7 ms·
US Cities Could Verge on Becoming Ghost Towns by 2100, Study Finds
- Longlius 3y agoI mean, it wouldn't exactly be unprecedented. New cities spring up and old ones die every few generations or so when we go through logistical churn. When the old passenger rail system died off, ghost towns emerged. When the old pre-interstate highway system was obsoleted by the interstate system, ghost towns emerged. And I imagine as we shift the way we build things and where value is generated geographically in this country, ghost towns will probably emerge. The nature of low-density suburbs and exurbs is that it doesn't take a lot of people leaving before they become unsustainable. I feel like Americans should be more used to this.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 3y agoThere are already states like Nevada with more ghost towns than live ones.
- Balgair 3y agoArkansas too. Lots of places where the biggest and best export they have is their kids.
- greenie_beans 3y agoit mentions jackson, ms but has no context whatsoever. do they even consider metro areas in the study? looks like it's hyperfocused on cities/towns, surely they consider movement within a metro area, because that's what happened in jackson (aka white flight).
- dingnuts 3y agowhen yt moves to the suburbs or the country it's white flight, and when he moves to the city it's gentrification. is there somewhere yt can move without it being racist?
- noworriesnate 3y agoAccess to white people is basically a human right at this point, so any attempt by whites to prevent non-whites from exercising their human rights is by definition racist
- greenie_beans 3y agoi don't know what you're talking about. white people in jackson, mississippi moved to the suburbs. this is a fact. this has nothing to do with your comment.
- nemo44x 3y ago"White Flight" is a bit of a misnomer as people that could afford to leave cities did leave cities (including non-white people) for a variety of reasons. One reason is that through the 1930's (depression) and 1940's (WW2) very little new housing was built and the housing inside of cities was beginning to age with minimal investment in upkeep. Costs were still very high, like they are today in many cities. But by the 1950's we were able to expand out of cities because of the automobile and new house construction was more affordable due to advances in materials and methods. So people began to leave cities because you got more space, your own yard, and an automobile and the costs were the same or cheaper than living in a cramped apartment in the city. The second reason for people leaving cities was because of a sharp increase in crime, especially violent crime. The political leaning of the 1960's and 1970's were to be very soft on crime and that era is marked by a stark rise in crime. People that can afford it will not live in a high crime area - go figure! They move to an area that is nicer and the politics of those areas tend to be protective in that they don't want the same political policy that allowed crime to soar. This of course starts a chain reaction where there are better living conditions and lower crime outside the city and the city begins to rapidly lose its tax base. The entrenched politicians are more concerned with having power than managing a city and the city rots. So they scapegoat people for being "racist: because they didn't want to live in a crime infested, cramped, hellhole when there were viable alternatives. The market speaks. The main reason people left cities was because of better living conditions in suburbs and the rising tide of high crime in cities. That's it.
- telotortium 3y agoThat's not to say that racism played no role - of course there were racists at the time, and it probably played a role in influencing the decision to move. But without the rising crime rates in the 1960s and 1970s, I don't that wouldn't have been enough to lead to large-scale abandonment of neighborhoods these racists had lived in for generations.
- nemo44x 3y agoRacism in part but even looking at redlining it isn't how it is portrayed. Redline documents would point out not only where clusters of blacks lived but also Jews, Polish, Italians, Irish, poor whites, etc. And those regions were all difficult to get loans to buy because the homes were often older and the banks were pretty sure that the working and lower class people living in them would not be able to afford upkeep. So they didn't want to lend money to buyers of homes that were likely to decrease in value. There was no Federal guarantee in those days. Racism played a part too of course but class is often completely ignored in the USA.
- DaveExeter 3y agoIf rents drop, not such a bad future.
- itsoktocry 3y ago>If rents drop, not such a bad future This is a fallacy similar to hoping for interest rates to drop; these things don't happen in a vacuum, they are the result of other factors. Rents might drop, but that's because the area is getting less appealing (much like interest rates might drop, because the economy is faltering). Is that net good? I don't know. Having more people living cheaply in an area with crumbling infrastructure doesn't sound great.
- DaveExeter 3y agoHuh? If housing supply exceeds demand, rents drop.
- itsoktocry 3y agoSo why is the supply increasing? Are people are going to keep investing in housing in cities with crumbling infrastructure? Are people moving away?
- JamesBarney 3y agoHis argument is that demand will drop.
- xhkkffbf 3y agoIf demand drops for your chosen neighborhood, it probably has nothing to do with people hoping for lower rents. It usually means people don't want to live in a place because it's less attractive. And that means it's not as nice. Be careful what you wish for.
- nostrademons 3y agoIt's a bit different when overall population is dropping, which is predicted for all major developed countries by the second half of the 21st century. When population drops, demand drops for reasons entirely unrelated to how desirable your neighborhood is relative to other neighborhoods. Demand is dropping everywhere. We only think that unusual because we've grown up in an era of perpetually-rising population. A lot of our economic rules of thumb don't hold once population growth reverses. It is true that de-growth generates all sorts of other problems, though. One is labor: you may have houses, but they'll be shittily maintained, and you won't be able to find people to do the maintenance. Another is peace: when growth is happening, everyone has an incentive for peaceful trade so that they can capture the long-term profits of growth, but when growth reverses, the incentive reverses to conquering and pillaging as much of the pie now, before it shrinks, so you don't get left without a slice when it's gone.
- dpflan 3y agoNature Cities Paper from the article: https://www.nature.com/articles/s44284-023-00011-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/s44284-023-00011-7
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoNot including climate change in their study was a huge miss. Saying the midwest is going to face population decline when frankly, the great lakes region is likely to boom as people look for an area that doesn't have as many heat waves and has a plentiful fresh water supply. Edit: I never said the great lakes region would be immune to climate change, just one of the best places to migrate to in the continental us
- J_Shelby_J 3y agoThe Midwest is a continental climate. It will and does have heat waves.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoEverywhere has heat waves. British Columbia was thought to be the safest place on the planet from climate change but the heat waves a few years ago, and it's steadily declining snow pack put that idea very much in question. If we carry on business as usual, millions of people will be looking for the safest port in the storm, and the great lakes region is one of 3 regions in the US that I think will have a large influx of climate migrants, especially by 2100.
- jjulius 3y agoSo, about how they don't have that many heat waves[0]: >Increased heat wave intensity and frequency, increased humidity, degraded air quality, and reduced water quality will increase public health risks. >More than 20 million people in the Midwest already breathe air that fails to meet national ambient air quality standards. >Air quality is expected to get worse with higher temperatures, due to both human-induced emissions and longer pollen seasons. >The frequency of major heat waves in the Midwest has increased over the last six decades. Between 1980 and 2010, the rate of warming in the Midwest increased three times as quickly as it did from 1900 to 2010. >Extreme rainfall events and flooding have increased during the last century, and these trends are expected tocontinue across the entire region. In the Midwest, when it rains, it will – more and more frequently – pour. What about that "plentiful fresh water supply"? >These lake surface temperatures are projected to rise by as much as 7°F by 2050 and 12.1°F by 2100. >Higher temperatures, increased precipitation, and lengthened growing seasons are likely to result in increased production of blue-green and toxic algae in the lakes. Blooms of these algae can harm fish, water quality, habitats, and aesthetics—and could worsen the impact of invasive species.[1] [0]https://www.edf.org/sites/default/files/content/regional_releases_midwest.pdf https://www.edf.org/sites/default/files/content/regional_rel... [1]https://toolkit.climate.gov/regions/great-lakes https://toolkit.climate.gov/regions/great-lakes
- cjs_ac 3y agoIf the legacy infrastructure of the current cities becomes too difficult to maintain and operate for smaller populations, we might see the populations establish newer communities in adjacent areas, like mediaeval Lundenwic and Lundenburg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglo-Saxon_London#Lundenwic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglo-Saxon_London#Lundenwic
- telotortium 3y agoAren't the suburbs in the US essentially this, especially for the really decayed cities like Detroit and Baltimore? Many suburbs even have a lot of employment, so the city isn't necessary for that. Another reason that cities are abandoned historically is that they become too hard to defend. In such cases, the people often relocate to a more defensible location. Similarly, in the US, many cities were abandoned by those who could afford it because of increasing crime, and they retreated to suburbs that were less hospitable to crime.
- jjulius 3y ago>A new study has run the numbers and found that by the end of the century, almost half of the nearly 30,000 cities in the US will face some sort of population decline, losing between 12 to 23 percent of their resident population. I am genuinely curious to know what number of cities and towns in the US have lost at least 12 to 23 percent of their resident population, or have become ghost towns, in the past 100 years.
- cafard 3y agoA lot of mining towns have closed up when the ore (or coal) ran out. Some of them may have gained back population because they are in country that is attractive to the well-off.
- Gibbon1 3y agoI think it's fair to say that some of the rust belt cities decline is due to the iron ore running out in the great lakes region. And some of it was the rentier capitalists attempts to break unions.
- nostrademons 3y ago12-23% is pretty easy, and includes some very prominent present-day cities. Detroit lost about 2/3 of its population between 1950 and today. Pittsburgh lost about 60%. St. Louis lost 65%. Buffalo lost 53%, Cincinnati and Baltimore around 40%. Ghost towns are rarer, and it doesn't usually happen to major cities that have national recognition. There's a good list [1] on Wikipedia. tl;dr: they number in the hundreds, easily, but are largely small towns that you wouldn't have heard of unless you lived locally. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lists_of_ghost_towns_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lists_of_ghost_towns_in_the_Un...
- rayiner 3y agoLots of them. “Ghost towns” is an exaggeration. But Detroit has shrunk from 1.8 million to 650,000 and that’s caused tremendous economic problems. Philadelphia has shrunk from over 2 million to about 1.5 million and is stuck in a constant state of stagnation. Chicago has shrunk from 3.6 million to 2.6 million. It’s in much better shape than the other two, but went from being the “Second City” to a one with a questionable future. Baltimore shrank from nearly a million people to under 600,000, and seems to be in a state of terminal decline. Pittsburgh almost hit 700,000, and now is less than half that. The city has enjoyed a recent resurgence due to CMU and biotech, but the prosperity is not widely shared, and the city is kind of a museum to its more prosperous heyday.
- debacle 3y agoAmerica can't afford to maintain cities and it can't afford to maintain the infrastructure required for suburbs. There is a serious breakdown in our ability to simply exist as municipalities. It's a complex issue and many people are sure they know the solution, but the reality is that the only way we know how to govern ourselves anymore is scraping the bottom of the barrel with knee-jerk responses to acute events. Edit: I can tell by both responses that I wasn't clear enough in my main comment. Civically, America's representative governments have collectively established a policy of maintaining function just slightly above total catastrophe, while robbing taxpayers blind through nearly every single initiative they fund.
- 303uru 3y ago>America can't afford to maintain cities and it can't afford to maintain the infrastructure required for suburbs. Big piece right there. If cities can finally stop subsidizing suburbs, they can probably shore themselves up just fine.
- rayiner 3y agoNew Yorkers saving a few dollars in taxes instead of shipping them upstate won’t be enough to address the fact that it costs $3-5 billion to build a mile of subway in the city these days.
- renewiltord 3y agoSomething people have discovered is that if you offer to spend more on something, the guy who is selling it to you will gladly accept.
- skissane 3y agoCompared to many comparable countries, the US has such a huge number of local governments, with so many functions devolved to the local level. If state governments took over more of the functions of local governments, or if local governments were merged – such as a single local government for an entire metro area – that might solve many of these problems. When the state government takes over, the suburbs contribute to the state-wide tax base. Similarly, when the suburbs are merged into a single metro-wide local government, their local taxes now start contributing to services in other parts of the metro area which they commute to or rely on.
- beej71 3y ago"A new life awaits you in the off-world colonies."