4 ms·
I think the opposite -- that oil is one of the larger factors that endangers global security.
by JohnFen 3y ago
I think the opposite -- that oil is one of the larger factors that endangers global security.
- robotnikman 3y agoAgreed, even more so when you look at some of the countries a lot of the oil comes from...
- llsf 3y agoThe global economy is addict to fossil fuel. So fossil fuel like any powerful drugs that is in limited supply (limited resource), it is threatening the global economy, if we continue to use it OR if we stop to use it. We need a withdraw plan. Where we shift usage from fossil fuel to other energies (hopefully less damaging for environment, and more sustainable). People asking to cut the production without a plan are as dangerous than people who are asking to keep using fossil fuel.
- MBCook 3y agoWhat happens when the wealth ends for the Middle East? That could go very very badly. It’s going to happen though. Even if climate change and pollution and all other ill effects didn’t exist we’d run out at some point and be in the same place.
- gyudin 3y agoDepends, United Arab Emirates nowadays makes more money from tourism than oil. Oil is like 1% of their GDP. Climate change is accelerated, but it’s a natural process. We are literally still in Ice Age, just in interglacial period.
- theandrewbailey 3y agoOne of the things keeping Saudi Arabia together is oil welfare payments. If that ever goes away, things could unravel quickly.
- rib3ye 3y agoFrom every report I have seen, oil extraction is at least 30% of the economy.
- nradov 3y agoThe UAE has the potential to become another Singapore if they want to. But to make that work they'll have to reach a mutual accommodation with Iran while also not pissing off their other allies too much. It's going to be difficult to thread that needle.
- The_Colonel 3y agoThis says ~16% of their GDP is from oil (directly). 2021 data. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PETR.RT.ZS?locations=AE https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PETR.RT.ZS?locat... Saudi Arabia is at ~24% for comparison. The question is what happens if you remove those 16%, how much other GDP is tied to it, more or less indirectly.
- lioeters 3y agoExactly what I was thinking when I read the headline. The oil industry has been a historic disaster for global security, including the ecosystem.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Animats 3y agoYes. Without oil dependence, the US can let the Middle East sink back into the sand. That's going to happen eventually anyway.
- bobthepanda 3y agoSo long as the EU is more or less aligned with the US and the Suez Canal exists, the Middle East as a flashpoint is not going anywhere.
- Animats 3y agoRight now, most container sea traffic is going around Cape Horn rather than risking the Red Sea. China is working on the Belt and Road scheme to move container traffic from China to Europe to rail.
- dogsgobork 3y agoIsn't rail shipping far more expensive than, er, ships? Also, good luck getting anything from China to Europe via rail without going through either Iran (the Middle East) or Russia (not exactly on friendly terms with Europe at the moment, to put it lightly).
- ben_w 3y agoI was thinking that, but on the map at least there's the possibility of Turkmenistan-Caspian-Azerbaijan. I know almost nothing about these places, despite an Azerbaijani coworker, so this may be unrealistic for other reasons.
- bobthepanda 3y agoGeorgia has its frozen conflict with Russia and the Azeris have had recent on-and-off war with the Armenians, so it's not a great route either.
- ed_balls 3y ago
- lettergram 3y ago... I mean to I guess that is -- without oil we'd have an order of magnitude less food and no means of waging war at scale. So the world would be more "secure" in the sense that we probably couldn't wage war across the globe. That said, we'd be starving and far more isolated.
- Gibbon1 3y agoI think I roughly guess if you're using electrolyticly generated hydrogen to make ammonia it'd take about 10kwh/kg of electricity. If you can get wholesale renuabes at $0.05/kwh that'd be about $0.50/kg energy cost. Wholesale ammonia prices are about $0.30/kg. A lot of that wholesale price is natural gas. You can see the relation here. https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=52358 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=52358 If you dig at industry press releases you see a lot of interest in using renewables to generate hydrogen to make ammonia. Which says the above is on track that it's economic. And also shields manufacturers from natural gas price swings. Not to mention you can locate plants anywhere.
- lettergram 3y agoI wasn't really just talking about the ammonia. Tractors run on diesel fuel, the trucks that move the grain run on diesel, the trains typically run on diesel, the ships typically run on diesel. The plant that processes it into food runs on coal or natural gas, or possibly some hydro power or nuclear. The bag that stores the food comes from natural gas (sometimes oil). Then that package is shipped to a store using diesel. The store powers its lights (also made from a polymer from natural gas) via natural gas generators. One of fertilizers you point out is ammonia comes as a product from natural gas & it's the only current viable way to do it commercially, at scale. Sure one day, we may replace all these components, but in-reality it's not anywhere close to being replaced.
- PeterisP 3y ago"Endangers global security" often is treated as equivalent to "endangers the status quo", especially by the organizations and people who are powerful right now and so usually benefit from whatever the current situation is, as opposed to those who feel they lack power and thus are motivated to shake things up with a hope of ending up at the top afterwards. And change tautologically does endanger the status quo. So proceeding with business as usual with perhaps a slow gradual shift would always be seen as the safe choice, and rapidly abandoning oil would be perceived as dangerous, no matter what harm or risks oil is causing.