6 ms·
NASA Peregrine 1: US lander will not make it to moon's surface due to fuel leak
- patall 3y ago> Peregrine 1, which is also the first commercial space probe to attempt a soft landing on the moon Afaik, that honor belongs to SpaceIL and their Beresheet spacecraft.
- cuSetanta 3y agoAs someone who built, tested, launched, and crashed another commercial lunar lander in the last two years the media around this lander has been quite frustrating. Sorry to see the lander fail though, I know what they are feeling now and it sucks.
- soliton4 3y agoso bitcoin doesnt go to the moon?
- ArizonaJoe 3y ago[flagged]
- teekert 3y agoWhat ever you may think of the US, it is also home to SpaceX which is doing some amazing things wrt to "space". Producing a successful privately funded "space" company, to me, sounds like success as in, the economic model is, at least in some regards, a success. Sure, in come the socialists, and I agree with them and like living in Europe... Still, Europe is not fertile ground for companies like SpaceX. Please don't take this comment as Europa or the US is superior. I'm just saying they're different.
- ArizonaJoe 3y agoBut SpaceX is a private company. Sure, we can argue the environment of America produces more such companies than anywhere else but at the end of the day it's a man with billions of dollars dragging a country to space. It makes no sense that the government equivalent is NASA and each launch is expensive and slow. The US govt is seeking contracts with a private entity because NASA simply does not have the ability to go to space quick and cheaply.
- ben_w 3y agoNASA isn't the government equivalent of SpaceX, NASA just commissions launch vehicles from the private sector and does the missions that use those launch vehicles. Space Shuttle? United Space Alliance, Thiokol/Alliant Techsystems (for the SRBs), Lockheed Martin/Martin Marietta (for the external tank), Boeing/Rockwell (for the orbiter). Apollo? Boeing (first stage), North American Aviation (second stage), Douglas (third stage), North American Rockwell (CSM), Grumman (LM). IIRC, NASA have never made their own complete launch vehicle in-house.
- jfengel 3y agoGovernments send people to space more as a matter of national pride than serious technological or human progress. That was why we stopped moon landings after Apollo, and the Shuttle was hamstrung. And it's why the Chinese have put on only token efforts. If it's finally profitable to do space, it's up to a private company to do it. NASA's version is just more flag waving. The best it can hope for is to be a jobs program for technologists. Which is awesome and undoubtedly has benefits, but it's no surprise that it isn't profitable or gutsy.
- bigbillheck 3y ago> And it's why the Chinese have put on only token efforts. China's got two rovers up there, returned 1.7kg of moon rocks in 2020, has another sample return scheduled this year, and another rover in 2026.
- kibwen 3y ago
- robofanatic 3y agomay be too much focus on "first world problems"?
- sixothree 3y ago> the change in the world over the last few years Can you expand more on what you interpret them to be thinking here? Who is on the rise in their minds?
- dzink 3y agoThe presence of social media means you hear of a lot more attempts than before. Russia used to only announce its successes and none of their failures in space. In making anything new, the only way to truly make it is to try a lot and the failures tell you the US tries at scale. Decline comes when you stop trying.
- bilgamesh 3y ago[flagged]
- manicennui 3y agoWe have done amazing space missions over the last couple decades with mind-blowing discoveries; they just weren't manned. As far as manned spaceflight, Artemis 1 was a complete success two years ago. Artemis 2 will launch with people at the end of this year or early next year. We are waiting on multiple companies to complete their part of what will become Artemis 3, when we actually land. I'm not sure that the average person even knows that SpaceX is part of Artemis 3, and the entire project is being drowned out by Elon's nonsense. I think you are just seeing more noise, but not less signal. There is so much work being produced now, and so much of it is worthless that it can appear as though we no longer know what we are doing.
- ArizonaJoe 3y agoIn the modern digital age, countries all over the world are catching up at incredible speeds. One thing the US has is a moat on existing prebuilt technologies and supply chain lines, i.e. military equipment and gas but new technology threatens that at any time. For example, look at the frivolous spending of the US on it's superior military budget and its belief it is the strongest military in the world. Meanwhile there are a growing number of people highly concerned that in a modern war with drones and technology, the expensive US technology would be quickly overwhelmed and defeated by cheaper technology that were not accounted for in the last few decades i.e. UAVs + AI.
- cartermatic 3y ago> For example, look at the frivolous spending of the US on it's superior military budget and its belief it is the strongest military in the world. One can just look at the Ukraine vs. Russia war to see there is an immense technological gap between the US and Russia. Everyone thought Russia was the #2 military in the world before the war, but nowadays might be at best #3. Ukraine is holding Russia back and/or inflicting horrendous casualties on Russian forces using only a couple percent fraction of the US defense budget, and largely with old/leftover/unused equipment. Reminder too that Ukraine doesn't have the backing of the US Air Force or the US Navy, which the US would absolutely use in the event of conflict with Russia. Granted, this war has exposed a lot of shortfalls with the US Military with respects to advanced weapons procurement, artillery shell production, and drone warfare, but it's also been an intelligence goldmine for western militaries that is already starting to produce changes in strategy. > the expensive US technology would be quickly overwhelmed and defeated by cheaper technology that were not accounted for in the last few decades i.e. UAVs + AI. Russia has failed to destroy a single Patriot battery or HIMARS system, despite those being in-conflict for a while now. If drones were such a wunderwaffe that made advanced tech useless, then all of that tech would have been destroyed by now. China is likely #2 now with an impressive on-paper military, but they also have not been battle tested in decades with lots of unproven tech.
- adolph 3y ago> just how rapidly it has lost its perception of being a dominant superpower This is probably a good thing. Hard to stay focused on improvement when one is dominant. When just as many people from the US go outside for education and/or immigration as people from outside go to the US, we will know that things outside the US are in better condition.
- aweiland 3y agoThere's a ton of jingoism in this country and those suffering from it pretend "we're #1" without wanting to do the things that made/make it possible.
- standeven 3y agoDo you have any evidence that bridges, planes, trains, etc are failing at a higher rate? I suspect you have it backwards, and these events are less frequent than ever which is what makes them newsworthy.
- cdchn 3y agoA false door fell off a plane and nobody died and now planes are "failing at a higher rate" but if you look at the actual statistics flying has never been safer.
- inglor_cz 3y agoBoeing MAX 8 crashed twice, but not in the US. Those hundreds of deaths will optically disperse into the generally worse air safety record of the Third World, but the mechanism had nothing to do with the usual Third World problems; it was a software error made by Boeing.
- hulitu 3y ago"I only lost all my data once in one year, so my data is generally safe"
- lupusreal 3y agoA ton of bridges around the country are near their end of life and are in disrepair; something like a third of all bridges. This is mostly because so many bridges were built in the mid 20th century. The good news is states are starting to pay attention to this and are allocating more funds to address it.
- shadowtree 3y ago[flagged]
- carlwaverley 3y agoHonest question - what do you mean by this? What are these 'harsh truths' and the 'facts of DNA'? I feel like there is something you're alluding to that I'm not quite understanding. I promise this question is in good faith, I genuinely want to understand what you're getting at.
- shadowtree 3y agoIt's a taboo topic, people lose their jobs, existence over it. You can see it play out here right now. This map shows 50% of the world's GDP: https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2Fthese-three-regions-make-up-50-of-world-gdp-v0-4x5bno56ofbc1.jpeg%3Fs%3D9caefbb36c4ee07f47bb1546491b561a3211f7af https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2Ft... From first principles: why? and why does it map to one of the most replicated, but most taboo findings: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/average-iq-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/average-i... Now, sort the table in the second link in reverse order. And compare with this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_disability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_disability What are the consequences of this? What does it mean for law, education, social fabric? Ironically, the make up of HN replicates this TO A DOT. Hypocrisy so thick it chokes you out.
- dustingetz 3y agodo you have a rigorous source on the key claim? i would like to read more, and with rigor
- kergonath 3y agoA lot of words to say pretty much nothing. I wonder whether this comes from laziness or just wanting the reader to fill the gap themselves with whatever sounds dark and dramatic in their heads. > Turns out there are pretty fundamental reasons why "3rd world" is "3rd world", and it's not a magic piece of land that turns anyone on it into "1st world". Right. What does “1st world” mean according to you? Because its commonly accepted meaning pretty much is “people in a couple of specific countries”. If you use the phrase as a proxy for “developed”, then duh. Of course 2nd or 3rd world countries can develop as well. The fact that the US will be overtaken at some point is something commonly accepted by people at least familiar with History. > The data science revolution is not only falsifying decades of social sciences (replication crisis), but exposing some very harsh truths that are still too inconvenient to deal with it. Right. Such as? Can you name say 3 harsh truths hidden by social studies and exposed by data science? How are they “inconvenient to deal with”? > How humanity deals with the facts of DNA is the question of the next millenium. What are “the facts of DNA”? Is this some kind of dog whistle? > Personally my bet is on a new dark age as we depopulate. How can that be a consequence of how we deal with “facts of the DNA”?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eagerpace 3y agoIt's important to remember that this was the first launch of ULA's new rocket, the first launch BO's new engine, and the first launch of anything for Astrobotic. This was a very experimental launch with a payload only slightly more serious than when SpaceX launched a car on Falcon Heavy's inaugural launch. They will all learn a lot and try again.
- auspiv 3y agoAs far as I can tell, the Vulcan (rocket), and the engines, all performed flawlessly. The Astrobotic Peregrine has a uncontrollable propellant leak (not sure if it's best characterized as a leak or something else but the net result is the same) and will not be able to complete its primary mission (moon landing).
- runeofdoom 3y agoI was following various live coverage (just as an interested observer) and it sounded like there were orientation issues with the Peregrine lander after separation. It seems possible tgat it could have used so much fuel trying to get solar panels and antenna aligned right, or even just doing unintended maneuvering, that it now cannot complete the lunar orbit maneuver, but is still otherwise working nominally.
- Fatnino 3y agoA stuck open valve would explain all this. Not saying that is what happened, just that it's a theory that also fits. One of the maneuvering engines gets stuck on while trying orient the solar panel at mission start. Loss attitude authority until it runs out of propellant. Now that it's done, control is restored, so power positive on the panels, but the fuel situation is beyond recovery.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ortusdux 3y ago
- dylan604 3y agoDoes that mean the bitcoin is lost in space? Seems like an apt ending for such a useless PR move
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paulproteus 3y agoThe article doesn't mention Bitcoin, but I was able to find another reference to that here: > More controversially, the lander contains non-scientific payloads, including a physical coin “loaded with one bitcoin” and a Japanese “lunar dream capsule” that contains 185,872 messages from children from around the world. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2024/jan/08/nasa-peregrine-1-vulcan-rocket-carrying-nasa-moon-lander-lifts-off-in-florida https://www.theguardian.com/science/2024/jan/08/nasa-peregri... Happy to hear that more Bitcoin is lost.
- darknavi 3y agoThis is good for Bitcoin.
- pmontra 3y agoThe actual coin is in the blockchain. It's lost only if they wrote the private key on the physical coin sent to space (I didn't check if they did that) and deleted the key from every backup on Earth. It's going to take a lot of Bitcoin hype before it beats the cost of a recovery mission from that orbit.
- matthewfelgate 3y agoWell as they say: Shoot for the moon and you'll land among the stars.
- zoomablemind 3y agoIn this case it's more like shoot for the moon and you run out of fuel...
- rational_indian 3y agoCommiserations.
- cdchn 3y agoHow many times have Gene Roddenberry's ashes been to space now?
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated discussion: Peregrine lander suffers anomaly after launch https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38913857 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38913857
- ipnon 3y ago13 centuries passed between the construction of the Roman Pantheon and the Florence Cathedral. The technique to construct an unreinforced concrete dome was lost in Italy until the diligent research of Filippo Brunelleschi. We forget the engineering capabilities of our forebears to our own peril. To those who may say I am picking on this incident unfairly, that I am making a mountain of a molehill, I would only ask you to share whether you feel more comfortable riding a Boeing airplane built this year or built a decade ago.
- refulgentis 3y ago"It's important to remember that this was the first launch of ULA's new rocket, the first launch BO's new engine, and the first launch of anything for Astrobotic. This was a very experimental launch with a payload only slightly more serious than when SpaceX launched a car on Falcon Heavy's inaugural launch. They will all learn a lot and try again." - eagerpace https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38927338 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38927338
- loloquwowndueo 3y agoFalsely attributed quote - the poster is eagerpace not edgarpace :)
- refulgentis 3y agoFake news everywhere!!! Thanks :)
- cuSetanta 3y agoI would argue that we havent forgotten how to do spacecraft or even landers. We have the documentation and plenty of engineers in the workforce that have had success in landings, its just that its really hard to do these things. And on top of that we are doing this in a totally new way with the rise of the 'New Space' approach.
- qp11 3y agoI take the bus and don't really need domes for anything.
- myself248 3y agoIs it accurate to say this is NASA's lander, or is this headline-bait? By my understanding, it's Astrobotic's lander, with a handful of payloads on it, some of which are NASA's. I'm sure this headline A/B tests better for the same reason anything referencing "Elon Musk's SpaceX" does better than "SpaceX", but that's orthogonal to its accuracy.
- 0xffff2 3y agoIt's definitely AB's lander. That's the whole purpose of the CLPS contract that NASA used to pay for it. I'm on another NASA team that is "customer" of AB's for their Griffin lander. The degree to which AB's product is a black box to us is quite frustrating.
- lupusreal 3y agoSo the Navajo Nation has won after all. https://www.cnn.com/2024/01/05/world/peregrine-moon-mission-navajo-nation-objection-human-remains-scn/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2024/01/05/world/peregrine-moon-mission-...
- paxys 3y agoKinda related: I get that there will always be some amount of mission-related junk, but a for-profit company charging people to dump their DNA, cremated ashes and other random souvenirs on the moon always rubbed me the wrong way. If you can't do this in a national park you shouldn't be allowed to do it on the damn moon.
- DarmokJalad1701 3y ago> If you can't do this in a national park you shouldn't be allowed to do it on the damn moon. https://www.joincake.com/blog/scattering-ashes-in-national-parks/ https://www.joincake.com/blog/scattering-ashes-in-national-p...
- unbalancedevh 3y agoRegulations for stuff like this seem frivolous and overly restrictive, until you remember that what seems completely benign when one person does it is potentially destructive to the future of humanity when done at scale (like burning oil, throwing away plastic, etc.).
- EA-3167 3y agoA national park is a vibrant ecosystem that can be accessed by potentially millions of people, all of whom might have some thing they want to leave behind. The Moon is a lifeless, airless rock which is only accessible to a tiny number of people and only in a limited sense. The concerns for preservation are just so different between the two. As far as we know national parks are unique in the Solar system, maybe beyond. As far as we know lifeless, airless rocks are downright common, the only real thing going for the moon is that it's relatively close by.
- o_nate 3y agoThe DNA and cremated ashes are not being put on the moon, they are going to be put in orbit around the sun. Its a separate mission but they both hitched a ride on the same rocket.
- 3y ago
- danbruc 3y agoThe lander also contains non-scientific payloads, including DNA from former US presidents, including George Washington, John F Kennedy and Dwight Eisenhower, which could now remain in space. The ashes of Gene Roddenberry, the creator of Star Trek, as well as those of former stars of the TV series, are also onboard. Did we not always try as much as possible not to contaminate things in space? And this seems especially pointless, who needs presidential DNA and TV star ash on the moon?
- o_nate 3y agoThe DNA and ashes are not going to the moon - they are going into orbit around the sun. Two missions, same rocket.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- blindriver 3y agoI guess the Navajo were able to get their gods to scuttle the mission. Impressive! https://www.space.com/nasa-responds-navajo-nation-objection-human-remains-moon https://www.space.com/nasa-responds-navajo-nation-objection-...