12 ms·
AMD Reveals Next-Gen Desktop Processors for Extreme PC Gaming
- dralley 3y agoThese aren't Zen 5 CPUs, they're Zen 4 chips with better integrated graphics (which gamers likely won't care about anyway) and some AI accelerators (which probably won't see wide adoption for at least another year)
- kkzz99 3y agoDo these AI accelerators even support common implementations for LLM inference or stable diffusion models? Last time I checked, AMD's support was terrible.
- diggan 3y agoI'm guessing no, as these newly announced processors are the first with those accelerators. > AMD is also bringing the power of a dedicated AI neural processing unit (NPU) to desktop PC processors for the first time with the introduction of Ryzen™ AI
- wtallis 3y agoThey're merely the first desktop processors from AMD with these NPUs. This is last year's laptop silicon repackaged for their desktop socket. They also re-branded the laptop version with new model numbers, because laptop OEMs basically demand new model numbers on an annual cadence. This year their marketing for these chips is heavily emphasizing the NPUs, because they actually have some tooling for them now, but they were basically dead weight when the silicon first shipped.
- zamalek 3y agoAMD's support is terrible, if you believe their documentation. ROCm/hip works just fine (well, with Torch - Tensorflow is shamelessly an NVIDIA shill) on many "unsupported" GPUs if you enable an override envar.
- NekkoDroid 3y agoTo add a bit more context: I remember reading somewhere (may have been in the Phoronix forum) from an official AMD engeneer that "supported" means validated and actively tested in their pipeline, while "unsupported" generally just means "we don't do any or minimal testing on these, they should work and we don't explicitly prevent them from working but we don't guarantee anything" (at least when it comes to same die/gen cards). In the same post they also wrote that they are gonna look at integrating more of those "unsupported" cards into their suite. Honestly, I hope they change their wording for this to something like "validated", "supported" and "unsupported" with actual explenations what each of these mean (fully tested, works theoretically, does not work even theoretically) Edit: I actually found the post I was talking about https://www.phoronix.com/forums/forum/linux-graphics-x-org-drivers/open-source-amd-linux/1428866-amd-rocm-6-0-now-available-to-download-with-mi300-support-pytorch-fp8-more-ai#post1428924 https://www.phoronix.com/forums/forum/linux-graphics-x-org-d...
- makomk 3y agoROCm is also incredibly fragile and buggy at the best of times, so anything not actively tested by them stands a good chance of not working. Hell, I remember that a while back people were having problems with machine learning code giving garbage results on one of the few consumer GPUs that was officially listed as supported and AMD eventually replying to the bug report and declaring that actually, no they weren't going to support it and they'd remove it from the list ratther than try and fix the issue. I think this was back when newer consumer GPUs were genuinely unsupported as in the code simply wasn't there too. Integrated GPUs have also alwayu had a lot of problems. There's also questionable OS compatiblity. ROCm is Linux-based and has extremely limited and rather experimental Windows support. Their fancy new neural processing unit is Windows-only, tied in with a Microsoft framework, and they don't seem to have any kind of definite plan for supporting it elsewhere. So there's quite possibly no single OS where all the hardware that theoretically could be used for machine learning and AI in these chips actually has even vaguely functioning code that works on that OS to make it work that way.
- CuriousCosmic 3y ago
- caycep 3y agoas long as PyTorch supports it, does it matter?
- antx 3y agofor as long as I'll need to recompile PyTorch for it to adequately support my card, yes, it matters.
- weebull 3y agoThe problem there is with PyTorch. They've got bugs in their AMD build flow that people keep pointing out to them, but because it's people with consumer cards which are "unsupported" (which just means AMD won't personally solve your problems with those cards, not that they aren't intended to work) they close the issues / PRs without fixing the bug. AMDs wording isn't helping either of course.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoExtreme integrated GPUs? Marketing department going wild
- _cenw 3y agoThey are enough to run the Ally, and they're closely related to the one in the Steam Deck. So maybe they're extreme in the segment of integrated graphics??
- bonton89 3y agoThey're just trying to compete with Intel Extreme Graphics from 2002. Must be they're reaching performance parity. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_graphics_processing_units https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_graphics_process...
- seabrookmx 3y agoParity? AMD integrated GPU's have outperformed Intel's for many years.
- dathinab 3y agoonly APU like the 5700G, 8700G or the recent Steam Deck APU (in reasonable comparison targets) The integrated GPUs of the 7000 serious (not APUs) are maximal minimalist to a point I think they couldn't have shrunken them more without running into unusual issues (assuming not changing the architecture/design). They are only suited for web browsing, office use-cases and debugging (but also kinda where made only for that use-case). Well I guess Dead Cells and similar "low requirement/high optimized" games still run nicely on it on 1080p. Still nice to have them if you only have such use-cases saves a ton of money.
- seabrookmx 3y agoAPU is a marketing term. The GPU's in them are still integrated GPU's. Intel didn't have anything that held a candle to them until the Iris branded parts, and even those lagged behind. > integrated GPUs of the 7000 serious (not APUs) are maximal minimalist to a point I think they couldn't have shrunken them more Right, because these are meant as a backup display output in parts that are aimed at the gaming market, where they will almost always be paired with a GPU. Comparable parts in prior Ryzen generations didn't even have an iGPU. Intel offers you the choice (no GPU in the "K" SKU) which is nice.
- Dalewyn 3y ago>they're Zen 4 chips with better integrated graphics (which gamers likely won't care about anyway) Integrated GPUs are becoming far more appealing to the general consumer, including (especially?) gamers, with how fucking expensive discrete GPUs are getting these days (AMD is part of that problem). We might just witness dGPUs becoming the sound cards of this decade.
- mirsadm 3y agoExtremely unlikely. The types of GPUs these compete against don't cost a lot of money.
- Dalewyn 3y agoAn RTX 4060 (with a pitiful 8GB vram) is about $300. Something a bit more practical like an RTX 4070 (with 12GB vram) is about $550. That is bullshit expensive. It's still nowhere near as bad as during the cryptomining craze, but remember a GTX 1080 MSRP'd for about $430 back in the old days. An RTX 4080 for context is around $1,500 to $2,000 right now. If I'm just looking to game and only have a reasonable budget like most people, I'll just grab some AMD APU and be done with it. Better yet just go and buy a console or game on my phone.
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoHow do the best integrated graphics compare performance-wise though? If they are way behind in performance, you might be able to buy a cheap 2GB VRAM GPU for less than a cutting edge integrated graphics CPU.
- justsomehnguy 3y ago> you might be able to buy a cheap 2GB VRAM GPU Lol? It's another ~$100 what would not yield you any performance gains. Older 5700G was ~$300 so it was hardly a part of a budget build, but 5 5500GT is $125 (and would probably drop below $100 in a half/year) and would clearly offer at least 30fps on FullHD[0] and you would buy it anyway because it's a CPU. https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/amd-ryzen-5-5600g-review/3 https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/amd-ryzen-5-5600g-revie...
- 0x457 3y agoWell, look at the steam hardware survey, you're going to be surprised.
- sva_ 3y agoPeople playing on laptops and the steamdeck? All legit uses for the iGPU (I have one myself) https://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/videocard/ https://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey/videocard/
- shmerl 3y agoSteam Deck users would disagree about integrated graphics. Besides, APUs really got good for gaming unless you push resolution high.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jabroni_salad 3y agoI used to play WoW on a Llano APU. Plenty of gamers are addicted to something like that and just want a serviceable cheap machine. Pretty sure my current 3070 cost more than the entire computer I was killing Deathwing with.
- Arrath 3y agoI played healer so I could just point my camera at the floor zoomed in as far as possible and suffer the least bad performance possible. And scramble to get back in-game after guaranteed disconnects on big events e.g. every time Nefarion spawned a wave of ads. What a struggle.
- dezsiszabi 3y agoIs that extreme gaming though?
- seuraughty 3y agoMaybe extreme in the other direction lol
- dathinab 3y agoThe 5700G had for some time been one of the best options for budged gaming. The 8700G should be seen as a successor of that I think. Enough to play a huge amount of games nicely under 1080p. But in a certain way at the lowest end of desktop gaming. Still better then the low-mid range of gaming on a laptop, tho. But for a lot of people that is exactly the right balance of what they get to what they pay. Weather that's because they don't have a lot money or they don't do a lot gaming and don't want to wast money. The main "problem" the 8700G might run into is I guess that the cost of AM5 motherboards and RAM. Also AMD (and I think Intel, too) have in recent years slowly worked to take advantage of integrated graphics even if you have also dedicated graphics (of the same vendor) if that sees some more improvements the 8700G could also become interesting in some use-case you wouldn't expect today. We will see.
- NohatCoder 3y agoA quick check puts a Ryzen 5 5600 and a Radeon RX 6600 at $360 combined, where the 8700G is set to $330. And a RX 6600 will deliver around double the graphics performance. So even without factoring in motherboard and memory the 8700G is hard to justify for a cheap gaming rig.
- chx 3y agoSource: https://www.newegg.com/amd-ryzen-5-5600-ryzen-5-5000-series/p/N82E16819113736 https://www.newegg.com/amd-ryzen-5-5600-ryzen-5-5000-series/... $150 https://www.newegg.com/p/pl?N=100007709%20601394871&Order=1 https://www.newegg.com/p/pl?N=100007709%20601394871&Order=1 starts at $210 indeed. People might argue the 5600 is Zen 3 where the 8700G is Zen 4.
- snvzz 3y ago$30 more ignores cost of electricity. That combination uses more than a little extra power, relative to the APU.
- kevingadd 3y agoGenerally speaking, you can set the power target of a high-spec GPU below 100% to get most of the performance at significantly reduced power draw. So if you're cost sensitive it's still probably better to get a dGPU, just cap the power. The dGPUs have more cores and wider memory buses/dedicated memory which delivers higher performance than the space constrained integrated GPUs.
- nottorp 3y ago> which gamers likely won't care about anyway Seriously? I'm through with buying expensive space heaters. These CPUs are 65 W so I might upgrade the cpu with integrated graphics in my x86 box with them. And my main entertainment is games.
- DeathArrow 3y agoAnd using the quiet expensive AM5 platform.
- kube-system 3y ago> New AMD Ryzen™ 5000 Series Desktop Processors Bring More Performance to Legacy Socket AM4 Platforms Wait, what? New chips for the old platform? I wonder what the driving factor even is to compel them to produce these?
- diggan 3y ago> Wait, what? New chips for the old platform? I wonder what the driving factor even is to compel them to produce these? A lot of people are already using AM4 socket and might not want to do a socket upgrade, but want a new CPU. Also, I seem to remember AMD made a commitment before/at AM4 launch that they would support it for at least N years, but don't remember the details about that. Maybe that could be related?
- borissk 3y agoNope, AMD promised to support AM4 socket until 2020. AM4 came out in 2016, supporting it with new CPUs for over 7 years is unheard of in the PC industry.
- zamalek 3y agoAnd it earns them a lot of good will, and sales.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago
- bloopernova 3y agoHaving just recently built a Ryzen 7 7800X3D CPU based desktop, I was worried I had bought just before a new line came out, but from my reading of the press release, none of these CPUs are considered a replacement for that chip. I think?
- dawnerd 3y agoLiterally did the same last month but heard rumblings about what was coming and felt much better. The 7800x3d is really awesome though.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoSame with the Ryzen 9 7900X3D. I got a System76 machine, and it is really good. Nvidia card for GPU / local inference.
- _cenw 3y agoThe 7900X3D is by far the worst value AMD currently offers. It only 6 cores per CCX, but two of them, so not only do you get the scheduling issues of the 7950X3D where sometimes games don't use the X3D CCX, you also only get 6 cores if it works. And you get a "7600X3D" (not a real thing) if you disable the other CCX, something 7950X3D owners would sometimes do to benchmark the scheduling difference to get what's essentially a 7800X3D.
- theogravity 3y agoThis is the reason why I went with the 7950X and not the 3D variant. Too much additional work involved to get the other cores to play well. Also I read that only one set of 6 cores as full access to cache while the other doesn't or has partial access.
- _cenw 3y agoThe cache is on a single CCX, yes. Which is why the 7800X3D is so good: There is no second CCX. Another big advantage is that to get them to work, they need to use higher bin chips. CCX overheats easily because the stacked cache acts like a heat shield, so you get the most power efficient ones.
- piinbinary 3y agoThe press release has a strange title for new chips targeted at lower-end PCs (those without a dedicated GPU).
- phkahler 3y ago>> The press release has a strange title for new chips targeted at lower-end PCs It's a pretty high-end CPU though, and the graphics support AV1 encode/decode. This would be perfect for software development, video production, or pretty much anything but high-end gaming.
- piinbinary 3y agoTrue, I should have said "low-end gaming PCs"
- KennyBlanken 3y agoBy the looks of how deep they had to dig to get frame rates to show off, this chip struggles at almost any 3D game that's been made in the last few years. It's equivalent to a six year old mid-tier discreet GPU.
- trynumber9 3y ago> the fastest integrated desktop processor graphics in the world I'm pretty sure the Mac Pro is a desktop. I'm pretty sure the M2 Ultra configuration includes an integrated graphics processor. And I'm pretty sure it's faster than the 780M in almost every workload. AMD marketing team needs to be a bit less wrong. At least add a "PC" caveat.
- MacNCheese23 3y agoRight, the topic "Extreme PC Gaming" - PC - PC - PC - yeah just for you spelled again PC - is extremely misleading - next time they should include "Not Overpriced" that people like you know their beloved Hardware isnt meant.
- trynumber9 3y agoIt's in certain spots but not the text where they claim that nor the footnote. And in any case only the best by the technicality of Apple selling desktop personal computers that aren't IBM PC lineage.
- ClassyJacket 3y agoYou know Mac is a specific brand of PC, right?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tempestn 3y agoA Mac is a brand of personal computer. The acronym PC comes originally from the IBM PC, and then from IBM-compatible PCs, and is generally understood not to include Macs.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoThe PC term predates IBM and was also used for the Apple II, Commodore, etc era "micro"computers.
- shmerl 3y agoKind of a misleading title. It's not next gen processors (you'd expect Zen 5). It's still Zen 4.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoVery misleading. As I have said before, HN needs a "misleading title" flag.
- flumpcakes 3y agoIs it actually misleading? AMD never makes claim that their consumer branding relates to uArch. AMD still has Zen 2 in their 'modern' lineups. Intel also has previous generation uArch in current SKUs, and let's not talk about the 10->11 and 12->13 gen "refreshes". Maybe the technically inclined of us would expect Zen 5 because we're keeping note of CPU uArches but to the general public they won't care. They will just see it's the biggest numbered AMD chip and expect it to be their best offering - which for integrated graphics on the desktop it is.
- shmerl 3y agoI'd expect next generation to imply new architecture.
- flumpcakes 3y agoDoesn't it have a GPU architecture never released into desktop CPUs?
- toast0 3y agoIt's the next generation of AMD G desktop processors with significant graphics. (The earlier Zen4 chips have graphics, but not significant graphics) The last gen of those was Zen3, 5000G series. These are now Zen4 and also RDNA3 instead of Vega. So new generations in cpu and gpu.
- GeekyBear 3y agoIf you consider "Extreme PC Gaming" to be AAA games at 1080p on low settings, sure. https://www.anandtech.com/show/21208/amd-unveils-ryzen-8000g-series-processors-zen-4-apus-for-desktop-with-ryzen-ai https://www.anandtech.com/show/21208/amd-unveils-ryzen-8000g...
- declan_roberts 3y agoFor a desktop without an additional $200-$500 graphics card this is impressive.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoNot really, since the APUs themselves are historically quite expensive.
- Moto7451 3y agoThat hasn’t been true for the Zen based models at least. The 5700G and now the 8700G occupy the $350-370 price slot. My comparable 13th gen Intel CPU with lesser graphics was the same price. That’s a great value for a casual gamer. I’m sure at some point we’ll see Intel based APU equivalents on desktop with some teeth. Intel needs to solve their driver issues first.
- brucethemoose2 3y ago> That’s a great value for a casual gamer. It depends. If you're truly performance insensitive and have to buy new, maybe, but these APUs are extremely slow compared to even older, low end discrete GPUs. AM5 is an expensive platform. The total cost of a DDR4 platform is peanuts in comparison.
- toast0 3y agoThe cpus are currently significantly more expensive, yes, but is the AM5 platform that much more expensive than AM4? On AM4, pcpartpicker says I can get an A520M board for $70, and 2x16GB DDR4-3600 CL18 for $55; total $125 On AM5, an A620M board is $75, and 2x16GB DDR5-5600 starts at $76; total $151. The real question is where the Microcenter bundle pricing will end up, if you live near a Microcenter.
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoNot an expert, so excuse me if this is obvious, but would these integrated graphics be any good for NLP? A GPU with 24GB of video memory costs $2000, you can put one of these in a system with 128 GB or 256 GB of DDR4 or DDR5 and give your neural network training software over 100GB of video memory if you want. You only have 12 CUs, 768 shading units, 48 texture mapping units, and 32 ROPs but huge amounts of cheap memory. I'm not sure where the bottleneck is but at least it won't crash and burn if you ask it to start neural network training routine that requires 100 GB of RAM, and you don't have to take out a second mortgage for a video card with the requisite amount of graphics memory.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoThey're slow, but OK for inference. In practice no one uses AMD/Intel IGPs because no knows about the mlc-llm vulkan backend. llama.cpp is en vogue on the desktop, which does not support IGPs outside of Apple, and otherwise people use backends targeted at server GPUs.
- eightysixfour 3y agoThey’re good from the “do it at home” perspective, not from the business or enterprise performance perspective. One of the ways folks do this now is use the Mac M* chips, since they have so much combined RAM. The raw performance isn’t as high as GPUs, but they can fit substantially larger models in memory.
- bb88 3y agoThe bottleneck would most certainly be memory, as you'll quickly overwhelm the on-die cache, without careful optimization. That said, I think AMD's chiplet strategy might come into play. I could see AMD release a 4 core 8 thread processor with increased on die cache and other chiplets being neural compute units.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoPeople keep reiterating this, but in practice one needs compute and bandwidth, especially outside of tiny context test prompts. On my 4900HS, mlc-llm vulkan is far faster than CPU inference on the same memory bus, with less cache, which wouldn't be the case if it was bandwidth/cache bound (since the CPU has far more cache as well). My 7800X3D has 96MB of L3 and a golden-bin DDR5 overclock, but its absolutely dreadful for inference.
- throwup238 3y ago> “AMD continues to lead the AI hardware revolution by offering the broadest portfolio of processors with dedicated AI engines in the x86 market,” said Jack Huynh, senior vice president and general manager, Computing and Graphics Group at AMD. I can't believe anyone actually said this with a straight face.
- jasongill 3y agoIt's not an inaccurate statement... I think that Intel's AI engine (NPU) is only available in one very-recently-released mobile processor, correct? AMD has had their dedicated AI on-chip thing for a year or more on multiple lines of CPU's.
- tempestn 3y agoSure, but it's pretty clear that Nvidia "leads the AI hardware revolution", if such a thing exists.
- trynumber9 3y agoThere are only two (and a half) companies in the x86 market. They shipped their Phoenix processors with an inference accelerator a year ago. And Intel only now is shipping their equivalent.
- flumpcakes 3y agoThis looks perfect to me. I have a big desktop, but I also want a tiny NUC-like PC with a decent integrated graphics for playing with Linux and trying gaming on Linux - without having to have a full sized PC. I also don't want to bother dual booting, or running hypervisors with passthroughs.
- twotwotwo 3y agoNot a great headline when the distinguishing feature of these chips is building a complete system without a dGPU. You can make an all-around solid computer with these, like the well-regarded new 13" Framework laptops but in a desktop, but they're not "extreme" or "gaming" devices the way buyers see those things. Perhaps there just isn't enough of a market, but ASRock made a series of nice little machines they called DeskMinis with 5x5in motherboards that were a bit larger than NUCs, but in the extra space could fit a socketed 65W chip and quiet low-profile cooler (NUCs I've used were noisy under load), two full-length NVMe M.2 disks, and two 2.5" SATA drives. An updated AM5 version could potentially ditch SATA to be smaller, since there isn't a huge premium on NVMe capacity now. I wonder if they could also handle some non-G chips, since those now have very basic iGPUs (though power and/or chipset requirements could still limit that). One issue is that AM5 is still the relatively expensive option; AMD is still adding new AM4 5xxx SKUs because there's still seemingly a market for them. The DeskMini systems could be economical, and if a similar AM5 system couldn't be, due to the mobo itself needing to be pricy or the 8xxxG + DDR5 SODIMM cost, maybe it's hard to sell enough of them to get it to make sense. Still, it's a fun idea, and if you're listening, ASRock, I can promise you'd sell at least one.
- bee_rider 3y agoMaybe they mean “extreme gaming,” for example if you are going to game while jumping out of a helicopter or something you can’t have a dGPU slowing you down.
- BossingAround 3y agoSounds like next-stage capitalism: feel the immersion of Mario jumps due to actual free fall.
- soylentcola 3y agoIt's how you avoid VR nausea from the disconnect between your eyes and your inner ear.
- hackerlight 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sspiff 3y agoWhile these aren't "extreme PC gaming" by any stretch of the imagination, I love how powerful these modern integrated graphics are. These RDNA iGPUs and the Meteor Lake Arc graphics are going to be the baseline that a lot of kids with hand-me-down laptops are going to end up with. And when they inevitably will go onto whatever replaces reddit in the next 5y and ask "can I play X on this", a lot of the time, the answer will be "yes, kind of". I believe these integrated graphics may do more for PC gaming than all those $2000 graphics cards ever did. They'll make PC gaming accessible to more people, who have been priced out of the market for years now.
- reactordev 3y agoI think you’re partially right. However, big AAA engines will want all that $2000 worth of GPU if they have it available. The difference could be Cyberpunk 2077 on RDNA vs Cyberpunk 2077 on RTX. I think we’ll see more and more RTX style GPU architectures become integrated as NVidia et al push AI cards on us next year. It won’t be crazy to see 512GB GPU ram with 64GPU cores in the next 5-10 years.
- EtienneK 3y agoYes, exactly! These new integrated graphics chips are great for 1080p 60hz for the games kids actually play, like Minecraft, Roblox, Fortnite, CSGO, etc. Integrate graphics will be the default in the future with discrete GPUs used only by the niche gamers and AI developer. Lowest common denominator consoles like the Series S and Steam Deck are also contributing to this push as gamedevs are forced to optimize for integrated AMD graphics.
- tommica 3y agoNow that is some out-of-touch thinking. The GPU industry is only going to expand more to the AI area, but the gaming area is going to keep making money for the same exact reason that it does now, players bragging, being envious, and the good old FOMO. Ain't no discreet graphics on a CPU going to make a dent in it, until they start selling them with marketing like "it comes with RTX 4080 included".
- DeathArrow 3y agoWhat extreme gaming when most discrete GPUs will going to beat them?
- BossingAround 3y agoFolks confused here about the word "extreme" and seeing an iGPU might be missing that Steam Deck exists, and the market for handhelds is huge. Of course, you won't be putting a 65W CPU into a Steam Deck, but if it scales down nicely, it's an amazing news. Steam Deck already enables playing the vast majority of current gen games (it was my Baldurs Gate 3 machine when BG came out); jumping in power so that I can enjoy some better graphics would be excellent.
- mkesper 3y agoSadly, even the detailed specs don't tell how much unified memory (UMA) can be used. Would be quite relevant for running LLMs on the iGPU (like on Mx Macs). https://www.amd.com/en/product/14066 https://www.amd.com/en/product/14066 (AMD SmartAccess Memory: Yes)
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 3y agoI posted that link 3 days ago but nobody commented ... how these things work at HN?