4 ms·
FTC Continues to Wade into Copyright Issues in AI Without Understanding Anything
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoSophistry and namecalling.
- ImAnAmateur 3y agoThe angry tone is making the details harder to grasp. The first thing the article does is point to an older article about a previous FTC statement. In it, TechDirt seems to disagree about what fair use is and then uses that disagreement to say that the FTC is saying that fair use itself is bad. Am I reading this right? That posturing is frustrating. Still... The argument that developing these tools under the assumption that publicly available data is fair use is what allows upstarts to develop LLM AI tools instead of giant companies is very astute. I think it's 100% correct. It makes me understand why LLMs are a battleground for copyright reform. I appreciate that the article makes the stance of both sides understandable. It's enough to make me begrudgingly say that I'm glad for having read it.
- freejazz 3y agoI agree with you. It's a bit disingenuous to report the issue as pro or anti fair use when the real question is what constitutes a fair use? Similarly, statements like: "they held with a ridiculously one-sided panel of folks from the creative industries, who more or less all agreed that everyone should be forced to give them money at every opportunity." just reflect Techdirt's own bias as to what they believe the outcome should be. I also think that Tech Dirt's analysis of the FTC's position is conclusory regarding the downstream effects of increasing wealth concentration and reducing competition. It seems like Tech Dirt came to this in the absence of any thought as to what the implications would be for competition in a world where training data of copyrighted materials don't need to be licensed. I'm not so sure that such an outcome would improve competition in creative fields, and I'm not seeing anything from Tech Dirt explaining how they got there.
- kj4ips 3y agoThis article is really thin and disappointing. It's perfectly reasonable for the FTC to be involved here, and what constitutes unjust enrichment and anti-competitive practice when covered works are used as components in a training set is within their purview. The USPTO will be involved in issuance questions, and the legal system will be involved in determining single cases. On this issue, the following is my opinion (not a lawyer, not legal adv.). A training set is a collection of representative input, which may or may not be covered works. The training set is a simple aggregation, it does not alter the works contained in any significant way, so it is not transformative. Therefore, the training set is as an omnibus of other works. The weights of an system are a product of the input training set (if DL is used), and the parameters of the training environment. 1 is an omnibus of potentially covered works, the other is likely non-covered (but maybe patent-eligible in some cases). It is unclear if this is transformative, but it is certainly not covered by any of the existing exemptions (such as covers of songs). Therefore, it is possible that the product of the above is a non-transformative derivative work based on one or more covered works, and therefore would have required a license or grant from the author(s) of those covered works. Note that authors often retain their ownership of UGC, and grant a service provider the ability to make that available to others in limited capacity for specific purposes. Some service providers (Like stack overflow) require that contributors license contributions under a specific license, and yet others transfer ownership as part of the terms of service. If the training set was built from only entirely public domain works, then there wouldn't be a question, but the extension of copyright term over the years has robbed the public domain of anything even remotely useful for these kinds of cases. On a side note, StackExchange contributions are CC BY-SA, which means that if the training input included anything from stackoverflow, the weights could be be affected by the Share-Alike requirement, which could lead to some interesting results if someone ever tried to request them. (However the attribution would probably be pretty easy, because you could pretty much say "all stackoverflow contributors" and be correct)
- TimPC 3y agoI think under any reasonable definition of transformative it's impossible for the weights themselves to not be transformative. The weights of a neural network are substantially different in type and nature from the omnibus of works that generate them. The more pertinent question is whether the outputs generated by the weights are all transformative. The weights themselves being transformative is not sufficient to make an entity hosting an AI model not responsible for outputs that are not sufficiently transformative and I think most AI models we've seen to date tend to expose direct copies or near copies of their input data in part or all of a response.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mcpar-land 3y ago> it’s no surprise that the participants insisted that training on their works was a horrible infringement of their rights (something that has still not been determined by any court, and would be a disaster for creativity should it be found to be accurate). I cannot currently search the web for any sort of art without drowning in a swamp of AI results. Even if the SEO-tag-laden midjourney slop wasn't ugly as sin (it is), it's drowning out the art made by humans. A 'disaster for creativity' is already happening and if we don't get copyright protections for artists and creators against their works being made into the grist for AI content mills, this will only get worse.
- SideQuark 3y agoI ran a few searches like "Oil paintings for sale" and found the vast majority seem to be human made and sold. Same for "scenic art", "fantasy art", "animals playing cards art", and so on. I've found no searches where AI made art is "drowning out the art made by humans". Do you have some example searches where you find this to be true? Also AI tools will let more people make art they like, and perhaps sell some to others that like it. I suspect this will be like the claims recording music would kill off musicians since up to then music was live. If anything, it expanded music by making it available cheaply and easily to more people. (See the Luddite story on textiles for yet another example).
- kranke155 3y agoWhy do you think it would show up in searches first? I work in advertising and it's becoming common to hear that concept artists aren't hired anymore. People are using Midjourney and other tools. The thing is, they are likely not asking for a "random" style, there is a list of 400 or 4000 artists (I can't recall off the top of my head) that Midjourney is deliberately set to imitate. That means oh - I like this Star Wars concept design, can I get more in the same style of This Artist in Particular (AI) is a real thing and it's costing people real money. My understanding of fair use is that this might be a violation, since one of the factors to be considered is the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work. edit: Here is evidence for the list (4000 artist names) https://twitter.com/JonLamArt/status/1741545927435784424 https://twitter.com/JonLamArt/status/1741545927435784424
- AlexandrB 3y agoCopyright law sucks. "Fair use" is rarely applied in practice (see how YouTube enforces copyright, for example). Copyright terms are wayyy too long, and those with deep pockets have a significant advantage when protecting their copyright. Having said all that, I don't buy the framing of "big bad creators vs. UwU small bean AI companies" that this article puts forward[1]. For example, OpenAI is Microsoft as far as I'm concerned. And a lot of the training data came from small-time creators on sites like Deviant Art, not from "The Disney Vault", because the former is publicly accessible while the latter is not. Meanwhile, the first movers in AI are already "salting the earth" for any AI newcomers since AI content is now flooding the internet and is inferior for training. [1] > Last month, it published an FTC “staff report” about “AI and Creative Fields,” based on a roundtable they held with a ridiculously one-sided panel of folks from the creative industries, who more or less all agreed that everyone should be forced to give them money at every opportunity.
- Supermancho 3y agoPlease stop linking to techdirt. It is a self-proclaimed rumor tabloid. It's not the Weekly World News, which makes it even worse, when it masquerades as news.
- xtiansimon 3y agoThis is a rant.