6 ms·
SpaceX launches first phone service satellites
- yreg 3y agoThese are Starlink satellites that could be accessed with 5G phones. These are _not_ the first satellites with such capability, other competitors are working on such constellations as well: https://www.space.com/spacex-launches-1st-5g-satellite-internet-of-things https://www.space.com/spacex-launches-1st-5g-satellite-inter...
- londons_explore 3y ago"launches", as in sends to space a prototype, not "launches" as in "service is available for everyone to use".
- tekla 3y agoYes, that is what the title says.
- paxys 3y agoSatellite phones have been a thing since the 1980s, and at least a dozen companies are operating some form of commercial 3G/4G/5G satellite services today that you can use on your phone or an IoT modem. Apple recently enabled this as well on iPhone 14 (via Globalstar). The article is about the first Starlink satellites with phone service, not the first overall.
- fabiospampinato 3y agoThese work with phones though, not _satellite_ phones.
- paxys 3y agoThe first satellite 5G call between regular phones was made a couple of years ago by AST. There are plenty of companies already in this space.
- 0xfae 3y agoIf you've used old style satellite internet and then used starlink, you'll know that this is not the same technology. Starlink has latency and bandwidth that doesn't even compare to the companies and satellites you are mentioning. This is a tech and nerd forum. Let us be excited about new technology.
- vel0city 3y ago> If you've used old style satellite internet AST's satellite wasn't "old style satellite internet". It was at an altitude of 513km. That's roughly the same altitude as SpaceX's satellites (~550km). AST's satellite was absolutely "new technology", last September. SpaceX was beat for the "first phone service satellites", even for low orbit 5G satellites with unmodified phones. https://ast-science.com/2023/09/19/ast-spacemobile-achieves-space-based-5g-cellular-broadband-connectivity-from-everyday-smartphones-another-historic-world-first/ https://ast-science.com/2023/09/19/ast-spacemobile-achieves-...
- pkaye 3y agoHow many satellites does it have up in space?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 3y agoI wish everything wouldn't be referred to as just "5G". Looks like they used 800MHz, so basically the longest range cell phone bands. Which is about as expected, none of that super-fragile millimeter wave stuff. SpaceX is using 1900MHz, which will make a difference but probably not a huge difference.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThat's the thing that wasn't clear to me. Do these work with any old 5G phone, or does it need special hardware? E.g. the satellite functionality in the latest iPhones is essentially "emergency only", and it requires a bit of a song and dance to make sure you have visible sky and a direct line of sight to the satellite. The article seems to imply this would be different, and would (eventually) feel just like expanded cell coverage. So curious how this would work.
- cloudwalking 3y agoAllegedly it's LTE and higher bandwidth than the Apple solution, although still relatively low bandwidth. Enough to text and call but not browse. LTE, text only, with voice and browsing coming supposedly in 2025 https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2024/01/spacex-launches-first-starlink-satellites-that-will-work-with-t-mobile-phones/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2024/01/spacex-launches-...
- summarity 3y agoBeing able to call is still a major improvement for small handhelds. My current Iridium device (in reach 2) usually still takes minutes to send messages even under a clear sky (and does so out of order).
- esprehn 3y agoOne of the most notable being the Iridium network: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_satellite_constellation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_satellite_constellat... Lots of interesting stories from their time (flares, collisions, market issues). It wasn't regular cell though, so maybe Starlink will do better.
- _xerces_ 3y agoWho else allows you to use an unmodified (hardware or firmware) cell phone? Certainly not Iridium. You have to have a specific iPhone 14 that was updated to support Globalstar and using it is awkward. I can't use an old iPhone or my Samsung phone. Other players have had single test satellites that again required a modified phone.
- paxys 3y agoOld iPhones or Samsung phones (aka without some specific 5G radios) aren't going to be able to use this either.
- panick21_ 3y agoTheir are other compnies in this space that have done the same. But non are commercially operational. AST and SpaceX are the leaders in this space as far as I know.
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoEarlier even than that, INMARSAT goes back to the 1970s.
- ianburrell 3y agoiPhone with Globalstar are not satellite phones. They are phones with satellite. They are only text messengers similar to the SPOT and Iridium ones. Starlink is starting with text but planning on doing voice and slow data. There is a big jump from going from device that have to pay for and pay subscription to working with every iPhone for free. Nobody knows if partner providers will charge extra for service or not but it should be free.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoWill it be free, though? I think we can assume for now it won't be. Will it work with every iPhone? I don't think it will. So, not that big of a jump.
- ianburrell 3y agoWhich "it" are you talking about? Apple added Globalstar antenna in iPhone 14 so it works with any newer iPhone. If you are talking about Starlink Direct-to-Cell, it will work with any phone with 5G and 1900 MHz band. For Starlink Direct-to-cell, they are partnering with mobile providers, like T-Mobile in the US. I can't find it, but my understanding is that it will be included in the service. It will be incentive for people to use T-Mobile.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoBased on some googling, the latest iphone is 15, so that means it works on 2/15ths of iphones, or an even smaller fraction if you count all the variants apple has released. If we're looking at non-iphones, the fraction likely gets even worse. Remember 3g was only shut down a couple years ago. And this requires 5g to work? As in 2 entire generations newer? But yeah, I also haven't found any confirmation it would be free for T-Mobile customers (who have the right phones), so I think it's safe to assume it won't be until we get that. It'd be cool if true, though!
- mlindner 3y agoiPhone with Globalstar is absolutely a satellite phone. They've added a satellite phone to the regular cell phone. That's different than what Starlink is doing which is broadcasting a regular cell phone signal.
- why_at 3y agoIt's interesting how the phrasing in the headline leads to different readings of its meaning. I read it as "SpaceX launches [their] first phone service satellites" which is how I think the author meant it. The first sentence clarifies: >SpaceX launched a rocket on Tuesday carrying the first set of Starlink satellites that can beam signals directly to smartphones from space. I don't think this was intentionally deceptive. If the headline said "North Korea launches first rocket" it would be clear that it meant North Korea's first rocket, not the first rocket ever I can see how this could be confusing though if you're not familiar with the existence of other satellite phones, and maybe a journalist should be held to high standards for clarity when writing headlines.
- mr_toad 3y agoPhone satellites not satellite phones. They’re basically orbiting cellphone towers.
- mlindner 3y agoApple's thing is basically a satellite phone. It's a completely different modem and protocol from what's used to contact cell phone towers. They just added satellite phone functionality to a normal phone.
- nickthegreek 3y agodupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38856845 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38856845
- trident5000 3y agoAwesome. My wireless bill is too high and competition never hurt. I would think satellites are way cheaper than setting up ground based towers and therefore will offer cheaper service.
- foxyv 3y agoThey are not cheaper unfortunately. Almost by an order of magnitude. Even though you need far fewer of them.
- trident5000 3y agoWhere is this info from? Hard for me to fathom this. Surely digging up ground to lay wires with lots of labor and materials is more expensive...at least I would think.
- Dylan16807 3y agoPer unit bandwidth, satellites are very expensive boxes of electronics, and need to be replaced more often. And we already have very extensive wire networks. Satellites are cheaper per square mile, but they can only provide a sliver of service when they're covering such a large range. If satellites were competitive anywhere with moderate density, a simple extra-big tower would be even more competitive. But we need more than that to split up users into smaller groups.
- hattmall 3y agoReally? How is it hard to fathom that building something on Earth is far more simple than sending a satellite up into space. Running wires isn't as expensive as a rocket generally. Also rural towers can use line of sight antennas to get backhaul from other towers that are connected to the wires. A simple google search for cost to launch a satellite comes back with "between $10 and $400 million dollars". And cost to build a cell tower being "around $250,000." If it costs $100k to run a mile of fiber, which would be very high, then you could run about 95 miles to a new tower before you even get to the low end of satellite costs.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kova12 3y agoIf T-Mobile provides as much as just SMS in the dead zones, I'd be quite satisfied with the outcome already.
- MBCook 3y agoSpaceX: Kessler what now? But you get 7G in the woods!
- TheBlight 3y agoI wonder if this is all part of a long play to introduce his own phone and circumvent the Google/Apple app store walled gardens.
- AlexandrB 3y agoWhy would that require running your own cell network? The Verizons and T-Mobiles of the world would be happy to stick another cell phone in their roster. The only barrier is getting people to buy it. Edit: Actually there are plenty of third party app stores for Android already - including several from popular phone manufacturers[1]. The main barrier is probably getting developers to put their software on these stores and getting consumers to buy from them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Android_app_stores https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Android_app_stores
- TheBlight 3y agoConsider the Parler case study. There the app was removed from the app stores but also Amazon stopped servicing the application. You could imagine a scenario where if the app stores had decided to not remove the app, then the underlying carriers could've been leveraged to disable the application. To truly escape the walled gardens of the cell phone world, it would seem you need to control the entire stack from carrier up to device and application.
- esaym 3y agoAnyone else extremely skeptical that this will be able to pick up the ~2 watt cell phone transmissions from 500+ miles away?
- phkahler 3y agoNope. But I'm extremely interested in how that's possible. Remember, Elon starts with the question "does basic physics prevent this?" If the answer is yes he won't do it.
- ianburrell 3y agoThe new V2 satellites have a large, 5m x 5m, antenna to be able to pickup the cell antennas.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoThat explains most of his antics, basic physics doesn't prevent things like endorsing anti-semetic conspiracy theories or telling business partners to fuck themselves. One imagines he might benefit from asking more than that 1 question before doing something. I'm kidding, of course. I don't think anyone actually believes elmu thinks about physics. He pays people to do that while he shitposts on the internet.
- callalex 3y agoSome one probably thought about that for a few minutes and ran some numbers and tests BEFORE they paid to lunch satellites in to space, don’t you think?
- harporoeder 3y agoLine of site transmissions can go massively further than with even minor obstacles. While a different frequency amature radio operators easily contact the ISS on $30 5 watt handheld radios. If I recall Iridium phones are only a couple watts.
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoAlso it's all about SNR, not absolute power. And you can infinitely decrease bandwidth to increase snr.
- bloopernova 3y agoOnce fully deployed, I wonder if this will have much impact on wilderness rescues? If you can get a text message out, you can send your GPS coordinates out too, and even if it's not perfectly accurate, it will get the rescuers to within range to hear/see you. Or, to view it from the opposite end of humanity, you could send a text message with gps coordinates and a time, and a high altitude loitering drone will put a mortar round or simple smart bomb at that spot.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoIt might decrease the cost of going out into wilderness, which otherwise encourages prospects to purchase an emergency locator beacon or GPS/satcom device and associated service (e.g. Garmin In reach). Depends if this is cheaper.
- colechristensen 3y agoOnce fully deployed, you'll have the same connectivity in the remotest wilderness as you do from your living room. Apple already has the Emergency SOS [1] feature for sending texts from remote locations in emergencies. This SpaceX service will start with something similar and grow to indistinguishable phone service. Coverage might be a little slow so maybe your youtube playlist will have a bit of buffering while you wait for your rescuers. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT213426 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT213426
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- marssaxman 3y ago> Once fully deployed, you'll have the same connectivity in the remotest wilderness as you do from your living room. What a dismal prospect that would be. Why bother going at all? Might as well plug ourselves into those bio-pods from the Matrix and be done with it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- blackoil 3y agoFor certain topics HN is worse than reddit, at least there memes are funny.
- waffleiron 3y agoCan anyone tell me if this is a realistic thing to worry about when thinking about state surveillance, i.e. van the US use this to track phones in other countries? Edit: I know very little about 5G and satellite tech, but love to learn more
- vinniepukh 3y agoNote: the bandwidth is around 7Mbs per "beam" and the "beams" are 40-100km in radius, so very large. This isn't a replacement for traditional cell service, but specifically designed for emergency service in remote areas. This service will work with all phone equipped with LTE (4G). Sources: - https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1742396904619581642 https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1742396904619581642 - https://twitter.com/TMFAssociates/status/1742430541574791566 https://twitter.com/TMFAssociates/status/1742430541574791566
- muttled 3y ago2 other strategies currently being attempted: Pepper a bunch of pizza-box sized satellites out there (similar strategy as popping them on SpaceX satellites) and go for a giant mesh: https://lynk.world/how-lynk-proved-direct-two-way-satellite-to-mobile-phone-connectivity/ https://lynk.world/how-lynk-proved-direct-two-way-satellite-... Put gigantic satellites that unfold using the tech from snap-bracelets and compensate for distance with a gigantic antenna: https://ast-science.com/spacemobile-network/bluewalker-3/ https://ast-science.com/spacemobile-network/bluewalker-3/ With how many cell-phone providers and towers out there, I have no doubts they'll all be up to their eyeballs in work on this. Also, SpaceX just lost funding and might be trying to pick up some of the rural broadband funds Lynk and ASTS are going for: https://www.pcmag.com/news/spacex-loses-appeal-to-receive-886-million-in-fcc-funding-for-starlink https://www.pcmag.com/news/spacex-loses-appeal-to-receive-88...