7 ms·
The U.S. added 216,000 jobs in December, much better than expected
- hammock 3y agoSo much for a rate cut
- blitzar 3y agoI am old enough (i.e. > 2 years) to remember when politicians were complaining that rates were too low and pledged to increase them to make things great again, in stark contrast to now where they are all but promising to slash rates to make things great again. Lest we forget that actually they have nothing at all to do with the government on your tv screens every day; and in all likelihood cutting rates is a sign of bad things in the economy and hiking rates is a sign the economy running a bit too hot.
- mdorazio 3y agoAll the pundits who have been predicting large rate cuts this year just baffle me. The jobs situation is very strong, wages are still rising, and consumer spending is still going up [1] despite predictions that everyone was going to run out of money in Q4. On top of that, housing is still sky-high and the commercial real estate market hasn't collapsed yet. I must be missing something. [1] https://nrf.com/research/monthly-economic-review-december-2023 https://nrf.com/research/monthly-economic-review-december-20...
- matwood 3y agoAnyone predicting large rate cuts is also predicting a recession. Felt like nearly everyone predicted a recession last year that never came. More likely given the data is we end up with 2-4 small rate cuts this year as the Fed tries to stick the landing.
- rKarpinski 3y ago>> I must be missing something. The upcoming presidential election
- HDThoreaun 3y agoThe fed is independent.
- hammock 3y agoIndependent of what?
- hibikir 3y agoIf you want housing prices to come down due to raising rates instead of home building, we wouldn't just need the rates themselves to be up. If rates are high, most people don't want to sell their house either, as moves to a bigger house become prohibitive when you go from a smaller house at 2.5% to a bigger one at 7%. What we have now is relatively few home sales, which aren't enough to stay on the market for long, as there are barely enough to meet the demand of people who don't care much about mortgage interest rates. The typical force for prices to go down in a situation like this involves too many houses for sale. And given that most new construction froze, as the interest rates also hurt builders, we'd need an increase of supply from people being forced to sell, at a time few want to. That means large job losses and being unable to afford the mortgage they already have. A job market so bad, we'd most likely been in a pretty big recession. Given that the fed wants to avoid this, it's very unlikely that we'll see home prices fall at all unless they mess up. This isn't that weird in other parts of the world: There's been soft landings in other countries, just never in the US. The whole idea of rate cuts isn't just a matter of pundits. Jerome Powell suggested up to three rate cuts in 2024, and him speaking is not punditry: Depending of who you are learning macro from, it is forward guidance, a form of monetary policy. Covid, the lockdowns, and the post-lockdown period have been large natural experiments, testing whether different macroeconomics theories hold water. We had a by-the-book supply shock, followed by different levels of fiscal and monetary stimulus throughout the world. Economists will argue about this for decades.
- sgerenser 3y agoI think home construction will be the thing to do the job, it just takes time. For years, my area (The Triangle area of NC) has had a huge amount of home construction that has kept home prices rising at only a very reasonable 3-4% per year over the past few decades, despite large job growth and lots of tech employment. No reason to get into a bidding war over an existing house if you can go a mile down the street and have your pick of 7 different new home communities. Suddenly when construction ground to a halt in early 2020, prices started spiking by 30%+ per year (extremely low interest rates obviously was a factor as well). Construction seems to be back in full swing over the past year, so basically anyone who wants a new house can buy one if they're willing to wait 6 months or so. New construction prices have leveled off and the junkiest tract houses are closing at $100K or more below their prices a year ago (still $200K more than they would have sold for in 2019 though).
- sf_rob 3y agoThe argument for a rate cut is that the effective rate (real rate adjusted for inflation) will increase as inflation subsides and headline rate is held. So the same rate that was pumping the brakes at 7% inflation would be slamming them at 2% inflation. I agree with your skepticism though.
- el-dude-arino 3y agoRate cuts will still likely happen, just look at what's going on with the bond market; we're already in conditions similar to the 2010's. The US Gov can't afford it's current debt load at the current rates. We're probably never going back to ~0% interest rates again but current inflation numbers show that the inflation we felt in 2021 and 2022 were transitory because of supply-chain shocks and corporate greed. Now we'll have to deal with the boomers retiring and moving into consumption-only mode instead of consuming AND producing, the former of which is inflationary. Besides, corporate and white collar donations are Biden's bread and butter, and they're pricing in cuts of 75-150 bps over the next year. TL;DR - Don't discount that we're on the up from a low in a slow-rolling business cycle.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wombat-man 3y agoLast I heard they were maybe going to cut towards end of 2024, so it could still happen. I am reading optimism for the US economy's 'soft landing'. Fingers crossed
- oldpersonintx 3y ago[dead]
- bryanlarsen 3y agoIMO, the Biden administration is going to go down as one of the greatest in modern American history. It's one thing to do well in easy conditions. But the true measure is how you handle challenging conditions, and few terms have been more challenging than the last 4 years.
- swader999 3y agoWhat specifically have they done policy wise? I'm Canadian, don't have a stake in this.
- ceejayoz 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CHIPS_and_Science_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CHIPS_and_Science_Act is a commonly cited one around here.
- pyrophane 3y agoThe Biden administration is behind a few big bills: 1. The Infrastructure Investment Bill 2. The Inflation Reduction Act 3. The CHIPs Act The name of 2 is a bit of a misnomer (extremely common in US politics to give bills misleading names to make then more popular). Between them, he significantly increased government investment in domestic infrastructure, green energy, and the semiconductor industry. Short term, that has probably been a big part of the magic formula that has kept unemployment low while interest rates have been high in order to combat inflation.
- dkrich 3y ago> few terms have been more challenging than the last 4 years. I can’t tell if this is sarcasm or not
- Izikiel43 3y agoWell, it’s the first time since the 70s Americans have had to deal with high inflation (for developed world standards)
- mbfg 3y agoCan someone explain to the clueless among us (me) how you can increase jobs, but not decrease unemployment? ---------------------------------------------------------- POINTS December’s jobs report showed employers added 216,000 jobs for the month while the unemployment rate held at 3.7%. That compared with respective estimates of 170,000 and 3.8%. ---------------------------------------------------------- Also, isn't this just the most american thing ever? ---------------------------------------------------------- Markets reacted negatively to the data, with stock market futures sliding and Treasury yields sharply higher.
- Lewton 3y agothe population increased
- rightbyte 3y agoYear cohorts are not uniformly big. Immigration.
- mdorazio 3y agoIn addition to population increasing, the number of people in the job pool can increase in other ways. Unemployment generally looks at the number of people looking for a job, which can change based on people deciding they want a job / don't want a job in a given month. More details at BLS: https://www.bls.gov/cps/cps_htgm.htm https://www.bls.gov/cps/cps_htgm.htm And re: market response, continuing strength in the job market means the Fed is likely to keep rates higher for longer, which the markets hate.
- hotpotamus 3y agoYoung people join the workforce every month, and also some who have been sidelined for one reason or another can re-join. Who counts as unemployed is a bit more detailed than just people who aren't working.
- mbfg 3y agoi would expect that more people are retiring than are first time entering tho, right? Given demographics?
- melling 3y agoIs there a HN or Reddit group where economics, finance, etc are discussed in boring details? For example, I see a lot of growth in government jobs. Does anyone analyze month over month growth by sector?
- ajross 3y ago> For example, I see a lot of growth in government jobs. Where do you see this? You'll forgive me, but statements like that have the smell of a conspiracy theory ("Biden is hiring people for fake jobs to goose the numbers", something like that). In fact this is measured and has been for a long time. Here's the FRED chart. Always go to FRED, always. Almost everything else has spin to it: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/USGOVT https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/USGOVT And it's basically on trend. There was a big downward crash in the pandemic, which has been corrected for a while. Certainly there's no data to suggest a "lot of growth in government jobs", they're growing just like the economy is.
- melling 3y agoFrom the article that we are all reading: “ The hiring boost came from a gain of 52,000 in government jobs and another 38,000 in health care-related fields such as ambulatory health-care services and hospitals. Leisure and hospitality contributed 40,000 to the total, while social assistance increased by 21,000 and construction added 17,000. Retail trade grew by 17,000 as the industry has been mostly flat since early 2022, the Labor Department said.”
- ajross 3y agoThey're just listing numbers from the report, though. It's boring "here's the breakdown" journalism. It's clearly not saying these are growing faster. Those are just the biggest categories. I repeat, if you want data, look at data. FRED is free and great.
- melling 3y agoSorry, I guess I need to understand the current size of each group too for relative growth. This goes with my desire to better understand the economic numbers, in general
- DoubleDerper 3y agoNumber of jobs is only as interesting as the wages of those jobs (real wages not nominal wages.) I wish journalists would do better.
- blitzar 3y agoThe number of hours that they work matters as well (2 hours a week would be pretty low quality). I wish commenters would do better. Average Hourly Earnings MoM DEC 0.4% Average Weekly Hours DEC 34.3 (-0.1)
- bryanlarsen 3y agoFrom the article: The report showed that inflationary pressures, despite receding elsewhere, are still prevalent in the labor market. Average hourly earnings rose 0.4% on the month and were up 4.1% from a year ago, both higher than the respective estimates for 0.3% and 3.9%. The average workweek edged lower to 34.3 hours.
- lukas099 3y agoIf there are more jobs, workers have more leverage to negotiate higher wages.
- thinkerswell 3y agoHow many of these were government jobs or government supported/subsidized?
- hotpotamus 3y agoI believe the military had one of the biggest recruiting misses ever in 2023, so that branch of the government at least seems to be shrinking.
- nerevarthelame 3y agohttps://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.nr0.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.nr0.htm explains that "Government employment increased by 52,000 in December. Employment continued to trend up in local government (+37,000) and federal government (+7,000). Government added an average of 56,000 jobs per month in 2023, more than double the average monthly gain of 23,000 in 2022. " So, the government sector did see above average growth, and it was mainly through local governments. Tracking employment related to subsidies would require a lot of assumptions and analysis. I don't think it's done as a part of any regular reporting.
- thinkerswell 3y agoYes this is my concern, 52k direct hires but with Medicare, Medicaid, etc the subsidy to employment in the medical space is massive.
- nerevarthelame 3y agoNot a concern of mine. I'm happy that someone (the US government) is willing to pay for the health care of elderly and desperately poor people.
- thinkerswell 3y agoTo each his own, I'd prefer they be taken care of by locals who actually personally care for them, know them, and are invested in their lives.
- AnarchismIsCool 3y agoLooks like rates will stay high for the time being, if you're at a cash starved startup, it may be a good time to look around as that's not gonna fix itself any time soon. On the bright side, if you don't have a house yet, this may mean that rates stay high long enough to have some impact on median home prices. The Q4 2023 home sale numbers will be interesting in that regard. OTOH, if you're buying a house or bought one recently, I admire your optimism, might I also interest you in a bridge?
- FooBarBizBazz 3y ago> OTOH, if you're buying a house or bought one recently, I admire your optimism, might I also interest you in a bridge? Is this a reference to the "date the rate, marry the house" play (which is supposed to be relatively short term, on the order of 1-2 year timescales)? (I.e., the strategy of buying something you can't really afford now in the hopes of refinancing soon at an anticipated lower rate.) Or is this a reference to longer-term demographic issues -- the "boomergeddon" thesis, that as that generation dies off there will be excess housing capacity?
- AnarchismIsCool 3y agoThe former, just about everyone is buying with an ARM and expects rates to fall this year, but with that not likely to happen they're mostly just setting more money on fire than they would be renting at the moment. Boomergeddon is a fun thought experiment for y/z but the US has made it far too difficult to build affordable housing at a rate matching the population growth of the country. The more likely effect IMO is y/z will just never see the levels of net worth growth the boomers did.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoGotcha. And, agree on both counts.
- matwood 3y agoThe problem with homes is supply. Eventually rates will push some prices down, but without more supply there isn't going to be some big reset (~35% of houses are bought with cash). A soft landing in this case could mean flat (+/- 5%) home prices for a couple years. Those same higher rates also starve out new supply because it drives up cost of capital for builders. I think if people follow the old house buying rule of planning to stay at least 2 years they'll probably be ok.
- TradingPlaces 3y agoBe aware of 2 things: -That includes another 11k of returning Hollywood strikers. -There has been a string of downward revisions for 2023, including more for October and November in this report, 71k altogether. If you subtract all that, only 134k were added versus the November report
- vaadu 3y agoAnd then there’s the fact that the employment gains for October and November were both revised downward in the latest report. "The change in total nonfarm payroll employment for October was revised down by 45,000, from +150,000 to +105,000, and the change for November was revised down by 26,000, from +199,000 to +173,000. With these revisions, employment in October and November combined is 71,000 lower than previously reported." Zero Hedge https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/inside-catastrophic-jobs-report-record-15-million-crash-full-time-jobs-multiple-jobholders https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/inside-catastrophic-jobs-r... points out that this trend is deeply concerning because the job gains for 10 of the last 11 months of 2023 have all been revised downward. “Why? So that the White House can take credit for a strong number (one which also sparks algorithmic buying in the market) only to quietly revise it lower one and two months later when nobody is looking." But here’s where things look really bad. https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t09.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t09.htm According to the BLS, the number of full-time workers went from 134,727,000 in November to 133,196,000 in December. That’s a whopping 1.531 million decline. There’s another dirty secret lingering in the data. Next we turn to the numbers behind the headline job prints which were rather terrible: the monthly nonfarm payrolls (from the Establishment Survey) may have been weak at 216K but the far more accurate Household Survey showed that the number of Employed workers actually collapsed by an unprecedented 683K, the biggest drop since the US economy was shutdown by covid! "In short: December was a catastrophic month for the jobs market, which is why we expect the usual theater: non-stop spin and lies from the Biden admin, and not a single relevant question from the liberal media whose job is not to educate or inform, but to carry water, spread lies and enable propaganda,” observes Zero Hedge.