6 ms·
Harvard President Gay resigns after rocky testimony, plagiarism allegations
- camillomiller 3y agoHer proven plagiarism is quite egregious. Can’t understand how other academics can keep defending her.
- ejb999 3y ago[flagged]
- ambrozk 3y agoShe didn't say it's okay. She said that whether it's against Harvard's CoC is dependent on the context, which is obviously true.
- gruez 3y agoThat's be fine if they didn't have a history of shutting down dissenting speech on campus.
- ejb999 3y ago[flagged]
- jjulius 3y agoThis feels like you're putting words in that user's mouth.
- noitpmeder 3y agoAre you intentionally being obtuse? The GP made no statement as to his personal beliefs, just as to whether or not the statements violated a university's CoC, which none of us have more insight into than the current (now prior) president of said university.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- recursive 3y agoStop it. It's about whether it's a violation of a code of conduct. Not being "OK".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- woodruffw 3y agoI'm Jewish. It's clear to me that her actual statement has been significantly distorted; in context, it's clearly a very minor flub (and factually correct, with respect to Harvard's policies). (Evidence of her plagiarism is also overwhelming, and she should not be Harvard's president with that record. It remains to be seen what percent of academics would stand up to that level of scrutiny.)
- thorum 3y agoThe fact that it’s technically true doesn’t really help her. Getting hung up on the technical details of Harvard’s code of conduct just comes across as uncaring about the big picture issue, that is, the thing people outside Harvard actually care about. Part of the job involves clear and sensitive public communication about politically charged topics, and that’s where she failed.
- pgeorgi 3y agoTo quote the exchange (taken from https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023/12/8/gay-apology-congressional-remarks/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023/12/8/gay-apology-con...): “At Harvard, does calling for the genocide of Jews violate Harvard’s rules of bullying and harassment?” Stefanik asked. “It can be, depending on the context,” Gay responded. But Stefanik pressed Gay to give a yes or no answer to the question about whether calls for the genocide of Jews constitute a violation of Harvard’s policies. “Antisemitic speech when it crosses into conduct that amounts to bullying, harassment, intimidation — that is actionable conduct and we do take action,” Gay said. Stefanik tried again. “So the answer is yes, that calling for the genocide of Jews violates Harvard code of conduct, correct?” Stefanik asked. “Again, it depends on the context,” Gay said. --- The middle part with its "that is actionable conduct and we do take action" could mean that she understood the question as "does the university take action?", and that truly depends on the context: There are situations that aren't the university's business but law enforcement's. (even though I'm not saying that she took it that way, I don't know what she thought at that moment, but it seems like it wasn't a lot.) Even with such a 'most charitable' interpretation her communication sucks though, which makes her unsuitable for a role that's to a larger part that of a figure head. And with any other interpretation, she's even less suitable for basic decency reasons.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 3y agoOptics, social desirability bias, omertà, etc
- ReptileMan 3y agoThey know they are vulnerable there too.
- lainga 3y agoI'm not playing the fool here, I just am one (i.e. ignorant)... wouldn't the plagiarism stuff have come up when she was appointed President? Like would she have had a hearing or something first?
- gruez 3y ago> Like would she have had a hearing or something first? A hearing doesn't imply that they thoroughly checked.
- noitpmeder 3y agoI believe they were only uncovered (re-uncovered?, but definitely largely publicized) after those who were dissatisfied with her congressional testimony looked deeper into her past for more ammunition to use in their push to remove her as president.
- submeta 3y agoThis! It was all about her testimony. See my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38848351 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38848351
- kcplate 3y agoDoesn’t matter if some political enemies discovered it, she still owns the mess she put herself in over all of this. And let’s face it, it’s not like the political enemies she made were all on one side. There was bi-partisan outrage over the hair splitting of genocide answer she gave to congress. Also bear in mind that Harvard tried to stick by her and even excused her congressional testimony and after investigating the initial plagerism instances. At a certain point the plagiarism instances just became way to numerous (50?) to reasonably explain them away by carelessness.
- camillomiller 3y agoI honestly lean more towards her general beliefs politically (except on the Israel-Palestine issue) but I don't care what was the reason behind it. She still committed plagiarism, and someone who did it in such a provenly egregious way is not fit to run a place like Harvard, period.
- userbinator 3y ago[flagged]
- cm2187 3y agoI find it sad that she has to resign for that and not for covering for the blattant antisemitism of the campus.
- mplewis 3y agoPlease elaborate on what you found antisemitic.
- cm2187 3y agoit's a campus you get fired/rescinded/expelled for micro-aggressions and the slightlest transgression to political correctness. So the "it depends" could only be interpreted that way. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/16/us/jews-harvard-antisemitism-israel-war.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/16/us/jews-harvard-antisemit...
- infamouscow 3y agoAccording to Harvard's campus policies these are perfectly acceptable: - "Disgraced former Harvard President Claudine Gay is finally back picking cotton where she belongs" - "I think the black students should be picking cotton, not studying at Harvard" Those quotes are also protected under the 1st amendment. Regardless, they're so unbelievable vile, and the merits of the expression are so vacuous that it has virtually no value for mind-expanding endeavors that universities claim to be for. Similar to calling for a genocide.
- unethical_ban 3y agoElise Stefanik is not a good human, and those hearings were designed to get the soundbites they got. The interactions that people got mad at were part of a longer exchange of wordplay set up by the congressperson. The hearing was not in good faith.
- megaman821 3y agoHow hard is it to say calling for genocide of a group would probably make individuals of that group less safe, and therefore a violation of university policy? University Presidents at some of the most prestigious universities didn't get outmaneuvered by a slick operator, they just let it slip how they felt about a certain group.
- BryantD 3y agoSame reason evangelical Christians are willing to endorse Trump. I don’t mean this as a gotcha. When group X criticizes a member of group Y based on standards that group X doesn’t really care about, in order to gain an advantage for group X, group Y will tend to discount those criticisms to a varying degree.
- InTheArena 3y agoThis. Absolutely this. This is group identity and culture war ideology 101. It doesn't matter what you stand for, as long as the other side is "worse".
- wolverine876 3y agoI think the both-sides-equal analysis is not only simplistic (and very unlikely), but just serves the far more corrupt side. Yes, we can make endless arguments based on relativism, but I don't think the level of corruption is comparable. For one thing, brazenly corrupt reactionary right figures remain very popular and stay in power - they embrace and flaunt corruption.
- InTheArena 3y agoYour post is my point. Or rather, your post proves my point.
- 6R1M0R4CL3 3y agobecause their own work is based on the same copy-paste. those people co-elect and co-opt one another. they're like rotten cops : everyone protects everyone else, because everyone's getting cash in their pockets... most universities are nowadays of very poor quality : they can't stand anyone with an opinion they dont like (if you're a republican you have to hide it or get in serious trouble). they are very low of intelligence because the filter is not set on selecting the best but selecting people with the good politics (left and democrat) and color (the darker, the better).
- burkaman 3y agoThese are the new allegations from yesterday if anyone is curious: https://freebeacon.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Complaint2.pdf https://freebeacon.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Complaint2....
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoSeems like more than just "duplicative language". In one case, the language she is duplicating is coming from sentences in a paper where the author is citing others' publications. She could have at least copied his citations/sources along with, or instead of, his language. This just looks like laziness, carelessness, incompetence or perhaps something worse.
- endisneigh 3y agoIf you think President Gay’s plagiarism is bad, wait until you see Mr.GPT’s.
- mupuff1234 3y agoI was honestly surprised to see that her CV is nowhere the caliber I would expect from the president of Harvard.
- ejb999 3y ago[flagged]
- klyrs 3y agoSerious academics don't go into administration.
- ggm 3y agoYou're inviting people to go looking at people like Mark Oliphant, Brian Schmidt, Howard Florey, Fred Banting, Lord Thompson of Kelvin, Rutherford...
- BryantD 3y agoI think it’s probably worth doing some research on typical university President resumes. Laurence Summers had zero experience as a university administrator before he became President of Harvard University, although he had an impressive career otherwise. Ben Sasse is running a 50k student university; his previous experience is with a 1500 person college.
- wolverine876 3y agoSasse was a political appointment, to force Republican politics on the students and faculty. That's a recent GOP tactic, and has happened in Florida too (and probably other places).
- rafram 3y agoWhat do you actually expect to be on a university president's CV? The last two chancellors of UC Berkeley have been not-very-notable professors who worked their way up the administration ranks; the presidents of most Catholic universities are priests. It matters that you're a good manager, not that you've won the Nobel Prize.
- temporary_ac 3y agoEven if the outcome is the right one, mob justice doesn't sit well.
- gruez 3y agoWas this an instance of "mob justice", or an instance of her seeing the writing on the wall and then resigning rather than trying to put up a fight? I skimmed the article and it doesn't look like she was explicitly forced out, although it's certainly plausible that public ("mob") pressure was a factor.
- noitpmeder 3y agoThe "mob" part is that people went digging for dirt as a reaction to their dislike of her recent comments in front of congress.
- gruez 3y agoGreater public scrutiny is bad? Or is it only bad when it's in retaliation for something? More importantly, why is this form of "mob justice" bad? It's easy to see why it's bad to subject people to extrajudicial violence, but in this case all conduct is done within the bounds of the legal system.
- wredcoll 3y agoSo now we're in favor of cancel culture? This whiplash is confusing.
- gruez 3y agoThere's a huge difference between being "canceled" for one's opinions and/or unsubstantiated allegations, and being canceled for actual misconduct. I'm not even sure how you'd defend the latter. Suppose someone lied about their credentials to get a position, and he got found out a few years later thanks to angry partisans, are we supposed to let him off the hook because "cancel culture"?
- hyperliner 3y ago[dead]
- submeta 3y agoShe came under fire for their dry responses to a line of questioning from Republican representative Stefanik, who asked whether “calling for the genocide of Jews” would violate the college’s code of conduct. But the premise of the question was nonsense[1], as Peter Beinart has made clear. The premise being „intifada“ meaning „an attempt at genocide of jews“ when it actually means „uprising“. It was acutally about silencing the Pro-Palestinian support at American universities in light of wealthy donors threatening to cut funding. [1] https://twitter.com/hahauenstein/status/1734608990628348303/ https://twitter.com/hahauenstein/status/1734608990628348303/
- zaphar 3y ago[flagged]
- wolverine876 3y agoThe first is a pretty extreme, inflammatory claim. I think it requires very strong evidence. Also, it would help if you dropped the hyperbole.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bongoman37 3y ago[dead]
- submeta 3y agoIt means uprising. Not killing jews. - On the other hand Israel‘s cabinet (Netanyahu, Gallant, Herzog, Ben Gvir, Smotrich) actively call for genocide: Netanyahu by comparing Palestinians to Amalek, of whom the Old Testament says „kill them all, men, children, women, babies, unborn“. Herzog said: „no innocents in Gaza“, meaning justified to kill children. Gallant: „human animals!“, cuts water, food, medicines for over 80 days. These and more statements and the actions of IDF are documented on a 85 page[1] accusation of South Africa against Israel accusing them of Genocide in Gaza. So while you insinuate „intifada“ means „genocide“, Israel is apparently engaging in genocidal acts. [1]: https://www.icj-cij.org/case/192 https://www.icj-cij.org/case/192
- wolverine876 3y agoI don't know about Gay, but let's be careful that it's not character assasination campaigns by the reactionaries, seeking to seize control of these (educational) institutions too. Such situations are tricky: If you dig through every aspect of someone's long career and life, there's a reasonable chance of finding something problematic or even serious [edit: also, in every field, the way sausage is made can be a little messier than the public's innocent, simplistic imagination]. On one hand, we want to maintain the integrity of the institutions and our society. On the other, we need to be careful about incidentally empowering political suppression. I suppose part of the solution is not making it political, and not replacing people like Gay with their political enemies - ensuring there is no political benefit. Another part is to hold reactionaries and allies to the same standards; now egregious behavior and corruption is tolerated, and even encouraged as a way to flaunt power and disrupt order. (I don't mean that as whataboutism - if Gay did wrong, Gay should go.)
- submeta 3y agoThe question is: Why was she under fire? See my answer below.
- chimeracoder 3y ago> I don't know about Gay, but let's be careful that it's not character assasination campaigns by the reactionaries, seeking to seize control of these (educational) institutions too. You don't have to question this - the guy who originally started the campaign against her literally stated that this was his plan on Twitter. Both his motives and his tactics were public record long before the mainstream media picked up the story.
- wolverine876 3y agoCould you provide some info so I can find it?
- dekhn 3y agoThis is a good starting point: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/12/business/bill-ackman-harvard-antisemitism.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/12/business/bill-ackman-harv... but he basically says all of this in his tweets.
- perihelions 3y agoThe most egregious part of this story is the part Harvard University pays white-shoe law firms to threaten newspapers reporting about their administrator's misconduct. Casual abuse of power by those with far too much of it. https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023/12/25/harvard-threaten-sue-post/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023/12/25/harvard-threat... ("A Law Firm Said Plagiarism Allegations Against Harvard President Gay Were ‘Demonstrably False.’ Then She Submitted Corrections.")
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- InTheArena 3y agoI'm very much of two minds about this. The first is that, at the very least, the three women up in front of Congress did a very, very poor job dealing with Congress. That reflects the unequal treatment by the administration of different groups, depending on the types of speech being said. Saying that schools considered calls for genocide against Jewish people's protected speech ... was a bad tactic to take, given all of the other examples raised at that session. Rules for thee, not for me, has been Ivy League's privilege for years now. She previously ran the DEI initiative that was found to discriminate against Asians at Harvard by the USSC. It's only equitable if some are more equitable than others. That said, this will only further the restrictions on speech at universities, which has been weaponized to an almost inconceivable degree, as it was in this case.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wolverine876 3y ago> Saying that schools considered calls for genocide against Jewish people's protected speech That's the power of talking points. Once people internalize them, then the conclusions are inescapable. If you can frame the question, you've already won the debate. It's like calling abortion the murder of children - if you accept that, then the abortion debate is of course over for you. The only protection is to question our premises. Did Gay say that? It would seem pretty odd ... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38848351 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38848351
- InTheArena 3y agoIt's pretty easy to interpret "from the river to the sea" as the extermination of Israel. It's also easy for those who define Intifada at face value when they say that only with the death of every Jew will the Second Intifada be complete. This is like people stating in 2000 that when Bin Ladin said Jihad against America, it didn't count - he was talking about Big Jihad and not small Jihad.
- 3y ago
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- submeta 3y agoWhy is this flagged now?
- userbinator 3y agoAnything to do with the culture wars tends to get political.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- r721 3y agoAnother discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38844980 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38844980
- sha2468 3y ago[flagged]
- seydor 3y agoSurely the next one will be a perfect person
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More discussion over here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38844980 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38844980
- 6R1M0R4CL3 3y agoit's too late. saying in public that calling for killing of jews because they are jews not being a problem (after the holocaust) is unnacceptable. they got killed by millions using gas and you have your students calling for a second extermination and you see no problem there ? second, she's a fraud. if you check her "intellectual production" she barely published 10 papers in YEARS while the norm at the university is about 10 papers or so PER YEAR. if you study her own work, it's a fraud based on stealing other's people work and copy paste. seriously : if ANY student currently at harvard did the same as she did in plagiarism, that student would get, AT MINIMUM a 3 years suspension. if not getting expelled forever from getting a diploma from harvard. why did she get that job ? her skin color, and her leftist politics. nothing else. her university and intellectual production is worth nothing, and she's clearly not the brighest lamp at harvard, by a very long shot. it's too late. where i work, anyone from harvard gets ejected to the nearest trash bin if they try to get in. bosses told us they will never, ever, get someone from harvard as long they will be around, which is at least 10 years at minimum. and those big CEOs they all know one another, and talk with one another. harvard students, good luck finding a job with your crap diploma.
- doomleika 3y agoMy advisor will hang me in the public square if my thesis have sentences remotely close to any paper. Rules for the but not for me.