7 ms·
Driverless cars immune from traffic tickets in California under current laws
- lolinder 3y ago> According to the Texas Transportation Code, the owner of a driverless car is “considered the operator” and can be cited for breaking traffic laws “regardless of whether the person is physically present in the vehicle.” This is all well and good when the owner is Waymo or Cruise and actually has direct control over the code that caused the vehicle to fail, but for consumer cars it brings up important questions of what "ownership" even means these days. Let's say I own a self-driving car that's able to reliably park itself. I pay close attention the first few months to make sure that it's safe and reliable, and once it's proved itself I start trusting it. I've been as careful as can reasonably be expected, but one day the manufacturer pushes a mandatory, automatic over-the-air update that contains a critical bug, and my car suddenly starts misbehaving and I get ticketed. This isn't an unlikely scenario—how many of us have "owned" a product that has suddenly changed its behavior in undesirable ways after we purchased it? It doesn't seem reasonable to me to hold an individual consumer liable for bugs in a machine that they are unable to fully control. Either manufacturers need to be required to provide important software freedoms to vehicle owners, or the manufacturers themselves need to be liable for infractions.
- kevindamm 3y agoThis is why the judicial system exists.
- djbusby 3y agoUsually invoked after some harm has been caused. Perhaps there is something we can do before the, nearly obvious, harm occurs.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- erikaww 3y agoWhat is the utility for deciding is one party or another is liable first? Since self driving accidents are rare, we could just have shared liability and defer to courts. I’d imagine a lot of these accidents go to court now. National streamlined processes could be established as more motorists opt into self driving technology.
- ajross 3y ago"Nearly obvious" seems to be doing a lot of work in that sentence. Maybe elaborate? There are now millions of cars on the road with some level of autonomy, you don't need to hand-wave about what you believe "will" happen. Just show the data.
- djbusby 3y agoIt was the items mentioned by @lolinder - software updates causing cars behavior to change, who really owns it, etc. That context was easier to see when this thread started. The "nearly obvious" was referring to things already mentioned, which I also think are obvious but many others don't.
- cmmeur01 3y agoWhich as we all know is a super level playing field.
- eropple 3y ago> It doesn't seem reasonable to me to hold an individual consumer liable for bugs in a machine that they are unable to fully control. They chose to buy it. Manufacturers should also be potentially liable for some classes of problem, but consumers are the ones pressing the "run the self-driving car" button. The court system exists to apportion liability properly past that.
- stavros 3y agoIf I buy a defective toaster and it burns down my house, am I liable for choosing to buy it?
- eropple 3y agoIf it isn't UL or ETL certified? You very well might be, depending on circumstances. Your insurer may treat all fire as covered peril, but it is not guaranteed.
- stavros 3y agoSo, if cars are certified, which they are, I'm not liable.
- eropple 3y agoAre they? Forget even fully self-driving cars right now--who's certifying your lane assist after every OTA update? Like, point at the guy with the clipboard at USDOT or the NHTSA. Because as far as I know, that's not happening, you're open-palm slamming updates into a system you chose to bought and use, under an operational model where you must be fully ready to take over with no warning, and undertaking that is your call. To be totally clear: I want a regulatory regime for this stuff such that it is safe-as-possible and not predicated on a human's attention not wandering in the way that a human's attention is going to very understandably wander. Without one, consumers need to not buy it on pain of their own significant liability.
- 3y ago
- PopAlongKid 3y ago>how many of us have "owned" a product that has suddenly changed its behavior in undesirable ways after we purchased it? I'd be interested in some examples, as I can't think of any offhand, despite your claim that this "isn't unlikely". Also, when it comes to vehicles misbehaving in traffic, I'd say "harmful" is a more apt term than "undesirable".
- j4yav 3y agoReally any cloud-connected device would fit this bill. Many have gone out of business and turned off their backends or changed the way they work in a way that is incompatible with the original purchasing intent of the user. Not to mention software products that evolve in ways the user doesn't like all the time. https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-64249388 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-64249388 is an article with some more specific hardware examples if that's what you're looking for.
- lolinder 3y agoHere is a (very) incomplete list. Not all are ones that I've personally experienced, but they're all products that either I or someone in my direct acquaintance have owned/used. * Microsoft Windows starts showing ads in new and creative places, even though I shelled out $200 for the Pro version. * An Android update broke my preferred home screen. * Roomba vacuums go through regular periods of stupidity in between software updates. One day it's able to dodge obstacles, the next it's sucking up anything and everything. * Basically every SaaS product changes its UI on a semi-regular basis in ways that throw off existing workflows. EDIT: Oh, and a bonus one that's more on topic—Tesla recently rushed an update to their software and introduced a lot of bugs: https://www.autoevolution.com/news/tesla-s-holiday-update-screwed-up-people-s-cars-yet-tesla-refuses-to-acknowledge-226761.html https://www.autoevolution.com/news/tesla-s-holiday-update-sc...
- PopAlongKid 3y ago>Here is a (very) incomplete list Unlike the potential of a vehicle making driving mistakes, none of your examples is harmful, especially not to random third parties. The only thing on your list I have direct experience with is Windows--I've had the Pro license ever since Win 10 came out, now on three different machines, and I don't see any ads on my desktop or popping up in my file system. (of course, I don't log in to any Microsoft account, maybe that explains it).
- krisoft 3y ago> one day the manufacturer pushes a mandatory, automatic over-the-air update that contains a critical bug, and my car suddenly starts misbehaving and I get ticketed Don’t buy it if the company who controls it does not put it in writing that they indemnify you properly.
- ajross 3y ago> one day the manufacturer pushes a mandatory, automatic over-the-air update that contains a critical bug This is a hidden two-fault scenario, which isn't always "bad engineering" but is usually a smell in that direction. You're (1) accepting that the operator/owner/whatever of the vehicle is technically responsible, (2) acknowledging that this supervision is likely to work in practice, then (3) imagining a hardware/systems failure in the car and simultaneously (4) supposing that the supervision you took for granted in (2) fails at the same time. Basically, you don't need point 3 to make your point about safety logically. You added it to change the villain from the driver to the manufacturer.
- lolinder 3y agoI'm explicitly not accepting points 1 or 2. I set up the scenario to show that no matter how careful the consumer is, their supervision will not work in practice (since the vehicle's behavior can change at any time and without warning) and therefore they cannot be held responsible for the behavior of the vehicle. Either the manufacturer should not be allowed to market it (because it cannot be operated safely) or the manufacturer should be considered the operator.
- ajross 3y ago> I set up the scenario to show that no matter how careful the consumer is, their supervision will not work in practice (since the vehicle's behavior can change at any time and without warning) Sorry, can you explain that better? The whole point to the metaphor of "supervision" (e.g. of party A by party B) is that party A is not trusted to behave correctly in all circumstances. You seem to be saying that supervision can only work if B is never required to intervene at all (and by extension, won't, if A's behavior changes)? In which case there's no supervision happening, right? Again, it really seems like you're just playing tricks to make the manufacturer into an unsolvable villain. I mean, you get that's ridiculous right? We trust our cars not to fail already. And have, for a century. And sometimes they do fail, and when that happens we adjust regulatory strategies to minimize risk. Why is any of that different when there's a scary robot involved?
- epistasis 3y agoIn this case the consumer should of course still be held responsible, and if they think it's wrong they can join in on the class action lawsuit against the manufacturer. Or, owners should enter into a pre-existing legal relationship with the manufacturer to get reimbursed for any manufacturer error that gets pushed out. Those who choose to operate driverless vehicles must have some skin in the game in order for this to be fair at all. Bringing your driverless vehicle into an area is the customer's choice, after all.
- tallowen 3y agoGoing to repeated class action lawsuits every time there is a bad software update sounds like an inefficient use of the court system to me. I think most people will eventually want the manufacturer to be the defendant in court cases that result from crashes due to a manufacturer updating cars. I can only imagine NHTSA (US Auto Regulator) will evolve to make this the case.
- t0mas88 3y agoThat's the mostly overly American thing I've read this year... Make consumers file a class action against car manufacturers (good luck with a Tesla and mandatory arbitration), all to avoid doing the sensible thing: Make some rules for this market. The likes of Musk will moan and bitch about it, but regulation is a perfectly good solution for this.
- epistasis 3y agoWell if you read to the second paragraph, you will see I'm not attached to class action lawsuits, and alternatively suggest other legal arrangements. My point is that operators must bear some of the responsibility for their operation of these vehicles.
- kristopolous 3y agoSo basically the eventual outcome here is known (industry regulation) but we must take every step to do it the hardest way possible? Intentionally start with a free-for-all then have deaths, a social movement, lawsuits, court cases, politicians talking about it, campaigns, legislative debates, etc to arrive at what we all know is the end game to begin with? I think there may be some optimization steps here.
- solardev 3y ago> Either manufacturers need to be required to provide important software freedoms to vehicle owners FOSS robot cars seem like a great way to bypass emissions controls, safety regulations, and plain common sense. It'd take what, half a day, for some teenager to modify the firmware to double the 0-60 and blow up the battery pack at the same time? I'd want the opposite: for self-driving firmware to be locked down and hardware signed to heck, with an independent auditing body code-reviewing every update. > or the manufacturers themselves need to be liable for infractions. Can't it be both? Split legal responsibility between each consumer and manufacturer. Doesn't have to be 50/50, but personal liability (even capped at a few grand) could make people pay attention and take over when the self-driving doesn't seem to be doing its job. We don't need more drivers on the roads who think their wondercars are infallible and blame everyone else for their accidents.
- lolinder 3y agoThat's a reasonable argument. In that case, I argue that the manufacturer who wrote and signed the firmware should be liable as the operator of the vehicle.
- solardev 3y agoSorry, I edited my comment as you were replying. Do you think it would be possible (and desirable) to split liability, or should it remain solely the manufacturer's?
- lolinder 3y agoSince we're talking about traffic tickets, which are (currently) routine and generally try to avoid the court system as much as possible, I'd say that we need laws that provide no ambiguity, and I'd rather those laws place the blame on the party with the most control.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoThis isn't just a matter of ticketing for minor violations with no consequences. These are unregulated robots that have and will continue to kill people.
- bluescrn 3y agoAs individuals we are never going to own self-driving cars. If buying the hardware is even an option to begin with, there's going to be a hefty fee to subscribe to the required 'cloud based' self-driving service. (And there's certainly no way individuals/small businesses will be able to buy such a car and run a self-driving taxi service profitably when a megacorporation could have all the income from all the cars)
- exhilaration 3y agoWhat about comma? https://comma.ai/ https://comma.ai/ Seems like our old friend geohot built exactly what you want. Positive HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36927971 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36927971
- bluescrn 3y agoIf it became popular it'd be regulated out of existence
- rpmisms 3y agoDiesel tuners are still very popular.
- shkkmo 3y agoThat is only a level 2 autonomous driving system, with capabilities on par with many other stock manufacturer driver assistance system. Having an open source alternative is coolsl, but it doesn't really bear on the argument I think is being made. I think the argument is that we won't see the same availability beyond level 3, since level 4 is the first step where a human is not required behind the wheel. This means you probably need subscription to have a remote human who can step in and take control in edge cases, at least until we develop AGI. Even then, I suspect the economics of running a full AGI from each vehicles will make a subscription mandatory.
- hahajk 3y agoI still believe the free market can work for self driving cars. If there's demand for offline self driving cars, someone will make them. Probably someone in Asia will make them affordable. But I believe regulatory capture and anti-competitive tariffs are likely to make affordable, buy-and-use cars impossible to sell in the US. Regulations will likely change annually, like they do for cars right now. The govt will be worried that China has control of our morning commute. I hate being cynical, but cars do seem like a lost cause.
- Swizec 3y agoWe already have laws that make it so the driver is liable for infractions, crashes, etc. Even if you own the car, but someone else drives, driver gets the ticket. If this weren’t the case, rent-a-car agencies wouldn’t exist. The same rule should extend to self-driving cars. The manufacturer is driving, ergo they should be liable for everything the car does. Mercedes’s approach to self-driving feels the most promising here. Afaik they are so far the only manufacturer who has said “we’re driving, we’ll take the liability” – https://insideevs.com/news/575160/mercedes-accepts-legal-responsibility-drive-pilot/ https://insideevs.com/news/575160/mercedes-accepts-legal-res...
- iwontberude 3y agoBut there are games like Rocket League who have never changed their controls or physics. They changed everything else except for those things so that people could predictably build and maintain skill. I think it’s not holding a car company to too high or a standard.
- coryrc 3y agoIt's immaterial. Auto manufacturers' product designers and executives aren't being held responsible for rising pedestrian deaths because their oversized killer vehicles keep running over people when driven by humans. Self-driving is responsible for almost no deaths or injuries, most likely net-negative.
- turquoisevar 3y agoThere are two components here that both already have an answer in the real world. 1) making owners of cars responsible for (most) traffic infractions 2) issues caused by third parties, with the first party bearing initial liability Number 1 is surprisingly common in overseas countries. Some of those countries have figured that your garden variety traffic fines clog up the courts, so they’ve lifted simple garden variety infractions out of criminal law and placed them in administrative law. In doing so, they’ve made the owner of the car (i.e., license plate holder) responsible for these types of traffic infractions, who then receive their fines by mail (which are technically settlement offers to avoid prosecution) with a generous appeal window, after which the fine is finalized (doesn’t end up on criminal record because it’s not criminal anymore). This frees up court resources, allows for ticketing without stops, and shifts responsibility to the car's owner, who then, if applicable, can settle it with whomever they borrow their car to. For more severe infractions, it’s still tied to the driver, with the car owner being the initial presumptive driver. Number 2 is a common situation in the US and overseas and is resolved by going after whoever is responsible (e.g., manufacturer) after the fact to be made whole again. It’s similar to going after the seller of the stolen goods after the original owner takes back their property from you in jurisdictions where property rights don’t transfer after stolen goods are sold.
- FpUser 3y ago>"so they’ve lifted simple garden variety infractions out of criminal law and placed them in administrative law." Many "garden variety infractions" are human errors. I do not think those were ever a subject to criminal prosecution disregarding whether the ability to clog the courts.
- turquoisevar 3y agoIn the US, they are still firmly part of the criminal system and recorded on your criminal record, to the point that if you don’t show up, a warrant will be issued for your arrest in some jurisdictions. Elsewhere, they also used to be part of the criminal system and handled similarly to how it’s dealt with in the US (minus the more severe tools the criminal justice system has on hand).
- cyanydeez 3y agothe answer obviously is you're getting a service contract and the company will claim you're responsible 99.9% of the time. the best of capitalism will definitely happen.
- ozymandias12 3y agoOTA updates would require not only 5y simulation testing (dine in 5 days w the right computing power) but would also not be applied all at the same time, in order to get flaws in time before full fleet deployment.
- michpoch 3y ago> Let's say I own a self-driving car that's able to reliably park itself. I pay close attention the first few months to make sure that it's safe and reliable, and once it's proved itself I start trusting it. I've been as careful as can reasonably be expected, but one day the manufacturer pushes a mandatory, automatic over-the-air update that contains a critical bug, and my car suddenly starts misbehaving and I get ticketed. But this is very easy. The self-driving is a component, same as brakes or lights. If your brakes stop working because of manufacturing issue and you crash into something it's the manufacturer's fault. Nothing new here.
- lolinder 3y agoI agree that's how it should work, but the TX law that the article quotes changes that rule to make the owner of the vehicle at fault for self driving failures.
- albert_e 3y agoHere is an recent example from a slightly different area: > Exam invalidated over... Facetime emojis??? > https://www.reddit.com/r/AWSCertifications/comments/18p8uub/exam_invalidated_over_facetime_emojis/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AWSCertifications/comments/18p8uub/...
- tomohawk 3y agoIssue the tickets anyway. Impound the vehicles. Make the companies fight to get them back.
- josephcsible 3y agoImpounding the vehicles would punish the owners for what the manufacturer did. We definitely shouldn't do that.
- verisimi 3y agoGood citizen transportation. Another government incentive, to help usher in further loss of personal autonomy - appeal to greed version.
- verisimi 3y ago> “It seems like while they make fewer of the kind of mistakes that we see from human drivers, they make interesting new kinds of mistakes,” Raicu said. “It has the feel of a human subject mass experiment, right? Without the kind of consent that we usually want to see as part of that.” "human subject mass experiment", "consent"? No, she's wrong there -that's the past. For the past 4 years mass experimentation is fine. Just do it!
- kelnos 3y agoThey shouldn't be immune from traffic tickets, but manufacturers should be the target of those tickets, under the condition that the driverless features were used in the way the manufacturer intended. I'm not liable for a traffic ticket when I get in a taxi or on a bus and the driver does something wrong. In a driverless system, the "driver" is the manufacturer, or whoever wrote and updates the self-driving software. But this also needs to come with some regulation. Driverless mode needs to be audited and certified against a standard, by a third party. Similar (in spirit, anyway) to how human drivers take a driving test before being issued a license.
- Rebelgecko 3y agoWhen I've taken Waymo rides, the weirdest part of the experience was that it actually obeyed speed limits and stopped at stop signs. The latter actually freaked out other drivers. I can't wait until the selfishness of humans is no longer a factor when it comes to road safety.
- kart23 3y agohere you see two waymos turning right, and the one behind actually turns right from the left lane before the first car proceeds. neither were using indicators either. honestly you’d have to be an incredibly selfish human to pull this off. https://youtu.be/kN0MLclnWa0?feature=shared https://youtu.be/kN0MLclnWa0?feature=shared
- toast0 3y agoMakes sense if the 2nd waymo identified the 1st. If I drove around waymo cars enough, I would probably consider driving around them like this at turns like this where gaps in traffic were typically long enough for humans but not waymo.
- kart23 3y agoit’s pretty irresponsible and probably illegal to do that, it’s dangerous because now you’re impeding the first cars ability to see oncoming traffic or turn timely, as well as making it harder to see possible pedestrians crossing. waymo can also take way tighter gaps that most humans would find dangerous, it’s really just not that consistent yet. https://youtu.be/P6sw4EKegp4?t=1444&feature=shared https://youtu.be/P6sw4EKegp4?t=1444&feature=shared
- marcosdumay 3y agoWTF is that crossing mark? The place is completely unsafe for a pedestrian, why does the city wants people to cross there?
- 05 3y agoThere's more discussion of that video on selfDrivingCars subreddit (including comments from Kevin Chen who shot the video) [0]. The turn indicators use PWM'ed LEDs and can be invisible in daylight with fast enough shutter speed on the camera. [0] https://old.reddit.com/r/SelfDrivingCars/comments/18myjc6/driverless_waymo_cuts_off_another_driverless_waymo/ https://old.reddit.com/r/SelfDrivingCars/comments/18myjc6/dr...
- crazygringo 3y agoMaybe this is an unpopular opinion here, but "tickets" don't make any conceptual sense for driverless cars. The entire concept of tickets and fines are to act as a deterrent to individual drivers who might make unsafe choices -- that they'll actively choose whether to obey a speed limit or not. Driverless cars don't seem to be programmed to break laws in the first place. They're incapable of making a choice to break laws to save time. They're simply programmed not to speed, not to run through red lights. And when they do, it's not out of some "choice" -- it's just a bug or deficiency in their code. Driverless cars absolutely do need to be held to safety standards. But the way to do that isn't through issuing tickets. It's simply for a governmental regulatory agency to set statistical limits for the manufacturer's software for mistakes like running a red light, and if the whole fleet of cars goes above that limit you require the software manufacturer to fix it, risking fines if they don't fix it quickly, or losing the ability to operate at all. Issuing tickets for driverless cars makes as much sense as issuing tickets if pharmaceutical companies put the wrong amount of a drug in a pill. Tickets are for individuals who make choices; safety regulations with fines and revoking licenses are for corporations and things like driverless cars.
- lallysingh 3y agoNo it doesn't, but they should ticket the cars anyway. The ticket gets paid by Waymo or whoever runs the car. They don't want any more resentment from other drivers.
- RandomLensman 3y agoAvoidable costs are still an incentive to improve for the companies owning or running driverless cars. As it feels unlikely all things that will ever happen are captured within regulations, fines could still be useful. The bigger question is what to do with things exceeding fines, i.e., stuff that would lead to a custodial sentence for a driver.
- renewiltord 3y agoThat's a pretty good point. Just wanted to comment to say that I found it convincing. Ticketing is a less effective tool for large scale operators. The benefit is that ticketing is the administrative mechanism we already have so we can use that to aggregate and judge performance.
- 6stringmerc 3y agoField testing yet to be conducted but so many ambulances in the hood getting clean audio will be no problem. Bluetooth speaker on the sidewalk. In Dallas CBD as long as it’s part of performing of art (so maybe I’m doing yo-yo tricks next to the speaker) or is permitted as well as a tip receptacle. Being asked to move by a business is about it.
- kevincrane 3y agoEveryone is immune from traffic tickets in California because our cops are too lazy to enforce any traffic laws in the first place.
- ijhuygft776 3y agobecause they know people need money to pay their rent
- prepend 3y agoI got a ticket from a DC traffic camera. Even though wasn’t me driving, I was forced to pay or be sent to collections. The ticket was $100 and I could appeal it by paying $175 of which $100 would be refunded if my appeal was in my favor. Their city ordinance said I was responsible because I owned the car. I imagine it’s the same for driverless cars. The registered owner will get and pay the ticket. They don’t care who is driving. An interesting question though is they driverless cars should probably have different speed limits as they can respond very differently from humans.
- jactoryfoe 3y ago[dead]
- 1letterunixname 3y agoTraffic tickets will need to belong to the competent supervisor of an autonomous system violating stated restrictions, even if they lack a driver's license. (The need for a driver's license will decline for FSD L4-L5, especially if the human won't be operating the vehicle anymore.) Also, under what circumstances/edge-cases should speed limits and traffic laws should be breakable by an autonomous system? a. If you were someone bleeding out to death and need to get to a hospital, do you honestly want it to complete to complete stop like a Canadian Mormon nerd at every stop sign rather than be the most aggressive NYC cab driver-meets-ludicrous speed safe-ish enough so you don't die? b. Evading someone believed intending on causing great bodily harm to reach a safe place like a police station? c. Following a vehicle containing a kidnapping or human trafficking victim? d. Commandeering by a LEO in active pursuit of a dangerous suspect? e. Fleeing an incoming regional disaster threat? It is probable to likely that, by over-regulation, untold numbers of preventable deaths, injuries, suffering, and property damage will be incurred by vehicles created by corporations to always follow laws blindly rather than spend additional money to handle edge-cases or allow exceptions.
- bshipp 3y agoThis kind of reminds me of when the Concorde first started flying and technically could cancel IFR flight and proceed under visual flight rules over the atlantic because it was above 60,000 feet. An interesting legal possibility but likely not a practical consideration until driverless cars are afforded the same legal status as a human driver. As it currently stands, an AI would be considered a driving aid under the command of a licensed human driver, no different than cruise control.