5 ms·
Half of high school seniors won't apply to colleges costing more than $40k
- c0balt 3y ago> “The original purpose of tuition discounting was to make higher education affordable to low-income students,” Bridgewater president David W. Bushman said in a press release explaining the dramatic shift. “But over time, the practice has resulted in higher and higher tuition sticker prices that bear little resemblance to the actual cost of education. This somehow seems inevitable in hindsight. It is quite bizarre, as a German student in university, how the education sector in the U.S. is working acceptable-ish[^1] and yet everytime I read something about it is seems to in some stage of self-imploding for colleges/ universities. It would be interesting to see how this societal issue can be addressed in the longer term. Imoe neither technology alone nor any simple approach will work but it definitely is a great challenge for the future/ present.
- smt88 3y agoThe college system in the US works well. The vast majority of students go to community colleges or public schools and end up with very little debt (if any). The nightmare stories you hear are about the small, vocal minority that go to expensive private schools and/or major in something that doesn't pay well (like theatre) and/or get Masters degrees that put them in debt.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- elliotec 3y agoI don’t think so. > As of 2023, approximately 44 million Americans carry student loan debt, with the total student loan debt in the United States reaching $1.76 trillion according to the Federal Reserve. This figure includes both federal and private student loans. It's notable that the number of people with federal student loans is around 43.4 million, and there are about 3.5 million private student loan borrowers, leading to a total of around 46.9 million American adults with a student loan. The average student loan debt in the United States as of 2023 is approximately $37,645 per borrower. This figure represents the average amount owed by those carrying federal student loan debt https://www.studentloanplanner.com/student-loan-debt-statistics-average-student-loan-debt https://www.studentloanplanner.com/student-loan-debt-statist... https://www.finder.com/student-loan-debt-statistics https://www.finder.com/student-loan-debt-statistics
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoAverage? Mean? Median?
- elliotec 3y agoAverage, eg mean.
- oldpersonintx 3y ago[dead]
- leereeves 3y agoThat average is the mean (we can tell because it roughly equals $1.76 trillion divided by 46.9 million borrowers). The mean is notorious for being affected by outliers, that is, the few borrowers like doctors who owe tremendous sums. (As GP says, "the nightmare stories you hear are about the small, vocal minority") If 90% of borrowers only owed $10k each, and the other 10% owed 210k each, the average would be $30k per borrower. In fact, if 90% of borrowers only owed 1k each, and 10% owed 300k each, the average would still be over $30k. Edit: According to the census, the median student loan debt is slightly under $20k, which certainly seems like an amount that people can pay off. https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2021/08/student-debt-weighed-heavily-on-millions-even-before-pandemic.html https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2021/08/student-debt-...
- elliotec 3y agoThe median amount of education debt in 2021 among those with any outstanding debt for their own education was between $20,000 and $24,999. This reflects the central tendency of student loan debts, providing a perspective less influenced by extreme high or low values compared to the average debt amount. https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/2022-economic-well-being-of-us-households-in-2021-student-loans.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/2022-economic-we...
- leereeves 3y ago
- alistairSH 3y agoAll true, however the amount of student loan debt (in total) is still a staggering amount. And while state colleges have sticker prices well below those of privates, the pricey private schools are more likely to discount tuition. So students have to guess at where they’ll get the most aid/discount (most schools do a decent job getting these figures to prospects, but you have to apply to get them). IMO, “shopping” for college shouldn’t be anything like buying a used car. The prices should be affordable and publicly shared.
- starttoaster 3y ago> IMO, “shopping” for college shouldn’t be anything like buying a used car. The prices should be affordable and publicly shared. The price of a used car is more transparent than US universities. I think the main comparison for the cost of going to college is more similar to the cost of going to the emergency room. You get individual bills coming in from every doctor and nurse that gave a sideways glance at your X-Ray. Likewise with a university they talk about the price of tuition, and oh wait you're too far from home and need a place to stay? And you're under 26 years old? Going to need to spend another $10k per semester for staying in a dorm. You'll need food passes and parking passes. You'll need books and everything.
- quickthrower2 3y agoFood and accomodation shouldn’t be a surprise cost, as it wouldn’t be if you buy plane tickets to Thailand. Is there any real gotcha costs that you only find out later?
- alistairSH 3y agoBook cost is highly variable. And not remotely affordable.
- starttoaster 3y agoFood is not really a surprise cost. Accommodation is surprising with how much it costs considering you're basically staying in an tenement home with people stacked on top of each other.
- ttymck 3y agoSource?
- burnte 3y ago> The college system in the US works well. From an educational standpoint, this is arguable, as most students are forced to take classes unrelated to their area of study simply to fill out a the credit requirements. But overall our schools are world class. It's the money side that's a wreck. > The vast majority of students go to community colleges or public schools and end up with very little debt (if any). The nightmare stories you hear are about the small, vocal minority that go to expensive private schools and/or major in something that doesn't pay well (like theatre) and/or get Masters degrees that put them in debt. This is just the exact opposite of the truth, with literally no room for interpretation. The vast majority of students graduate with debt, the number is about 64%. Average debt from non-profit schools is about $35k of debt, and about $60k of debt from for-profit colleges. This is two thirds of students, and the amount rivals car loans, which are NOT insignificant.
- TheNewsIsHere 3y ago> The college system in the US works well. > > From an educational standpoint, this is arguable, as most students are forced to take classes unrelated to their area of study simply to fill out a the credit requirements. The point of this is to help round out an education. I started and finished my college career as a science student, but in the middle I switched to humanities. I witnessed an extraordinary difference in the ability to clearly articulate ideas between those areas which really highlighted for me the value in requiring a curriculum beyond just a student’s chosen major.
- burnte 3y agoThat's one argument, another is they're filler to make people think paying huge sums is reasonable for what they get. If these classes were teste for and only given to those who need it, I could believe it was for student enrichment. This is rarely the real case, and many administrators will admit it.
- atmavatar 3y ago> The vast majority of students go to community colleges or public schools and end up with very little debt (if any). I wonder if that's really true for state schools anymore. The two state universities in Kansas (LCOL state) quote ~10-12K annually for in-state tuition alone (KSU: https://www.k-state.edu/sfa/cost/manhattan-campus-costs/undergraduate.html https://www.k-state.edu/sfa/cost/manhattan-campus-costs/unde..., KU: https://admissions.ku.edu/costs https://admissions.ku.edu/costs). I can't imagine many (if any) states charging significantly less than that. When you add room and board, food, books, and all the extra hidden fees tacked onto tuition, you're closing in on ~20-25k. Students aren't getting out of that without debt unless they have a sizable nest egg saved up beforehand and/or work a decent number of hours throughout their school life. And, while it's certainly doable for an individual to make it through school without debt, there aren't enough decently-paid seasonal jobs around said schools for even a majority of students to follow suit. It used to be significantly cheaper when I got my BS ~20 years ago, but a push by Republicans to make student loans non-dischargeable in 2005 (see https://www.congress.gov/bill/109th-congress/senate-bill/256 https://www.congress.gov/bill/109th-congress/senate-bill/256) along with significant cuts to Kansas spending on education tripled tuition shortly after I graduated.
- candiodari 3y agoYou don't have to go that far. The education sector in the Netherlands is quite similar, perhaps 5 years or so behind the US.
- tmaly 3y agoI often wonder why we don't provide free university education in the US. It would benefit society and employers as a whole.
- Quillbert182 3y agoSome states effectively do. Georgia and Florida will pay full tuition for In-State students with high enough GPAs. Students still have to pay some fees, so it isn’t perfect, but it provides incredible value.
- faeriechangling 3y agoThe pricing makes a lot of sense when you consider there’s one price for domestic students and one price for international ones.
- jmakov 3y agoIsn't it cheaper to come to EU and attend the uni here then return?
- uxp8u61q 3y ago[flagged]
- elliotec 3y agoDefinitely. Uni in the EU is very inexpensive and all expenses will really be cost of living (or room and board if living on campus). Uni in the USA is outrageously expensive and is in addition to the cost of living.
- fxd123 3y ago> Uni in the EU is very inexpensive For public universities, not private ones. In the US, private universities are also the most expensive...
- gumballindie 3y agoYou get what you pay for though. As with a lot of things, universities in the UK rank highly but I would say - as someone that went to oxbridge - that they are nowhere near the quality of American universities. Smart people attend, the smartest in europe by a wide margin, but still lag behind.
- bitcharmer 3y agoCould you explain how Oxford and Cambridge lag behind? How did you measure this?
- dudul 3y agoCheaper to just go to community College.
- DiscourseFan 3y agoSchools in the US are better funded, generally (see above), and have more variety and more interdisciplinary work.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI question if half of high school seniors should apply to colleges that cost MORE than 40k. Some of the best educators I had were at community colleges with tuition ~1k per year. It didn't have the marble buildings and heated pools of my UC, but class size was 20 instead of 200 and the primary vocation of the professor was education, not Nobel prize research
- soupfordummies 3y agoTuition has gone up a LOT lately though (like everything else I guess). I remember my school was like ~2200/semester and last I checked it was now up to like ~5000/semester. So there's 40 grand right there if you finish in 4 years.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoIs that a community college or destination University? Some of the community colleges near me are going in the opposite direction and have even eliminated tuition altogether.
- soupfordummies 3y agopublic university that is mostly local folks. So, not quite community college but still one of the more "cheaper" options around here
- BriggyDwiggs42 3y agoCan you direct me to my UC’s marble heated pools pls
- s1artibartfast 3y agoDifferent objects. Marble facades, and heated pools. I don't know what you see you go to
- tafda 3y agoBerkeley’s Hearst Gym at Bancroft & Bowditch https://www.nollandtam.com/portfolio/hearst-gymnasium-pool https://www.nollandtam.com/portfolio/hearst-gymnasium-pool
- ipnon 3y agoI will recommend my kids go to college outside the US unless they get into a household name university. It’s not worth the money anymore. If college was about education surely a benevolent government-university axis would conspire to lower the price by any means; if it were about signaling inclusion into a higher social strata perhaps we might expect college to become ever more expensive… Thiel and Will Hunting have said it better: “You wasted $150,000 on an education you coulda got for a buck fifty in late charges at the public library.”
- whateveracct 3y agoin-state tuition for a CS/eng degree at a good school still seems affordable to me. I checked my alma mater in Indiana and I'd do it again.
- whateveracct 3y agoi will say - the merit-based scholarships have dried up a bit though.
- DiscourseFan 3y agoIt's true, unfortunately. If we had more funding for public universities, the aid would be re-appropriated, but for now they're struggling to make it affordable for students who are just "average."
- DiscourseFan 3y agoYeah, public universities in the US are often comparably priced for in-state students--after financial aid does all their clerical bullshit--to the prices in the 70s and 80s, adjusting for inflation. And you can't replace the experience of being amongst other students, professors, club members, etc. who are all contributing to the ensemble of your intellectual and personal development. Sure there are things you can find in the library, but oftentimes you won't be embedded directly with those who are working on these problems, and you won't be thinking about/discussing them on a day in, day out basis.
- 3y ago
- ladzoppelin 3y agoI know its a different era but I always felt like taking two years to work before going to college would of been very helpful at least for me and I assume some types of people.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoWhat do you see people doing while working in that time? What sorts of jobs?
- jjcm 3y agoThis is something quite close to me. Our family was fairly poor growing up (though later moved into upper-middle class), and when it came time for college it was a matter of "which college is offering me the most in scholarships?". It was never a consideration to simply choose the highest ranked university. $40k of tuition per year and graduating with $160k in student loans was both unfathomable and untennable. Looking back on this, it's actually something that I'm now much more unsure about, especially in the light of a fairly large tech salary. When applying to universities, I had an impressive application: a perfect on my math SAT, captain of the football team, professional opera experience, volunteer work and great grades (all credit goes to my parents for pushing me to do all of this). I got into great colleges such as Stanford (#3 on Forbes' university rankings), but turned them all down due to the price. I ended up going to Loyola Marymount (#203) as they gave me a $40k grant for 2 years. When that ran out I transferred and ended up graduating from Hawaii Pacific University (unranked, but objectively quite poor). Was this the right choice, and would I have made the same call if I could go back? I'm not sure. $160k is much less to me today than it was when I was 18, so the value of the college feels more worth it by comparison. That said, I ended up successful regardless of the university I attended, but this might just be survivorship bias, especially considering when I look around at my peers, almost all of them are graduates of ivy leagues. From a more objective lens, I think colleges offer three things: education, maturity, and access. Educationally, there was a stark difference between Loyola and Hawaii Pacific, so I do think there's merit in pursuing a good university, but would there have been the same delta between LMU and Stanford? For that I'm not sure, especially with the resources online today. From a maturity standpoint, I think I could have gotten this anywhere, as long as it was out of my hometown. Being out on my own was a fairly important aspect of my growth, and interestingly this increased when I moved out to Hawaii and was even further separated. I lived out in Sydney for a bit, and this too stretched me. I'd have loved to have had the opportunity to study overseas for this fact - I think being challenged by a different culture and being out on my own would have amplified the maturization effects of this. On the access side, higher end universities excel here. They offer both peer connections and a stamp of approval. I've seen these two things open plenty of doors for my peers. Because of these aspects, I think if I could go back I'd likely pursue the following: Study overseas for the first two years, then transfer into a more prestigeous ivy league to graduate from. Ideally that captures the best balance of optimizing for the three things universities offer, while minimizing the cost.
- bastard_op 3y agoReturn on investment, and colleges aren't worth a food stamp. Maybe in weird niches they get recognized, but not as a normal thing. They drown like the rest in the higher education racket.