10 ms·
Flying kites deliver container-sized power generation
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoGotta be more to it. They blithly say, reeling it in takes a fraction of the energy it generates when it pulls the line out. But that's nonsense on the face of it. I'm guessing, it changes it's wind profile, maybe going edge-on or closing up, to make it easy to pull down again. Gotta be something.
- greesil 3y agoI think the kite might have control surfaces, thus would be able to control lift by changing its angle of attack.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoTrailing edge control lines, pretty standard. You let them out and the kite will no longer be able to catch the wind and will float down. Keeping some tension on those lines and wenching it in will keep the kite controllable.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoBrake lines on a traction kite like that can cause the foil to fully de-depower and fall out of the sky. So you can let the wind pull it up, and then let gravity bring it down.
- jdiff 3y agoOnly as much nonsense as rowing a boat without taking the paddle out of the water. In that specific example, you're going to be going in circles, but you will be moving.
- pacaro 3y agoYou can propel a boat forwards with only one oar, without lifting it from the water. It's a useful skill, Kayakers use the same stroke to move sideways, and for stability in rough water. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stern_sculling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stern_sculling
- jdiff 3y agoExactly, that's why calling this concept nonsense is so weird. It might be a tiny bit counterintuitive at first glance, but there's plenty of examples of it all around.
- LazyMans 3y agoOn its face it sounds silly, until you get experience with wind surfing. It's using the same concept. Figure 8s generate the pulling force. When you stop the figure 8s, and change the angle of the kite, you get minimal pulling force.
- pierrekin 3y ago> Reeling it in takes a fraction of the energy it generates when it pulls the line out. But that's nonsense on the face of it. Why is this nonsense on the face of it? This is just how kites work. Do you imagine that kite surfers just overpower the kite with their might and pull it back to the ground when they've had enough?
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoIt’s also how turbines work. The fluid pushing on one side isn’t cancelled out by the drag created on the other.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoNo. I said I didn't. I said I believed there was more to it. Others have actually elaborated on the likely mechanism. But sure, mocking people is a kind of post I guess.
- jollyllama 3y ago>The energy generated by the system while reeling out is greater than the energy consumed to reel the kite back in. There's something about it that just triggers the "perpetual motion machine" identification heuristic.
- zardo 3y agoOn a multi line kite you can control the angle of attack and speed. That gives you the ability to dial the pulling force up and down over a large range.
- bentpins 3y agoYou're not wrong - they do that. Have a look at https://thekitepower.com/products/ https://thekitepower.com/products/ There's a diagram of the flight path and power generation over the cycles. The flight path on the way out is much much longer going cross wind in figure 8s. On the pull back in it's a direct path back in, and it looks the kite shifts to point back at the base station more so there's a ton less resistance than on the way out.
- jitl 3y agoI’m happy to see this idea continues to develop. I was worried its failure was foregone when Google shuttered their moonshot Makani in 2020. It seems like this iteration is simpler.
- SCM-Enthusiast 3y agofor some reason, this always happens with the google moonshots; They come at it from the wrong angle. Someone comes along with a slightly simplier solution after google scrapes the whole thing as uneconomical or beats them to the punch on using a far more technical solution. Don't seem to have a big "Cost per KWH" KPI's internally nor a sense of urgency.
- pfdietz 3y agoI wonder how Malta is doing. The News blurbs at their website seem... ok?
- skyleradams 3y agoNot to be a HN naysayer, but wasn't this tried already with Makani Power?[1] They even made a documentary about it[2] Compared to traditional wind turbines, this solution trades an enormous amount of complexity, maintenance, etc for small reductions in material cost. We should be churning out traditional wind turbines for cheap instead. [1]https://x.company/projects/makani/ https://x.company/projects/makani/ [2]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qd_hEja6bzE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qd_hEja6bzE
- jdiff 3y agoThe article poses a different use case, replacing diesel generators for off-grid power, not hooking into the grid to replace turbines.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoThis is a very different approach. The google approach is making an airplane fly in circles generating continuous power, this slowly lets a kite out then reels it in generating pulsed power that would need a battery to smooth out. This approach can use pretty standard kite technology which is far cheaper than airplane technology.
- jacquesm 3y agoUse multiple kites in a staggered pattern so one of them is always generating near peak power. That complexity of course offsets all of the gains, but that's fine because it illustrates why this is an idea that just won't fly.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoBatteries are fine, the majority of the time it'll be in the pull stage as once depowered (the power is taken out of the kite by releasing the brake lines) you can bring the kite back down pretty quickly. Having two with the cycles staggered would reduce this but you need batteries anyway because you can't rely on demand being flat. The algorithms to control the kite are pretty straightforward, the complexity to self launch would be a bit tough but it's easy enough for a human to do so there is no need to include that complexity for the use cases this is targeting. This wouldn't be a set and forget solution, not yet. The kites will wear out relatively quickly but they're cheap to replace. I consider myself a pretty skeptical / practical Engineer and I don't see any show stoppers, I think it'll fit the niche they're targeting quite nicely.
- datadrivenangel 3y ago60 square meters of kite surface area is a lot of pull. 5 square meters can be enough to pick up 100kg in the right wind conditions.
- helpfulContrib 3y agoA sailboat typically flies about 5 - 8 square meters of material in the sails, pulling 3 - 4 tons of material around the world ..
- pierrekin 3y agoThis doesn't seem right to me, in my experience a 3 - 4 ton sailboat is around 9m long, which has a sail in the 20 - 40 m^2 range. A 5 - 8 square meter sail is really teenie tiny.
- zardo 3y agoYeah, that's sailboard territory, or a small dingy with no intention of going fast.
- helpfulContrib 3y ago[dead]
- usrusr 3y agoRobotic boat, a large tank, some power-to-storable tech, a power generating turbine beneath the waterline and a huge kite. Just send it out on the oceans, to cruise aimlessly wherever the satellite uplink suggests favorable weather and have it head home when the algorithms assumes that remaining tank capacity might get filled up on the way back. Most attractive post-fossil future ever. Unfortunately, unattended power-to-anything is very much a far away dream, despite all delusions of being able to do it large scale on Mars. All other technology is basically ready to go, and the "lateral lift" of a fast-moving boat is a perfectly adequate substitute for mooring when it comes to tapping wind on the high seas.
- boringg 3y agoOperating the kite isnt easy on its own. A lot of complexity involved in this. I am intrigued as someone who kites and develops clean energy. I have a tough time seeing how this is a set and forget situation. Maybes it the first step in a direction with something better down the road!
- Gys 3y ago> After the tether reaches its maximum length, the ground station winches the kite back in. Though the Hawk must expend energy for reel-in, it only expends a fraction of the energy, resulting in a net energy gain that varies by wind speed. An entire cycle takes about 100 seconds: 80 for reel-out and 20 for reel-in. This is an interesting approach. Also, the kite is doing eights all the time. Although I suspect that is only while reeling out.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoPresumably they can adjust the attitude to make it easier to real in.
- brlewis 3y agoMy recollection from flying kites a long time ago is that operating a kite gets easy after a certain height. I imagine the Kite Control Unit (KCU) can easily keep it aloft once it's high enough. The tether is 352m long according to https://thekitepower.com/the-hawk/#components https://thekitepower.com/the-hawk/#components
- nothercastle 3y agoI don’t think you can make a kite that can last a decade of load. We just don’t have materials strong enough. Also you need a sophisticated algorithm to fly it and never crash
- dtx1 3y agoAs someone who regularly flies hobby kites, I think it can be done. Modern kites are made of nylon and kevlar. With regular maintenance these kites should last at least a decade. Cables might have to be replaced every few years. As for the flying algorithm, I doubt it has to be very sophisticated at all, especially if the kite is itself designed to self right and stabilise. After all, a single line kite has 0 controls.
- nothercastle 3y agoI sort of assumed it would power and depower like a kiteboarding kite to create work. You could probably depower by collapsing the kite leading edge and dragging it back in but that seems less efficient than flying it in a figure 8 to power and depower.
- smusamashah 3y agoHow is the kite raised initially and what happens when air stops, how is it re-raised? Reading the article seems like it's pulled back if air is stopping, and slowly released based on air speed perhaps.
- cjbgkagh 3y agoOn islands where this is targeted the winds are usually very predictable, especially at higher altitudes. This isn't like flying a kite at ground level, there is no need to wench the kite back down to ground level, just up and down where the faster high altitude winds are.
- timdiggerm 3y agoAll of the raising is done by the wind.
- tamimio 3y agoI wonder how they will deal with bird attacks. Falcons and eagles (ironically, they share the same name with this kite) are territorial and will go after these drones. I once had a huge heavy-lift drone that got attacked too. But with a pilot nearby, the easy solution is to fly to a higher altitude, that seems to determine who rules the sky in their eyes apparently. I’m not sure how this kite will manage such situation.
- patall 3y agoBy being 60m2 big? I mean, helicopters are also not being attacked by eagles, why would this kite be?
- tamimio 3y agoHelicopters do get attacked, not so common because of several factors like the size, flight behavior, altitude, and most importantly the engine size and placement, these birds from my observation they usually attack from behind and/or above, both are properly “protected” in the helicopters, not so much in this kite, additionally, when the pilot is flying, they usually avoid it and continue their path, the birds mostly won’t chase and lose interest, but this kite is stationary and if the bird decided that it is hostile, it will keep trying to prey on it especially when you can’t increase the altitude substantially like a normal drone.
- Vvector 3y agoPeople cannot be anywhere in the radius of the kite cable. Kinda limits where is can be deployed. But the quick deployment could work for some situations.
- brlewis 3y agoDetails: https://thekitepower.com/the-hawk/#space_requirements https://thekitepower.com/the-hawk/#space_requirements
- shkkmo 3y agoThis is not correct. Untrained people can't be inside the flight zone while operating. This is roughly the downwind quarter of the potential flight zone.
- Vvector 3y agoEven a quarter is a huge area. Using the "safety buffer" radius of 425m, that is 560k m2 or 140 acres. A quarter of that is 35 acres, for 30 kW. For regular wind turbines, it's 30-70 acres per MW generated. That is 20x-40x more power for the same land area. And almost all the land under a wind turbine is freely usable.
- krisoft 3y ago> Untrained people can't be inside the flight zone What kind of training makes you immune to being sliced in half by a tether?
- shkkmo 3y agoThe same kind that makes you immune to crashing a car, none. However the training presumably could help you asses and mitigate risks better than someone with no training.
- MostlyStable 3y agoAre these less visible than traditional wind mills? If so, maybe they could be used at sea and get around the hatred of wind power as an eye sore.
- antisthenes 3y agoSo it's just a really big battery. The kite thing is just a novelty/marketing move. There have been containerized commercial battery systems available for at least a decade. The barrier to adoption is, as always, price, not "kite delivery". Is this for really remote places, like Greenland/Alaska? Because otherwise you can just use a truck/tractor.
- 123pie123 3y agoI'm surprised other ideas have not taken off yet?(intended) although not really a kite, this looks promising : https://www.youtube.com/shorts/zGGn-HY1jak https://www.youtube.com/shorts/zGGn-HY1jak
- brazzy 3y agoYou completely misunderstood. The kite is not for "delivery", it actually generates the power.
- antisthenes 3y agoYes, you're right. I'll have to re-read the article to see how much this kite can actually generate.
- psd1 3y ago40KW.
- qnsoaejacniln 3y agoHow will this work with aviation? I know it probably won't affect most IFR flights, but still possibly dangerous for VFR. Will there need to be a new restricted area for each deployment?
- nameless912 3y agoDepending on the altitude, they could keep these within class G airspace, which means VFR's job is to see and avoid. I think that's a pretty defensible solution as a pilot who spends all of his time in VFR operating in Class E/G airspace.
- tamimio 3y agoA project I did a couple years ago was to have an onboard SDR that communicates automatically with airplanes in the vicinity, or switching to manual where the drone operator can communicate as if they are “on-board” through the internet by a mic on ground. I can see something like this is doable, with a modified system to fit the length flight, after all, the position is fixed so I don’t think it would be a problem.
- qnsoaejacniln 3y agoJust wondering, how were you communicating to the airplanes in vicinity? Radio would require the planes to be listening on a specific frequency and ADSB Out would require the planes to have ADSB In which is not guaranteed.
- tamimio 3y agoIt wasn’t an ADS-B, Transport Canada (the FAA equivalent in Canada) doesn’t like ADS-B on drones yet, so the solution was to have an SDR (BladeRF, full-duplex for Tx/Rx), the on-board SBC had a server the received the voice sample (either direct through ground station MIC or automated reading directions, alt, etc every X period of time) and then broadcasting it to the airband, so it’s simply: Ground station mic -> internet -> server on SBC -> SDR -> airband (AM, I think it was ~120Mhz that time) -> other pilots If you have the manual communication (where the drone pilot comms and not an automated broadcast), you can pretty much talk with pilots as if you are on-board. I had a better write up if interested on how it works in here, in the “SDR” section. https://tamim.io/professional_projects/nerds-heavy-lift-drone-with-low-latency-command-and-control-over-cellular-5g-and-4k-video-stream-in-realtime/ https://tamim.io/professional_projects/nerds-heavy-lift-dron...
- Nick87633 3y agoAt first look, it seems like simply by having so much less mass of material involved that you have a good head start at competing on LCOE, even if the system needs the kite and tether replaced every 5-10 years. I think the biggest roadblock would be making sure it can return to the perch with high reliability otherwise you will have a lot of service calls for kites that landed on the ground.
- nirolo 3y agoThere's been a recent video by the German "Sendung mit der Maus" (basically how does stuff work for little children) about these kind of generators. I did not double check if the company in the video is the German one mentioned in the article, but chances are high. Video and subs are in German only, but it's less than 10 minutes and one can see a little how it works. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=aqfFZDWiJOI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=aqfFZDWiJOI
- NullPrefix 3y agoWhy are these people wearing safety helmets? Does this imply that everyone living under the kites will have to wear one too?
- IanCal 3y agoThey're under a crane lifting stuff up overhead on a work site, that's probably why.
- NullPrefix 3y agobut it's not a construction site though
- throwuwu 3y agoFalling bolts and tools don’t really care if they’re on a construction site or not
- NullPrefix 3y agoSo let me quote my original question >Does this imply that everyone living under the kites will have to wear one too?
- IanCal 3y agoMaybe just the ones living under the crane while it's lifting stuff over them. That also assumes people are living under the kites. I think you're overthinking a short demo video and hats. I doubt anyone fought hard against wearing it, and company liability is different from your own personal risk assessment.
- tamimio 3y agoI wish if there’s an actual video of the whole system being operated and not just 3D renders, a lot of questions in mind about some details but probably most of them will be answered in such video.
- jimmySixDOF 3y agoI can only imagine how many 3D models they render in a physics simulation platform like Nvidia Omniverse so they likely just used what they already had.
- sytse 3y agoThis is the best article on the problems of airborne wind energy. It is 10 years old but I think Michael Barnard did a great job explaining all the variants and why it is hard https://czmphorfqgktmzxu.quora.com/Airborne-wind-energy-a-collection-of-challenging-compromises?comment_id=953638&comment_type=3 https://czmphorfqgktmzxu.quora.com/Airborne-wind-energy-a-co...
- michaelbuckbee 3y agoYou were not kidding. That article really covered a lot of the obvious questions I had (and was the single best thing I've ever read on Quora).
- mikepurvis 3y agoI've always loved this idea since hearing the Swift Navigation founders talk about it in their Kickstarter video: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/swiftnav/piksi-the-rtk-gps-receiver/ https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/swiftnav/piksi-the-rtk-... Glad to hear there are people still working on it.
- Scea91 3y agoInterestingly, the very first statement is quite misleading. The statement: > On average, a humble wind turbine uses less land area per megawatt-hour than almost any other power source. The article itself refers to this citation [1]. It says, unsurprisingly, that the most land efficient power source is nuclear. The statement is of course technically true because it says "almost any power source". With wind, however, even that is tricky because you can either count just the area directly below the turbine body, which is still higher than nuclear and unreasonably optimistic because you severely limit a far bigger area. If you count also the spacing (too pessimistic on the other hand because part of the land might be used for farming) then wind farms range across the whole scale of land efficiency. I think its fair to say that land use of wind farms is "complicated", but saying its almost the best in this regard sounds like manipulation. [1] https://ourworldindata.org/land-use-per-energy-source https://ourworldindata.org/land-use-per-energy-source
- londons_explore 3y agoWind turbines can be built big enough that the blades, at the lowest point, are higher than almost all other land uses, except perhaps forestry. To be honest, the access roads are probably the biggest real impediment to using the land around a wind turbine. Can't exactly farm millions of acres of corn with robotic combine harvesters with a criss-cross of access roads to the base of every turbine.
- kingkawn 3y agoWhy not? Seems easy to teach the robots to not harvest on the road
- londons_explore 3y agoOdd shapes and constantly starting/stopping the plougher/seeder/harvester mean you get less ROI on your equipment. Farming is super tight margins - if your machines waste 20% of the time starting and stopping every time they pass over a road, your farms profits are wiped out. This is true whether the machines are robot driven or not, and it's the reason most commercial farms have huuuuuge fields rather than lots of small ones.
- dukeofdoom 3y agowhy not a blimp? Come to think of it, I'm kind of curious why a RC blimps have never become popular. I own DJI drones. But no blimps.
- Abekkus 3y agoHelium supply is an issue and blimps are risky in adverse weather. Also these kite models keep the generator on the ground, saves from trying to float so much delicate weight.
- jrockway 3y agoInteresting! I always try to guess how these things work before I read the article. My imaginary design would have the kite pull a heavy weight up and as the weight moves, it rotates a generator. When the weight reaches the end of the travel, it falls back down and the cycle repeats. The flaw with this design is if the wind was strong enough to pull the weight up, then the weight is not going to be able to fall back under its own power. That's why the real design just uses a motor to do that. Makes sense!
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 3y agoI used to work on this at a different company, and I'm glad to see work on it continuing! It's one of those things where the physics works out really great for fantastic power generation, but the engineering is just so damned complex, so it's tough to... get off the ground.
- londons_explore 3y agoI think the Google approach suffered from too much engineering. Specifically they had sunk too much money and too many people at very expensive prototypes before they'd gotten the design even close to running reliably. As soon as you become a big team, you become less nimble - which isn't what you need when your product still has big unknowns. They should have started with five 2 guy teams, a year and a budget of $50k each, and tried 50 different ways to get a scale model that could reliably not crash in all weather conditions for a few months on end. Only when you have a craft that can either survive all weather, or reliably pack itself away whenever the weather changes quickly, then figure out how to scale it up and make it generate power.
- thechao 3y agoThe back-of-the-envelope analysis for kite-based power is very compelling; enough that I tried my hand at designing a kite-powered system in ~2004. I don't think anyone can really appreciate how challenging the engineering (control systems) are for all-weather kite-flying until they just try to reel-in & reel-out a kite on a relatively calm day. I literally couldn't even write-down the differential equation which describes the inverse control path for the kite, when there's one vector for the kite, and one vector for the tether, under the reel-in load; none-the-less, solve the equation, and then get it to work with a freakin' stepper motor.
- londons_explore 3y agoDon't take the hard maths approach when you can take the lazy AI approach... Just fly a kite by hand, log the data, stick it through a reinforcement learning system to make you a controller that keeps the kite in the air. Reinforcement learning loves these kind of problems that only have double digit numbers of scalar inputs and outputs. Either way, my kite flying experience tells me that your reel-motors must move with quite some speed and power if you are to keep the kite in the air when the wind suddenly reverses direction.
- trefn 3y agoI wonder if you could make the kite itself lighter than air to avoid issues where the wind dies down? E.g. a kite shaped airship.
- usrusr 3y agoThere are no issues, at least as long as you can supply power to the base station: just make the motor/generator reel in the kite, that causes plenty of movement relative to the stationary air to keep it afloat and controllable right down to the reefing mechanism.
- dandrew5 3y agoIs there anything stopping them from adding a turbine system to the kite that would continuously spin (when there's wind ofc) instead of reeling it in/out?
- smileysteve 3y agoThat increases costs because now you need transmission lines down to the kite instead of only the dyneema lines for control.
- soperj 3y agoWhy would they ratchet the kite in instead of making it dive and quickly winding the cable in? Should be easy enough with software right?
- smileysteve 3y agoStalling is more controllable than diving
- purpleidea 3y agoHow long does the Kite and Dyneema rope last before either breaks and one or both need replacing? Their site https://thekitepower.com/the-hawk/#space_requirements https://thekitepower.com/the-hawk/#space_requirements mentions the lifetime for the battery and ground station, but I'd be most curious about the durability of the whole system.
- dendrite9 3y agoI suspect looking to sailing would get you the best answers as an outsider. Dyneema ropes are used for sailing but I don't know about the replacement rates, or if they are replaced preemptively for racing where the risk of an issue after some use is too expensive and replacement is cheaper. I have have seen lots of parachute or hot air balloon fabric offered because companies have a limited number of hours of use before they retire them.
- russellbeattie 3y agoAfter seeing Big Hero 6, I've always wondered about the feasibility of giant floating blimps with generators...
- Aeroi 3y agoAs a longtime kiter and sailor, the durability of the kite and line system seems to be the biggest weakness. Constant uv exposure and stress to these systems would make the economical calculations interesting. I don't know of a current setup that could see sustained continuous use for 1 year without significant material replacements or maintenance...
- UncleOxidant 3y agoI worked at a small kite power startup in 2019. Unfortunately we couldn't secure funding to keep operating. It became quite difficult to secure funding after Google suspended their Makani moonshot project - potential funders were like "well, Google got out of this so why do you think we should fund you?". (though our kites were much smaller than Makani's and we didn't need a huge amount of funding to keep developing) It's a very difficult problem keeping a kite flying in a figure 8 pattern allowing it to rise to the end of the tether and then effectively stalling it to pull the line back in - repeat over and over and while you're at it try to maximize power output for the weather conditions (and then there was the problem of automatically launching - we were leaving that for last). We were starting to look at reinforcement learning for the problem, but it was going to take a lot more data and a very accurate model of our kite and weather conditions. Definitely one of the more fun jobs I've ever had even if it was short-lived.
- behnamoh 3y ago> potential funders were like "well, Google got out of this so why do you think we should fund you?". Google shuts down projects and products because it's Google and can't productionize ideas. It's sad that this results in such secondary effects.
- tschwimmer 3y agoI know nothing about kites but as someone who currently works at Google and knows a bit about how projects are funded, the first argument doesn't really make a lot of sense to me. At Google's scale, a materially impactful opportunity needs to have the opportunity to generate billions in revenue and have high margins. That's just a function of Google's size and opportunity cost (people can otherwise work on Ads, Cloud, etc). However, just because something isn't a Google business for Google doesn't mean there isn't an opportunity for a (very) profitable or successful business. Sounds pretty weak - perhaps the VCs you guys were pitching to were more focused on SaaS vs hard tech.
- UncleOxidant 3y agoI think they saw Google's decision to defund Makani as a sign that kite power wasn't viable. We certainly weren't in the same league as Makani - their "kite" was essentially a largish 4prop airplane. Google must've spent in the several hundreds of millions on that project. Our prototype kites had a ~8' wingspan and we were operating on a shoestring budget.
- scblock 3y agoArticle needs an editor: "As of late 2022, the world contained about 900 megawatts of wind power capacity." I've worked on single projects larger than that. Presumably they mean gigawatts?
- dtgriscom 3y ago900GW it is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_by_country
- samstave 3y agoHave you folks ever heard of a company called CAT? They tend to make things for pushing around dirt. So, TEU containers are TINY. What if - we used an army of CAT-like dirt movers in key areas to FUNNEL wind through a bunch of "wind-tunnel" type things and feed higher power wind in the directions we prefer? Maybe call it "planetary vehicular land transmogrifcation" - or "terra-forming" for short?
- psd1 3y agoThat would be both interesting and cool, but I suspect you'll find it extremely uneconomical use of land, and wind is less energetic at ground level. Maybe if this "CAT" company builds machines that can operate at a few hundred metres of altitude...
- xg15 3y agoIt's an amazing project, but, out of curiosity: Why do all the AWE projects except Google's seem to use the reel-in/reel-out approach and don't attach turbines to the kite itself? Reel-in/reel-out seems a lot more complicated, power inefficient and taxing on the material than just having the kite up there (semi-) permanently. I assume there are some technical reasons why turbines are less practical, but could anyone explain what those are?
- fwip 3y agoI only have wikipedia-level knowledge, but my understanding is that turbines are heavy, and wind power spent holding the turbines up is power that isn't converted to electricity. If you want to put the turbine up high, you can save power by just building a traditional fan-on-a-stick wind turbine.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoThis is wrong in physics terms. Lifting things requires power, there is a formula for work done. Keeping things up does not require power, a chair does not collapse under you when it runs out of battery. A ‘normal’ wind turbine generates a huge force on its foundations when it operates - that’s why they have to be so heavy. It’s not moving so no work is done. That force does not care what is opposing it - whether it is fighting the strength of the tower holding up the turbine, or if it’s fighting gravity and a steel cable holding the kite. As long as the forces and their directions cancel out, it’s all the same. Lastly, waste does not matter, wind power is available for many kilometres vertically. If a kite is flying 500 meters above ground, it can suddenly access the power a turbine could not. So if it accesses power that was inaccessible before, it’s a win even if half of it is wasted. Lastly, none of this discussing has any relevance, only economics matters. You care about cost of equipment, how long it lasts, how hard it is to repair, how many people are required to operate it and therefore salaries, where can you build it - a system could be 100% efficient but unprofitable.
- sjducb 3y ago> This is wrong in physics terms. > Lifting things requires power, there is a formula for work done. Keeping things up does not require power When my helicopter is hovering it runs out of fuel. What is my pilot is doing wrong?
- hamandcheese 3y ago> After the tether reaches its maximum length, the ground station winches the kite back in. Though the Hawk must expend energy for reel-in, it expends only a fraction of the energy work=force*distance, so presumably the kite can be controlled such that it exerts less force when they reel it back in?
- smileysteve 3y agoThat's my thought from kite boarding, releasing tension on the trailing edge will depower the kite to stall speed
- bimguy 3y agoOddly there is no mention of being safer to flying animals like bats for example, which have their sonar wigged out by the turbines. I assume the kite would be friendlier to our flying friends but I guess this is not a concern in every country.