14 ms·
Higher fees, more ads: streaming cashes in by using the old tactics of cable TV
- downrightmike 3y agoAmazon recently sent me an email saying that if I wanted to use my Prime Video without ads, like I have had the ability to do for the last decade, I'd need to pay $3/mo. Welp, not going to happen, the interface itself is already an ad after ad carousel. And that drove me off earlier. They need to show what I'd like to see, not what they'd like to sell me or get me to rent something.
- Dunedan 3y agoAlso mind that even when paying the additional $3/month, it's not completely ad-free, as Freevee content will still show ads.
- Rebelgecko 3y agoIs there a reason for that, other than "because we can, screw you?" Amazon owns freevee, right?
- edmundsauto 3y agoIt’s an experiment to understand other ways of making money. I also believe freevee is available without prime video.
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoSo don’t watch it, or pay for it.
- abawany 3y agoI was saddened to find a few years ago that some of my favorite shows on playlists were moved from then ad-free prime to the ad-infested freevee (e.g. Allo Allo) - made it a no-brainer to not renew after the year expired.
- lkramer 3y agoAmazon was already being scummy by locking some movies behind their ad service, even if you have Prime (and mixing them in with your normal selection).
- gnicholas 3y agoThis was probably testing to see how people would react, how much they would put up with, and what types of ad formats are least objectionable. I noticed this also and saw it as the writing on the wall.
- midasuni 3y agoThe irony is if they’d have sent out an email saying “prices going up, but we’re launching an ad supported one at a lower price” I’d have been fine. Instead prime got cancelled, and that means I deleted the Amazon app from my phone, which means I’m going to be buying far less from Amazon (probably nothing)
- noduerme 3y agoI can't imagine they didn't A/B test which of those statements would drive away more customers. A lot of people would balk at a $3 raise, but only a very few will immediately cancel because of the ads. I expect they'll start with a few ads and boil the frog slowly.
- midasuni 3y agoFor me one ad is too much. And they’ll be losing far more than my prime fee - I’ve just bought £130 worth or stuff from Argos instead of Amazon because of it.
- shostack 3y agoThey want it opt out vs opt in as they make more off ads.
- midasuni 3y agoSky TV shows adverts. Their annual report shows subscription income outweighs adverts by about 10:1. I don’t subscribe to sky hell I don’t watch ITV but at least that’s only adverts, they don’t try to double dip.
- FireBeyond 3y agoMax sent me an email that must have thought I was an idiot, and was being all self-congratulatory over not raising prices. "Plans are changing. But don't worry, you won't be paying any more!" ... but you will get less. On my plan they reduced the screen count, removed 4K, removed Dolby Atmos. but for some strange reason they didn't say "... unless you want to keep the same features, that is."
- nickthegreek 3y agoI canceled when I got that email from Max, and I canceled Prime when I received their $3 ad free email. Canceled Netflix last year over the household stuff. I’m really going to save some money in 2024!
- matwood 3y agoHigher fees, fine. If you look at the amount and cost of content over the last decade it was clear it was unsustainable. The amount we all were paying vs. the amount of content was/is staggering. We were in a content golden age. On the other hand, ads are a problem and I refuse to watch them. There are too many other sources of content to ever sit through an ad.
- nytesky 3y agoI’m skeptical that content quality is as high. Movies especially are stumbling, and many streaming service originals seem very derivative or written by algorithms. Now content quantity is enormous, but that just makes separating the wheat from the chaff even harder.
- edmundsauto 3y agoTo be fair, every generation says “they don’t make $media as well as they used to.” This may or may not be true, but looking at the past few years I have to say it’s subpar. That was probably exacerbated by the pandemic.
- walterbell 3y agoThere are decades of quality films worth seeking, some are on Criterion Collection physical media and their streaming service.
- k12sosse 3y agoVinegar syndrome filled a big niche for me in the last few years
- tacocataco 3y agoSwing by archive.org, they have full movies! This one is next in my watch list: https://archive.org/details/Gattaca https://archive.org/details/Gattaca I've also "discovered" their software tab recently.
- 3y ago
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoOnly this time with big data. And much harder to save your own recording of your favorites for when they inevitably get yoinked from one streaming service and you have to wade through a hundred others to find them.
- mdaniel 3y agoFor the 2nd half of your complaint, I've had pretty good luck with https://www.justwatch.com/ https://www.justwatch.com/ It's for sure not 100% accurate, but better than "login, search, close window, goto 10"
- AlbertCory 3y agoPublic service: IF (I know it's a big if) you can put an antenna within line-of-sight of the broadcast towers, ads-only TV has never gone away. People think they have to pay a cable provider for local channels, but you don't. No, that doesn't replace streaming. On the other hand, most NFL games are still broadcast. PBS is still broadcast. The old sitcoms are still on.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoIn the US there are no ad free channels over the air. Even PBS is full of fundraising.
- koolba 3y agoTime shifting with a DVR solves that. Watching the 7pm news at 8pm and you can jump over the funding pleas and stories you don’t care about.
- AlbertCory 3y agoI said "ads-only." Not "ads-free."
- fnordpiglet 3y agoDoh my bad misread
- koolba 3y agoAmazon used to sell a great product for this called FireTV Recast. You plug your antenna and network cable in, and all local channels show up on your firetv. You could set it to record like any other DVR. Similar products exist, but this was literally plug it in and you’re done levels of setup. They discontinued it, likely cause it was a one time purchase and they don’t make money off what you watch or have an opportunity to present ads.
- jawns 3y agoI got a DirecTV subsidiary to install a powerful OTA antenna on our house. Small and sleek. We are about 40 miles from the metro area where the signals are broadcast, but we get a pretty strong signal. Haven't paid a penny in years, apart from the $99 antenna and $99 installation.
- teeray 3y agoThis is why I’m just going to the library’s DVD collection or picking up enormous hauls of secondhand DVDs for dirt cheap / free at the transfer station. Great content, pay once (if at all), always available.
- medion 3y agoAgain and again big tech comes in and busts established industries with subsidised products, only to eventually remove the subsidy and virtually revert back to the original industry product and pricing… I swear, technology only speeds things up and very rarely has any actual substance.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoThis issue might be big money, not big tech. In the 1980's, I recall the local Stop and Shop supermarket morphing into a "Super" Stop and Shop. It had an in-store florist. Apparently SS&S kept the prices below those of local, independent florists until they went out of business. Then SS&S raised the prices once they'd killed the independents.
- m463 3y agoReminds me of the minivan and "dumping" It's hard to tell if it is an attempt to gain market share early¹ or the second part of predatory pricing² [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penetration_pricing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penetration_pricing [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predatory_pricing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predatory_pricing
- maximus-decimus 3y agoAt this point I believe they should make it illegal for companies to sell products at a loss.
- rolobio 3y agoI recently canceled my Prime subscription. One of the major reasons was all the pre-roll ads. I refuse to pay, and also have to watch ads. I ripped the few shows I had purchased (they were not available on disc) before I left. I also canceled my Hulu because of the price hike, as well as how difficult their interface is. They put things I have never watched up top, the show I would like to continue watching is several rows off screen. Very predatory. I have moved to Plex, but will probably move off of that as they continue to poison the product. In the end, those with physical media, and pirates win.
- beAbU 3y ago> but will probably move off of that as they continue to poison the product. Check out Emby. Very similar to Plex (it's either an early fork or another XBMC offspring or both). I moved away from Plex because of there being persistent bugs and QoL issues that remained unfixed, but they started doing bullshit like VR apps etc. Emby seems to be laser focused on being a very good self-hosted media server + client, and nothing more. I'm a happy paying customer.
- matrss 3y agoEmby has upset many people in the past, with their move from open source to proprietary. Jellyfin is a fork of emby that is still foss.
- juice_bus 3y agoRecently switched off Emby to Jellyfin - having a permanent "buy premium!" in the player (auto search subtitles) sucked.
- glimshe 3y agoI'm very happy with Jellyfin. I built my entire collection in it.
- magicalhippo 3y ago
- winternett 3y agoSubscription Services are the laziest and most exploitative low-value corporate business model ever. Most cable TV channels are lazily running re-runs anyway (e.g. Comedy Central running reruns of South Park and "The Office" Non-Stop), which have already earned massive amounts of profits. Channels also aren't producing anywhere near as many quality shows and movies as the 1990s had, despite having much lower overhead with advancement of home editing and CGI. There are tons of individuals producing better content for TikTok than most TV & Streaming channels, but the industry is not giving them a shot because of cost cutting and lazy profit control as well. Subscription Models are making a bad name of software as a whole, where features are slowly taken away at the whim of a company's decisions to undermine value and up-sell different tiers of service in secret, and where ads and bugs are carefully added and tweaked into software to undermine the very value a service is based on to encourage upgrades. The prices of each of these service tiers, and the their features are also constantly complicated to create class-ism that becomes a wallet-draining total barrier to success and functionality for people that can't afford to keep up with ballooning costs of subscriptions as prices get raised unreasonably to please company investors... Just take a look at Adobe Photoshop, which shuts out new artists (with high pricing) who haven't even made a dime off of their work before they can even begin to properly use the app to make a name for themselves. I've even seen monthly subscriptions creeping into the silliest things like coffee shops and fairly essential car functional features.... Big business is waging a war on customers that has a horrible end result, and we need to be more vocal in stopping this trend of monthly subscriptions. It's a hostile move to distract us all from the real fact that customer service is being slowly killed, and companies are trying to transition us into a place where they profit no matter what the reliability of their products and services are... Worse yet, when a customer cannot cancel a subscription, this subscription model completely does not work properly, and many will end up paying for services they forget or don't even use. When a subscriber dies, they can go on for ages still being billed on automatic payments, with no one to protest the charges and payments, which should be considered a crime... The subscription model is based on corporate opportunism, and we shouldn't allow it to be normalized, otherwise every aspect of our lives will become a utility bill that locks us in to low value and limited services that unexpectedly zap our ability to budget.
- jay_kyburz 3y ago
- notyourwork 3y agoYouTube has gotten beyond out of control. Ad to start, ads in middle. I’m giving up and reading more books, playing more video games. Used to enjoy YouTube, cooking, aquariums and other hobbies. I feel bad for the content creators who are at the mercy of Alphabet. Seeing prime announce ads broke the camels back for me.
- KittenInABox 3y agoI use ublock origin on firefox and have never seen a youtube ad. Whenever I enjoy a video very thoroughly, I just donate money directly to the creator's ko-fi or something. It's a much, much smoother experience.
- notyourwork 3y agoI use an htpc (nvidia shield) so that’s not an option. Either way, I’m sort of tired of going out of my way to avoid a shitty user experience. If it sucks, I’ll do something else.
- pierat 3y agoIt definitely IS an option, but at the network level. https://pi-hole.net/ https://pi-hole.net/ It runs on damn near everything, and is a DNS level adblocker for the whole network.
- notyourwork 3y agoI guess you can dismiss my point, I’m aware of those options and frankly, not interested in deploying them. I have better things to do with my time and life.
- pierat 3y agoComplaining without action is pointless, especially when the action is so damned easy. So, why complain if you're not going to do something about it?
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoI am just surprised people are surprised. Of course this was always the endgame. The thing that is nice, for now anyway, is that: 1/ I get to watch what I want when I want it, so this is better than cable and 2/ I can pay extra for no ads, which is something that has genuine value to me and I will happily pay for.
- ghaff 3y agoAnd overall even with on-demand video, physical and digital content rents/purchases, etc. I’m sure I’m still paying less than I did for cable TV which wasn’t great for movies anyway. I do wish Netflix still had a good DVD by mail service but when many people, especially younger ones, look at you oddly if you suggest popping a DVD into a player, you know that’s a lost cause.
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoI hear you about discs. The movies I want to watch again, I buy on 4K disc, but that is primarily for the audio. Sometimes, being lazy, I'll start watching something on streaming, but then the flatness of the audio will make me get my ass off the sofa and put in the disk.
- aledalgrande 3y agoThe thing that is not nice is that 1) content is now super split between different providers and 2) you can't bring it with you on your travels (different licensing for different countries)
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoOn 1/ the content was always split across providers - you just had a middle man bundling pointless shit in with the stuff you wanted and charging you more. If a "single user interface" is what you want, my Apple TV does some aggregating across apps. It's good enough I'm replacing my other TV's roku with another Apple TV (just got to figure out the digital output). On 2/ can you do that with cable? Inside your own country, could you take your laptop and watch your cable subscriptions on the road? DVDs are region locked too. I've have also watch some Netflix content in Europe with my US Netflix account when I was traveling so it's not a 100% block.
- graphe 3y agoI'm pleased to announce that despite this problem with ads, I like that they make a lot more media accessible for free tier YouTube. I can stream Barry Lyndon on YouTube anytime for free thanks to some HBO deal. I'm sure you can find tons of free movies you can watch now, I love YouTube, if you need ad free, you can buy a different cheaper country's YouTube yearly subscribe. With AI media I expect this kind of ad in the very near future. https://youtu.be/HnXgbMgfkYg https://youtu.be/HnXgbMgfkYg
- eikenberry 3y agoDo you need to VPN if you subscribe in another country? Or do they not track access location of subscribers?
- graphe 3y agohttps://youtu.be/Ad_WS6h6NJw https://youtu.be/Ad_WS6h6NJw I'm not sure, you can try here. It sounds like it might be location based.
- rblatz 3y agoTV with ads isn’t an option anymore. We went back home over Christmas and our parents both watch either cable tv or ad supported Hulu. I felt like i couldn’t get into the shows, we were constantly interrupted by ads. I’d rather just not watch television than watch a never ending stream of advertising.
- avalys 3y agoJust your regular friendly reminder that you don't need to consume any of this garbage at all. Go read a book! Play a video game!
- aledalgrande 3y agoAgreed just finished both Agassi's biography and Elden Ring and they were much more entertaining than all those braindead movies out there
- caseysoftware 3y agoI used to have Amazon Prime Video but canceled it a couple years back and instead just use their free tv options occasionally. It has ads and what stuns me is how un-targeted they are. You know what I've bought and browsed recently, why are you showing me HIV meds!?* * No, I don't have HIV and don't think I've ever searched anything remotely related to it.
- JayStavis 3y agoI remember predictions that cable TV practices (bundling/ads/high prices) would eventually get into the "easy/cheap/fast" streaming tech and undermine its newfound value. Even if streaming prices were just as bad as cable TV, you have to admit that the lock-in effects are minimal and that's pretty great on its own: no hardware, no-contracts, no brick-and-mortar, no service appointments or technicians, etc. With that in mind, I don't mind at all if companies are implementing these tactics. The barriers to compete are now way lower and the situation is much better for consumers (compared to ISP entertainment).
- acidburnNSA 3y agoMy dad told me that when cable TV first came out, one of the big selling points was that, since you pay for the subscription, there will be no ads, unlike broadcast TV. Then one day someone in cable decided to run an ad....
- kmbfjr 3y agoFor some of the channels, yes. Not all though. Ask your dad if he remembers the in-band signals on ESPN and CNN. Those tones were to trip automation for commercials.
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoMy understanding is that cable tv early on was called CATV (Community Antenna Television) and was used in places where the local topography made television reception difficult so the community came together to have one high quality antenna in a good location for reception and then distributed that signal to members of the community who helped cover the costs. In that case, advertising would have been whatever already was being broadcast to the antenna.
- _benj 3y agoI might be totally misled here but, why would a company need to turn to such practices? Like, I’ve heard about enshitification but, can there be a company that provides a service, is profitable, the customer are happy and that is that? No need to swallow the world, destroy the competition, lock in their customer, sell their data? Like, honestly, why? I know about human greed, but is greed so stupid as to destroy itself?
- figassis 3y agoVCs don't invest in a company to make it last forever. They want their 10x return as soon as humanly possible. So they push companies to grow as fast as possible and then exit (ie. sell to the next bag holders). Their strategy is not steady 2x dividends from successful companies, it is multiple companies exploding at different times so they have a steady stream of 10x money bags falling from the sky.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago> can there be a company that provides a service, is profitable, the customer are happy and that is that? Sure, but with every artistic medium except video games you are making very little or even losing money on the medmium itself. The average episode of a TV show costs 1m dollars per episode (and I'm unfortunately being very conservative here. feel free to look up how much your favorite show costs) and it's being offered on a streaming service that people pay $5-15 a month for. BUT it is also offered alongside hundreds of other shows and payout is based on views. Even if you were the only show here, were talking about needing 100k-200k views per episode to be sustainable. But no one is paying $5/episode to begin with. Video games only succeed because they charge these sorts of premiums (or because of various f2p monetiztions, but that's another rabbit hole). People will pay $60-70 per new release. But of course, your average AAA video game is much more expensive to produce as well, so it still has issues. For the scale of presentation desired and the amount of money people are willing to pay, you really can't have a profitable service from the service itself. And unfortunately that mentality is part of why companies are jumping so hard into AI. pay less people, make more content faster. It's a win-win-win if you only care about money and not artistic quality and integrity.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoI don't mean to be too contrarian here to the core message (yes, streaming captured the market with low prices and they are ending low prices), but I think people often forget how bad and expensive cable TV was back then when making such comparisons: - obviously, it wasn't on demand. You catch a show at that timeslot running at its own pace with no ability to pause. You take it or wait for the next airing, which is probably a different episode anyway. 20 years later we get recording hardware, but it's still a similar dance of remembering or programming such devices to record. - Subscriptions to streams are monthly. Subscription to cable tended to be yearly, with monthly payments and penalties for cancelling early. - basic cable was just that. you got maybe 10 channels, half of which were news and maybe 1 kid's network for the young ones. you'd typically get something more like a 50-60 channel package just to get some variety. As it is now, streaming still includes 99% of its catalog under the most basic package, with the only instability being if licencing or public outrage (perceived or actual) gets shows taken off. - Ads suck all the same, but we are still far from the nearly 33% ratio of ad to content, and ads almost never disrupt your program. - Not that they existed, but content is much more widely available. mobile devices, game consoles, Tv's that don't have to be in a specific room that your ISP ran wire through to, and computers. They have clamped down on the number of devices, but you still have much more freedom of where you want to watch content. some services even let you view content offline (not a download, just a cached copy on your device memory). - And of course, there is curation and library organization built-in. Tailoring your viewing to you instead of whatever channel/airing slots the network and studios pitched for. Among various other small and large factors I can list. It always sucks having stuff get worse or taken away, but we should keep in mind that this is still a far better medium for consumers. ---- The main interesting point the author made was one of congress stepping in to regulate such behavior. But I'm not quite sure where and how they could. Cable TV was laid out in landlines and over airwaves that the governments took responsibility for. Streaming works over the internet which is not regulated as much. They can intervene with ISPs (and so far have done negative progress on that, between net neutrality and the ISP monopolies. But that's a whole other rabbit hole), but otherwise this is just companies doing business. Landlines were limited and it was nearly impossible for other airing stations to push themselves in. With the internet it's a matter of hosting your own site. Which also is reassuring on why it'd be difficult for the medium to suddenly become Cable TV again. It's easier for a new competitor to rise and undercut existing companies. And on top of that, TV is no longer only competing with itself and radio: social media as well as video hosting sites means attention is harder to get than ever. If it becomes too expensive, people will just move to youtube or be satisfied with Tiktok/Instagram or whatnot. Still ad-ridden, but "free" for now (and I dont' really see those sites charging for subscriptions exclusively anytime soon)
- walterbell 3y agoFilmRise is a backend for ad-supported streaming and they also distribute directly to consumers, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FilmRise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FilmRise > FilmRise became .. content provider on numerous ad-supported streaming services including NBCUniversal's Peacock, Amazon's Freevee, ViacomCBS' Pluto TV, Fox Corporation's Tubi, Redbox, Vudu, Crackle, STIRR and others ... the FilmRise Streaming Network has reported more than 31.5 million downloads in the U.S. and can be seen on Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Comcast, iOS, Android and Apple, among other platforms.