internet Archive free of charge: https://archive.org/search?query=creator%3A%22Hall%2C+H.+S.+%28Henry+Sinclair%29%2C+1848-1934%22 https://archive.org/search?query=creator%3A%22Hall%2C+H.+S.+... And, also, How to Prove it by Velleman is a must read.
- jasfi 3y agoSome years ago I got back into math basics, so I could do mental math as a hobby. I'm still doing it today, nearly daily. I've also added crosswords. I've found that this helps to keep me sharp (I'm in my 40s), and should help me even more as the years go by.
- moi2388 3y ago50 a month for what Khan academy does for free? Ads do be getting smarter, albeit more annoying
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nicholasbraker 3y agoI work in IT as a network architect and when I tell people I graduated high school with one F on my final list being math they frown a bit. In my high- schooldays (90'ies era) they made a distinction between "math-A" which was more statistics and "math-B" which was more algebra and calculus. I really sucked at math-A which was considered by some as not even real math. I will definitely check this one out and hope to improve this even now in my 40'ies..
- pprotas 3y agoSounds like The Netherlands, no? At the very least, the same system is used in The Netherlands to this day. I graduated high school with a barely-passing grade in Math A, and years later was able to finish exams in Math B with a passing grade. All it took was dedicated practice, and I suck at math! You can do it as well.
- nicholasbraker 3y agoYup, The Netherlands. My plan is to check out my daughters math classes she gets in high-school next year. She’s way smarter than me, so she can teach me!
- jb3689 3y agoLearning grade school math won’t really help you understand these things. Yes, you will learn to think numerically and practice applying opaque algorithms, but you’d be better off starting with basic set theory and logic and learning “real” math. Book of Proof is one of my personal favorites. Then you can move onto some Real Analysis while brushing up on Calculus, then maybe consider formal probability starting to learn the foundations
- mjburgess 3y agoThe "math" used in ML/AI papers is usually just a sort of 'whiteboard math' which is a domain-specific mishmash of linear algebra, calculus, set theory and statistics. If you could find a book just going through the relevant bits you wouldnt really have to "learn math again", it can be translated into english straightforwardly -- very very few ML papers relevant to industry have extended proofs, etc. that require eg., even being able to differentiate anything yourself. 90% of it is: here's the domain (ie., type) of our variables, here's the formula of our functions, we're taking a weighted average with some inner products involved. It might sound like a lot of math, but it's really all doable in semester-1 of an undergrad course, were it focused enough.
- programjames 3y agoNormalizing flows and neural ODEs are becoming a bigger thing, and they do involve some more heavy maths.
- jurgenaut23 3y agoYes, and if you look at neural operators, then you're in for something that even math majors need to put a bit of effort into.
- programjames 3y agoOh, I read that paper about a year ago. I feel like it could have been explained better, but the concepts aren't that hard if you've taken numerical methods.
- sjducb 3y agoI think you don’t realise how much math you know. I’ve heard of set theory, but never studied it.
- mjburgess 3y agosure, but you dont need to understand actual set theory -- it's just notation for mostly obvious programming stuff, R means float, Z means int R^2 is actually notation from linear algebra, but here it means a point is 2 floats with a measure of distance between points etc. A lot of this could just be given in a "crib sheet" for tech people, and you'd get 80% of it straightaway. It's years of work to understand this notation as used by the professional domains it was invented by, but it's a couple weeks for most "good, technical, software engineers" -- since they arent really using notation in much more than superficial ways. Of course there are hard mathematical papers, etc. but they're rare in ML/AI mainstream papers; and not something most would read. If you need to be able to read, eg., some sort of adv. statistical time series research in economic modelling, you'd already have the background to do that. If all you want is to be able to read 90% of the popular papers, the notation in them is just syntax sugar for things you could state easily in english or python
- mabedan 3y agoI tried math academy for this exact purpose, but I had to give up because it didn't let me test out of lessons that I was already good at (Similar to how duolingo would allow you to do). So I ended up wasting a lot of time sitting through all the exercises which I didn't need.
- eps 3y agoYou could've asked them to add this option. They are very responsive and reasonable.
- mabedan 3y agoI did. They replied a generic corporate answer that we do the best for our customers and they said I’m free to cancel my subscription
- Math-Ninja 3y agoHi, I'm Alex, Curriculum Director at Math Academy. It is on our radar to allow students to "place out" of certain topics and modules if they feel ready. We'll call them "mini-diagnostics" or something similar when they're ready. I believe it will be worked on within the next few months. Unfortunately, these things do take time to implement, but we are listening. FWIW, we're a tiny, bootstrapped company with literally two programmers (Justin, our ML/backend dev, and Jason, our founder and solo UX/UI) working on the entire codebase. The content team is a little larger. We have around 12, mostly PhD mathematicians, working on the content, which is why the context is probably a little further ahead in some respects.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoAbout a year ago my wife and I made the joint decision to get her into college for a bachelor's degree in either English or computer science. Here in Finland, university admissions are based around how well you did on various end of school exams, and she fortunately did quite well on all of them a decade ago - except for math. She bombed math due to health and family problems as a teenager decimating her ability to pay sustained focused attention. Luckily, soon after the decision was made, I finally got my first full time job in Finland. I could easily support the two of us and give her an uninterrupted life to focus on grinding up for the math exam. We took the last ~10 years' worth of math exams online, turned their problems into Anki cards, and set her nose to the grindstone. I had had tremendous success with this in college with abstract algebra and real analysis, so I figured the same methodical approach + a very stable living situation was bound to work for algebra through basic calculus. Five months later, she retakes the high school exam and gets the highest score possible! Her rapid success at this convinced her to give CS a serious try, and indeed her improved math exam was the differentiator - without it she would not have been accepted to the CS program. She got top marks in her first semester at CS as well, I couldn't be more proud. My wife is truly an incredible person.
- NeutralForest 3y agoCool comment, it's great seeing people being supportive of their SO =)
- baq 3y ago> set her nose to the grindstone Worth calling out the key observation: it takes practice, and lots of it (for most people, anyway) to get good at math. Just reading about it does zilch.
- tux3 3y agoIt does a little more than zilch. Exercise is important. Reading is also important. If you want to learn fast, you need a balance of both that works for you. Some people will spend months grinding hard problems on their own in a single chapter to make sure they really understand. Some people will read too fast and have to go back because they don't have solid foundations, and only thought they understood. Reading is about as important as doing exercises. You're not going to reinvent all of math on your own. You get insights from both.
- burrish 3y agoNice Ad post, there are A LOT of free resources to learn math on the web, why go through $49/month ? People are citing Khan Academy which I warmly recommend, there are a lot of good Math teachers teaching math on YouTube, and there is also OpenStax.org [1] which releases free public books on different subjects including... you guessed it... math ! Go check it out ! But maybe for some people, spending money is a necessity because it motivates them to finish the courses. It happens. [1] - https://openstax.org/subjects/math https://openstax.org/subjects/math
- wodenokoto 3y agoThere are plenty of resources that will go through proofs and tell you about math. Much fewer resources that will give you exercises and some sort of framework to help you move through them. Khan does this really well for up to high school. Not really sure about beyond that. I think a good service could be worth $50/month, but I agree it’s a tough ask.
- felideon 3y agoDo you know how much people pay for tutoring for their kids IRL? You might find a college student willing to charge $25 an hour or whatever, but if you take them to one of those corporate tutoring places you’re looking at $400/mo at minimum. $50 is a bargain when you have nervous parents whose kids are struggling and Math is hurting their GPA.
- burrish 3y ago$0 is a bargain too :)
- corethree 3y agoUse chatgpt. The math isn't actually hard, it's just the person who wrote it wants to look smart so he makes it hard by writing it in a mishmash of formal notation. There's a lot of domain specific stuff too that a straight up math major won't understand.
- thefz 3y agoAd in disguise.
- wodenokoto 3y agoGiven that khan academy is free, I think 50/month is a steep ask for trying something out. Especially when it is labeled as beta.
- larodi 3y agoI feel like the author, and did like the author for like year now. And I know lots of people feel this way, and we're telling each other to like "learn math, man, coding is something LLMs be doin in 10 years". Indeed, these ML/AI papers are indeed full of cryptic writing, but in essence they are not so difficult compared to like... understanding what a FSM is and how to produce a minimal automata it from regex (hey ML guys, would like to see you do this on paper!). The greek-letters-infused-notation is what scares most people, and you know what - this notation has its origins in pre-computing age. Perhaps ppl need a new notation, or like magazines should require math geeks to also provide pseudo-code for dummies. I also note that lot of things in ML seem to be about algorithms really, and very much about how things are engineered when implemented. Then I love graphs, discreet math, et. and were surprised to relearn that stuff like Markov chains is something very natural to me. Then the linear algebra needed for ML is not so much also - matmul, diagonal matrix, eigenvalues, inverse matrix, Hessian... wait! that's a lot already. But not so difficult, it is basically a lot of definitions. And some of these were not in the curriculums back in the day. Like... my mother does not have any recollection of learning about median and mode in statistics, even though they (with my father) attended a technical (by nature) university in the 70s. You know, I'm starting to realize that even our professors in the university back in the day did not fully grasp what all these things were about, because I remember them reading from educational sources, and also being very punctual about the material, which is not something that s.o. who groks certain domain is going to do. And only few of them gave some actual examples why all the math nonsense could come handy. Well perhaps they are to blame that we have to le-learn, or perhaps it is the natural thing to happen in this new brave world.
- imetatroll 3y agoDo "current gen" llms use Markov Chains? I have been wanting to look into trying to understand this stuff but I honestly don't know where to begin. I guess I should clarify that I prefer being able to purchase textbooks or use free online sources.
- larodi 3y agoThere are many attempts at using attention-less approaches to the architecture, and Markov Chains being one of them. Nothing to compete with transformers yet though, AFAIK. Some people experiment with graph-based rules systems, like very smartly compressed grammars (otherwise the task is NP-Hard i think).
- shannifin 3y agoParsing math notation has been a big weakness for me, especially with AI stuff. If I can see it in code, or at least pseudocode, stuff clicks much more intuitively. Wish there was a more efficient way to bridge that skill gap. Maybe condensing variables to single letters that have to be kept in mind just annoys me too much.
- bsaul 3y agoI've been looking for exactly that, for exactly the same reasons, for a few years now. Never got the motivation to start digging back into my old math university books. Thanks for the post. It does read a bit like an ad, but it feels authentic, and meets exactly my current need, so i'll just jump right into it ! Thanks again !
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- coderedart 3y agoI will recommend a couple great channels for Math: 1. https://www.youtube.com/@SawFinMath https://www.youtube.com/@SawFinMath : She is a great Professor that walks through problems/solutions one step at a time, so that you can follow along. Has a bunch of Under Graduate course playlists like discrete math, calculus, (abstract or linear) algebra, statistics. highly recommended for the great pacing and solving a lot of problems live. 2. https://mathispower4u.com/ https://mathispower4u.com/ : Another professor who takes an open math textbook (free), and makes a course out of it. Its a little bit more difficult because of denser "pure math" material, but in return, you basically cover everything that a college usually would. He has courses like discrete math, calculus, graph theory, trigonometry, statistics, algebra, geometry etc. Also solves a lot of problems live. I haven't really tried it, but apparently there is https://www.myopenmath.com/index.php https://www.myopenmath.com/index.php which is sort of like exercism in that you follow along a textbook and solve problems. If someone has tried this, maybe they can share their experience.
- lifeinthevoid 3y agoI'm a 38yo male and was (in my high school at least) some math prodigy. But hormones got in the way, I wasn't a great student at university and decided to study economics. I have a pretty good job at a well-known software company but it still itches to do something with my talent. My dream right now is to become a Math professor. I'm really considering starting a Math degree at my local university and see where it takes me. If I'm just mediocre or even bad, or don't enjoy it, I'll stop pursuing it, but if I'm great than I really hope to get a kick out of it and just keep going. I've kept my Math skills a bit up to date, so I won't have to overcome a 20 year pause. I've got some cash to keep me going for a couple of years, but would need a plan to generate money in meanwhile, that's what's holding me back somewhat at the moment.
- koromak 3y agoAlways wanted to try this, but I've got a hangover from my highschool days. I was bad at math, or it was taught very badly, or both. I'm worried I'd need to start from zero, like Algebra 1 and Geometry
- danielvaughn 3y agoI'm in the exact same boat. I'd literally have to relearn basic algebra and geometry.
- econner 3y agoFor anyone coming back to math I can't recommend enough the book "Journey through Genius: The Great Theorems of Mathematics". It's interesting how much of algebra came originally from geometry and the path to developing these fields makes it so much more intriguing / understandable vs just learning math to learn math.
- gmays 3y agoSimilarly, I've been enjoying "The Joy of X" as additional context around the fields and how they connect in an entertaining wyay.
- ykonstant 3y agoSince we're doing some ad posting anyway, I am available for online undergraduate and graduate mathematics tutoring one-on-one. So we can solve problems together, I can give you roadmaps for specific math topics, or we can analyze mathematical aspects of software development. You are not getting any certifications, though! (´• ω •`)
- armcat 3y agoSince the original motivation from the OP was to understand maths in ML papers, has anyone tried the free Maths for ML book, https://mml-book.github.io/ https://mml-book.github.io/, and if so what are your thoughts?
- clbrmbr 3y agoI was literally doing random exercises out of Apostol’s Calculus the other night. But I’d love to do good exercises from something more recent and advanced… gotta find my copy of Chris Bishop’s pattern recognition.
- jacknews 3y agoIs there a 'developing nation discount'? An entire school fee is not much more than even the beta subscription of this.