5 ms·
Most homes for sale in 2023 were not affordable for a typical U.S. household
- andrewstuart 3y agoThe future ….. indeed the present in many cities ……. is all housing is owned by the rich and mega corporate landlords and if you are not one of them already then forget ever owning.
- Racing0461 3y ago> Future Present.
- fbdrgvv 3y agoThis was literally the reason I became a landlord. All the houses on my street were being rented. Why work when I can get a management company that will give me 2.5x my mortgage each month so I can rent in a big city.
- satvikpendem 3y agoWell you know what they say, better to be capital than the opposite.
- caditinpiscinam 3y agoHow do you feel about that choice, ethically?
- cycrutchfield 3y agoWhy would it feel any different than renting out any other piece of property, ethically? If I rent my car to somebody, is that unethical?
- caditinpiscinam 3y agoI'm talking about the "not working while living off the income of other people" aspect. Because when poor people do that they're called freeloaders and welfare queens.
- worik 3y agoIt all depends on what you think about capitalism, which is the social theory that the key determinant of what happens to resources is who owns them If you are OK with that then living off rent is a natural conclusion Me, I am not "anti capitalist" (a silly identity many of my comrades have adopted) but I believe capitalism should be an economic theory that society restricts to where it is useful and away from where it is harmful
- cycrutchfield 3y agoSo any passive income is unethical? Receiving interest from your bank deposits is something to be ashamed of?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- satvikpendem 3y agoIndeed, by this logic no one should be able to retire, as the primary means of doing so, using accumulated investments, exists due to others' continued work. Even social security payments are simply the current tax base funding retirees' spending.
- worik 3y ago> If I rent my car to somebody, is that unethical? Possibly If you find a car dependant market where you can rent clapped out bangers at high prices I do not know what sort of land lord you are, but there are plenty that do exactly that
- jjav 3y ago> Why work when I can get a management company that will give me 2.5x my mortgage each month I don't believe this. What city and neighborhood? It is very difficult to find a rental property you can buy and be slightly profitable, let alone 2.5x. Where?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- manuelabeledo 3y agoSo, feudalism then?
- Racing0461 3y agoYeah it's crazy out here. It looks like the low interest rates of 2020 seems to be the cause of the low availability and since those are fixed rates, it incentives people to not sell lowering houses on the market even more.
- api 3y agoSo build more housing.
- wenebego 3y agoReal estate lobby hasnt/wont let that happen
- Racing0461 3y agoBuilders won't build at 7% interest rates ironically.
- cycrutchfield 3y agoBuild more houses then
- seandoe 3y agoSure, but who can afford them? We're building a house right now... My god it is expensive.
- patch_cable 3y agoIndeed. We also acquired a lot and are getting bids to build a modest 3 bedroom house for us and two kids. People saying “build more” seem to be under the impression that construction labor and materials are cheap and we’re just refusing to do it.
- NegativeLatency 3y agoSingle family housing is not the way that you’d build your way out of this. You need all sorts of housing, like the missing middle of affordable townhouse style units with one or two bedrooms and no onsite parking. It’s going to take decades to get out of the system we’ve built for ourselves with sprawl and the automobile. Until it’s possible to build in volume and cheaply you won’t see prices go down because there so much pent up demand.
- bugglebeetle 3y agoThe market is not how you build your way out of this. You need state-backed construction on a postwar scale, bans on corporate investment in real estate, abolition of zoning, and myriad other interventions that are blocked at every step by people looking to profit off their neighbors being forced into the streets.
- cycrutchfield 3y agoPretty sure you can increase supply without having to resort to building shitty Khrushchevkas for everybody.
- ivanche 3y agoWell this had to happen once. You can't increase home sizes indefinitely and expect them to stay affordable. I'm sure that a lot more families could afford 900 sqft homes/apartments.
- adolph 3y agoWhy is that? Why cannot dwellings become higher value and decrease in cost?
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThe market will always just prefer even more value and costs will rise? Somehow we’ve reached a weird equilibrium since the market still hasn’t crashed (yet). In contrast, Japan goes for relatively cheap structures since they will be torn down in 20-30 years, it definitely makes renovations easier when you just raise and build a new house.
- manuelabeledo 3y agoPrices and sizes are completely unrelated.
- bugglebeetle 3y agoYes, seriously. Come check the 600 sqft, 80+ year old shitboxes in Los Angeles that sell for 800K+.
- rufus_foreman 3y agoDoes a 2,500 square foot new house in the same neighborhood typically cost more or less than the 600 square foot 80 year old one?
- bugglebeetle 3y agoAlmost no one builds new houses in Los Angeles, outside those in the wealthiest of neighborhoods, so I couldn’t tell you.
- nickff 3y agoPerhaps their owners at the time couldn’t afford them either? I wonder how many of them were subsequently foreclosed.
- logicchains 3y agoIf a bunch of butchers got together and lobbied to prevent any new butchers from opening up in the neighbourhood, we'd call it anti-competitive collusion. Yet it's apparently fine for a bunch of home-owners to get together and lobby to prevent any new home building in the neighbourhood. People with a vested interest in limiting housing supply (in order to increase the value of their own properties) should not be allowed any significant input into decisions regarding the construction of new housing.
- singleshot_ 3y agoI don’t want to limit the housing supply around me to increase the value of my house. I want to limit the housing supply of my neighborhood to prevent it from becoming an unlivable hellscape.
- cycrutchfield 3y agoYes, NIMBYs tend to have creative rationalizations for their behaviors.
- singleshot_ 3y agoHey, man, at least I have a back yard.
- MikePlacid 3y agoWell, what about your own dwelling. Each of your rooms can house one additional family. And yes, I am counting a living room and a dining room too: Communal apartments (Russian singular: коммунальная квартира, romanized: kommunal'naya kvartira, colloquial: kommunalka) are apartments in which several unrelated persons or families live in isolated living rooms and share common areas such a kitchen, shower, and toilet.[1] They generally lack privacy. Well, I’ve lived in a communalka without a shower, a toilet was outside. These are bourgeois luxuries, they increase price of the house.
- fragmede 3y ago
- nox100 3y agoThey're not affordable for FANG employees. According to levels.fyi an L5 at Google makes $349,163, of that they'll keep 60% after taxes so 209k. It sounds like a lot (and it is in comparison to people making less) but a 1bd apartment costs > $1 million almost anywhere near one of those jobs. You need to pay rent until you've saved $200k-$400k which will take 5-6yrs and then you buy a 1bed apartment and pay $7000-$9000 a month (apartment + hoa) (seen HOAs as much as $3k a month!). AFAICT the only way they can do it is as a couple or down payments from family. If you wonder why traffic is so bad, it's because the only places affordable are 90 minute commute
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoL5 at google here, your numbers are a bit off. I’m in Seattle, so you can still get a one bedroom condo for $600k or so. HOA will top out at $1k, for a new place, it’s often much lower for those $600k places, like $300/month. I saved for my down payment while working for Microsoft in Beijing: rent is pretty cheap, even if a 1 bedroom apartment sells for $1m, you can rent it for less than a thousand a month. I did make less in China than what a level 64 would make in the states, but my expenses were pretty low. I bought 3.5 years ago, today it would be much harder, I would have sell some stock to put more in a down payment to make my mortgage payment more reasonable. It also helps that my SO works as a designer for another FAANG.
- nox100 3y ago> today it would be much harder, > It also helps that my SO works as a designer for another FAANG. Thanks for confirming my point :)
- fragmede 3y agoA FAANG engineer with a take home pay of $200k/yr should be able to save, let's say, $50k/yr. that still leaves $150k/yr, or $12,500/month to spend on housing, doordash, groceries, entertainment, and other savings. Which should be plenty, but maybe I'm not spending enough on Doordash. After 4 years, they'll have $200k saved up. Here's a million dollar, 1 bed condo, and its HOA is $600/month. I don't doubt that there are HOA's charging $3,000/mo, but that's not remotely normal. If you put $200k down, that's 20%, so you have a mortgage of $800k. At today's interest rates of 6.358% on a 30-fixed, that's $6,062+$600 HOA/month. Which is a lot higher than a couple years ago, but that's a whole other thing. Since they're no longer saving, their take home of $209k - $6700*12, leaves them $128k/yr, or $10,700/month to pay for food and entertainment and savings. Again, maybe I'm not spending enough on entertainment, but $10k month seems a lot to me, enough to survive on, at least. https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/400-Avila-St-APT-102-San-Francisco-CA-94123/15069899_zpid/ https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/400-Avila-St-APT-102-San-... Of course this is San Francisco, and housing goes for over-list-price, so here's an $800k condo. https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/417-Carl-St-San-Francisco-CA-94117/2119479203_zpid/ https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/417-Carl-St-San-Francisco... Both of these are in reasonable neighborhoods, though everyone's got an opinion about which neighborhood is the best.
- skipkey 3y agoMy house has roughly doubled in value in the Phoenix area in the 5.5 years since we bought it. We couldn’t afford it today if we were buying new.
- losteric 3y agoPerhaps the area is underzoned
- skipkey 3y agoNot really. The east side of the area where I live is bounded by mountains, so can’t really expand more. To the southeast they are putting in thousands of starter homes. I’m not sure where the water is going to come from. The problem is twofold - one issue is there is a lot of the real estate tied up being used only during the cold weather months from snowbirds. The population goes up by roughly a third then. The other issue is folks moving here from other states, primarily California. The influx has greatly exceeded the rate of new construction.
- losteric 3y agoBy underzoned, I meant building up not out. Sprawl is not a long-term answer to any growth challenges.
- hasoleju 3y agoThe high interest rates make all the difference. In Germany the interest rate for a house loan quadrupled over the last 2 years. 2 years ago you had to pay 2k per month for a 500k loan, while 0.6k of that was interest. Now 2k per month became almost 4k for the same loan. This already lead to a small drop in prizes at least.
- nine_zeros 3y agoHow timely as I just read this about the German market: https://wolfstreet.com/2023/12/24/qe-giveth-qt-taketh-away-german-home-prices-tank-as-ecbs-balance-sheet-drops-by-e1-85-trillion/ https://wolfstreet.com/2023/12/24/qe-giveth-qt-taketh-away-g...
- caditinpiscinam 3y agoI see responses saying that we need more housing, but does that really fix the problem? Landlords will keep buying up the available houses and renting them out as long as they can keep raising rents, which they can since... people can't afford to buy houses. It's not clear to me how building more houses changes anything.
- cycrutchfield 3y agoThe principle of supply and demand doesn’t just magically turn off when talking about the price of housing. It’s very clear that there is a shortage of housing in places people actually want to live, and this is a huge driver in the price of housing in those areas increasing.
- caditinpiscinam 3y agoIf you raise the price of tea, at some point I'll stop buying tea. If you raise the price of housing, I don't stop needing a place to live. "Supply and demand" is the "friction-less, mass-less pulley" of econ: a simplistic principle for a hypothetical world.
- cycrutchfield 3y agoYou also need food to live, but the principles of supply and demand seem to hold quite well for such goods. You can go ahead and call these principles simplistic but it doesn’t mean they are wrong in broad terms.
- satvikpendem 3y agoIt's simple, you will move, either voluntarily or be forced to via rising costs. I know many people who lived in high cost of living areas that now live in lower cost of living areas. Yes, they had to find new jobs and new friends, but that is really no different than any other time in human history. This is not to say that we should not build more housing so as to increase supply and thus lower prices, of course.
- 3y ago
- worik 3y agoThe elephant in the (property market) room is demographics With populations declining for the first time in centuries, everywhere, over the next few years there will be a surplus not a shortage of houses. Not much good for current twenty/thirty somethings, they have been royally screwed by the greed head baby boomers. But it will cause all sorts of unpredictable things to happen in the property market Because of the blindness of capitalism the property market is a big chunk of the economy Interesting times
- nojvek 3y agoUS has a big net flow of immigration to replace lost population. Surplus of houses is quite unlikely.