5 ms·
> You don't need to defend the trillion dollar company. They are not your friend, they do not care about you, your work or your life. True. > All they do is s
by ben_w 3y ago
> You don't need to defend the trillion dollar company. They are not your friend, they do not care about you, your work or your life.
True.
> All they do is steal 30% from society that could be used for more productive purposes than make a few people who already have everything even richer.
I'm old enough to have developed software before the App Store existed, and remember that everyone was very excited both buy it finally being introduced to iOS, and by the relatively low fees of only 30%.
You're free to argue that 30% is too high, or even that the 15% for small developers is too high, that this is rent-seeking by Apple and only made sense when they were also a small company… but I think this is also true for the businesses trying to convince everyone that it matters, and I think they would like to charge the same sticker price while collecting the difference for themselves.
- sofixa 3y ago> and by the relatively low fees of only 30%. 30% is low compared to what? Mafia extortion rates?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ben_w 3y agoWhen the App Store was new, the web hosting for my indie shareware games was about 30% of their net revenue after the payment processor and marketplace fees. The payment processor (cheapest PayPal (U.S. Accounts), most expensive American Express/Optima International[0]) and marketplace (Kagi[0]) fees were on top of that hosting fee, and cost anywhere from (1.9 to 5.0)% + $0.30 (payment provider) plus 2.5% + $1 (market place for ≤$25), which makes those two items combined also more than 30% for any item sold for less than $5.08-5.77. Hosting fees are of course cheaper today, more so when bulk bought (I think more than enough to compensate for games today getting into the 100GB range when my shareware was 10s of MB). I'd hope that payment providers are also. But at the time, it looked amazing. [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20090903044400/http://www.kagi.com/kagisolutions/pricing.php https://web.archive.org/web/20090903044400/http://www.kagi.c...
- zzbzq 3y agoI don't understand what hosting fees have to do with apps. The app store seemed to be more or less a ripoff of Facebook's (now long defunct) app store, back when Facebook was a web-based app-of-apps, and AFAIK Facebook apps were free plugins.
- ben_w 3y ago> I don't understand what hosting fees have to do with apps. Apple hosts the apps, doesn't charge devs or customers anything for bandwidth used when downloading them. At the time the store launched, this was a big part of my overall costs, which Apple covered in full from their take. > The app store seemed to be more or less a ripoff of Facebook's (now long defunct) app store, back when Facebook was a web-based app-of-apps, and AFAIK Facebook apps were free plugins. I forgot that ever existed, so I searched for it. Looks like FB's was announced about 4 years after Apple's App Store?
- xigoi 3y ago> Apple hosts the apps, doesn't charge devs or customers anything for bandwidth used when downloading them. But it doesn’t allow developers to host the apps themselves, so they are being forced to pay for a service they don’t need.
- ben_w 3y agoNeed is the wrong word there, developers absolutely need it. They may well be able to do better value for money with their own choices, and I appreciate the argument that everything bundled together isn't great, but unlike e.g. the CloudKid data sync Apple also provides at no extra cost, app download bandwidth is mandatory and unavoidable. I could also go the other way and say that being tax-like is good for the same reason actual taxes are good: that it gets spent on building up an economic environment from which others can profit (at this point one would then want to retort something about democratic values). But as I'm not hugely interested in defending a trillion dollar company (just giving a historical perspective that 30% was, when it was first announced, an improvement over the status quo), I say that if anyone feels the world has changed enough this is no longer good, it is good to call for change — companies may not be democracies, but the nations they operate in generally are.
- matwood 3y agoAt the time it was low compared to any retail software distribution. If (a big if) a developer could get on a carrier App Store (they existed) it was much more than 30%. Go back and watch the keynote. Developers cheered because 30% was so much lower than any other stores available at the time.
- pjc50 3y agoIt's a small amount compared to retail; it's a large amount compared to a download; and it's infinitely larger than the 0% platform royalty required by IBM-compatible PCs.
- merrywhether 3y agoThat 0% platform royalty was on top of the $300 flat fee for the Windows operating system (or however much, I never ran Windows myself), whereas iOS is technically free (no fee for major updates). You’re paying for the OS/platform one way or another.
- seec 3y agoVery few people bought Windows separately, its price was bundled with the hardware sale just like it is with iOS. This is a completely moot point. You could try to argue that Apple give more value by supporting longer, but then again you would be completely wrong (some hardware manufacturer are not super good at supporting their stuff for the very long term, but windows in itself has a support timeline way beyond anything Apple ever did...)
- nolok 3y agoThe problem is not that 30% is too high or too low, the problem is that it shouldn't be a % but a flat fee structure, like every other services ever. If you have an app tomorrow that sells for $10 to 10k people you owe Apple $30k, now you manage to up your price to $30, same work same size same everything, but suddenly you now owe Apple $90k ? That's called a tax, not a fee. Doing so wouldn't stop apple from having a separate, "pay 30% all inclusive" fee, and it wouldn't stop them from "if your app is free you have no fee" (beside the xcode sub fee).
- HatchedLake721 3y ago> like every other services ever Apple didn’t invent a marketplace. Please have a look how other online and offline marketplaces work and how they monetize access. You can look at anything from Salesforce, Shopify, to Microsoft, Epic Store, PlayStation and your local Target store. Hint - it’s not a flat fee structure.
- nolok 3y agoWhat makes you think I agree any more with any of these ? But as a user I'm able to buy my pc games, my groceries or my music from another store. Apple prohibits me from doing that.
- ben_w 3y agoWhile true, I think these examples are sufficient to dispute calling it a "tax". "Excessive" or "monopolistic", if you like, but not really a tax.
- qwytw 3y agoYeah but technically nobody is forcing anyone to use Steam. Yet pretty much all the games are published there and the market has decided that the 30% fee is "fair" (AFAIK they can get away charging even more than Apple on average because there is no 15% tier?)
- 3y ago