7 ms·
A Theory of Grift
- Analemma_ 3y agoVery interesting theory. Here's the key point: > Meanwhile, the growth of software corresponds to a drop in the number of required human touchpoints for a given transaction. When travel was booked by phone or in person, there was a direct financial reward to being a good conversationalist in the travel business; rhapsodizing about the beauty of a beach was a good way to upsell customers on a nicer hotel a bit closer to it, and sussing out whether someone was more interested in beaches, landmarks, or bars meant figuring out exactly what to pitch them. All this work is now silently and efficiently happening on the backend of the big online travel agencies, with no human interaction required.The pre-Internet white collar economy was basically a universal job guarantee for personable people. That's increasingly going away, to be replaced with a more neoliberal attention economy with a more extreme distribution of outcomes. My usual theory for the increasing around of grift, particularly in politics, is that various disintermediation efforts which were in theory supposed to make government more democratic actually mean there is less incentive than ever for working hard to fix anything, but big rewards for torching the commons for your own gain. I don't think this runs contrary to the article's thesis but actually works hand-in-hand together with it to explain why so much public life-- politics, obviously, but also academia and public intellectualism-- consists mostly of charismatic psychopaths insisting we have to "burn it all down and click here to donate to my campaign or subscribe to my Substack)" instead of offering any useful advice.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- netbioserror 3y agoIMO widespread grift seems to directly correlate with money printing and suppressed interest rates, which create a financialized economy that lives and breathes based on monthly Fed minutes. If you can make lots of money doing nothing, you can swindle lots of money doing nothing.
- from-nibly 3y agoThis right here. Here's hoping for an economic crash that corrects this kind of stuff.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoIt's not exactly the kind of grift the article is talking about, but grift is very common in the poorest countries where "free" money and low interest rates were never a thing because there's few other opportunities. Far from removing grift, I'd expect an economic crash to dramatically increase the amount of grift as everyone tries to extract whatever dollars they can. That also points to the uniting factor between the grift the article talks about and the traditional definition of the word: grifts are the strategies you use when other avenues of making money are difficult, say because your investors are demanding increasing returns from a saturated market.
- username332211 3y agoI don't have statistics, but I strongly suspect monetary ...maneuvers are in fact more common in developing, rather than in developed economies. It a fairly common reason why developing countries stay "developing". As for making money becoming difficult, without monetary and interest rate manipulations it would be rare for capital to exist while the opportunities to employ profitably are reduced. Capital is supposed to be created trough the act of saving, and income is normally saved with the idea of funding larger consumption in the future (or maintaining the same consumption with less labor). That plan for future consumption is, in and of itself, an opportunity for profit to those that can satisfy it.
- JacobThreeThree 3y ago>an economic crash that corrects this kind of stuff This is exactly how Bernie Madoff was caught.
- boeingUH60 3y agoAnd many crypto bros like SBF
- WallyFunk 3y ago> Buy The Change You Wish to See in the World Isn't this 'Vote with your wallet'? I know I vote with my wallet. Everything I buy is a vote for how I want the world to be, and what products I want to see flourish and prosper. I also evangelize these products to others so they get on board too, because I alone will not make much of a dent, unless I recruit others to purchase it too.
- IngoBlechschmid 3y agoI disagree strongly with this position: * No amount of personal spending decisions can advance systemic changes like better public transport or more careful military funding. These require governmental action. * With our wallet, we can only choose between those alternatives which are offered. In many cases, we can only choose between bad options. * Voting with our wallet requires immunity against professional PR campaigns, time (for researching on what to buy), money (to afford options which are better according to personal views but more expensive), friends who appreciate instead of belittle our purchasing decisions, ... In the end, I believe the story "vote with your wallet" internalizes a form of victim blaming: The consumers are blamed for their irresponsible purchasing decisions, but the responsibility really is with the companies and governments. Of course, not spending consciously is also not a solution. But we obtain greater leverage by using our influence on society. Only few of us are editor-in-chiefs of important newspapers or important politicians, but most of us can engage in visually powerful protests which are also able to generate political wind.
- wharvle 3y ago> With our wallet, we can only choose between those alternatives which are offered. In many cases, we can only choose between bad options. One weird thing markets do is make unusual alternatives far more expensive than the difference in cost of manufacture between them and more-common options. The market “chooses” the $80 option because the one that costs $5 more to make but is way better retails for $200. You also see whole markets (effectively) collude to make cheap upgrades expensive to buy. There are several very-cheap upgrades that make a refrigerator much nicer, but are only available on expensive refrigerators. Think, things like making the drawers open and close much more smoothly. There is no low-end-except-for-$30-in-upgrades option. The car market does some similar things.
- photochemsyn 3y agoGrift is nothing new, it's existed throughout human history. See for example Herman Melville, "The Confidence-Man: His Masquerade" (1857), which is a catalogue of various kinds of grift common in that era. If anything has changed much recently, it's that grifters have taken control of the entire system of government and economic activity - they're no longer just a pack of con artists preying on riverboat travellers, but have infiltrated all the branches of government and business and academia in the USA. Today's most successful grifters are not isolated criminals like SBF, but rather the leading politicians and media talking heads and government bureaucrats and corporate executives who sit at the top of the American Empire - it's a nice example of the systemic institutional corruption seen at the ends of previous Empires, from the Roman to the Byzantine to the French, British and Soviet collapses, and appears to be heading towards the same conclusion.
- soco 3y agoIronically this is what conspiracists call "global government" - in reality a network of mafia-like operations kept together by the same interests, spread internationally because the world became so small.
- dingnuts 3y agoI don't know how you can start out a comment by saying, essentially, that there's nothing new under the sun and then immediately contradict it by saying "grifters have taken control of the entire system of government and economic activity.. Today's most successful grifters are not isolated criminals like SBF, but rather the leading politicians and media talking heads and government bureaucrats and corporate executives who sit at the top of the American Empire" Yawn. Cynicism masquerading as insight; all claims and no evidence. An adequate rebuttal to something with so little of a foundation might be "nuh uh" >it's a nice example of the systemic institutional corruption seen at the ends of previous Empires, from the Roman to the Byzantine to the French oh my gawd the Roman Empire took 1000 years to fall from the death of Caesar and had been around for 500 years when he was assassinated. If you want to demonstrate complete historical ignorance, definitely reach for the "Fall of the Roman Empire" as part of your fear campaign when describing the world today. There is very little that the US has in common to the singular Classical civilization that your high school history class covered.
- mandmandam 3y agoPeople seem to be missing a hugely important fact here: The level of grift seen in American society today is not normal. It's worse than what I've seen in other Western countries by a lot. Do I have hard data to support this? No. But anecdotally, everyone - everyone - I know who visits America has noticed this. "The people over there are like wolves". "They're shameless". "They're all so focused on money". "That whole culture is just scams on scams on scams". "Christ, they're all so fake!" - All actual quotes, with emphatic expletives removed. I know it's not a common topic of conversation for Americans, but the world hates us now. We're the number one threat to peace and stability since 2003, and only getting worse. Yes, I am ashamed of us. We had so much potential. Presidents are grifters now. The military industrial complex is a grift. College is a grift. Healthcare is a grift - to an absurd and horrifying level. Banking is a grift that hurts the poorest the most, far worse than in other countries. The news is a grift. The legal system is stuffed to the brim with grift right up to the Supreme Court and right down to the police on the street. It's been normalized to an extreme degree, at every level of American society. "I'm a hustler". "Don't hate the player". "Looking out for number one", etc. These are not normal phrases in other countries! This is seen as the sign of a very sick culture, one where to survive you need to fuck over other people; one where fucking people over to "get your bag" is seen as a necessity rather than as an abhorrence. Again - this isn't normal in other countries. We've always had caveat emptor, but the idea that it's fine and normal to get 8 spam phone calls a day would be absurd in any other wealthy country. This is, imo, fallout from the relentless attacks on anything that could be construed as socialist or taking care of people - itself a massive grift. The war on terror was a grift - one that has resulted in trillions of wasted dollars - and it resulted in absolutely no consequences for anyone except the whistleblowers who exposed atrocities, war crimes, and global surveillance.
- slily 3y agoI doubt you've lived in other countries long enough to compare those systems based on what you're saying about banking, there's virtually no difference anywhere I've been and I still have a number of foreign bank accounts. Every time I see someone criticize US banking it's based on the assumption that poor people are too stupid to understand that interest is charged on loans or that withdrawing money you don't have incurs a fee. I agree with college and health care being ridiculous in the US and arguably mainstream news too (no wonder they're losing influence to podcasts). Everything else is either nowhere near unique to the US or exaggerated to the level of caricature.
- jeffreyrogers 3y ago> There's an ongoing debate over whether or not people skills are undervalued, and perhaps for many people they are, but it's hard to deny that there are many, many more ways for someone who doesn't like social interaction much to get rich. If ads and sales are on the same continuum, then the world's best salespeople are engineers, data scientists, and product managers. This seems completely wrong to me. If you look at who is the top 0.1% it's either inherited wealth, a few professionals (lawyers, certain medical specialties, etc.) who own their own practices, or people who've managed large groups of people (i.e. business executives). The third group is overwhelmingly full of people with good social skills, and skilled professionals are almost always personable too.
- creer 3y ago> inherited wealth We keep hearing that. (Because it sounds good). It should be true because it's not all that hard to keep wealth increasing at least modestly - and let time do the work. But take heart! "The Missing Billionaires" argues that in practice inherited wealth is reliably lost over shockingly few generations.
- neutralino1 3y agoI wouldn't go as far as to say business executives have good social skills. They are often ruthless, cunning, and deceiving, which makes them successful. If by good social skills you mean the ability to convince (read deceive) a lot of people, then sure they have good social skills. But who wants to have a beer with their CEO, VP of Sales, or other top exec? They are often depicted as wolves or sharks for a reason. It is true that they are good at networking with other people like them, but not really good at empathizing, helping, or caring for others.
- smugglerFlynn 3y agoIs there some research that would suggest % of ruthless, cunning, and deceiving people among execs is statistically different from any other professions?
- 3y ago
- latchkey 3y ago> Block Trading—Block trades create a massive temptation to leak information, and once this becomes a habit, it's a very bad look. Funny you should mention Block Trading... this Matt Levine just dropped... https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-01-16/morgan-stanley-leaked-some-block-trades https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-01-16/morgan...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hristov 3y agoI am going to say something that will earn me a lot of downgrades, but it needs to be said because it is the truth and it is important. Grifting in our society went sky high when Trump started doing it and he was not punished for it but rewarded. To be fair, Hillary Clinton was also a liar and a grifter but she did kind of get punished and publicly humiliated for many of her lies. Generally speaking if someone behaves badly in public and is not punished, it creates a great incentive for millions of others to do the same thing. Some people are moral by nature and will behave morally even if evil and amorality is all around them. Those are the heroes and saints. The people that will help slaves escape in slave societies the ones that will help safe victim populations when their own government is openly encouraging genocide. These people are great, but very few. There are also the almost criminals, people that are always thinking in the backs of their minds of doing something awful, and it is only the possibility of punishment that is keeping them. Well when someone engages in bad behavior openly and publicly, and is not punished, even rewarded, those people will rush into bad behavior themselves. So there you have it. P.S.: To be fair Elon Musk deserves honorable mention for openly and publicly engaging in amoral behavior and getting away with it.
- pphysch 3y agoThe Art of the Deal was published in 1987, before Bill Clinton was even president. Trump has been grifting for a long time at a fairly steady pace. The reason "grifting went sky high" is because of the profit model of Internet media. Engagements = ad revenue. This strongly incentivizes grifter behavior, from Trump and Alex Jones to Oprah and Rachel Maddow. Also, grifting became a lot more accessible with social media. Anyone can grift, you don't need radio or television deals.
- shermantanktop 3y agoLet me guess, Rachel Maddow is grifting by...promoting her books? That's a far cry from shilling colloidal silver and gold bars to elderly shutins.
- pphysch 3y ago
- llm_nerd 3y agoThe word grift has been diminished to polarized meaninglessness. The linked piece defines it as- "So the heart of a grift is that you get something that, in a technical sense, is what you paid for, but that is also not worth what you paid for it." This arguably makes literally every transaction a grift through some lens. And none of this is new.
- jprete 3y agoNot all transactions are grifts, because frequently something for sale will have different values to the buyer and seller. Things aren't strictly worth what you can sell them for, unless the only thing you want to do with the thing is to sell it.
- bluGill 3y agoThe reason for matching gifts is because charities run into problems if they only have a few donors - the IRS starts to assume they are not a real charity instead they are a tax dodge for the rich. It is easy to setup a charity that really exists to put a tiny amount of money into some cause while spending most of the money on things that help donors. One sign the IRS looks for (because this is easy to look for) is total number of donors. While you can fool a few people, they assume if there are a lot of small donors most of them are not fool - instead they believe in the mission of the charity. Thus if you are a rich person trying to donate a lot of money to a truly good cause the charity will sometimes be forced to refuse your money despite needing it - just to keep the IRS away. To get around this they will match, thus ensuring that plenty of little donors to keep the IRS away from the charity while allowing them to make the large donation they were planning on making. These are always structured with the hope to give the full amount, so if you are planning on a small donation it is to your advantage to donate during a match since otherwise your charity might not get as much from the rich person. Note that none of the above applies to politics where there are laws in place limiting total donations per person that a match cannot get around.
- bloudermilk 3y agoWhy would a charity that is legitimately serving a mission and operating above-board be afraid of the IRS taking a closer look?
- GauntletWizard 3y agoThis is why Bill Gates spends so much time fundraising for the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation - He's providing the social proof to the IRS that it's not simply his pet projects or marketing arm. He provides much if not most funding, but he gets assent and agreement from other wealthy donors. (My opinion is that it's nearly all bullshit - A ton of what the foundation does is provide incentives for both government and NGO aid-services to stay locked into Microsoft products, but I don't think it's at the level of charity fraud)
- pi-e-sigma 3y agoI think it's just elaborated PR. Bill is getting old and thinks more and more about his 'legacy' and how he will be remembered.